In South East Asia religion, where I am now, there are so many Catholic churches with people worship Mary and her statue, but many Christians do not know that. There is no mistake in the Qur'an.
Sorry, Catholic dont worship Mary. it is in your peoples sayings to destroy .. God people dont lie or need to shame and destroy what catholic really teach. Just curious isnt the black stone shape of vagina that you guys go in the circle ? think about that.
Ameen! And we Muslims all bear witness that Jesus the Son of Mary (peace be upon them both) is the Word of God, Spirit from God, and His Servant and Messenger.
While Jesus is the Son of God, not just some *slave of Allah* :-) I'd rather be *one eternally free child of God than one *eternally **_slave_** of Allah* .
We used to pray to Mary and were asked to even ask her for help…. Before my mother became Muslim. So although they are not saying she is God catholics worship her as a god
Lucky you sister. You have twice the reward. 28:51 Indeed, We have steadily delivered the Word ˹of Allah˺ to the people so they may be mindful. 28:52 ˹As for˺ those ˹faithful˺ to whom We had given the Scripture before this ˹Quran˺, they do believe in it. 28:53 When it is recited to them, they declare, “We believe in it. This is definitely the truth from our Lord. We had already submitted ˹even˺ before this.” 28:54 These ˹believers˺ *will be given a double reward* for their perseverance, responding to evil with good, and for donating from what We have provided for them. God bless you and may God guide us all to the right path.
@Jomy Mathew If you watch the full video, you will understand everything, then you can discuss whether the supplication for Maryam (Mary) and describing her as the queen of this universe is with you or not.
@Jomy Mathew 1- When did I say that you follow the Qur’an, do not tell me things that I did not say 2- Jesus, peace be upon him, did not say in the gospel that he is a god and that we must worship him, but always referred to his father (who is God and whom we believe is the only one worthy of worship and does not have a son) If you really follow your book, you will worship God alone 3- You must respond to the arguments that Paul said, which in my opinion are strong and you have them, such as that you call Mary and supplication is a type of worship and you call her the Mother of God (Watch the full video to understand) 4- Yes, we agree that she is a woman chosen by God and that she is righteous, and also in the belief of many Muslims that she is the best woman God created, but does this mean that we raise her above her rank and make her divine? of course not
@Jomy Mathew 1- You know that your accusation is false because we perform circumambulation around the Kaaba because it is one of the rituals of God who commanded us and kissing the Black Stone is nothing but a Sunnah that the Messenger, peace and blessings be upon him, did and we follow the Messenger in everything. You can compare this with the rituals of the children of Israel inside the temple in Jerusalem in ancient times. Does this mean that they worship the temple? And even at the present time, the Jews are praying towards Jerusalem, does this mean that they worship Jerusalem? A little thought makes you realize it's not like that 2- Something really strange that you cite a hadith that the Messenger, peace be upon him, said as evidence against us. Did you understand the hadith as the Muslims understood about their Messenger Or are you making up words out of your head? 3- You Christians like to play around with words and take what you want from our religion without listening to the whole religion, and this, if it indicates, only indicates compound ignorance. 4- Yes, this is a true hadith on the authority of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, but where is the proof of the divinity of Jesus, peace be upon him, in that? Mary’s mother was a righteous woman who prayed to God to protect her daughter and her daughter’s offspring from Satan, and God responded to that, and this is one of God’s blessings upon Jesus, peace be upon him. 5- The prophets, peace be upon them, are the closest people to God, and God has protected them from major sins, and from telling lies about God and commanding them to convey His messages, and they did, but they are still human beings who make mistakes in minor matters, and then quickly seek God’s forgiveness and repent to Him, and among them is Jesus, peace be upon him. 6-(And We did not send before you any messenger or prophet except that when he spoke [or recited], Satan threw into it [some misunderstanding]. But Allah abolishes that which Satan throws in; then Allah makes precise His verses.1 And Allah is Knowing and Wise.) surah 22 verse:52 There is no prophet sent by God except that he made a mistake in reciting God’s words because of Satan and Jesus, peace be upon him, among them. Of course, it was not intentional and they quickly corrected it. This is a refutation of your words that even in Islam, Jesus, peace be upon him, is without sin 7- No person enters heaven with his good deeds without God's mercy and forgiveness. If we worship God throughout our lives for 24 hours without interruption, we will not fulfill his right This is what you must be aware of, even Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon them, who are the best 5 prophets. 8- Again, my friend, try to see the video objectively and try to compare it with the Catholic Christian world. Did we lie to you, or did we say the truth and support it with evidence?
I had recently seen a a picture of the Pope bowing down before a picture of the Virgin Mary and thanking her for her protection. He had indeed seeked protection from her. This in my mind is worship. The prophet had mention supplication is worship.
@Gary Madrass Sure, sure, we know.😂😂😂 But you have manny Gods beside the real. Jesus Christ says: I comes only for the lost sheep’s of the house of Israel and not for the Gentiles ! All where in Jesus Christ time Gentiles , except the Jews/Judaism ! Jesus Christ never ever says I’m God or Worship me as a God !!! ( in the entire Bible ). Old Testament---God is One ! New Testament---3 Gods 🤔😂😂 ( With Trinity ) Both are together valid , but both stand and are opposite ! Make no sense 🤔🤭🤭🤭 Trinity don’t ever stand in the Bible/Old Testament or New Testament,s Think the Jew says Christianity is Polytheism !!! Think they knows about that they spoke.
@Gary Madrass The one with the black stone 🪨 is in the Bible and God, the pilgrimage pleases again! And that God also likes to see the animal sacrifices, which have no longer existed in Judaism since the destruction of the Temple of Solomon! The prophet of the peoples (saw) Instead of just grumbling, think about the fact that he became the prophet of the prophecy in Jesus Christ times, even from Jesus Christ himself. But instead of following Jesus Christ, you follow those who perverted everything that Jesus Christ teaches ordered to hold !!! The one who cancels even one letter of the law of the prophets will be the least in the kingdom of heaven! The law of the prophets, that is the Torah, the Old Testament! And will be the least: Means eternal life, forever in hell this will be punished !!! Think Jesus Christ meant the false prophet / apostle Saul / Paul! Who abolished Jesus Christ teaching and installed himself as a prophet! He prophesied that Jesus Christ would come down from the kingdom of heaven during his lifetime, and then the last judgment would occur! Yet false prophecy false prophet says the Bible itself! As simple as that ! Jesus Christ was asked when the end of the world is!? He said that nobody knows, not the angels in the kingdom of heaven, nor do I - only God knows! A god who doesn't know something so irrelevant !?
@Gary Madrass Someone who sees an IPhone 📱 is an atheist and immediately knows that a very intelligent person, a factory, can only manufacture something complicated. So he doesn't believe in pure coincidence! But a person complicates without end, or the universe, or the earth itself. Should have come about by chance! ??? That would probably be as if a hurricane were passing by in a junkyard, and an airplane would be finished ✈️, with all the finesse, complexity ! ??? Verily you are an Einstein! Their parents gave them their live, but when they die, why can't they bring them back to life !? Or who gave you your children for free !? If there is a Creator, he did not leave his creation without instructions as to what to expect from them! Those were the prophets, starting with the first human prophet / Adam! And they only had one core message: This life is a test, To believe and worship only the 1 God of Adam, Noah, Lot, Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Joseph, Moses and Jesus Christ + John the Baptist + the last of all prophets, prophets Muhammad !!! ( Peace be upon all of them) All similarities come from the fact that all the prophets told their people God is One! Judaism was only valid temporally and locally, until the last prophet! Islam was the religion that God for all people, even for the Jews, and this false religion, namely Christianity, which was not willed by God. Jesus Christ says: I was send only to the lost sheep’s of the house Israel and not to the Gentiles !!! ( I come from God, and I come only for Jew/Judaism than only they know God is One We saw what the Gentiles make from the One God ! For these reasons he say that !!!
Quran also says "Have you seen the one who takes as his god his own desire? Then would you be responsible for him?" Sura (25:43) So here people can take their desires as God too. Because there are people who just follow their desires for their guidance.
@Md. Tunazzin Ul Arefin “taking one’s desires as god” this makes even more sense even when you take our prophet’s explanation of how the jews and christians took their monks as gods into account - the did so by making the haram halal and the halal haram. People who follow their desires do just that - they do things that Allah has forbidden and they refraining from things Allah has commanded.
@@faisalwho Why Allah says that is more appearant in today's time. Look at the celebrity culture, people cross the line to show their love for their favorite actors or athletes. In my country, many people praise political leaders in such an extent that it can be in the trajectory of worship. They can do anything just to make their leaders happy.
@@khaledurrahmanarfat6197 Like Diego Maradona, one of the world's greatest football players, was called *The God of Football* Sachin Tendulkar , one of the world's greatest cricket players, also called *The God of Cricket* Freddie Mercury was called the *The God of Rock music* Gods to the crazy followers of sports and entertainment
They distorted their books, trying to change the meaning of the words of the Qur’an. So Allah keep Quran by him self, So I tell numbers that don't lie, *speed of the earth’s rotation around its axis = 463m/s preserves the Qur’an himself. The repetition of the word earth in the Qur’an = 463 times = the speed of the earth’s rotation around its axis = 463m/s😄 Allah is the greatest The period of the moon = 27 days. = The number of the word Moon repeated in the Qur’an = 27 times = The number of words in the verse 5:97 is =27، 😄 5:97➡️Allah created the Kaaba so that we know that He is the One *who created the universe⬅️ So Qur'an not distorted 😄 Allah is the greatest
I heard several times in movies and tv shows that people say "oh mother of god" or "holy mary help me". If that's not raising someone to the status of divinity idk what is.
@Isaac Abraham normaly, bro if you're worshiping a person as a god you're going to worship everything that related to this person , maybe they're going to worship his poop and give it a name as "THE HOLY POOP"💩 , well, you'll never know 😂💩
It is perhaps even worse than suggest. There have been some Catholics who have identified Mary with the Holy Spirit. In the Orthodox Church Sergius Bulgakov identified her with "Sophia", who is perhaps divine or semi-divine. There are ancient Catholic Hymns which speak of Mary as "our sweetness and our hope" (Salve Regina). I have always been uncomfortable with describing Mary as "our hope". Surely only God is our hope? However, I understand what our Catholic friends would say that that.
@@aw6029 Unfortunately the same bid'ah and shirk that plagued the ancient astray is also plaguing "Muslims" today, where many are calling to shirk, grave worship ect. All you can do is give dawah to them call back to tawheed and if they deny, then it's on them.
Stop saying bs like this, there is nothing even remotely close amongst Muslims today. There is no grave worship. Salafis go extreme and do takfir on everything.
Koran 5:116 is one of the reasons *I rejected Islam* many years ago. Interestingly where in the Koran does *Allah **_mention_** the Holy Spirit as one entity of the Trinity* ? After all Allah accuses the Christians to worship three gods. God, Jesus, Mary and Holy Spirit now are all (so the accusation it seems) gods in Christianity especially Roman Catholicism. If one wants to *form a trinity out of these four beings* it would be necessary that one is left out, but please keep in mind that the Holy Spirit is also accepted as *ONE OF THREE in the trinity*.
another epic video again !!!! and many beautiful posts in the same day !!!! and a short vid !!!! we must be proud , you deserve more support from us !!! thank u Mr paul RESPECT 🤩🧐
A little bit off-topic here, but my comment would be about God's impeccable planning/timing in motivating Paul to do what he does through this channel. Subhan Allah. The stage was ripe during COVID in a world that needs the likes of this gentleman, through whom--inshaallah--many shall see for themselves, just as Paul obviously did, the light that comes with the surrender to the Almighty (in Arabic: "Islam"). Paul, stay humble and don't let Satan turn your good effort into food for your ego. May Allah the One support you in "converting" more Muslims back to their religion! Thank you.
@Loki Loki jumping straight into ad hominems... you really are pathetic lmao. smh why don't you islamophobes ever come up with an original argument? You people always parroting what Islam haters say.
Thank you Paul, When I heared James White saying no one worshiped Marry,I was like this guy dont know what worship means.People praying to Marry is all over youtube.Thank
Most Catholics 100% do. Hence the rosary , and many novenas addressed to her. Even the many places of pilgrimage . Not sure if it still is or not , but in Ireland the national tv channel played the Angelus at midday and 6pm every day (that's a special prayer set dealing with the annunciation ) Sorry for all the large weird 'catholic' terminology . Alhamdullilah , after learning all that , Allah (swt) shows me to the straight path :-)
@@marykilbane7738 Catholics in South India ( goes back to st.thomas, they say) literally worship Mary, have festivals and rituals similar to the Hindus, idol worship. Just search RU-vid for Velankanni festival
Azraqi” (D. 864), in his book, “History of Mecca”, which is probably the oldest available book, written about Mecca that we know, writes down some quotations in a chapter titled “the events about the reconstruction of Kaaba by Quraysh”: At the time of ignorance in Mecca there were many pictures and images inside Kaaba, one of them was of Jesus Christ and Lady Mary (PBUT). Jesus Christ (PBUH) was sitting on his mother’s lap in that picture. The house of Kaaba was in this condition until the 8th year after Hegira when Muslims entered Mecca, and Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) ordered all the idols inside of the House of Kaaba to be broken. When Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) entered the house, and observed the images, he ordered to remove all the images and pictures inside the Kaaba, except the images of Jesus Christ and Lady Mary (PBUT), which he pointed out and ordered not to be removed and the images remained in the House of Kaaba. Until they were removed at the time the second Caliph Umar-ibn-Khattab. In another chapter Azraqi wrote down that there was a woman from “Ghusan”, who came to Mecca to perform Hajj. She was impressed by watching this pictures and said to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) that you are a real Arab. Thus Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) ordered all the images to be removed except the pictures of Lady Mary and Jesus Christ (PBUT). This question may arise that if the house of Kaaba was regarded as the place of idols, how was it then that the images of Jesus Christ and Lady mary (PBUT) were hung in this House? The answer is that the one of the reasons that Arabic people in the age of ignorance placed their idols at the House of Kaaba, was that they regarded the idols as their intercessors before god and in fact these idols were mediators between the god and the people.
I believes back then there were Christians who believed such things, because, nowadays some group of people still believe the concept of Mary as a Deity. See Mary of All Virgins Our Lady of the Holy Trinity of god, Juan De La Cruz.
I was actually approached twice in two different cities to come to a bible study where I would learn about “God the Mother” So it’s possible that this belief of Mary being a God is making a real comeback.
@@NazzYr101 In Arabic #god doesn't means part of Creator . But Everything you warship called as god , that can be a tree, or man , or child even your watch. if you believe that your watch have some supernatural power or this watch is a mediator between you and The God☝️ So Christians pray (warship) to marry that means islamicly she is a false godess
My god I really like everyone of your videos man I just wish I can meet you in real live and meet an amazing and intelligent person like you wish you the best brother may Allah bless you and grant you heaven 👍much love ❤❤
@@BloggingTheology In Arabic #god doesn't means part of Creator . But Everything you warship called as god , that can be a tree, or man , or child even your watch. if you believe that your watch have some supernatural power or this watch is a mediator between you and The God☝️ So Christians pray (warship) to marry that means islamicly she is a false godess
@@BloggingTheology @Rob MTT Middleman between The God and human used to pray to the God is called إله (god) in Quran . That's why we say who pray to saints and made the middleman between The God and human is Disbeliever. “ And they worship besides Allah things that hurt them not, nor profit them, and they say: "These are our #intercessors with Allah." Say: "Do you inform Allah of that which He knows not in the heavens and on the earth?" Glorified and Exalted be He above all that which they associate as partners with Him! ” [Quran Sura Younus 18] " Surely, the religion (i.e. the worship and the obedience) is for Allah only. And those who take Auliya' (protectors and helpers) besides Him (say): "We worship (ask an pray to) them only that they may bring us #near to Allah." Verily, Allah will judge between them concerning that wherein they differ. Truly, Allah guides not him who is a liar, and a #disbeliever." [Quran Sura Zumar]
@Blogging Theology Bro.. in Jordan where I studied at school.. a Christian school.. arab Christians used to pray infront of us... it was a part of the morning queue.. Mary was called Mother of Allah..it was common then.. not sure what it is now. Just wanted to note this!
First of All you need to understand what "إله" means in Islam. You often see Christians say "O mary Help us" which is very wrong since this attribution can only be applied to god not a mortal. The moment you apply godly attributes to someone then he will be called god or "إله" in Islam and that what christians did to Mary. So thats why Allah said Mary as god or "إله" here since Christians pray and ask help from her.
@@MegaTrueTalk Pope Francis prayer to Mary O Mary, you always shine on our path as a sign of salvation and of hope. We entrust ourselves to you, Health of the Sick, who at the cross took part in Jesus' pain, keeping your faith firm. You, Salvation of the Roman People, know what we need, and we are sure you will provide so that, as in Cana of Galilee, we may return to joy and to feasting after this time of trial. Help us, Mother of Divine Love, to conform to the will of the Father and to do as we are told by Jesus, who has taken upon himself our sufferings and carried our sorrows to lead us, through the cross, to the joy of the resurrection. Amen. Under your protection, we seek refuge, Holy Mother of God. Do not disdain the entreaties of we who are in trial, but deliver us from every danger, O glorious and blessed Virgin. ------------------- Say, "Who is it that can protect you from Allah if He intends for you an ill or intends for you a mercy?" And they will not find for themselves besides Allah any protector or any helper. -Surah Al-Ahzab, Ayah 17 Or have they taken other than Allah as intercessors? Say, "Even though they do not possess [power over] anything, nor do they reason?" -Surah Az-Zumar, Ayah 43
@@MegaTrueTalk Then why pope Francis ask protection from her? ( dead woman) ------ Or have they taken other than Allah as intercessors? Say, "Even though they do not possess [power over] anything, nor do they reason?" -Surah Az-Zumar, Ayah 43 Indeed, to Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth; He gives life and causes death. And you have not besides Allah any protector or any helper. -Surah At-Tawbah, Ayah 116
May Allah bless protect and guide sir Paul, not just because he is defending Islam, but because he is a voice of truth, he is doing even more than many muslims should do. May Allah reward him greatly in this life and the hereafter.
1- Very important and accurate information I really want to buy this book 2- Brother Paul, you are doing a very great job of giving people the spark to think with their minds that they have locked in a dark cave for years. 3- Many Muslims do not know such information and the Christians take advantage of this thing by casting flimsy suspicions on weak believers in order to make them bewildered. 4- You are really a good Muslim who searches books in order to guide people (God willing) and the most amazing thing about that is that you know a lot about the hadith of the Prophet. You are a rare man in this time.
Excellent brother Paul, if truly the virgin Mary peace be upon her is considered the "spouse"of the Holly spirit and mother of god then this hence means that"God the father" is not the original father of Jesus but s son of the third person of the Trinity and any claim of him being a "son of the father the first person a bastard son because his real father is the Holly spirit!! Let the Christians tackle that dilemma.
Mr. Paul, first of all I would like to thank you for these important videos. There is a similarity in the Qur’an by using the word “take” in Verse (45:23) " Have you seen he who has taken as his god his [own] desire" , and Verse (5:116) "And when Allah will say, "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah ?". indicating what you affirm that this does not necessarily mean declaring someone as god, but rather giving him the status of God by obeying him and adhering to his commands.
Excellent review in the issue of Tawhid which is the central core of Islamic monotheism. Infact if you look at the issue of Shirk( joining partners with Allah) , it has a very wide range of manifestations such that the Prophet (SAW) said shirk can be as subtle or inconspicuous as a dark ant on a dark rock in the dark night. So Allah has also said that inclining to ones desire can lead to shirk or as a god in chapter 45 verse 23.
Mashallah, very well described. Every clip Blogging Theology share with truth and with intentions of educating every one honest and true message surely will earn you best plaçe in hereafter.
Thank you , For a poor reader and researcher like me , i took it another way , i lived a while in Eastern Europe, I’ve seen people kneeing in front of resembling statue of the Purified and the chosen Maryam. Asking for protection and blessings. I’ve seen more (but no i hate long comments) then I realised the verse from Quran, Allah will never leave an excuse for those who will insist fall .
When a person stands in front of a statue of a dead person and ask it something to give him, definitely he considers the dead person is a God. This is what the Christians and others are doing regularly,
@Jomy Mathew Bro, kissing the black stone is an expressing of love and respect. It is like kissing your son. We , the Muslims, belief that the black stone does not harm or benefit, it just a stone from Paradise, Don't you love Paradise ?
Because Jesus is God and Lord. He is the king of kings and prince of peace. Mothers of Kings and Princes are called Queens. Mary is the mother of God the Son, Lord of Lords, and prince of peace so therefore she is appointed Queen of the universe/heaven. This does not mean in anyway that she is uncreated or divine at all. Only that she has the proper titles of respect and veneration for being the mother of our lord and savior.
Paul, I think a good topic you could make a video on is Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahab and his book Kitab-at-Tawhid (Book of the Oneness of Allah). Another topic would be on the 4 Sunni Imams Abu Hanifa (Nu'man-at-Thabit), Muhammad Ibn Idris- ash-Shafi'i, Malik Ibn Anas and Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (may Allah have mercy on them all). Will you ever start a series by the way? Maybe a playlist on Quranic history and what top orientalists and scholars say.
@Loki Loki perhaps you should listen to this video first... y'all trying to project your idolatry on us, it's not working for you. idk why you keep insisting. show me where kissing a black stone forgives your sin
@Loki Loki truth is i cannot show you in the bible that Mary is a deity, but i cannot show you either where Jesus told people to worship him alongside or instead of God. That's the problem though. You guys invented a religion that's NOT in your bible. Goes against everything Jesus taught in the bible. So no, i cannot show you that in the bible, just as much as you cannot show me Jesus claiming to be God in the bible.
@Loki Loki what i love about christians is every single time they fail to act as "christians"... preach one thing and show true colors, Jesus wouldn't be proud. how can you ever prevail with something you don't even believe in ;) I do have a clue about your book. In fact, i'm going to quote who I imagine you will be one day 21 “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. 22 On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ 23 And then will I declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you workers of lawlessness.’ Touching stones does nothing. Prove your claim.
@Loki Loki call me Muhammadan if you want, you think it's an insult, at least i cannot call you a Christian ;) everything will testify against or for you on the day of judgment. Your limbs, your eyes, the earth you sinned on, etc... We pray our judgment is easy inshallah
بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَٰنِ الرَّحِيمِ رَبَّنَا لَا تُزِغْ قُلُوبَنَا بَعْدَ إِذْ هَدَيْتَنَا وَهَبْ لَنَا مِنْ لَدُنْكَ رَحْمَةً ۚ إِنَّكَ أَنْتَ الْوَهَّابُ (8) [Who say], "Our Lord, let not our hearts deviate after You have guided us and grant us from Yourself mercy. Indeed, You are the Bestower. (8) Aal-'Imran
@@srnp0007 no he is but it's not fair to punish someone without them doing it yet,if he punished you without you even doing it yet,that means that you didn't do it and thus he wronged you which he never does
@@srnp0007 yes,he just gives you a situation and then it's your choice what you are gonna do with that,whether you will do the right thing or not he only gave you a situation,that is his choice but you choose what to do with it
Thanks Paul for another extraordinary important topic you have raised. by the way, what happened to your book shelves used to be behind you ?!! We like to see you among all those books
PSA: If you're worshipping or praying to anyone that was alive and now dead you're doing idol worship whoever it is. Isa or Ali or whoever. There is only one God.
No true Muslims worships or pray to Hz. Imam Ali or Hz. Prophet Muhammad. Only some Sufis and ghulāt/ghulaw among some Shi'a Muslims do this, and if they do this, they fall outside Islamic orthodoxy. Mainstream Sufis and Shias do not do this, and it is forbidden in numerous Shia and Sufi books to pray to anyone or thing besides God. However, that being said, I must disagree with your wording of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and Hz Ali (KAW) being dead in the sense that you seem to argue that the Prophets and righteous ones are somehow spiritually dead and unconscious in the grave. The Qur'an makes very clear in two ayāt that the blessed martyrs (shuhada) are alive with their Lord (Rabb), so obviously since Hz. Ali is one of the most revered figures for all Muslims except for the accused Nusaybis, and he was also martyred, then this applies to him---he is alive in the barzakh, in what exact form Allahu alim, Allah knows best. Likewise this also applies to all the Holy Prophets of Allah (SWT), may His peace and blessings be upon them all. Since all Muslims believe that the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) jas the highest afdhal (rank) and maqam (station) of any of the prophets, then obviously any liveliness or consciousness that we would apply to Hz. Ali or any of the Prophets before Muhammad (SAW) logically applies to Prophet Muhammad, too. It is the mainstream, orthodox position of all major ulama of Ahlus-Sunnah wa Jamaa (Sunni Islam) as well as all Shia schools that the Holy Prophets *are* spiritually alive and conscious in the grave-life (barzakh). One can and should love and respect all the Prophets, the Imams, righteous Companions, and the Awliyya'uLlah, but one must be aware that while Allah (SWT) can indeed accept intercession from any of these holy men and women (as the Holy Qur'an says "Who may intercede with Allah except by His Permission", the word being bidhniLlah in Arabic), it is only by Allah's Permission that any intercession may benefit the person. It is a very ancient and mainstream Sunni (as well as Shia) belief that one may ask Allah for something, be it forgiveness, mercy, guidance, or a specific thing, through the wasila (means) of the love Allah has for a particular Prophet, Imam, Companion, or Wali. One can say "Ya Allah, by the love You have for Prophet Muhammad and his Family and Companions, forgive me/bless me/strengthen me, etc." This is totally fine. One may also address any of the Prophets, Imams, or Awliyya'uLlah and ask their aid *bidhniLlah*, by Allah's grace and permission. If one believes the Prophets, Imams, and Companions are utterly spiritually dead and unconscious in the barzakh, then one can be labelled as a heretic from an orthodox Sunni as well as a Shia view.
Isa AS is not dead... but the Christians say he is dead but worship him. But he will be raised from the dead.. By God. But they also say God is Jesus... so he raised himself? idk Allah swt bless you all
@@abdullaal-obaidi833 Jesus is not dead. He’s been alive for thousands of years. If he’s a mere human, how can he be alive? Only the holy is in heaven. Jesus is in heaven. Jesus is your Lord. Turn to him now, repent before he comes back as the JUST RULER/JUDGE as your Quran confirms. Only God can JUDGE! Wake up.
@@carolineshenouda8453 he is alive because Allah SWT saved him fulfilling the prophecy in the old testament jesus was raised to Allah SWT why can't he be alive as a human Allah SWT can save who he wishes and jesus pbuh wil return to fight the Antichrist
I've met some1 of Greek origin from Greek orthodox Christianity who claimed that he does not worship Jesus but that they worship Mary bcos she is the mother of God. I found that so strange. Most Christians worship Jesus, but here was an entire religion worshipping his mother.
Thank you very much br. Paul for another fascinating passage explanation. Here I would like to say that Quran also negates any kind of trinity which were made throughout history whether it includes Mary or the Holy Spirit.
@@agadirand4four347 ... and allah AKA mohammed thought those were the true Christians😂😂😂 BTW "Collyridianism (or Kollyridianism) was an alleged Early Christian heretical movement in pre-Islamic Arabia, whose adherents apparently worshipped the Virgin Mary, mother of Jesus, as a goddess." did you catch that "pre islamic arabia" .........."arabia" who was also an arabian????🤨🤨
@@agadirand4four347 that still doesnt explain why an omniscient being cant differentiate b/n a heresy and a widely accepted religion for instance if i wanted to say christianity is wrong i wouldn't criticize mormonism that would make me either iggnorent or a liar or i have a lack of knowledge so respectfully which one is allah in the qur'an from the options i gave or if i left any explain them to me BTW all paul (bloging theology) did was mental gymnastics he didnt address the argument directly his argument was, "there were some people who worshiped mary" and "some catholics worshiped mary (which is false)"
@@agadirand4four347 you must be confused which people do you consider as christians?? the mormons, the johova wittness, Collyridians or the actual christians (orthodox, catholic and protestant's) i dont think you know what christianity is?? can you tell me what you think christianity is and what you think they believe??
@@agadirand4four347 nope you are wrong they use a different bible that is a different topic, so please stop changing the subject engage my argument allah says in the quran "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah?" when we dont believe this and dont say he is talking abt all christians b/c no christian today believes this
This point that you have explained can also be taken as a refutation of Dr Yasir Qadhi's verdict that those who call upon dead saints should not be accused of Polytheism as they do not believe that those saints are divine in and of themselves. - just as how christians do not see mary as possessing divinity yet have taken her as an intermediary between them and God and exualted her in such a way that Allah has referred to their action as taking her as a God besides Allah.
To anyone who don't know yet, that verse is talking about COLLYRIDIANISM (one of Christian sect). They worship her as goddess. And it was one of big sect in pre-islamic ARAB.
@@LilBitDistributist Also search google image and you’ll see people on their knees praying to the statues of Mary. You people do it so often you don’t realize your actions of idolatry and how pagan you people have been. This is what pope Francis prayed to Mary recently knowing full well that Mary is dead and can’t help you or anyone else. Idolatry that’s what it is. Prayer O Mary, you shine continuously on our journey as a sign of salvation and hope. We entrust ourselves to you, Health of the Sick. At the foot of the Cross you participated in Jesus’ pain, with steadfast faith. You, Salvation of the Roman People, know what we need. We are certain that you will provide, so that, as you did at Cana of Galilee, joy and feasting might return after this moment of trial. Help us, Mother of Divine Love, to conform ourselves to the Father’s will and to do what Jesus tells us: He who took our sufferings upon Himself, and bore our sorrows to bring us, through the Cross, to the joy of the Resurrection. Amen. *We seek refuge under your protection, O Holy Mother of God. Do not despise our pleas we who are put to the test and deliver us from every danger, O glorious and blessed Virgin.* How can she deliver you or the Pope from anything when she is powerless and has been dead for two thousand years. Paganism is what it is.
May Allah swt bless you my brother.You was blessed by having an analytical personality that concentrate on the meanings and explanation of hidden meanings .May be this was the reason you was guided to Islam ,coz you have analytical personality without being biased
After over 35 years of studying for my own Creed... I heard some Catholic do take Mary as a Mother of.. Being miraclious give birth to Jesus * Peace be upon him *.. Divine Breath.. I never heard we as Muslims believe or understand anything like what's mention here.. We believe She is The Best Woman of her Time... Quran Clearify we Believe in His Unique Oneness.. Surat Al Iklas.. Also the Arabic language is Preserved in Books.. For anyone who like to know the Rootwords of those Ayah mentioned..
I have always loved your commentry on topics u choose. But in this video your pointing out how people create their gods from the Book "Quran" was epic. I wanted to kiss your hand when I heard
Just discovered your channel and I have to say, LOVE listening to you speak! You are incredibly passionate and knowledgeable on these topics. Thank you so much for making these videos ♥️
They distorted their books, trying to change the meaning of the words of the Qur’an. So Allah keep Quran by him self, So I tell numbers that don't lie, *speed of the earth’s rotation around its axis = 463m/s preserves the Qur’an himself. The repetition of the word earth in the Qur’an = 463 times = the speed of the earth’s rotation around its axis = 463m/s😄 Allah is the greatest The period of the moon = 27 days. = The number of the word Moon repeated in the Qur’an = 27 times = The number of words in the verse 5:97 is =27، 😄 5:97➡️Allah created the Kaaba so that we know that He is the One *who created the universe⬅️ So Qur'an not distorted 😄 Allah is the greatest
@@kingofdetroit358 ewe how stupid they are that is so horrible may the dirty hands of these evil authors be cursed and cutted off how dare them them to manipulate the message of God and insult the prophets of God... how low they are 😤😤🤨🤨
@Jomy Mathew in Jewish scriptures that Christianity translated to fit Roman pagan ideas n glue in there NT, it says if anyone dies a embarrassing way like hang in a tree or cross naked, means they are a curse to God. So that means all Christians think Jesus was a false prophet n a curse to God. Y did they glue the Jewish scripture in their NT? Because they knew it had no validity so they stole n glued it in the front of their NT. The rabbis n anyone that knows Hebrew, for 2000 years have proven Christianity is false. Chriatianty is actually the most false religion ever created. Hinduism at least created there own thing, but Christianity stole another scripture n glued it in there book. #jewsforjudaism #outreachjudaism have done a great job exposing this false Roman pagan religion.
This kind of Bid'ah was refuted by our scholars (may Allah have mercy on them) Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Abdul Wahab and the Salaf. Speaking of the Salaf, I think something very interesting/eye-opening you could do Paul is make a playlist on the Salaf, who they were and their beliefs.
There is no misunderstanding whatsoever in the Quran about the worship of Mary or the Trinity in Christianity. Protestants and Unitarians do not worship Mary. All other Christian sects do. I heard Catholic monks and Coptic and Roman Orthodox priests WORSHIP Mary in their prayers and hymns on YT and in person.
Amazing video Sir. But I would really like to share some insight on the point you have made at 07:15, indeed it is “deep stuff”. Because Quran 4:116 “ Indeed, Allah does not forgive association with Him, but He forgives what is less than that for whom He wills. And he who associates others with Allah has certainly gone far astray.” And Islamic Scholars have greatly written on this subject and still this as a particular subject “shirk-association” has a lot of significance, in the sense that it is greatly discussed and debated. Even within Muslims there are sects which are basically due difference of opinion because it is not easy how u separate God from the whole Universe that he has set in motion (Nizam-e-Qudrat or the nature of nature) well I can’t explain that in English due to lack of words. But Quran explains this phenomenon, as it always does by setting two extremes or duality model for our comprehension so at one extreme Quran denounces those who worship idols and make idols of the saints of God and on the other hand Quran mentions : Quran 42:23 “Have you seen he who has taken as his god his [own] desire, and Allah has sent him astray due to knowledge and has set a seal upon his hearing and his heart and put over his vision a veil? So who will guide him after Allah ? Then will you not be reminded?“ Indeed deep stuff, May Allah help us all in making things simpler and understandable and May Allah guide us all. Thank you so much for sharing such insights, may Allah reward you with the best of rewards. Amen.
Hey sir, Israel Biblical studies are putting an ad on your video. It is my first encounter with that ad. But I suspect others might be also getting that ad. There is a way to remove certain advertisers from your channel. If you can do that, then please do it.
Further note It is said that at the time of Mecca’s conquest, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), ordered to remove all the pictures inside of Kaaba but when he reached at the pictures of “Jesus Christ “(PBUH) and his mother Lady “Mary”, he ordered the pictures no to be removed , is it true or not?
the concept and term of idolatry in Islam is different from other religion, and this is where the Christian misunderstanding the accusation. Looks.., simply asking and obeying a king too much already falls to idolatry without declaring him a god. But from Islam point of view, it's already putting some one in the same level of God.. Because you give them attribute which only belongs to god. Even for something which seems less significant than that. For example. for a muslim, where he should perform salat in a certain time. But then his girl friend says that he shouldn't perform salat. If that muslim obeys the girl, that's already falls to idolatry.., even putting his girl above Allah. He obeys the girl to rebel toward Allah. The same the jews and nasharas did in the past. They forbid what Allah allows, and they did what Allah forbid them to do, by changing the rule and the law. So to those who follow this people of books (monks) who changing the law is already falls to idolaty. They follows the monks and abandon Allah. Now back to accusation about putting Mary as god beside Allah. Simply by glorifying her meanwhile abandoning what Allah tells them to do and what they shouldn't do, that alone already putting Mary above Allah. Basically, they mock Allah by glorifying others. And it doesn't have to be in the term of God literally. but substantially, they indeed put Marry in the condition similar to idolatry. Even saying Mary as a wife for Allah, remember they also said that son god and the father god is Allah as one, and now marry is the mother. what are you calling that except putting marry in the same level with Allah. if their logic is still healthy, they should realize, by saying the son god and father god as one, they are saying Mary is the mother of Allah. There's no fitnah greater than that. Accusing Allah to have a wife, to have a son which also himself at the same time and having a mother which also his wife in the same time. He is the son and he is the father, so Marry is the mother and the wife of god at the same time. how could some one so dumb to come up with such crazy idea and there are people who are far dumber believing and worshipping such kind of god??!
Benar pak, sebenernya saya juga mempelajari ke kristenan dan mohon maaf menurut saya mereka menyembah petinggi gereja bukan Tuhan. Saya beranalogi begini juga karena bingung bible mereka sendiri mereka langgar dan perintah paus mereka patuhi. Kalau anggapan mereka paus adalah rasul justru ini tambah membingungkan, analogi sederhananya kenapa rasul mengubah kitab suci pemberian tuhan?
Narrated Mu`adh bin Jabal: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "O Mu`adh! Do you know what Allah's Right upon His slaves is?" I said, "Allah and His Apostle know best." The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "To worship Him (Allah) Alone and to join none in worship with Him (Allah). Do you know what their right upon Him is?" I replied, "Allah and His Apostle know best." The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Not to punish them (if they do so).
The Roman Catholics not only refer to Mary as the Mother of God but they actually worship her. When you go to their churches you the statue of Mary along side the statue of Jesus and they go on their knees before them crying, asking for what ever need before them, which is an act reserved for GOD and GOD only. So actually and physically, the Christians worship Jesus and Mary. I have not seen or heard where the Holy spirit is physically worshipped. Though it is a sin to say trinity but it is a biggest sin to actually kneel down before the statue of Jesus and Mary and ask for forgiveness of your sin, help and all acts reserved for GOD and only GOD. NOTE: THIS IS THE CONCLUDING PART OF MY EARLIER SUBMISSION WHICH I MISTAKENLY PRESSED THE SEND BUTTON.
You are such an amazing person. You always explain both side of the argument wich shows how confident you are in proving islam right.inshallah you become more famous and enlighten more people
Bro, You are the true apostle paul. Vs Not the liar pauls was apostle Romans 3:7. 7. For if the truth of God hath more abounded through my lie unto his glory; why yet am I also judged as a sinner?
