I just bought the cosmic black one because I needed a new one anyway and I will say as someone who puts on a lot a mascara everyday, that the cosmic black is definitely a bit more black than the darkest shade of the pink tube Edit: the tube of the cosmic black also last about a month longer than the pink one before it dries up
I picked up the black and pink tube today, and was trying to figure out the difference. Honestly, I chose the Cosmic Black because I hoped it would have silver sparkles in it lol, but sadly, it's just black mascara lol. Thanks for letting me know the difference between them (which is basically nothing).
I don’t know if I’m crazy, but from your swatches I think the Cosmic Black is a darker black than the Blackest Black 😱 But on the eyes they look completely the same hahah
@@sittingprettywithj i have a question so if you get a brownish black shade in the sky high mascara why does it look a little different than the black like it doesn’t give that fan effect? or is it because it’s brownish black?
@hobistinyheartbag I despise mascara brands doing 5 dam shades of black. Makes it so confusing when you are buying trying to guess which truly is the blackest when that's what we are looking for! 🤣
Glad you did a video about this lol seriously Just bought this last night and I got blackest black and cosmic black and I had a really hard time seeing the difference.... My head tells me the cosmic may be a teeeeni tiny bit blacker but honestly my daughter and I can't tell and our lashes are blondish/brown.. so ya ultimately I don't believe there's a difference except for name and packaging. Your Beautiful btw
Thank you, that was very helpful! I had a feeling it would be impossible to tell the difference between two shades of black mascara. And they already had TWO blacks! Now there are three. What a gimmick 😝 It MIGHT be interesting to put both formulas on a white piece of paper to see if you can distinguish between them there. But even if you can, it’s ridiculous to have a new shade if it’s imperceptibly different when worn.
I agree with you 100%! They could have done something different like improve the formula or change the design of the wand or make it a travel size or value size, or make a dark brown version, etc. When I wiped the mascara off with a makeup wipe they still looked the same lol I’m happy I was able to help and thanks for watching 😊
Thank you!! I keep buying these on a rotating basis lol, cosmic black one day, blackest black the next. Couldn’t figure out the difference, I feel validated lol!!!
This is has been a helpful video! I kept trying to search which of the mascaras was darker but I couldn't figure out at all! So thanks for making this video, I needed this review😊
I was wondering the same thing! I was at walmart today & there was only cosmic black or black brown left. I looked at the shelf & I was like what is blackest black?! Seriously it just dumb having 2+ blacks. I didn't walk out with anything b/c I didn't know what cosmic black means. BTW I don't wear waterproof either. I don't want something that will take off my lashes when I have to remove it. Seems counter productive.
@@sugerless20 it didn’t transfer on my lids and it is a washable mascara (I use my Garnier micellar water on a cotton pad to remove mine) and unfortunately I never tried a tubing mascara before so I wouldn’t be able to compare. I hope that helps 💕
I think the 799 cosmic black shows more on your lashes than the 800 blackest black, the lashes look longer thicker on the right eye. I want the cosmic black but none of them is available in waterproof version in Vietnam. I plan to wear it at yoga, sports: with all the sweat, if not the Mansoon rain or humid tropical weather, it has to be waterproof. Only 802 Very black is available in waterproof so I wonder how different it might be from 799 cosmic black.
I get the water resistant mascaras because they don’t smudge, I’m always rubbing my eye and I forget that I have stuff on my lashes! So to not look like a raccoon at work I use the water resistant ones 😂 If it’s just for a virtual meeting I’ll just use the regular ones so I can easily remove them since I won’t wear it all day
Hi! Neither one of these are waterproof. The waterproof one is called “Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara” and it comes in 2 shades: brownish black and very black. 💕 thanks for watching 💕
Hi! The cosmic black one isn’t waterproof and color wise they are pretty much the same color. Cosmic black maybe a hint darker. I haven’t tried the waterproof one thou 💕 thanks for watching