Shine a Light studio version is definitely meh, but their live version is great. I can't listen to Above the Noise but some of those songs are great live, except for Party Girl, that song is unsalvageable
Sorry's not good enough is amazing musically deffo God Tier! Swap with Shine A Light at least haha. That ending with Danny belting 'sorry's not good enough' and Tom's gentle 'don't go changing...' always gives me goosebumps!
Hi, I'm a fan from Japan! My favourite song is Love is Easy!!! It's a song that taught me about a different values of love that we don't have in Japan. I think it is a God-Like Song! P.S. I really enjoyed the Live at the O2Arena!!! You guys are the best!!! Love You and All of the McFly Fans too!!!
Being someone who moved to Australia and the only song that ever made it big here was love is easy and you don't rate it very high is disappointing. Been a fan since 2005 and seen them in concert twice. Always love a good McFly session 😍
Tom how could you!! Putting "I'll be okay" in meh, that song still gets me through tough days 😭 Thankfully Harry put you semi straight with your bad judgement
I think their best covers were 'Don't Stop Me Now' (obviously) and I freaking love their version of ' My Heart Will Go On'. I wish they would record it.
Isn't it sad that they all hate "Party Girl", they hated it when they recorded it and when they were promoting it back in 2010 we all know that in hindsight, trying to say how pleased they were with it, that they were dead inside..... wondering where their career was heading :(
well tbh i think we all knew that that style of music just wasn't them... even back then. the album was still not totally bad and the whole visual album thing was legit epic hahahha
Remember the hype of SuperCity? Hahaha that's probably why "Above the Noise" only charted at #20, because we all got the tracks for free when we paid the £60+ membership lol.
I remember how disappointed I was with ATN, the whole SuperCity thing, the Party Girl vampire video...?? It just seemed like they were climbing on every trend and losing what makes McFly special in the process. I'm happy to seem them back in a more authentic way, I cant wait for the new album to drop!
Yeah I remember reading their autobiography where Tom says, "Dougie said 'let's just do one more album and call it a day'...", their moral must've been so low, hearing these tracks come out the speaker n thinking "this is just not us!!" :(
My personal ranking would be.... God Tier: Sorry’s Not Good Enough, Broccoli, Star Girl, Room On The Third Floor. Top Tier: Obviously, All About You, I’ll Be Okay, Baby’s Coming Back, Shine A Light Mid Tier: Please Please, Love Is Easy, Party Girl. Meh Tier: Five Colours In Her Hair (but I still love it because it’s a special song for the band and fans 😍)
Exactly how I would’ve put them. However, I must say I do love Party Girl too so I would’ve put that in mid at least but Shine a Light is one of my all time favourite songs of yours & ⭐️ girl too!! THERES JUST SO MANY GOOD ONES!!! 💖
Ah they missed out on so many of their best! I still remember 13 year old me falling in love with McFly listening to Please Please! I have too many favorites but if I had to choose ONE, it'd be Transylvania. I used to dance around that for hours especially on Dougie's birthday since he helped write it and he sings a lot in it. Miss those days.
I don't get the fact that everybody is talking about how they put "Shine a Light" on GOD tier... Can anybody pay attention to "Love is Easy" and how is it on Mid Tiers? Hahaha! Wishing the second part! Love you guys! From Latin America: Peru 🇵🇪
Party girl meh!? What planet are you on!! I 💜 them all and they are ALL top or god tier in my book 📖! 🙌🏼 “Dougie, don’t go into the woods! “ classic 👌🏼
My favourite McFly song is The End and one that no one ever talks about it. But man that song makes me fking bawl 😭 Bubble wrap, End of the world, Transylvania are some great ones they missed
