Matt Walsh is amazing. Although he may not agree with me being a gay man, I still think his principals are amazing and think they way he stands with the principals no matter what is something to aspire to.
Being a gay man is not the problem. The problem is when Any man tries to say they are the same as a "biological woman" and inserting themselves into what is and has always been the demarcation of male vs. female attributes we all instinctively know. i.e. sports, bathrooms, changing rooms ...
That's what an orthodox Catholic man does. Unfortunately many as they say are cowardly right now. I also greatly admire Matt for holding his ground and standing in the TRUTH.
From listening to Matt fairly often, I don’t think he has an issue with gay people. He tends to not describe people as a monolith. I’m sure Matt would be more inclined to get a long with a rational gay man than the heterosexual harpees at pride parades
Matt needs to have Kellie Jay Keen on his show. Her campaign slogan is “woman: adult human female”. Matt should acknowledge her work. Kellie has been fighting this for at least 6 years. There are many women who have been speaking out against gender ideology and they are getting no media coverage. Come on Matt-invite them on your show.
The APA doesn't support the anti-trans position, so what actual credible majority research actually is against gender identity that isn't anecdotal? I get that a person can be lead astray by the wrong Doctor, or getting a surgery that shouldn't (some need psychiatry), but I've seen enough to realize this is a very complex issue without a blanket answer.
I am so confused about the whole situation...but I ask myself this, if you wanna have sex men with men why do you need to look like a women and vice versa to do so and why are trans men attacking women who they claim to feel like or are. To me it's some type of mental confusion. Trans women hate women but wanna look like them...hummm!!!
Personally, I think consenting adults can do what they like in the privacy of their own home. I do draw the line when some of this encroaches on womens rights. Angry transvestite men who hate women are out there. It’s called “Transmisogeny” and yes, very real and disturbing.
Actually that's not the end point either. The end point is the destruction of our society via the destruction of the family and the rights and responsibilities of parents concerning their children.
Almost 20 years ago when this issue hit our family we started a web site and wrote books. People told us we shouldn’t address this issue but care about some other issue! Who are they to say what others should care about??? It’s crazy to say that to anyone. It’s only because it makes THEM uncomfortable.
Yesterday I googled...well, let's just say curiosity got the better of me, re: the physical reality of "sex change" and if anything, actually seeing with my own eyes what goes into it made the whole concept seem both tragic and criminal.
Thank you, Matt, & gentleman. On an upside, our pastor has addressed this from the pulpit. This issue has already affected some of the parents’ children in our church. I am the children’s church director & have had a special meeting with my parents & grandparents about this, also. I have been to school board meetings with our parents in defending Truth. I also belong to a local child advocate group fighting this evil
What instruction did they give? Religious people have done more harm than good to the LGBT Community, if someone actually does real research, without just anecdotal examples. Youth have been hurt by Christian reparative therapy for example which is why Exodus International closed. Which credible medical or mental health association supports this position? zero I know of.
Re: cell phone and kids. Not only did we not let out kids have cell phones we didn’t have cable TV, (they are 26 & 28yrs now) and they both thank us now… and they were really upset they didn’t have what other kids had.
So many LGB people distance themselves from the TQ+ You need to make that point. in the UK a black lesbian lawyer has taken Stonewall an insidious lgbtq+ org to court. You want more supporters you need to work with more people holding your view that a woman is a biological adult human female. That includes many more that your typical audience.
I think it's good that they decided not to bring religion into the documentary. This is an issue that a lot of atheists like myself are concerned with as well. I wouldn't even call myself a conservative(though I certainly lean right on some issues)and I think there are a lot of people like me out there that can see that this gender ideology is something to be concerned about. It was smart to market the documentary to the widest array of politics/philosophy as possible.
@@Kyrana4102 the concept of "Good/Evil" is one of a theistic nature, but it is based upon what we can perceive in the natural world as good or bad. You don't need a deity for either good or bad things to happen. Added to that, what is good for one group may be bad for another.
There was a Douglas Murray article in Unherd a few months ago which noted that many American liberals such as Bill Maher and Bari Weiss can see the problems with the contemporary left, but don't want to start calling themselves "conservative" because the word is too closely identified with religion.
Many women are fighting this. The media is silencing us, the men with large platforms need to interview women about how it is affecting us.. Please start with Kellie Jay Keen, she is brilliant! She is the one who came up with the slogan Adult Human female in the first place.
If, God forbid, the obituary is ever written on the United States and our brilliant Constitution it will say something like: And the people forgot the words of the Sir Edmund Burke's of history who foretold that 'All evil requires is good people do nothing to stop it.'
I’m not a conservative and I would ask how much conservatives are willing to reach out to people who aren’t conservatives but who might be sympathetic to their points of view?
I have found conservatives very willing to dialogue. In fact I find myself following more conservative sites and channels now than liberal or progressive ones.
@@pathacker4963 yes, I’m the same I guess. I just don’t want these guys to forget that it’s not just conservatives who are listening. I’m not sure they realize.
Insightful, thanks. I agree, as a father and a longtime grade school teacher, that the need for authority - Authority - is central. As is the loss of it to the degradation of American culture. Don’t call your son ‘dude’. Call him ‘son’. Let it remind you of the Son. There’s too many damn Peter Pans flying around.
Amen...My Mother and Father were still the Authority no matter how old I got. My Mother would remind me I will never be too old for her to reprimand me. It's a good thing.
The jezebel spirit has deeply come over men in America. I’m encouraged to see you point it out. It’s so important for elder men to raise up the younger generations of future men. Single women try hard to raise their boys into men but it’s not the same as when a man raises a boy. I worry manhood is a dying breed 💔
Rod, my husband and I read your book aloud on a road trip. It was life-changing in encouraging us to form and participate in more small groups as an exercise of freedom. (We have been more reclusive lately.) Plus all the other good ideas in your book. I marked and made notes on every page. I ordered an extra copy for my Little Free Library with readers waiting for it. My 91 yr old Mom is reading mine and loving it. Thank you. Need courage.
I'm encouraged to know there are two married people out there, who actually read aloud to each other! Wow! You must be an awesome couple! God bless you both!
I find myself in a funny position bc I don't feel like belonging to any particular political group. I used to be a liberal, but what I'm observing what they are doing now I can NOT support them. On the other hand when I hear from the conservative side how smart and visionary is Trump I feel sick. One thing is for sure I support wholeheartedly your view presented in this program. And because of that, I subscribed today to your channel.
Trump isn’t the definition of conservatism anymore than CRT and radical gender theory really defines all liberals. I am 72 and old hippy lady and I find I can talk with conservatives more than democrats. I will never vote democrat again, but I probably won’t vote for Trump either. I might if it was the only way to stop this insanity.
I think the vast majority are reasonable people who want to live together in harmony and peace and cannot accept the denial of biological reality plus gender ideology on the progressive Left and the QAnon etc hysteria in the far right. Most people want sanity and a balanced acceptance of reality without the extremes. Unfortunately the internet has encouraged extremism and ideological rabbit holes of all kinds.
Feel exactly the same way. It is extremely troubling to see that conservatives are blind to thier own delusion/cultish behavior, but point it out to others. Have always supported the gay community, still do. This is NOT that. This is predatory Trans Activists preying on the most vulnerable in society. It's heartbreaking, terrifying and sad.
🇬🇧 A question and a point 1. When a child claims to be trans is the father generally non affirming and is the mother affirming? Does this change if the child is male or female? 2. The start of hormones etc is the start of a biological war in the child's body. I have seen evidence of a child's body (MTF) trying to reject these drugs by trying to boost testosterone back to normal levels and suppress estrogen. The clinicians are using this child like a lab rat to destroy what his body is trying to do naturally. There is a chemical war going on and it's going to last his whole life and I suspect cause permanent damage. And finally. The fact any of this is a conversation is insane. I didn't think anything could be worse than flat-earthers. (Some) Humans are clearly de-evolving at breakneck speed to insanity perversion and oblivion.
Thank you all for producing this engaging program. The reason why most priests, pastors and laymen and lay women don't confront the spirit of the age is because of fear. Fear of losing their vocations and livelihoods, and their reputations being ruined by woke leaders and employers, and more generally the woke wob.
Indeed. The opposite of faith is fear. Without faith, it is impossible to please God. So what does that say about the leaders of so-called Christendom?
If you're looking around for "unstated goals" for all of this confusion, you should probably stop to consider whether our overseas opponents (who absolutely have an interest in our civilizational collapse, or civil strife) might be egging this on.
As an atheist I can say that Matt made the right decision keeping God out of the documentary. Not everyone believes in God, nor is it necessary to see the blatant truths the moive has exposed. This film is going to be instrumental toppling the tower the extreme left has built. Great job Matt!
i would prefer the three of you to name names when referring to christian leaders needing to step up. ive heard opposing views for a lot of secular ideologies from protestants and catholics. i have never once seen or heard anything opposing anything from any orthodox leader, ever in my life about anything.
The corruption of language does not make it impossible to think clearly. (How often have you thought of a concept, for which you can't think of the word?) The corruption of language makes it impossible to communicate with others. It's Babel, or the absence of the Holy Spirit, if you want to put it in religious terms.
I am a preacher and I discussed this stuff with our congregation especially with our youth. This is detrimental to our youth and it's an Abomination but the left side and some people from the right side supports it it's demonic. Matt Walsh I am so glad that you hit this topic. I love that what you did with this. And I'm a African-American male and I am a minister. And we do get this topic just like a pastor Apostle Gino Jennings, he hits this topic very hard. Keep doing what you doing guys love you
Actually I'm grateful for this transgender thing that's going on. It's made me research on the physical and emotional differences between men and women. I've been able to gather a lot of information about the differences between the two sexes. All this has established and proven that what is written in the Bible is very true. God made us male and female and He made us in His own image. We can never change that fact no matter how many surgeries we have and no matter how many drugs we take. Our manhood or our womanhood is written in our very DNA which was ordained by Almighty God from the very beginning of our existence. This transgender debate has actually drawn me closer to my Creator rather than the opposite. It's reiterated the fact that we live in a fallen world where humans are in active rebellion against their Creator. But no matter how much they try to change what God has created, they will never succeed and they'll just end up making a fool of themselves. All they have succeeded in doing is proving the sovereignty of Almighty God.
@@morbidmanmusic Believing in the Bible is not delusional. Also, you're wrong. A lot of people do care about God and faith and the Bible. The Lord Jesus changed my life and is changing and transforming lives on a daily basis. He is very real to those who know Him and have a relationship with Him .
‘Western’ ideology has promoted the idea we can be & do any thing we can imagine, this wild imaginings is a wonderful Fantasy but truth is physical life has limitations, my good Mother used to say “we live in a world if wonderful possibilities’ yes thats true, though the limitation is they are not guarantees, you explore your possibilities and make what you can of them, we need to start affirming the reality of the limitations we live with in physical life, we are limited to the race, ethnicities, gender we are born into, these are binary, immutable. Social status, education, career, creativity etc. we can build or develop for our selves depending on ambition & cognitive ability, life must be tempered with the obvious limitations we live with as a species.
As laymen and followers of Christ, we cannot use the lethargy of the clergy as an excuse not to evangelize the culture. It is about time we laymen chart a path for our children and grandchildren. Do you have any idea of the quality and depth of seminary formation that is obtainable? We laymen have to rise up, form ourselves and encourage each other. During the Arian crisis, most prelates were Arian. So counting on the clergy is not always a safe bet in a time of crisis. What is important is our individual witness to the Gospel and our bold effort to evangelize the culture with or without encouragement from the clergy.
My church (ACNA Anglican) on the North Shore of Massachusetts refuses to deal with these issues and actually rebuked me for raising them publically. This same church split in 2020 over CRT and Social Justice and yet STILL pretends like, "yes it is an important topic but the people are still hurting" and therefore ignores it and will not make a stand. As if these people were a bunch of weak children unwilling to hear Truth. Ridiculous!
"Why do you care so much?" is the defensive pose of repressive tolerance. What they mean by that is: we can relentlessly criticize everything on the Right, but you cannot criticize a single thing on the Left.
Hey guys! So I love all of this and I'm down with it. Loved the Documentary. However, I did want to offer up some encouragement! Our pastor has gone down to the basics. He has not ignored this topic in his sermons, he has not blasted hell and Firestorm type stuff but he has kindly but firmly shared what the Bible has to say about how God created us male and female. He has been very specific and even in the last couple years he has taken us through the Bible.... Still going!! Giving us the whole story. So, I know while some churches are really shying away from it. We know that it is a pervasive thing in our culture and we are not shying away from it.
It’s so disgusting that Matt and his family have to fear for their safety. Funny how the other side wants acceptance yet they threaten people who voice opinions they don’t like. Just think back to things you did preteen and teenagers. Most of the people I know shake their heads and wonder how we even survived in one piece !
"You have to be willing to put it on the line, to talk about this" TDW and PV are striking blows against cancel culture, giving a place to land for people willing to stand up and speak. There need to be a whole lot more places like this. Could TDW publicize these places, and to give people more confidence to stand up?
I very much enjoyed this talk. I agree that it would be beneficial to limit or not allow childrens access to cell phones, television and internet. But how can that be accomplished. If they cant access harmful information on their own, their friends are very willing to say "hey guys, look at what I found on the internet". Adults and especially children are influenced by peer pressure. Theoretically, children can be raised to be independent and not be so influenced by others, but children inevitably rebel as they get older. How can this be done without causing rebellion? I am reminded of a neighbor with a 7 year old diabetic daughter. The parents explained over and over, as they injected her with insulin, that eating sweets could be deadly for her. Try stopping a child from sneaking sweets when everyone around her is enjoying them. I believe that parents can be the role model by not eting sweets. Not Using the internet or cell phones. Not teaching their children to do as i say not do as i do. I would love having "realistic" solutions that work. I dont have any.
I only have one question because they never talk about sodom and gomorrah and give as an example what happened and start from it and give as an example what is happening with all this confusion
Kathleen stock in the UK talks about how, as a lesbian, she was being affected by the trans community. As a teacher, She was harassed out of her college by students, for stating that a trans man is not a woman.
"She thinks she's a wolf" She's turning back to animism, to make sense of persona development. It's not that mysterious, although it is atavistic by a few thousand years.
Right. This is exactly what is happening with the rampant revival of relativism that no one seems be able to name, despite its origins in ancient Greece. Everyone who subscribes to the idea that "there is no objective Truth" seems to think it's some philosophical idea they just invented yesterday. No. It was Protagoras who thought it up. Circa 450 BCE. Back then, though, they were smart enough to to understand stupidity when they heard it.
Interesting discussion gentlemen with many points worthy of comment. Matt I recently became a subscriber. I am a Christian, I am going to guess you Rod and Kale also claim to be. I say claim because I think its important to realize that many believers are in reality not Christians. In fact, that would be my first comment/question what is a Christian? Maybe you could make that documentary next? After all it might be a more important question to ask. It was said here if we can’t answer the question what is a woman, we are looking at the end of this civilisation? I think you’re right but then we knew all along it was going to end didn’t we? When I was younger and just beginning to study eschatology, I wondered how the anti Christ could every take the entire world under his spell? Why wouldn’t they see him for what he was, there were so many clues, so many ways to know him for who and what he truly was??? Well God has given me an answer. There was also a remark made concerning kids and phones and a frustration with other Christian parents? You know when people read not all that say to me Lord, Lord, enter but those that do the will of My Father…. many replace will with the law? This is the will of the Father who sent Me, that of all He has given Me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up at the last day. Keeping a phone away from a child is not going to save that child....salvation is going to save that child. Understanding the truth of how and what that is might be usfule. Look at this word ALL in Yashua's next statment? All that the Father gives Me will come to Me, and the one who comes to Me I will by no means cast out. The simple truth is that many claim to be something they are not….Christian. I am not saying they are not believers I would agree most are but that doesn’t make you a Christian. Faith makes you a Christian. Many conflate faith and believing but they are misled. All that have faith do believe, but not all that believe have faith. In fact the belivier that come to believeing by faith belives diffrently; they believe in the heart, while those who come a diffrent way believe in the head. To answer my own question what is a Christian they are those that have received the gift of faith from the Father those called who also have responded to the call. Both the way and the means have been clarified by Paul but I find most are ignorant of that truth. You ask what is a woman disturbed I trust by the need for the question; this confusion is a natural progression of sin. You are seeing the later stages of the condition on a mind but I would not say bringing them back to a firmer grasp on reality is a cure. There are three basic wrong views of Christianity obviusly there are variations within those but the most common is some form of law keeping. There is always the caviate thay we will still sin. We cant be pefect but we will be trying to be. Its a bit Budist. You are the branch I am the vine. A branch isnt trying to make fruit. Its the outcome of a position just as transgenderisim is the fruit of a possition. The second view says yes its not me it all God its all Grace grace grace and its there for everyone. Hyper grace. The last view says yes its all God but its not for everyone its only the ones He chosses like chicens running around in the yard and the farmer reachs in and grabs a few. No reason to chose one over the other at least none anyone can see Calvanisim. Can I say to any that care; none of these is Christianity; None are biblical. This is getting long though so I will end. If any wnat to look at what Paul actuly taught I am happy to do so.
Suggested reading for response to Matt Walsh: "What is a Woman:" Is a Feature Length Exploration of Conservative Ignorance and Prejudice by Nathan T. Robinson, Current Affairs Magazine, 6/15/22
I am from England, Every time i get onto public transport, be it train, bus, or coach, whatever. All you see is young parents with their children like 18m -4yr old babies. their sitting with the youngsters putting a phone into their hands to watch cartoons, watching movies or playing games. While the parent is texting or talking on their phone, watching youtube ,twitter, Facebook, etc. and the parent is just a child herself. There is no communication at all except if the baby cries or asks for something, then all you hear is either just wait a minute, i'm busy hold on, or stop crying. It certainly should not be Children having Children. 21 is young enough. and maybe laws should be made that if you have children at a younger age they will be taken and either adopted or fostered until the parent or parents, are of age. Depending on their circumstances. I feel so sorry for the parent and child. That society is crumbling around us. But that's what happens when we ignore God and his Word. From the Beginning. John Ch1 Ch 3:16-21. I mean look, God made, Man & Woman=Male & Female. Mankind's Thought process is to make. Homosexuals, Lesbians, Bi Sexual, Drag Queens, Cross Dressers, Transsexuals, Transgender. What's next T.W.B.M and vice versa ( top woman bottom man) I am sorry but i love How God made Us. Do you think when you look at the planet and places its so beautiful well i can tell you it is not because just like us it is in a state of decay.its dying. because just like us it is corrupted with Our Sin. and only God can and has if we would believe in what his son did for us, that he paid the price for our salvation on the cross. Repent ( turn from your sin) and Trust in Jesus. John Ch8:10-32. as a start read Genesis Ch1-4, Psalm 1, Isaiah 53, John 3, Romans 8, But Mostly Read the Bible for Yourself with an ear to hear.
There was definitely a BORAT feel to the interviews. Who the hell is this guy, and is he SERIOUS about wanting to know what a woman is? La femme, qu'est-ce que c'est?
You all would be happy to know that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints has been on this since it issued its Proclamation on the Family in 1995. I understand that you are of different faith’s, but if you are interested to know what they have been doing to combat this on a religious level and specifically with the youth in church, our Elders would be very happy to speak with you. I enjoyed this immensely.
Why do the clergy not discuss gender issues? It comes from the top down. Catholic bishops do not want this spoken about from the pulpit. They don't even want abortion discussed. It's crazy.
Im 47 a have 3 grown sons 28 26 24 yrs and my only daughter is 11. So my granny and great Aunt may helped to raise my sister and I. So im very old school my kids know when I say no ill not bend it anything ele. I put my fo it diwn in this area. Get off the black morrow go get dirty in the yard use your imagine. I have a saying I have told all my kids. My grown sons thank me all the time for my saying as it was my actions too. It was if while im parenting you and you d is like two what you think its hate me it the time. Good then im doing my job right your not supposed to be my BFF now that happens when your grown and even then im still momma! Love ill your guys work.
excellent podcast. My 4 sons are in trades and have avoided all the gender theory, identity politics, and wackiness of universities... even though my wife and I are academics. I never planned it that way but I am grateful
Now is see why muslim punishment for Transgender is reasonable. My head is spinning to listen to their explaination. Cant imagine to have a discussion.
Something to think about is that this issue is seen as political issue and the church might lose a tax exemption status. Like if the church supports a president candidate, the IRS will come after your money.
This leads to the eventual degradation of Christian faith where liberal have been left to interpret what they want to believe about the love of God and forgiveness it is easy today to profess that the will of Go is to allow the academics to come up with their version of the love of JESUS.
When I played football it was still normal for a girl to walk in a locker room in cleats and walk out in heels. But even in the 90s in Cali there was already pressure on youth about being gay as young as junior high.
The one point the move didn't address is the pushing of this ideology in the schools. There are so many video clips of teachers grooming their students, I wish he would have had a section on that.
LOVE NOT THE WORLD NEITHER THE THINGS THAT ARE IN THE WORLD,IF ANY MAN LOVE THE WORLD THE LOVE OF THE FATHER IS NOT IN HIM,FOR ALL THAT IS IN THE WORLD (THE LUST OF THE FLESH AND THE LUST OF THE SEES AND THE PRIDE OF LIFE )IS NOT OF THE FATHER BY IS OF THE WORLD AND THE WORLD IS PASSING AWAY AND THE LUST THEREOF
