Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves but lack understanding of it.
"Trivial difference exaggerated" "Do not preach hatred" "What is common between us is more, don't make small difference bigger than it needs to be" *Brilliant explanation, a must listen!*
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves but lack understanding of it.
@@MrARMOGHANHyou are right bro, On top of that, they created their own Towheed, in which they removed the name of our beloved prophet Mohamad's name. Can you check it deeply those towhead. Uluhiyah, Rubuwiyah, and Asmau-wasifat.
@@expertglow9588 Whether you believe Mawlid is a bid'ha or not, what is definitively wrong is to see the streets packed with people celebrating Mawlid while the Masjids are empty during Fajr.
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves but lack understanding of it.
From reading the comments, all I see is the immense love from all the commentators for our beloved prophet Muhammad صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم . It's the method of showing that love that is making us take sides
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves but lack understanding of it.
Agreed 100%. We have more pressing issues to address. The Mawlid debate needs to be put to bed. Especially, for Muslims in the West. Another pertinent lecture from YQ.
Thank you very much for a very enlightening lecture 😊 I am relatively new practising Islam. This has clarified a lot and helped me realise once again to remember that Allah SWT knows what is in my heart and not to concern myself with any differences. Alhamdulillah ❤Ameen
As Muslims we are suppose to forbid bad/evil and enjoin in good. So technically depending on the situation we may have to make a statement or take a stance and this concept of not focusing on difference becomes irrelevant.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves but lack understanding of it.
May Allah guide this brother. May Allah bring him back on understanding of quran and and sunna as he had some 10 years ago. My brother I am no aalim not even close to the student of knowledge but the time sahaba have ikhtilaaf like u mentioned Prophet Mohammad was alive and deen was not completed that's why. Now Allah has completed our deen now and there is no gunjayesh adding or deleting from islam. He is impressing people by using big words that's it.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
Jazak Allah Dr. Sahab, you have discussed one of the most sensitive question among the Muslims. Unfortunately, in Muslim countries, they do not care about academic understanding of Islam. We are allowed in this country to debate on every concept of our religion to make it more flexible for new generation to adopt and make their life beneficial. May Allah bless you and reward you for your struggle to strengthen the belief of Islam in upcoming generations. Your name and these lectures will stay for their consideration.
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Celebrating means different things for different cultures. We in cape town make this month special in learning more about our beloved prophet SAW. Nothing more. Jusr reciting more salawaat , more aware to our kids. Loving our Muslim brothers and sisters. No funny stuff. I personally attended 2 so far between magrib qnd esha. Leanring more about who HE IS. Khallas. You leave the masjied so refreshed seeing everyone trying their very best to implement a sunnah. Who ever else go little more extreme, i dont judge them. Let Allah be rhe judge. I rather let my kids sit in a moulid learning about our bekoved then watching movies and wasting time on social media. Allah knows best.
I'd rather not specify any time for it. It can be done in any time if we want to, even on the birth date of the prophet. It's no special day more than any other.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
He alway explain every topic in the most beautiful and comprehensive manner, this is deep knowledge. Exactly what we need because there is pure lack of comprehension and understanding among Ummah now. Jazakah’Lahu Khaeran
Not exactly. It is not “deep” knowledge; it is “beating around the bush “. Brother better search for Sheikh Saleh al Fawzan about mawlid. Get the correct answer from a REAL SCHOLAR!!!
Excellent message to share with the young Muslims. It’s about love for the Prophet saw and how one wishes to express that love. Well said we have more in common than differences.
“And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favour of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favour, brothers.” [3:103]
One of the most balanced analysis on the issue of Mawlid. Allah bless Sh Yasir and his family. We need to be blunt. The group called Salafi are the ones who create unnecessary havoc on this issue. They harass fellow Muslims on trivial issues We need to have scholars and thinkers such as Dr. Yasir to tell these bullies to stop. These bullies have done a lot of damage to us. We need to teach them to learn the idea of live and let live
"Bullies" = intolerance of tolerant Islam. "Unity" = broad church of Islam. Which one will maintain and uphold the purity & unadulterated Islam that the Prophet SAW left us with and which will open the door to a cherry-picked, lenient liberal ideology (barely passes as a religion)? The former is Islam and the latter is Christianity today, for this to remain in the future the vanguards of this Deen is Salafiyyah. The bluntness leads to the sanctity being intact, with the will of Allah SWT of course. The Deen isn't based upon ones desires or feelings, there is a strict doctrinal and legislative code to abide by, Salafiyyah (which is literally the methodology practiced by the first golden three generations of Islam), re-enforces this where others have lapsed or followed their desires. Alhamdullilah. Salafiyyah will always avail given its the Islam that Allah SWT and his Messenger SAW came with!
@@redman6790the groups calling them Salafi are doing sectarianism. Nobodoy in the golden generation called them Salafi or Ahle Hadith. So the name is bidah it self. Most of them act like they are superior then other muslims like the Brahmims do
@@taquilibriumcelebration of mawlid is a no.listen to his previous talks.doing such things for a single day to show love for our prophet s.a.w is a cop out.
@@muhammadridoy6366 Evidence that the Salaf are the golden generation to follow: Abdullah ibn Mas’ud reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The best people are those of my generation, then those who come after them, then those who come after them. Then, there will come people after them whose testimony precedes their oaths and their oaths precede their testimony.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 6429, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2533. Evidence that Mawlid isn't part of the Sunnah: Jabir ibn Abdullah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, would praise Allah in his sermon, as He deserves to be praised, and then he would say, “Whomever Allah guides, no one can lead him astray. Whomever Allah sends astray, no one can guide him. The truest word is the Book of Allah, and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The evilest matters in religion are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.” Source: Sunan al-Nasā’ī 1578 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Masha Allah I love my prophet and I celebrate maulid as my expression of garteful to Allah for the prophets birth and to reflect my progress for becoming a good ahlaq person even still far to our beloved prophet muhammad pbuh shalwat and slam for him
@Abdul-Salaam Alloh ﷻ need releigion ?Alloh ﷻ not even in need for anything, not only religion but everything that exist on this universe belongs to Alloh ﷻ even me, sorry brother Maulid is sunnatulloh it's the day when the one who picked by Alloh ﷻ as the final messenger was born to bring happy news for all minkind and jinn as rahmatanlil alamiin, celebrating by knowing his biografi and life is better cause he the only one perfect example how to run this life should be and the one who really understand Qur'an accurately, celebrating is not act of worshiping but as expression of happiness and grateful for me, because of his sacrificed in dawa I know islam and I know Alloh ﷻ in my life, shalawat and salam for him
@Abdul-Salaam btw to end this miss understanding I don't know where are you from and I don't know how you celebrate Maulid there, but what we do here is gathering at mosque hear about sirah Rosulillah Muhammad saw lecture from the sheikh longer than usual and do sholawat, so consider about what you saying and told if that activity is Haram, despite about history about Mawlid that some told it's inspired and start from Fatimiyah Dynasty or Shalahuddin al ayyubi for copying what Nasranian people do celebrating maulid of prophet Isa As - which in fact no one even know even famous historian or archeologist know when the prophet Isa AS was born
I am a neutral person and not from any sect. From what I have been reading and listening to the talks from ex Salafi’s like Yasir Qadi and Muhammad Hijab who have said that following Wahabism and salafi’s was blind following. They have openly said Mawlid is permissible from Qur’an and Sunnah. Why is it that Mawlid is celebrated by all across the world accept people with Wahabi mentality
@@sakhawattaj3905 same here, I'm not part of any sect but from many imam or sheikh that i've heard mostly they only said it's bid'ah. Some said swhy it's classified because it's bid'ah only by saying cuz prophet's and sahabi and tabi tabi'in didn't do it, and some there's no explanation from any hadist or Qur'an about it, first we should understand what for each terms and how it aplly, there are 10 Hadist or so that explain about bid'ah and according to mudhasin not all hadist can be understood the application of it with 3 methods need separates and long explanation about this, mawlid is only "birth time" it's not an Ied and the person that birth called "Mulud" all of it is sunatulloh no law on it no haram no halal, so think yourself if u are rejecting the mawlid of yourself or the prophets what is your already rejected ?, Read the Qur'an for carefully, Ibrahim As and Ismail AS they both pray for the birth of the prophets Muhammad SAW and they happy for it even far away before the prophets time coming their praying granted, prophet's isa AS also happy for the coming of the prophets Muhammd SAW even their separated 600 years away and I'm as his ummah not deserve and become gratefull at all for this sunnatulloh ? Read hadist prophets do celebrate his birth by fasting on his birth day not only once a year, the reason I won't guessing, Sahaba life in his era with him, do everything with him and me not even see him once, everyday mostly spent time for working why I can't be happy if in my country they a day off to respect the mawlid day, So it's better to go to party or do anything else that haram or sleeping more ? to fill that day ?, btw thera are many verse of the Qur'an and also hadist for this arguments matter, but I understand how it can become bid'ah and how it's not, but think rationally that's why Alloh granted us minds, if everything law decide by the shallow definition hadist (literally) almost all the thing what happen nowadays is bid'ah, for example we seeking information to gather more knowledge (ibadah) by youtube, also all the imam nowadays using microphone and sound system to spread da'wa (ibadah) which all of it not doing by the prophets, sahaba and tabi'in and many more, you name it, That not how to decide islamic law, there are many criteria that should meet after comparing side by side Al-Qur'an and Hadist, remember the point is no need to make it a conflict the both side arguments of why they should celebrate and not we should understand first and we can compare it by our own understanding relying to the Qur'an and Hadist about they arguments, and I don't think any side is wrong it's only matter of understanding and generalizing without knowing all facts
Mashaallah, Walhamdulillah. Barakallahu fi hayati Shaikh Yasir Qadi, Very important speech, This is how we all sunni muslim can unite . Wa tasimu bi hablillahi Jamiiaa, Walaaa tafarraqu. May Allah give Us the TAWFIK of understanding the difference of opinions and Show love towards each other.
Jazakallah shiekh, for this eyeopening thought 😢 about this sensitive issue. People are making eachother kafir on the small and trivial issues. May Allah forgive us all. Ameen
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
hadith in Sahih Muslim, al-Nasai and Abu Dawud, which says that when he (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays, he said: “That is the day on which I was born…”
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Don’t hate the person but hate the action. Separate the action from the person (individual). If u love the prophet u should practice what he and his closest companions did. The best of the three generation after the prophet Muhammad May Allah Peace and Blessings Be Upon Him.
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
@@MrARMOGHANH I think they do love the prophet because they follow the Sunnah of the prophet Mohammed (pbuh)..if you love the prophet you will follow his Sunnah as best possible as a sign of true love. But celebrating birthday and not following Sunnah properly is sign of weak love. So don't judge .you don't know what is in the heart Do you agree??
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
Alhamdulillah SubhanAllah. BarakAllahu feek shaykh. Our Lord glory be to Him has truly blessed you with wisdom beyond your years. 20 years ago i would never listen to Sh Yasir, his blessed transformation shows his true sincerity and loyalty to Allah swt and his Messenger salallahu alayhi wa salam. All the great ulema of the past had many many critics, it is no different today. May Allah increase you in khayr and ilm for the sake of the ummah of our master Sayyiduna Muhammad salallahu alayhi wa salam. Allahumma salli ala sayyidina Muhammad wa ala aalihi wa sahbi wa salam tasleema. May Allah swt allow us to love Him and his messenger with sincerity. JazakAllahu khayran. ❤
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh- Shaykh, This is my first ever comment on your videos(Please accept my apologies for any inaccuracies in my writing) Your knowledge and perspective , as well as your dedication to sharing Islamic principles, are truly remarkable. May Allah SWT reward you with His plentiful blessings for your persistent devotion to leading us in the correct direction. Your wisdom undoubtedly enlivens our hearts, and I and my family are grateful for the counsel you provide. JazakAllahu khairan Shaykh🙂
Mawlid innovation by shia Fatimid in Egypt in the year 362 by king irbil Prophet Muhammad's did not do it and he didn't encourage to do it in Surah hashar verse 7whatsoever messenger Muhammad's gives you take it and whatsoever he forbids you 😊abstain from it
I give you comparisoned the origin of birthday celebration is from pagan Greek in Europe third century after Jesus is gone the churches against birthday celebration so how can you celebrate maulid of Prophet Muhammad's s. a. w he himself didn't celebrate in fact 12 rabiul awwal the day he died and 9 of rabiul awwal the day he was born as authored by sheikh Abdulmmubarak fury Allah mercy on him. in his book raheequl maktum
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
@@expertglow9588 No mawlid celebration by prophet, peace be upon him No mawlid by sahaba No mawlid by tabi3ien No mawlid by tabi3 tabi3ien No mawlid by 4 aiemmah No mawlid by all great scholars Until one king celebrated it Now why you want me to celebrate
@@marzouklaili3228 Oh no! You are also one of shayateen until you do tauba. I think you have not read my comment. We can never be better than Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) even if we charity gold equal to Uhad mountain. The question is of permissibility and the answer is in affirmative.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Ya sheikh Yasir, despite many negative comments made specifically here, I will continue to listen you including but not limited to sheikh Omer Suleiman and Nouman Ali Khan. Many if not all the messages & evidences/facts you & them put across in your respective lectures are consistent across many other sheikhs & learned clerics not only in North America but also south-east Asia. Please continue with your lectures as you plus many of those I listened to had clearly demonstrated little if any fear from other than Allah s.wt plus your love of our Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. are in inspiration to me and many others. Thank you.
A very important reminder! The unity of the ummah is so much more important than the trivial differences. My parents are avid celebrators of the Mawlid. I personally do not agree with them but that doesn’t mean that I stop talking to them.
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this?
@@Peacefulbeing2 Yes, not as a "prescribed" ritual. A good ritual for attaining nearness to Allah can be done even if its not prescribed. Their is no harm in it rather Islam loves it. Dawateislami, a great religious organization, donated thousands of bottles of blood, for thousands of Thalassemia patients and others during peak covid days only and only to get nearness of Allah.
@@expertglow9588 bro Do you know how this much religions came in this world, atleast just look back how christians became Christians it also starts with small innovations then slowly becomes more important than primary acts in religion
Jazakallah khayr for thjs brillant speech. I guess that’s what I have been trying to say for over 10 days. It’s far worst to accuse each other of not being Muslims than it is to celebrate Mawlid or not. I knew you would not disappoint
Bwahabeez are yehoodi agents...they distance you from your own Prophet SallAllahualaihiwasallam... These dogs celebrate saudi day and are against celebrating Maulid of Aaqa Kareem SallAllahualaihiwasallam??? SallAllahualaihiwasallam
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah that is new sect is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez but lack understanding of it.
Debating very extensively and informatively about our religion enlightens everyone, and once you understand it in depth, hate among us goes through the window. Thank you Dr. QADHI for disseminating this lecture from different angles.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
It was terrific to understand that differences have existed ever since Sahabah and how it takes time to make a change. I highly recommend that Mr. Shaykh Sajjad Gul be concise and keep things short from a psychological standpoint related to attention timespan.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
Jazakellahu kheyr ya sheikh...please give us a lecture also on alwala walbara....we are confused as we live in non muslim majority country.baarakallahu fiik.
I don't celebrate Maulid and I've never done it. Sheik may Allah bless you immensely. I've never heard a lecture in my 49 years as this. Some of my parents practice maulid while some don't. Yet never have they argue or hate one another. The love they have for each other is nothing I've witnessed. May Allah accept their souls and forgive their trespasses
Brother, Rasoolullah sollallahi alayhi wasallam celebrated his own birthday every Monday by fasting. Adopt that Sunnah if you wish to honour our Master. The Nabi Muhammad sollallahi alayhi wasallam came to teach us the perfection of Good character.
There have been many mistakes in understanding the Prophet's hadith regarding the issue of heresy by saying that every act that was never done during the time of the Prophet was a heretical act of heresy and the perpetrator will be put in hell based on the following hadith: وإيَّاكم ومحدثات الأمور؛ فإنَّ كلَّ محدثة بدعة وكل بدعة ضلالة Meaning: Be careful of anything new, because every new thing is bid`ah and every bid`ah is heresy. [HR Ahmad No 17184]. Understanding this hadith can be wrong if it is not linked to other hadiths, namely: من أحدث في أمرنا هذا ما ليس منه فهو رد Meaning: Anyone who creates something new in our problem, which does not originate from it, will be rejected. [HR Al-Bukhori No 2697] The ulama explained that what is meant by أمرنا in the above hadith is religious matters, not worldly matters, because creations in world matters are permitted as long as they do not conflict with the Shari'a. Meanwhile, any creation in religious matters is not permitted. [Yusuf al-Qaradawi, Bid`ah in Religion, page: 177] Thus, the meaning of the hadith above is as follows: Whoever creates creativity by incorporating something that is not actually a religion, and then becomes a religion, then that something is something that is rejected. It can be understood that the bid`ah which is dhalalah (heretical) and which is mardudah (which is rejected) is bid`ah diniyah. However, many people cannot differentiate between religious amaliyah and religious instruments. It's the same with people who don't understand format and content, means and goals. Due to his lack of understanding, it was said that celebrating the Prophet's birthday was deviant, reading the Qur'an together was deviant and so on. even though the birthday celebration is only a format, the essence is offering prayers, reading the history of the Prophet's struggle, reciting verses from the Koran, praying together and sometimes filled with religious lectures where these kinds of actions are in accordance with the guidance of the Koran andHadith.And the lafadz كل in the hadith about bid`ah above is the general lafadz that is interpreted. In the Qur'an we also find several lafadz كل which are generally found in takhsis. One example is verse 30 of Surah Al-Anbiya`: وَجَعَلْنَا مِنَ الْمَاءِ كُلَّ شَيْءٍ حَي "And We made everything living from water." (QS al-Anbiya': 30) The word everything in this verse cannot be interpreted to mean that all objects in this world were created from water, but it must be interpreted as saying that some objects on this earth were created from water. because there are other objects that were created not from water, but from fire, as Allah says in Surah Ar-Rahman verse 15: وَخَلَقَ الْجَانَّ مِنْ مَارِجٍ مِنْ نَار "And Allah created the jinn from burning sparks." For this reason, not all heresies are punished as heresy and the perpetrators go to hell. Heretical heresy is bid`ah diniyah, namely adopting a religion that is not a religion. The celebration of the Prophet's birthday is not a heretical and prohibited heresy because the only thing that is new is the format and instruments. Regarding the law on birthday celebrations, As-Suyuthi in Al-Hawi lil Fatawi states the following editorial: "The original law of commemorating the birthday is a bid'ah that has never been cited by the pious Salaf who lived in the first three centuries, however, the commemoration of the birthday contains both good and its opposite, so whoever in commemoration of the birthday tries to do only good things and stay away from itthe opposite (bad things), then it is bid'ah hasanah." Al-Hafizh Ibn Hajar also said: And it has become clear to me that the basis for taking the Mawlid commemoration is based on thabit (Saheeh) propositions. Sayyid Muhammad bin Alawi al-Maliki al-Hasani, said: "That in fact celebrating the birthday of the Prophet SAW is a tradition from good traditions, which contains many benefits and benefits that return to humans, because of great gifts." Therefore, it is recommended in sharia with a series of implementations. [Sayyid Muhammad bin Alawi Al-Maliki, Mafahim Yajibu An-Tushahha, page: 340] From the explanation above, it can be concluded that the celebration of the Prophet's birthday is only a new format, while the contents are worship services that have been regulated in the Al-Qur'an and hadith. For this reason, many scholars say that celebrating the Prophet's birthday is a hasanah heresy and the perpetrators will receive a reward. The Proposition of Celebrating the Prophet's Birthday Among the arguments for celebrating the birthday of the Prophet Muhammad according to some scholars is the word of Allah: قُلْ بِفَضْلِ اللَّهِ وَبِرَحْمَتِهِ فَبِذَلِكَ فَلْيَفْرَحُوا هُوَ خَيْرٌ مِمَّا يَجْمَعُونَ "Say, with the grace of Allah and His mercy (Prophet Muhammad SAW) let them welcome you with joy." (QS. Yunus: 58) This verse recommends to Muslims to happily welcome God's grace and mercy. There are differences of opinion among scholars in interpreting الفضل and الرحمة. There are those who interpret the two lafadz using the Al-Qur'an and there are also those who give different interpretations. Abu Shaikh narrated from Ibn Abbas RA that what is meant by الفضل is knowledge, while الرحمة is the Prophet Muhammad SAW. The famous opinion that explains the meaning of الرحمة with the Prophet SAW is because of the indication of the word of Allah SWT, namely: وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَاكَ إِلَّا رَحْمَةً لِلْعَالَمِينَ "We did not send you but as a mercy to the worlds." (QS. Al-Ambiya': 107). [Abil Fadhol Syihabuddin Al-Alusy, Ruhul Ma'ani, Juz 11, page: 186] According to Sayyid Muhammad bin Alawi Al-Maliki Al-Hasani, rejoicing in the presence of the Prophet Muhammad SAW is recommended based on the word of Allah SWT in Surah Yunus verse 58 above. [Sayyid Muhammad al-Maliki al-Hasani, Ikhraj wa Ta'liq fi Mukhtashar Sirah an-Nabawiyah, pages: 6-7] In the book Fathul Bari written by Al-Hafidz Ibnu Hajar al-Asqolani, it is said that Abu Lahab received relief from his torment every Monday because he was happy about the birth of the Prophet. This proves that rejoicing at the birth of the Prophet provides enormous benefits, even unbelievers can feel it. [Ibnu Hajar, Fathul Bari, Juz 11, page: 431] Similar history is also written in several hadith books, including Sahih Bukhari, Sunan Baihaqi al-Kubra and Syi`bul Iman. [Maktabah Syamilah, Sahih Bukhari, Juz 7, page: 9, Sunan Baihaqi al-Kubra, Juz 7, page: 9, Syi`bul Iman, Juz 1, page: 443].
@yukimura5188 Your post is too long. However, a couple points without going through the res: YOU are translating dhla-lah as 'heresy'. That is a stretch. It means 'misguidance'. 'Every misguidance (or, items of misguidance) is in the fire'. The hadith does not negate the following meanings: 1- The act will be burned, not the misguided (who often make istighfar... with 'those I know, and those I do not'). 2. The act of misguidance (bid'ah) will not be accepted as a worship; but will be cast out. In neither of the cases, creators of bid'ah should be called a heretic "IF" his intention is performing a good deed, despite the fact that he is wrong, misguided, or a fool.
Celebrating mawlid is not bidah. It is proven from Qiyas which is permissible until against Ijma and there is no Ijma against celebrating mawlid. Infact through centuries of practice there is Ijma in favour of mawlid and there was no opposition until around 1750 which broke this centuries old entrenched ijma or unity of ummah thus created bidah and sect in Islam. Speaking against celebration of mawlid is regarding all ummah over the span of centuries to be on wrong path. This should be enough eye opener for anyone who speaks against celebration of mawlid. May Allah protect us from fitnah of End Times Can you imagine saying that expecting reward from Allah for donation of blood to save lives is bidah because Sahaba (May Allah Be Pleased With Them) never did this? Islamic Law has four Sources which are Quran, Hadees, Ijma and Qiyas. Some people forget about Ijma and Qiyas and get trapped in vicious cycle of calling great pious acts as bidah and reprehensible when infact they are proven either from Ijma or Qiyas. Under rule of Qiyas everything is permissible including ikhtilaf until against Ijma. So by analysis Bidah is to destroy ijma on any issue and create "new" sect and Islam wants us to stay united. Every bidah i.e. "new sect" is hell bound. Stay firm with Ijma, stay firm with those who never broke any Ijma done on any issue in last 1400 years. Thus those who regard celebrating mawlid as bidah are real bidateez themselves lack understanding of it.
