MAY 2024 IPSY ICON BOX UNBOXING! 

I cancelled the Icon subscription. Over-hyped big time. Nothing about your box says "iconic" to me and I don't blame you for being disappointed. Happy birthday!! 🎈

I enjoy watching you because I appreciate how you show your gratitude even if you don’t really need or want a product. I like your real opinion, and you give it without complaining as much as other reviewers do at times. ❤

I was thrilled with my box. I got the o/s mascara & blush, huda brow pencil, fenty lipstick & eye gel, a probiotic moisturizer, rare beauty's illuminizer, water perfume ... i love these products and have wanted them for so long

Oh yeah HAPPY BIRTHDAY!🥳👑🌹🥂🎂❤

I love Patrick, but the selection I got was underwhelming. I think the PMG Icon is still the best.

Happy birthday 🎉🎉 and yass I love fenty skin products

HAPPY BIRTHDAY!🎉🎉🎉

Happy birthday 🎂🎉 my dear friend ❤️🎉🎊. Great video unboxing your May Ipsy box 👏🏽👏🏽. Cheers 😉🌷

I like Kosas alot. Its my favorite concealer right now. And i have their pressed setting powder which is really nice. And then i picked their plumping lip gloss for my May box.

I canceled the icon box right at midnight..I really don't need anything and I just didn't think it would be that great. Happy happy Birthday to you!! ❤❤

Happy Birthday Sher!🎁🎈🎂

Happy birthday sweetie!! 🎉🥳🧁

I think we should get an eyeshadow pallet with the icon box. I got mostly skin care choices.

Happy Birthday. I hope your Boxycharm box is better.

Happy Birthday Beautiful ❤️

Happy Birthday! I wasn’t thrilled with my Icon Box. I also received the ONE/SIZEFantasize Lifting & Lengthening Mascara as my only makeup power pick. Although my box was meh, I did spend an additional $150 on adds and got some pretty cool items. So, it was indeed Iconic for Ipsy $67.11 (box) +$16.28 (boost) + $150 (add ons) = $233.39

Happy Birthday!

Happy birthday beautiful ❤

Happy birthday❤

I’m dry and 42 and I am not happy they are giving us all the same skincare. It really is supposed to be customized to each person. Last month they sent another cleanser for oily skin, that I can’t use. What’s up Boxycharm? What y’all doin??

HAPPY BIRTHDAY 🎂🎈🎉!!;!!!

Happy birthday Sher

Happy Birthday!!!

Happy birthday

Have you considered paying for a box so you can choose the items that you dont get in PR? I mean im sure u have but to me it is just so worth it to be able to choose what im getting and the amount of money i save is unreal. Like for example, this month is going to be my biggest haul yet. A glam bag 2 boxycharms and my first icon box with lots of addons. I spent just over $200 and im getting well over $1500 in products i would pay full price for if i could afford so i am beyond excited for this month. 45 products, 13 of which are deluxe samples. My family keeps telling me i should start a youtube channel with how many subscriptions and beauty product hauls I buy every month.

I got 3 of the Patrick star beauty I got that pink blush mascara and lip duo

Happy belated birthday, Sher. I was a bit disappointed in this box as well. I am excited about the things that I'm going to be receiving but it was very skincare heavy and the One Size products that I really wanted to try weren't even options like there setting spray. You couldn't even buy it in add-ons. I did get the blush pallette but it is in the lightest pink and I'm a deeper color type of person. However I am excited for my box just not as excited as other boxes. I have 2 subscriptions and to me my Boxycharm was much harder to make selections for because I wanted so many things in each category. I hope you enjoy your other subscriptions better. ❤

I like your box! I got a blush, foundation, and I picked a lip product from one size in my choices. I really wanted the blue eyeliner pencil but it is okay.

So glad I didn't shuck up the extra dough for this box. Total MISS. Thank you for your HONESTY so many influencers ohhh and ahhhhhh over AIR.

Wow, holy skincare heavy!!!

Happy birthday 🎂🎉🎈🎊🎁 I'm sending out love to everyone 💙💛❤💚💜

Happy birthday l!!!! Oh man, you can imagine I was critical haha soooo disappointing

Happy Birthday ❤

I’m getting the mascara, cc cream & blush clapper. Can wait ❤😂

Don’t feel and to complain or critique. They should expect and be open to their customers feedback. Also this is my first icon box and I’m not very excited about it. I expected something like an eyeshadow palette or more makeup. But even the choice options were skincare heavy. I don’t like to jump around with my skincare, so I don’t try things that often. I said I prefer makeup more. The last couple regular boxes I’ve gotten were also skincare heavy. And a lot of brand I’ve been r heard of and seem kind of cheap filler. It’s frustrating to pay for this and do the quiz thinking we will get better choices for it to seem the same each month.

I hope you have a wonderful birthday, so I was lucky to get the cheek palette and mascara by One size as my power picks. I’m excited to try it and it sucks they didn’t send it to u because personally I would love to see u try them.

Also happy birthday!!!!🎉🥰🩷

Happy Birthday sis❤😊❤ mine is the 19 th

The foundation and other great things sold out when it opened! I got FIRST AID BEAUTY, Cheek Clapper 3D Blush Trio Palette in Attention Seeker, Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen in Busty Brown, THE NUE CO Water Therapy Fragrance and SATURDAY SKIN Pretty Pop Probiotic Power Whipped Cream which I dislike so use on my legs before bed. I don't know how they consider it Iconic when it's my 3rd tube. I picked BYROE Basil Dark Spot Correcting Cream, ONE/SIZE Eye Popper Sparkle Vision Eyeshadow in Let's Pump, and LYS BEAUTY Glossy Lip Treatment Oil Duo in OG & Lovable. There were a lot of great choices but were sold out in each category. I added ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Marine Cream, ELOISE BEAUTY Ultra Glow Lip Oil in Ruby, NICOLE MILLER Lueur De La Ville Fragrance, GLOSS MODERNE Clean Luxury Shampoo + Conditioner Duo and KITSCH Satin Sleep Scrunchies - Black Set of 5. So I feel like I got pretty much what I needed not really all I wanted so I guess a lot of boxes sold. Sher I am sorry you didn't get a blush. I know that would have made a difference.

I like getting skin care in my boxes much better ,the Kosas was the one item I wanted the most

I’m pretty happy with my box honestly. Got the blush in pink, mascara, water perfume, kosas plump balm, sl miss glam brush set, saturday skin probiotic moisturizer, alterna volumizer, and pore aha foam and fresh rose mask for my boost. For me i wanted the blush in attention seeker, the sl miss glam brushes are my fav, LOVE Fresh products,and love alterna so i’m happy. Only things im dissatisfied with is the SS probiotic cream, the water perfume, and the porefessional item.

Happy birthday 🎉! Skipped icon box this month. Chose May glam bag (gorgeous bag with variations) and May Boxycharm. Luckily I was able to add the icon box products I wanted in add ons. That Porefessional mask has excellent reviews even for dry skin so I did buy that. It's apparently a 5 minute mask. Reviews for the Fenty Skin product indicate issues with the dispenser. I'm curious to see what the ingredients are for your First Aid Beauty Bounce Serum. The ingredients from their brand website and Sephora indicate it has pentapeptide-34 trifluoroacetate. According to the FDA (and mentioned in multiple reviews on Sephora), this product is a PFAS, AKA a "forever chemical". However I did not see this listed under the ingredients when I debated purchasing this in add ons. Is this ingredient listed on your product?

Happy Birthday beautiful lady! I turn 47 in September.

I was very happy with my Icon box and the ability to do some Icon box exclusive add ons. You find t get one of the better PR boxes since you like make up more than skin care. But, I would have been glad to get each of the eight products you got. I wish I had picked up the hair care item but it will probably be in a Boxycharm down the road. in my Icon box, they chose the O/S pink blush fir me and the brown eyeliner. my 3 choice items could have been better so i ended up having to get some of the items i wanted as add ons. On the ABH balm, which shade did you get? i got 4 and it was almost too light for me. It looks OK but does tend to come off. maybe i need to use setting powder or spray

Happy Birthday 🎉🎉🎉

Happy Birthday

Bon anniversaire, sweetie!🥳🥳

My box was okay, I was also hoping for the cheek clapper blush but I didn’t get it 😢 out of my power picks I only got one OS product 😅 it was the foundation but it’s too dark 😩 luckily it’s my best friends shade 🤣out of 8 products I’m excited for 3 of them, I picked the kosas juicy lip booster and the 5 sens perfume so I def am excited for those 🥰 we got 2 of the same products, the serum & benefit mask, im excited for the serum but I also don’t know if my skin will agree with the face mask 😢 the last time I really enjoyed an icon box was the Pat McGrath one 😢🤣

Happy Birthday. I don’t think they would send influencers foundation/ complexion products because they send the boxes random and there is a lot of different complexions. A lot of influencers have their own subscription in addition to their PR so they can make choices. Just a thought 🌸 have a wonderful birthday 🥂

Happy birthday Lovely 🧁💐

I did my Choice for Icon Box. What I noticed that the PR boxes never get get many of the curators own branded products. The PR boxes only get 1 or if they’re lucky 2. The paid PR boxes get far more. I think that is the right thing to do and the PR content creators should be grateful they are getting at least one of the curators own brand. There are some PR content creators who also pay for a separate box. Their paid for Icon box is always better. Patrick Starr is very into skincare. He says you need a good healthy base for makeup to look good so i’m not surprised he chose a lot of skincare items. In my box, I had 3 One Size items as Power Picks. My one disappointment was the One Size foundation shade was too deep. Other Black subscribers of the Icon Box have said they received the same shade in foundation. I am assuming that Deeo 3 was the only Black skin colour they had available from One Size. Which is such a shame as I’ve always been given good shade matches from Ipsy before.

Happy birthday and I also didn’t get the icon box or last months Ipsy box I didn’t see anything interesting in them from watch RU-vid videos n the boxes are pretty expensive month to month. If I end up seeing something interesting I might sign up again but looking at ppls boxes haven’t seen anything interesting yet. I think I will stick to my allure box cuz u get more make up in them plus skin care too. Also haven’t tried any other subscriptions yet. Besides those 2.

Go in and change your profile you can do that once and awhile it might help

I hope you have had an amazing birthday. ❌️⭕️

I don't blame you for being upset. Your box wasn't that great. I wanted the foundation, and they didn't choose that for me. They chose the same skincare and eyeliner as you got. I wasn't happy because I have dry skin, too. I can't even use the mask. We pay 65 dollars and 16 for the beauty boost. I don't mind skin care. I actually like getting it, but when you can't use it. It's disappointing. I wish they would do it like Boxycharm did, and you would get all the curators products. I would have loved to have his setting spray in the box. I like a mixture of makeup and skincare. I'm so sorry about your box. I hope you had a nice birthday, though.

Happy birthday, lady! IDK what is going on with ipsy but that isnt worth the cost even at a discount from price tag in the store. I skipped all this month.

We get so much treatment, I’ve got SO much of it & I only have one face’😢

Happy Birthday 😂

If I die at 110 I will still have a stash of mascara…HAPPY BIRTHDAY! Icon is $60 right? I’m sorry you didn’t get any fun stuff… hugs ❤

Hope you had a great birthday! That box is not very exciting for an Icon box. It it is any consolation, the one size liner is really good though ( I have tried it)

I’m downgrading after this box. Regular boxy; no boost. Received the attention seeker hot pink blush pallet (the one color that is a no on my profile) and 2 acne products, which again do not match my skincare profile. What a mess and disappointment this month. Meh.

Omg how disappointing 😩 I swear they always put the crappier products in the pr boxes 😂 I really hope I get a different variation than you, which I typically do.. I just don’t want that much skincare ugh!! I do already own the blush palette so I won’t be disappointed if I don’t get it but I would love to get mostly makeup!🤞🏼

Happy Birthday!!! Too bad you got a boring box.

But you got PR unboxing for free be thankful for what ipsy sent you

wawa

This is the worst box I've ever seen I used to get this box 2years ago and it was called glam bag x it was great back then

That had to be the most boring Icon Box I've ever seen. You'd think if its PR, they would send the most exciting products for you to highlight in your review.

Happy Birthday gorjois! You know honestly, I was not really looking forward to this iconbox; frankly it was sus from the first spoilers. Benefit skincare is a 🚩🚩🚩🚩, as an esthetician it is trash🗑️🗑️🗑️🗑️ in fancy packaging. I nearly skipped but the regular box looked worse by far. My icon box ended up being awesome. From O/S I got the pink blush clapper, the double lip snatcher in a rosy nude, and added on the BBB foundation. I also got a set of double ended lipliners with a sharpener, rare beauty liquid highlighter, a lawless tinted lip balm in a berry color, the FAB bounce serum and then I got the crappy benefit mask and a dermalactives cleanser. So I got a fabulous box- glad I didn’t skip it! I’m sorry yours was such a bummer!!!

So negative 😑

Happy Birthday!