Madewell Transport Bag Comparison Small Medium and Large Tote 

I'm so glad it was helpful, that is what I was hoping for.

It all depends on your needs. There is a big size difference between the Madewell Medium and the Love41 Simple. I like them both, but for different things. My fav go to bag is the Love 41 Simple for many reasons. I did a video comparing it to the Large Madewell Transport, so see if you can find that video. I've not seen or touched the Cuyana tote so I can't comment on that one.

I have not seen it, I'll have to go take a look right now. But I am on a leather diet at the moment, LOL

I would suggest you check the web site, because the design has changed since I purchased mine.

I generally prefer an open bag, but with the smaller one you would definitely want a zipper. I guess it's because with the bigger ones your stuff is further down in the bottom and "feels" more secure. Of course if your in a setting where security is essential, a zipper is handy.

@@robojunker thanks for the advice. I’ll definitely purchase the unzipped

Lisa, You take care of your bags so much better than I do. I don't store them in anything special. Most of them are hanging or sitting on a shelf in a closet. I like to see them, and any dust bag would hide them :) That said, I don't have any advise on your question about cotton vs silk. Maybe someone else out there does.

@@robojunker Good feedback! It makes me think about my priorities. These are not people! They are just things! I also should consider having mine on display so that I'm more apt to see and use them.

I apply Fiebings to my leather as it dries out, but no special treatment. Rain does not seem to bother these bags, but someone I know carries a plastic bag with her in her's in case it rains.