In the nicest way possible nick its obvious you don’t watch mctominay enough. He’s fully a defensive liability it’s a myth that he’s good defensively. He literally just takes the spot of Bruno at the 10 and impedes the runs of Hojlund regularly. His work rate isn’t as good as you think and he’s a passion merchant who’s still at the club due to him being an academy product
No he isnt the best but is a good squad player. Had some key moments last season that i think warrants him staying. I would sell him for the right price and what you said is true however but given the amount of games per season i think depth is key, look at all the top teams in the world.
@@RobertoSancheez well spoken cuh. we need a new cdm no United fan is denying that. I think most of us are having to admit that we’d take Scott and his unique profile over case and his liability even if Scott is a defensive liability and can’t pass the ball, Highkey the same could be said about case right now in his career
I dont think you know he was Originally a Striker, similar to Højlund its why he scored a couple for us. He was wrongfully forced to be a DMF due to his size
yeah, 60 million for a kid with a mid season under his belt. you overpaid at least 30 million, which is typical man utd, you overpay for every player because money is all you have to offer because your glory days are done and have been since SAF retired.
@@ingolf82hey so he’s actually the no5 golden boy and considered one of the best cb prospects itw! And when we resale him in ~3 years, he’ll be worth double, which is called good business
Mctominay might actually be the most limited premier league player, he offers absolutely nothing but a goal here and there. He’s a hole in the mid field
@@ryandavis7752 exactly, he ghosts the entire match and pops up with a goal or two and everyone forgets that he’s offered absolutely nothing the entire game, he’s easy to skip past and he’s not progressive
As a United fan - de ligt and ugarte deals are close. This means Casemiro will probably go to saudi and either maguire or lindelof will be sold. Wan-bissaka is linked to west ham and we will get frimpong if he leaves. For left back the main candidate is guittierrez from girona.
I wonder how Ten Hag will play he’s said he doesn’t have the players who are always fit to play out, but is also under a lot of pressure to not start off slow (which might be needed to implement an Ajax style)
The one thing about last season is united were shit. And a lot of that is due to injuries. Mainoo missed half a season, martinez missed the entire season, shaw missed the entire season, malacia missed the entire season, wan-bissaka with many small injuries. Having multiple games with only 1 senior centreback, 0 senior left backs, underperfoming rashford, squad players injured. United did not have a lot of depth, but when so many players missed games it’s incredibly hard without huge depth. Casemiro, mainoo, maguire, wan-bissaka, mctominay, højlund, diallo, shaw, varane, reguilon, martinez, eriksen, martial, mount, amrabat and malacia all missed 10+ games due to injuries. For some games united had 13 first team players injured at the same time. I mean, if arsenal had rice, saliba, gabriel, havertz, white, tomiyasu, timber, partey and trossard all injured at the same time, i would expect people to give them slack if they underperform. But with United that didn’t happen. United had 47 seperate injuries of various lenghts last season. 16 more than united’s worse injury season, and 26 more than last season. With good signings and hopefully less injuries this season, i think United is capable of suprising a lot of people. Fans are short memories, and most didn’t really know the extent of the injuries. They will compare United’s last season to what they will see now, and be shocked.
Martinez Shaw and Malacia have never made it through a PL season without injuries. You made it sound like it was bad luck but those players are just injury prone, it's not bad luck.
Lille were asking for €45m for him before the window started,all the top clubs in europe were interested in him and madrid were willing to pay upto €30m with add ons as the player was ready to wait for them a year anyways and lille aren't that powerful to stop a young talent leave like psg when they rejected €150m on a year left on mbappe's deal. Liverpool and psg were willing to pay the asking price also they were ahead in the race for him with negotiations,united offered €50m and lille accepted but they weren't willing to spread that fee in 5 years so united increased it to €62m and now they've only have to pay 10-12m year 1...people don't understand nothing about football rather sitting on your android and yap,also I didn't see a comment like that when madrid paid 60-70m for aura merchant Endrick💀?
Loved hearing your opinion, I do think Hojlund will start the season with zirkzee being the rotation to start with and then battling it out, I would prefer Amad on the RW but can understand why he’d pick Garnacho just a preference
Anthony celebrate like that becaause after the offside goal 2 players screamed in his face when he was ont he ground. Lucky defletion and a stupid pen got then back into the game. Anthny was 100% right to celebrate
Now the question is: are ManU fans gonna be patient while these guys adjust to playing together, or are they gonna demand imediate results and put even more pressure on them? There is a chance that this team just clicks together and hit the ground running once the season starts, but they most likely will need time figure things out
I think most of the fan base would be alright. Just some vocal voices online if things don’t go well. I think the bigger problem would be the higher ups and the leakers from the squad itself when inevitably things don’t go well even for a while. Then it’s ten Haag out and all that shit starts again.
The Pellistri situation is off his shown qualities when played but doesn’t get anywhere enough game time and when loaned out no one ever really talks about him. His a big part of the Uruguay squad but I don’t see him staying at United and I’ve seen loads lots of clubs interested in him but no great sides lower league Spanish teams Brazilian teams etc
We achieved 8th with all the injuries, leveled with the same point as newcastle who were also bad. Now with new signings and all players fit, and assuming you won't get the disaster of injuries as last season, we can definitely get in top 4. With a full squad we can't be that bad.
@@crysflake Shaw, Malacia and Martinez have never made it through a PL season without injuries. You can easily assume they will all be injured at some point this season.
@@TP-pq9xx that's why we have new cbs, yoro and potential new academy promotions like amass or fish. We are also looking for a new lb. The players you mentioned can't be trusted at all.
@@crysflake I don't think you can trust an 18 year old who's never played in the PL before either, no matter how much of a talent he is. Ligue 1 is still nowhere near the PL in quality.
@@TP-pq9xx I agree with you. But would you have said the same about Mainoo ? Yes. How did he do ? Way better than most ever expected. He could be the same but of course we definitely need someone like de ligt or another dm like ugarte. The point is that we still have the same players and even more, and we are still recruiting for more players. We can't possibly be worst.
These clowns bought an 11 goal a season striker “beat Madrid” by overpaying by 30m for an 18 year old CB, want Ugarte who doesn’t even play for PSG. And have the bald Southgate as a manager. Yeah they ain’t cooking a thing.
Shocking thumbnail tbf. A little bit weird that you could so easily have used Yoro instead of Zirkzee since it is a like for like replacement for Varane. I mean it was right there. Then you used Zirkzee.. Idk.. weird
on my FM24 man utd save psg came in for sancho and rashford and an offer to good to turn down and for some reason were incredible at psg won a CL lol but its only a game made about 200mil and saved 600k a week my team for 24/25 is ddg shaw dalot branthwaite and scalvini mainoo kenneth taylor joao neves bruno garnacho LST and tel of bayern i think im happy and a gk coming through and getting davies on 2024 summer maybe a rb to only areas i need work on FM is a great game love it
amads competing with the likes of anthony and sancho for the RW spot i hope he does well if he does well what happens to the likes of sancho and anthony cause the wages of sancho no club can afford that anthony still on alot to puts man utd in a sticky situation offloading insane wages but its the mistakes of the past regime same as rashford should not of been on 300k max 200k i also think its garnacho vs rashford for the LW
Wan bissaka is not good enough offensively for united. He's probably the worst fullback in the league when in comes to being on ball. Can't pass, can't dribble, zero technique. He needs to be on a mid table or lower half team, that doesn't want majority of possession
We will see, I think both will be great for us but I think it’s very likely that ETH wanted zirkzee bc he feels he will know his tactics already and be a great fit. It’s good we have 2 good strikers that will hopefully stay healthy so we have the ability to change a game and make subs
Mctominay touches the ball about 6 times in a match. For a midfielder at a team trying to dominate possession, that is Aweful. Ugarte and collyer are much better midfielders than Mctominay on and off the ball. Attacking wise zirkzee can do the role mctominay was shoehorned into due to his lack of creativity or positional awareness. He has a yr left on his contract and is pure-profit from ffp standpoint. Sell pls.
If you think this is overpaying you haven’t seen previous Manchester United windows. And when it comes to young players you have to still pay a lot bc it’s a bidding war. He’d probably cost around 70 if he had something like 3 years left on his contract
