no, it's just tv performances and what not where alot of people are made to do playback, i just saw him on his Hey Cruel World tour, no playback for any song what so ever even this one and i personally think he nailed it
Well I think he was singing for real, however, someone put the CD version in the video and turned off the original noise. The reason I say this is because there is a crowd of people and you cannot hear any of them.
for those complaining about the playback... it wasn't mansons choice, this specific tv show in europe has ALL of its performing artists perform to playback, its the format of this specific show and NOTHING more
Agreed his shows are more about the image in my opinion. But I do wish his old voice would come back. He probably could still sing as good as he use to if he took some voice training.
Difícil Ya está en los 54 creo No podría cantar como en el 90 Pero bajando algo de peso y mejorando su rango vocal podría llegar a cantar algo parecido al 2005 o 2007
I am pretty sure that Tim played bass here - this model of instrument he his holding during this performance is his Gretsch bass. I also think that camera was hit by swinging keyboard:) And this drumset is odd, as for me
I don't know why, but he always uses a playback for this song. anyway marilyn manson should come back and do something big again! its hard to believe MTV actually used to play his stuff like 10 years ago.
i have flagged this up as inappropriate under the heading of spam miming in deed how shameful, everyone seems to say well its MTV what do u expect, but just type Depeche Mode live MTV it is not the channel but the artist choice to sing live or not.
Nunca pudieron tocar bien esa canción en vivo, casi siempre con pista(playback) lastima, se la hubieran dejado a Reznor creo si la hubiera podido tocar chido en vivo, la idea del cover era de el originalmente, se la ganaron los de Manson. IGUAL ME ENCANTAN LOS DOS, MAS MANSON, MY EMPEROR.
@xXKittyTVXx No1 forced him to playback anything he had the option to mime or not if he wanted to! Have you not seen the MUSE mtv video where they play "Feeling Good" and completly take the piss!? This whole video was complete bullshit, ginger fish was the only one doing any work! Manson was happy to mime away and the crowd loved it, shows the standard of todays society.
