Thanks for this review. I think it would be a good idea to check out some of the other places that you have given mediocre reviews in the past to see if there have been improvements. It's always great to be able to expand restaurant choices in the parks.
I NEVER understood the hate here. It’s one of our favorites. The food has always been good, the environment is lovely, and the service is always kind. Is it the best/most unique you’ll ever have? No! But it’s certainly not the worst and a must do every trip for us. More reservations for us I guess💁♀️
Omg!! I ran into you guys on this day right before the parade was passing by on main Street. I was super fangirling when I said hi. I said it then and I'll said it again. I love you guys! You guys are adorable and an amazing duo. I watch every single video and I still can't believe that I was lucky enough to run into you guys. Keep it up! Hopefully next time I won't be too nervous to ask for a picture lol
I've eaten at Tony's twice (many moons ago) on high school trips, and it was PERFECT for that. We felt very fancy in the middle of a park day with the theming and decor, but the food was very well suited to our non-adventurous palates. It was a great break in the middle of a park day.
So many people saying it's the "Olive Garden" of WDW--I LIKE Olive Garden. I'd honestly still have other Table Service choices in Magic Kingdom though; particularly the Plaza and Liberty Tree.
The issue isn’t Olive Garden itself. It’s that people expect better than that for what it costs at Disney. I like Olive Garden and it has its time and place, but at MK and DW, I want what I CAN’T get at home.
I would like to see a review on cape mays cafe for breakfast and dinner. I never really hear people talk about this restaurant and the last time I went it was so good. I think it deserves more recognition.
We love Italian food, but have always heard mixed reviews about Tony's being "the Olive Garden of Disney World." We might have to give it a try after this review! There are just so few restaurants to eat at within Magic Kingdom, if not Tony's we can always pound some corn dog nuggs! lol
While not my favorite in WDW, we've eaten there in the past and now that we have a little (grand daughter will be 3 in April 94) we will probably eat there again. I actually have a picture of my son (her daddy) when he was 3 eating there. I've never understood the hate.
Interesting. We went there only a month ago and the food was okay but the service was terrible. A real fake server. Not very helpful at all. Ordering the meatballs for my daughter had only one meatball and they said that was normal. They didn’t even offer to go and get another. I disputed it saying the word is plural, but she said that’s how it is.
We ate there before and no there food doesn't go to the dogs. It's pretty good actually, It may not be top tier quality but definitely acceptable. If there is one thing I would change is the price but it's Disney after all.
Haven't had anything bad to say about Tony's for years now. It nothing amazing but sometimes you just want some easy Italian food in Magic Kingdom and Tony's does just that. The Garlic Bread appetizer is a standout for me.
Trattoria Al Forno had some amazing Italian food when we went last month, and our service was so good. I had the veal osso bucco and the caprese salad as an appetizer. 10/10 delicious and my favorite meal
We used to eat at Tony's every trip! Now we go once in a while, but not because we don't like it. My family actually thinks it's decent Italian food. Is it the best and like your grandma made? Probably not. But for theme park food, with a great view, in a fun atmosphere... we love it!
Mortimer is Mickey and Minnie’s baby, no? And hm, I might have to reconsider this moving forward. I opted for Liberty Tree Tavern to kick off our upcoming trip.
I love this restaurant!! I’ve never understood the hate, I’m a picky eater and I love the fettuccini Alfredo and garlic bread!! Sometimes when I go to Disney I just need something simple!!
I think maybe he meant the best steak in the parks? (Not including resorts or Disney springs) I personally loved the steak at skippers canteen maybe I should try the one at Tony’s
A long long time ago theyt used to serve breakfast and that was phenomenal. It was all Italian breakfast dishes like Frittatas. I really miss that. It was a tradition for us for first morning on vacation. Sigh......
As a gluten free person it was the worst 😂 we went in early May. I got the Alfredo and my wife got spaghetti with turkey meatballs. Both were not good. We had a lot of good gluten free food at WDW, Tony’s was definitely the worst though.
If this is the worst, why is it always busy. We have eating there at least 3 times in the past year since moving to the area and have always enjoyed it.
Are you all allowed to give bad reviews? "it's not horrible" as your review isn't much of a ringing endorsement and really just shows how low Tony's has set the bar for what to expect. All reviews I have read say, basically - It’s not terrible, but it’s not great. So I think I'll keep my plan of shooting over to Steakhouse 71. It's a great break from the heat and the food is actually amazing!
