Bitches, that was 8 years later since the song came out, 17 years later since her prime era, 23 years later since America knew her, and that was when she was 43 !!!! SHE IS THE LEGEND.
Dont honey me, when she lips she is trying o look pretty, its pretty obvious,given that after THIS version they were playbacks of this when she was caught lipping ,and her impression this was live weather u like it or not, also there is another version on which someone put off key notes and says its ,,live" which is completly false so i dont know by what metrick are u going on since this version is very very different then original but i hope u get well, delusion is a terrible illnes.
I feel like this is live cuz I think she attended to sing without pretty acting , the climax is adorable with strength and her face showed that she was tired from singing the last part , I believe that!! ❤️
This is one if not the best live performance of this song. She snapped and lost herself in the song and sang from the soul. I can watch this on repeat for DAYS
@@yureino yup, but the climax was 100% live. She pauses right before it begins and realizes it’s not playing so she starts it late. You can tell she was pissed at the end that she had to really sing it.
@@Harvyy99i usually can tell when mariah is lip synching but I genuinely think this was live. The playback didn't come in and she had to sing it live. Thats why after this performance, she used some of her vocals from this performance in her future ones.
@Cam Cam don't be silly, this video is not the original version, you can see that through the low quality, so the audio track is slower or faster a bit.
Na vdd, essa parte atualmente ela usa playback, por exigir demais da voz e para se preservar. Mas o playback falhou e daí ela mostrou que continua mesmo com idade, uma das maiores vocalista. ( observa a cara de p da vida e como ela ficou ofegante depois de cantar o verso final).
Vi um video de um show recente dela q ela n usa playback nesta parte. É possível comparar uns pontos de dinâmica comparado com a original e até umas notas da melodia que são diferentes da versão gravada. Ela canta demais ainda. É absurdo de bom!!
@@igorbraga5838na verdade ela canta mesmo, ela até usa o playback como suporte pra não cansar a voz, mas o final ali é nítido o tanto de ar que ela consegue respirar pro tanto de palavras que ela fala em um tom alto e simplesmente de se admirar a performance, tanto q quando ela para de cantar ela da uma boa respirada e a alma dela diz, voltei. Haha abraços
There is nothing better than a cracking voice on Mariah when she comes and takes care of business!!! The tones in the climax and note combo's are the best! This is why we love Mariah!!!
What makes her vocal outperform and stand out is that she always hits the high notes precisely and powerfully after going through the process of several flawed sounds . She just saves up the energy for the higher notes in the way of whispering.
Lmfao the white dude in the blue shirt at 2:13 was really getting into the song i fucking love it just goes to show how amazing this song is it just touches your heart
*100% live & still cant get over the "when you left" at ****3:04****.. shit was SO FUCKING PERFECTLY cohesive with the rest of the climax...& absolutely LOVE the note/rock & roll SOUNDING run SHE DOES at **4:25*
3:02 is a backtrack and then it faded out that’s why she improvised that fast ‘when you left’ at 3:05 and from then onwards you can tell it is live. Her face says it all. Also, you can actually see her struggling not just acting.
I love mariah but it's not live, the exact same track was used for her Jimmy Kimmel 2015 performance. She sounded great in the rest of the performance though!
Gianmarco Giuli you can't even tell when the audio of her voice sounds different? mhmm that's interesting. She lipped the part "when you left i lost a part of me, it's still", but after this she did the rest of the climax live. so stop giving people the false information because it's obvious that you don't know when she actually lipsync or not
Na vdd, essa parte atualmente ela usa playback, por exigir demais da voz e para se preservar. Mas o playback falhou e daí ela mostrou que continua mesmo com idade, uma das maiores vocalista. ( observa a cara de p da vida e como ela ficou ofegante depois de cantar o verso final).
I truly believe this climax was live. You can hear her start to struggle at 3:22 and at 3:35 she cuts off singing EXACTLY when the audio stops. Usually when she lips she turns to the side just in case she doesn’t cut off in time with the note but she didn’t need to do that because she was singing live.
Yup, but you can tell she was expecting for the backtrack to play and it didn’t. Which is why she started a second late and then was pissed at the very end.
She struggled in min 3:26 and the face in min 3:36 I feel bad for her I love her soo much and knew she struggled with the voice problems but I don't know what to think about this. Mariah Carey love you. My best wishes from Panamá.😍❤️❤️❤️
+Хосе Флорес STFU, it's critical "fans" like you that add fuel to negativity from haters towards Mariah. Did you see the time stamp on that video? 8:40 am. Imagine how hoarse your voice is that time of day. She manages to sing this song live "for the nostalgia" and as a human, is imperfect. Be glad everything she went through during mottola and being written off by critics she still perseveres and does this for her fans. Most people don't get back up when struck down, so be glad she's getting up instead of criticizing her stance in doing so.
She's rarely singing the climax live, due to very high note and its hard to singing at some concert, but thiss isss is crazy, she saving up her energy from the start
Her songs are so hard That is why she lipsyncs Try her songs to feel what she feels when singing her songs live But hey she did a great live performance here!!!!!!!
then don't make songs you cannot sing! She has such a poweful voice and she proves it with this performance!!! Why does she lipsync!!!!! She doesn't need it!
R' Paz Not only what Ombre said, she may have been able to sing it fine at the time of recording So she could sing it (evident from the recording lol).
R' Paz when you are on tour, you need to have backing vocals and sometimes lipsync, otherwise you risk losing your voice very quickly, and that could mean a potential loss of millions of dollars. Mariah obviously has the vocals ability to sing her own songs, but performing a live concert everyday is a different story.
Eu amo essa performance, essa parte final atualmente ela usa playback, por exigir demais da voz e para se preservar. Mas o playback falhou e daí ela mostrou que continua mesmo com idade, uma das maiores vocalista. ( observa a cara de p da vida e como ela ficou ofegante depois de cantar o verso final).
She sounds great here. I'm kind of astonished. This was only 4 years ago, 8 years after the song was released and she nails that climax and the entire performance is almost pitch perfect.
Ela está incrivelmente maravilhosa, o único problema é que parece que ela tá um pouco cansada. Mas as vibrações e saltos de notas continuam impecáveis., eu amo essa mulher.
Na vdd, essa parte atualmente ela usa playback, por exigir demais da voz e para se preservar. Mas o playback falhou e daí ela mostrou que continua mesmo com idade, uma das maiores vocalista. ( observa a cara de p da vida e como ela ficou ofegante depois de cantar o verso final).
The chills!!! Omg that voice ugh I been loving this woman since I was a child 😂 and have yet to actually see her in person but lord knows even through a video that voice give me chills 😍😍😍
One of my fav performances (along with Emotions from MTV Unplugged). Not sure what some of the hatin is about but when you compare Mariah to Mariah, you still get Mariah.
There were many flaws and obviously it was full live yet it was probably one of her best rendition of the song because she gave her all and it sounded amaziiiiiiiiin ❤️ And I loved that « Thank you baby » at the end that was hella cute 😃
I watched her Live show in Singapore and I can always say "Bish take my money and ill watch your show whenever possible!" 😅 ONE OF THE GREATEST SINGER INDEED!
I love the extended part of the performance when she went down the stairs .. And i still love this song after With You been released.. Who else watch this in 2018?!
I am the first to say "Mariah's lost it" and criticize her lip-synching over the past decade but... Here she's really singing live. "#Beautiful" fake whistle notes hurt my "fanness" but this is live. Even though it's strained, even though it cracks a f***ing lot, I give her a bow for singin it real live.
+Leonel Navarro +Leonel Navarro It's been a really long time comment. Now that I get to see again that WBT video (thx 2 the notification of your comment), I can't say anything else but "she rocked it", yet I need to emphasize on the fact that now her voice bizarrely splits (cracks, whatever you think is the less "haterish") into 2 different tones ATST when it gets to her high chest voice. Love her but I really do think she recently missused/mistreated her voice to that very breaking point where she can't use any of her highest register (chest or whistle) proprely. Once again, forget my poor english, I'm french.
+Leonel Navarro I do still think she has one of the most beautiful voice color ever whenever she lost some of her tones. I think we can compromise on that ^^
