I don't think she will hardly beat anyone without her healing ability. Not this version of malenia. Her damage is just much too low on the attacks she delivers the most plus almost all of her attacks are very slow to get off. The only plus for her outside of healing is the fact she has a lot of dash moves that causes her to land and not be left in harms way. Still her lack of damage will cause her to lose a lot in my opinion. Would like to see a run of her without her healing ability to see if I'm right.
I saw this mod, the first phase is interesting with Malenia having contact with the Ancient Crucible and the formless mother and managing to heal herself. The second phase is her becoming a true consort and it's also pretty cool. It would be nice to see Morgott or Godfrey fighting to avenge Mogh, of course both didn't support Mogh in his devotion, especially Morgott but it would be cool to see them fighting to at least honor him in his death like Ansbach does.Morgott appearing and using Crucible Magics similar to his father's knights or using melee moves like Godfrey, or Hoarah Loux himself appearing to assist in the fight. (This is a personal opinion, it would be nice to see Morgott using Vendrick's Sword, I think they are very similar and would be a good reference)
@@lhitman2222 Actually there would be a version of Malenia that goes better than the Unalloyed. Now I'll explain, but before I tell you I want to say that it would be a totally I N S A N E version, beyond any parameters. It would basically be the definitive transformation after we defeated her, after finishing the boss fight. As the end of Millicent's quest says, one day she will be reborn into a beautiful scarlet goddess, the scarlett rot is a continuous cycle of death and rebirth. Malenia who is reborn completely intact without the prosthetics, with sight and with full control of the rot and since the rot itself does not make her die, basically this version will even be totally immune to the destine death. So what do you think? This version would be called... Malenia The Inner Regenerate Rot
Well that is rather unexpected that you have decided to show the garden of eyes mod, but honestly thank you so much for making this version of malenia fight in her second phase, because I've been watching elden ring simulator's video the other day and what feelt missing for me in that video is that there were barely any bare handed action from malenia which she can do only in her second phase, because bare handed martial arts is my all time favorite type of combat and seeing my favorite boss to use them feelt like a blessing, and even though I'm not gonna buy this mod myself I'm still gonna enjoy watching it and even though that garden of eyes ain't exactly the best person I will still be grateful to him for making malenia fight with a bare handed martial arts
Yeah... at least with base game Malenia, she has low enough health that, the battles are much closer. This one seems to have Consort Radahn levels of health. And the drain is EVEN STRONGER than Base Malenia. Which, makes no sense, by the way. Her Great Rune, and Rot are why she even had the health drain in the first place. Guess what she's missing in this form?
It was really boring due to her low damage. All of the battles took way too long. It was like an npc with infinite health taking on rykard lol. Without her healing however I don't think this version beats too many of these bosses. Her damage is just too low for that in my opinion. Plus she a lot of slow starting attacks. Her projectiles look like they miss about 40% of the time. And one of her dash attacks she tends to start too far from the target causing it to not reach. She's not judging her distance with it well.
@@iuliuslovin37 Malenia is a B tier boss at best, and Radahn was a terrible choice for the final boss. Lemme fight Godwyn, he’s the only demigod aside from Ranni that I haven’t killed yet (yes I’m one of the few who’s fought Melina, she’s actually pretty solid).
What about Bloodfiend chief vs all base game bosses ? later do bloodfiend trio (Chief bloodfiend + strongest fork bloodfiend + strongest spear bloodfiend) vs all DLC bosses
People: *Whine about Radahn, who's no stronger than Bayle or Messmer, and get him nerfed, while also claiming he doesn't make sense lore wise* Also people: ''The DLC should've had this boss who's about four times as strong as and a thousand times more janky than pre nerf Consort Radahn and makes vastly less sense lore wise! Trash DLC! Modders do it better!''
@@spod5849 Nope. I struggled far more with Bayle and Messmer. I can't no hit Bayle or Messmer, yet have no hit pre nerf PCR a few dozen times even soloing him for the host and another phantom in co op where he had 120k health. Furthermore, Bayle and Messmer very often defeat bosses PCR can't defeat now, or get closer to doing so than PCR does. Post nerf PCR is about Rellana/Scadutree Avatar level. Hell if you start the Scadutree Avatar off in third phase, it actually beats him 1v1. He's like #4th most powerful DLC boss now. He used to be #2nd.
Cool video! I’m absolutely fine with the balance, you don’t need to nerf Malenia. Asking to nerf her is like telling a pro soccer player go easy on kids; we’re here to see how well Malenia would do
Dude it's one thing when she uses something honest like the final Radan. But she just has infinite poise and healing and unlimited health, it's not fair at all compared to the others bosses. I can also create a golden immortal dude who is invulnerable, the same thing.
Another moderator’s video showed that the only way Fu Bai Malenia could defeat her was Mizutori Ranbu, and it also took a lot of time to defeat Holy Light Malenia.
Maybe next time, disable her heal on hit.... This is legit so onesided. And not even in a funny way. Just... kinda bland? It would be more interesting to see how she handles bosses without healing about 5 hits of Consort Radahn worth of damage off of ONE hit....
