I just read about a man named Muhammad Sven kalisch. A convert to islam and a theologian and professor at a German university who tried to do a deep dive into Islamic history and discovered that Muhammad never existed. He subsequently renounced islam in 2010.
I’m always amazed at anyone intelligent/educated who buys into such obvious fraud. At least the man had the good sense to investigate and got himself out.
The whole idea that Abraham helped build the Kaaba in Mecca, a city that didn't exist until thousands of years after his death, that's about as believable as the sun leaving our solar system at night to the throne of Allah and getting permission to rise again in the east before setting in a pool of muddy waters. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Exactly! And since the area that would much, much later become Mecca was about a 1,000-mile journey from Hebron, ancient maps show us the infrastructure of ancient cities and wells didn’t even exist that would have made the journey possible.
god knows me islam is true islam is true islam is true corruption of the old testament and the many type of torah the masoratic text the original hebrew the septuagint corruption the many stream of translation we dont know where many of them but just some survived translation the samaritan torah only 5 book of moses these three are disagree with each other in many places quran have no interpolation unlike bible that come in transmission period return to original text is the very purpose of bible textual criticism which indicate a problem in the journey its make sense to god resend a new book and then preserve it for real unlike bible and for the whole world bcz the book is preserve to end time genesis 5:31 septuagint said 753 years for lamech masoratic said 777 years for lamech samaritan said 653 years for lamech Transmission break #1 - Sometime between Moses (approx. 1300 BCE) and King Josiah (approx. 600 BCE) Transmission break #2 - Sometime between King Josiah (approx. 600 BCE) and Ezra (approx. 400 BCE) And again, when God brings his firstborn into the world, he says, “Let all God’s angels worship him.” [Hebrews 1:6] The above quotation is made by Paul in the New Testament and is citing Deuteronomy 32:43. masoratic doesnt have taht if bible need a repair and correct the mistake after hundred of years to make the mistake disappears thats mean its not perfectly preserved and not aided by divine also not understandable by regular mental power so many copyist error that make into the text the bible is obviously intend to be preserved and unchanhed and whomever add or substract will get punished but instead what we get is interpolation and lost of the original word and many variation that get inside it for centuries until scholars repair amd work for it until now they even got divided variant amd corruption of translation jew adding n substracting from their own book, christian adding n substacting from their own book, only muslim dont, they dont have post interpolation after uthman or hereditary mistake the christian believe is poeple just see god yahweh as jesus but no one see god and live in error means you fail for what you claim matthew and luke jesus begot in womb not preexist that only in john in 385 ad people still undecided whether holy spirit is god diciple didnt understand crucified messiah and jew didnt expect crucified messiah there were blindspot it can be said that the crucifixed messiah is made up and jesus is a prophet like quran said the early follower want to obey the law paul split the shema ebionites like a muslim jesus is just a prophet for ebionites and early people septuagint translate man in exodus to be 600.000 in numbers whiches being denied by scholars that men in exodus cannot be taht much or even surpass the 100.000 research been done taht the calculation of census and taxes taht paid by israelite indicate that there were 600.000 not 600 clan and people taht much with much pot jar amd armor should left behind something probably even bones the septuagint missed passage some of jeremiah compare to dead sea scroll though masoratic have it many evangelical and scholars agree innerancy only apply to the original septuagint also have cainan as arphaxad child which not found in earlier manuscript and best manuscript taht used by church father and josephus and early lxx its not there before 220 ad cited by christian web not in codex bizae not even luke early times have cainan people from the past can be have different copies of bible taht have different contain inside of them so its not always the same bible textus receptus included 1 john 5 7 trinity verse and in latin vulgate for longtime earliest christian believe jesus exalted not incarnate and subordinate 72 14 citation luke 10 70 32 citation luke 10 modern bible trans 9 72 6 72 they even changed and revised the old testament book of god and its revised from previous problem thats mean its contained problems and its changed they reject the septuagint today reject the masoratic today and have disagreements and make an eclactic reading why would there are variants reading to choose after all, obviously that went into our modern bible is false variant reading afterall so they correct it the double entendre in jesus conversation with nicodemus doesn’t exist in aramaic also not in hebrew john is liar many lie 32:8 and 32:43. Even though we are comparing the same chapter of Deuteronomy, the texts never completely agree in all verses. Sometimes the DSS agree with the MT over the LXX, as in verse 32:43[ii], and sometimes the DSS agree with the LXX over the MT, as in verse 32:8[iii]. Genesis 16:16, Abraham was 86 years old when Ishmael was born: Abram was eighty-six years old when Hagar bore him Ishmael. And according to Genesis 21:5, Abraham was one hundred years old when Isaac was born: Abraham was a hundred years old when his son Isaac was born to him. just talking about text differences not talking about the inconsistency factual error and ethical error in OT and NT from 27 translation 14 : 70 diciple 13 : 72 diciple majority of quran qiraat differences is dialectical its normal and how it supposed to be christian said the personality and characteristic of god can be seen in the bible but why its contradict its own saying like the bible is confusing while paul said god is not the author of confusion , and god repented and feel sorry or even genocide why god allow interpolation to get inside the bible for centuries why not god cut it like quran which dont have hereditary error no two manuscript of nt is the same rasm uthman is so stable and no mistake is hereditary there are word differ but non uthmanic and isolated but still mention the companion reading tradition not hereditary mistake ten canonical reading more or less conform uthmanic reading ten qiraat is dialectical differences uthman is absolutly the architype text and carbon dating point out so you can even reconstruct the stemma that all quran we have today back to that 4 uthman codex shady nasser said oral transmission also soo good Interpolations in the Bible - IS the Bible God's Word? bible interpolation ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9SCECRhQHW0.html quranic preservation muslimprophets.com/article.php?aid=37 how can patriavh commit sin? www.jesus-resurrection.info/bible-prophets.html patraich commit sin? unpleasant.ffrf.org/ genocide www.layittoheart.com/septuagint.html septuagint problem sites.google.com/site/errorsinthebible/dss-lxx-vs-mt bible error skepticsannotatedbible.com/contra/topics/about.html contradiction www.lyingforjesus.org/Bible-Contradictions/ rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bible_interpolation interpolation sites.google.com/site/isthebiblegodsword/interpolations-in-the-bible/interpolations-in-the-bible lost verse or different version in old testament taht didnt exist while being quoted by prophet or apostle actually in order islam to be true that jesus is islam prophet is not necesserally jesus prophecied about islam or muhammad or probably he was we didnt know but the fact that if jesus actually only a prophet of end time taht command to obey torah law and only send to israel that alone is very inline with islamic messenge that jesus is israelite only prophet not this worldwide religion but only for israel and a prophet that said they need to obey torah and probably circumcision also with prohibited food, muhammad is the one that for universal world and quran as you see quran is preserve in recitation n text which more stable and no hereditary mistake also no interpolation , does this tell you something? because torah is corrupted you can see how ot god comman killing grey haired man child baby pregnant woman animal amd many patriach commiting ugly sin like adultery idolatary and incest its absolutly corrupt jew christian and islam is one line of god so if this two previous religion before islam is corrupt while this prophet are exist we can turn to islam for centuries interpolation inside the bible why god let interpolation inherited? im not make this up scholars said quran dont have hereditary mistake from scribes because sometimes people typos but its not hereditary amd no interpolation why taht happen with bible ? is it coincidence? that quran can be memorize as awhole book amd then have fixed and stable text and have no interpolation amd have no hereditary error, have no contradiction ,have more historical accuracy and more ethical, and scholars said jesus is prophet how far this coincidence could be? the bible depict prophet as sinner doing adultery , drunk, idolatry incest, and genocide command in bible that killed grey haired man infant pregnant woman and animal, and dead sea scroll scribes also ascribe themsels an authority to chnage text as they wish and jew corrupting masoratic text and septuagint that have many variant and disagreement also lacking of verses, it cant be coincidence thatvits happen i think quran is right its easy for god to revealed a new book because he can do all thing also preserving the book rev 22:18 I testify unto every man that heareth the words of the prophecy of this book, If any man shall add unto them, God shall add unto him the plagues which are written in this book: rev 22:19 And if anyone takes words away from this scroll of prophecy, God will take away from that person any share in the tree of life and in the Holy City, which are described in this scroll. but the proof is there are interpolation throughout the time until scholars take away the fake verse
@@jamesbaker2532 Give me an example of what you mean The Qur’an considers Jesus ,peace be upon him , as one of the most 5 greatest prophets who God sent What do you think of that ?
@@zicozico6961 no offense intended. But I think the Quran is man made book. There is no evidence to back it up. It teaches hate. Jesus even though he gave a few prophesies was only prophet but the son of God who came down from heaven to o give his body as a sacrifice for our sins. So you, me and everyone else can go to heaven. God proved this by raising him from the dead. He proved it by hundreds of fulfilled prophecy throughout the ages. It teaches to love even your enemies while the Quran teaches to hate your enemies. Christianity is not a man made religion. It's just the true and only religion. It is not structured to get followers. Lol. It's says you can't do the things you want to. To love your enemy, tp not have a love for money etc. Quran said you get virgins when you die. That's an example of a man made religion thank you
THIS DEBUNKS ALL THE LIES AND RHETORIC OF JAY. HERE IS A COPY AND PASTE from your bible study on Arabia. Take note that they ascribe many prophets in Arabia as well and even admit that Moses with the Exodus took his sheep to celebrate a festival to the LORD in Mecca. And I Quote from Bible Study Notes. The chief importance of the Hijaz arises from the fact that in it are situated the two holy cities of Mecca and Medina--the cradle and the grave of the Prophet. It is thus the religious center of the Islamic world. 2. Extinct Tribes: Of the extinct tribes the most familiar name is that of Amlak or Amlik (Amalek). By the Arabian genealogists he is variously described as a grandson of Shem and as a son of Ham. In Genesis 36:12 he is a son of Esau's son, Eliphaz, by Timna. They are said to be first met with in Chaldea, from which they were expelled on the rise of the Assyrian power under Nimrod. They migrated into Ar, occupying in turn the Bahrein, Oman, the Yemen, and finally the Hijaz, where they are said to have been the first settlers at Yathrib (Medina) and also to have occupied land round Mecca and Kheibar. In the time of Abraham they were expelled from Mecca on the arrival of two new tribes from the South, those of Jurhum and Katura (Genesis 25:1). Later, it is said, David, during the rebellion of Absalom, took up his quarters in Kheibar and ruled over the surrounding districts. According to another tradition Moses sent an expedition against the Amalekites in the Hijaz, on which occasion the Israelites, disobeying his orders, spared their king Arkam (compare Rekem, Numbers 31:8; Joshua @)--a reminiscence of the incident in the life of Saul (1 Samuel 15). In any case the Amalekites were supplanted in the northern Hijaz by Jewish tribes, who continued there until the time of Mohammad. North Arabian Tribes: Among the Arabs Ishmael holds the place occupied by Isaac in the Hebrew tradition. It was to the valley, afterward the site of the town of Mecca, that Abraham conducted Hagar and her son, and that Ishmael grew up and became the father of a great nation. The locality is full of spots connected by tradition with his life history, the ground where Hagar searched for water, the well Zemzem of which Gabriel showed her the place, the mount Thabir where Abraham would have sacrificed his son (Ishmael), and the graves of Hagar and Ishmael. The Jurhum, among whom Ishmael grew up, gave him seven goats: These were the capital with which he began life. He married a woman of Jurhum. He had twelve sons (Genesis 25:16) of whom Kaidar and Nabat are the best known, perhaps the Cedrei and Nabataei of Pliny; other sons were Dumah and Tema (which see). The subsequent history of the Ishmaelites is lost for several generations until we come to `Adnan, who is said to have been defeated by Nebuchadnezzar, when the latter invaded Arabia. All the Ishmaelite tribes are descended from `Adnan. They are the north Arabian tribes, as opposed to the Kahtanite or south Arabian. One of them, Koreish, under their chief, Kosay, became master of Mecca, driving out Koda`a. Later, as the tribe of the Prophet, they became the rulers of Arabia and the aristocracy of the Muslim empire; and the descendants of Mohammad remain to this day the only hierarchy known to Islam. 7. Foreign Elements: In Arabia there was and still, in spite of religious disabilities, is a large Jewish population. Before the age of Mohammad they lived chiefly in the Northwest, the two best known tribes--An-Nadir and Koreiza--occupying Yathrib (Medina). After the rise of Islam they were expelled from Arabia; but at the present time there are probably some 60,000 Jews in the Yemen alone 2. The Ka`ba, Pilgrimages and Fairs: Though there were many houses of God in the country, the chief religious resort even before the time of Mohammad was Mecca. The House of God (see BETHEL) here was called the Ka`ba, which is the English word "cube," the building being so called from its shape. It was believed to have been built by Abraham and Ishmael. The honor of acting as guardians of the House was a subject of rivalry among the tribes. The office was held consecutively by the tribes of Jurhum, Koda`a and Koreish, and last by the grandfather and uncles of Mohammad. These, therefore, correspond to the tribe of Levi in Israel. It is said to have contained a large number of images, but it is remarkable that the nearer our authorities get to the time of Mohammad the smaller is the number of images mentioned. The chief of these, Hubal, is not named in the Koran. The worship took the form of circumambulation (tawaf), running or marching round the sanctuary (compare Psalms 26:6). An annual visitation was and still is made by those living at a distance, and sacrifices are offered. This is the hajj or pilgrimage; the same name is used for the corresponding rite among the Hebrews (Exodus 10:9 and often). These religious assemblies were combined with fairs, at which markets were held and a considerable trade carried on. Before the time of Mohammad the great annual fair was held at Okaz, a place still pointed out about three days' journey East of Mecca and one day West of Taif. Here were not only all kinds of commercial transactions carried on--auctions, sales, settling of accounts and payment of blood-wit, but an academy was held at which poets recited their odes, and received judgment upon their merits. These fairs were generally held in the sacred months, that is, the first, seventh, eleventh and twelfth months, in which fighting was forbidden. They had therefore a great civilizing and pacifying influence. Ref www.biblestudytools.com/encyclopedias/isbe/arabia.html
I'm Italian, actually is being worked on a Rome’s new subway line, treasure trove of thousands of artifacts, including a Roman military barracks and an ancient home with more than a dozen rooms featuring frescoes, mosaic floors, and other decorations that and are nearly intact.
To be fair both Christianity and Islam are failed religions. Christianity needed Islam to push it out West so it could colonize the Americas and then conquer Africa to bring Humanity only to fail as these lands became independent and fought one another, while Europe remained contentious of constantly fighting itself no matter what faith was preached. This is why Christianity is a failure. However, Christianity is the intended world religion and so it must reform in some way to complete its purpose otherwise the purpose will not be achieved and if it is not achieved, humanity will not unite. If humanity does not unite, humanity will never become a tier 1 civilization and if such happens humanity will die out as is the Great Filter we are in. We are in the Great Filter, the mechanism responsible for decreasing the possibility of emerging Spacefaring Civilizations. We are in that and the only way to get through it is through unification. We know this. We all know this. But some of us have our heads up our butts about it. "But we need an "US" vs Them." Okay, can the "US" be call of "US" and can the "Them" be our deaths? At least then we would be fighting against extermination and against unfair treatment for something we should all support, right? "But it just wouldn't work." That is not an answer or a rebutal. "There is nothing out there." We have found Galactic Government structures on our moon. Bull F'ing S word. They are active and have people (if you want to call extraterrestrials, people in them). There are cities we have even found on the moon. They are watching us to see if we will be smart enough to realize all of this and just unite, do something that is really simple and stop bitching about it or we'll succumb to our fate for so ridiculous and stupid.
Pahimulin. Greetings from the Philippines. I had an ex-Muslim classmate from Iran. Before our professor and other classmates, he declared,"when Mohammed was young, he married a rich widow who was much older than he was." Then at the top of his voice he screamed : "SUGAR MOMMY !"
I was about to begin the prayer, when a Franj threw himself upon me, seized me, and turned my face to the East, telling me That's how you pray! Usamah ibn Munqidh
@Mkia Mokhiz Absolutely untrue. In the numerous archaeological digs that have been done in Mecca nothing has been found. The only thing found was a 12th Century Ottoman Fort, nothing else. Only a small amount of water that would support a few hundred people. Desalination plants are the only reason the number of people can live there now. Hundreds of prophets buried there & none found? How about the 300 praying prophets praying near the Kaaba? They are supposed to still be alive & praying to Allah. Why do you think the Saudis are cementing everything over? Getting rid of the evidence that Meccas is a very new city.
Mecca does not exist anywhere except in the imagination. 🤣🤣🤣 The person who imagines that Mecca is somewhere other than at its real location must be out of his mind or has to born on a different planet who has landed on earth fully drunk with travel sickness.
The speaker must quickly contact all the world's map makers to change their Maps and atlases, otherwtse there would be chaos among world tourists and Muslim pilgrims to Mecca
Eddie from “The Deen Show” was begging for money to build a mosque in an ad before your show. Glad to see RU-vid’s algorithm got this so terribly wrong!
@@dimejiolatunji5232 Honestly Dr Jay Smith has been a blessing to me, for the past 5 years I've been watching him, his videos has open my eyes to many deciet of islam n their false prophet whom mislead many to eternal dermnation for denying Jesus Christ as Lord n Saviour of the world.
I know anytime now in their digging foundations in the current Mecca they are going to run into the 300 live prophets, in prayer position, still alive & praying constantly. That's going to a shock to the system.
@@noorjahan1333 only one Quran but there many different bibles for all Christian sects and its proven to be currupted, christianity is silly with no historical evidence or an original book
Because uthman burnt the qurans and many companions of Muhammad were killed during the battle of badr who memorised the verses, so bukhari collected information from different parts of the world and that took a lot of time. There were actually more hadiths and they discarded the bad ones... I think 70000 hadiths altogether.
@@mohofpetra4956 common instinctive human behaviour of followers of a prophet/cult leader will have resulted in being convinced of he importance of that person, and the reaction to that is the urge to collect & preserve as much tangible "memorabilia" asap, not relying on "memorization". moreover, allegedly there were written (proto)qurans around from before uthman. then why at the same time there weren't any written hadiths if muhamad was recognized as "the greatest example for mankind"? so, the question of @ishtar lew still stands
@@mohofpetra4956 I do not see the logical connection between the burning of qur'ans, the deaths at the battle of Badr and the necessity to collect informations. Hadiths are, according to my knowledge, a totally distinct stuff than the one to be found in the Qur'an. The former is about Mohammad's life and the latter about the revelation he received.
@@didierfavre2356 there are many hadiths which are written to rectify the blunders by Muhammad and his scribes. For eg quran says Mary as sister of Aron and daughter of imran, which is the biggest blunder of all blunders, so in hadiths they tried to cover it up but in vain ☹️
Who'd have thought that the guy who claimed to have the truths superceding the revelations of books written 1000 years before his time and effectively retconning all of Judeo-Christendom would have inconsistencies in his story? XD As a son of Galicians from Spain I pride myself on Northern Spain resisting caliphate rule for so long. Santiago y cierra España!
Hey Brother Al Fadi love your work👍🏻 just a suggestion how about you and Jay do a monthly live stream updating us all of both your researches such as the Sana Manuscript or more Aramaic Origins etc as i feel videos are a bit short so live streams on a broad overview would be great! Nevertheless your work is Great God bless
Interesting note, I watch a history series. In the video on the Han empire, they presented a map of the central and eastern Silk Road routes. I was struck by the prominence of Merv, which Thomas Alexander likes as the source of the Koran. I was curious to see how many maps were available via a Google search that showed the same pattern. Merv (or Mary) does show up, but what was even more interesting was that more maps did not show any trade routes going through Mecca but rather they show the sea route up to Egypt. I even checked out the Spice Routes and it was similar. Sound like researchers are starting to look at the actual history, so you should find more receptive ears for your message. I didn’t even exclude the term “Mecca”.
@@generaljg4373 The only thing sketchy is your thinking process. Ancient Greek was the scholarly language of the ancient world, and most educated individuals would know how to speak their native language plus Ancient Greek, and often Latin as well. We also do have fragments in Aramaic and some early Hebrew, in addition to the Ancient Greek. Unlike the quaternity of worship in islam - muhammad, a pagan building that is circumambulated in adoration & worship, a chunk of rock that is kissed to remove sins, plus allah - the Judeo-Christian faiths have only one God, YHVH, who manifests in three distinct persons. Likewise, man created in YHVH’s image is a triune creation of mind, body, and spirit in each individual mortal.
Your ignorance is on full display. The Old and New Testaments are two halves of the same book: the Old Testament records YHVH’s covenant with the Hebrew people under the law as given through Moses, that looks forward to the divine promise of Messiah; the New Testament is the fulfillment of the promise of Messiah in Yeshua ha’Mashiach, and of His new covenant with mankind under grace. Christianity = fulfilled Judaism. The Christian world includes Catholics, but has no pope nor statues - and any artworks are nothing more than celebrations and reminders of mighty YHVH’s steadfastness to man. We do not worship idols nor kiss all over a chunk of rock nor believe an inanimate object (like a rock) can remove sins, nor do we encircle pagan buildings or monuments in adoration and worship. You do that.
I so want to thank Yasir Qadhi for giving us the image of the Muslim 'scholar' before the questions of his western colleagues' questions feeling like the emperor in the Children's story of the Emperor's New Clothes. I think that this was a truly inspired image that Dr Qadhi presented us with. The Muslim comes before the western scholars thinking that he is soooo finely dressed, he has such fiiiine arguments and what Muslims would always accept as irrefutable but before the questions of western scholars he finds that they have questions he just has no answers to. He recognises that, though his leaders before him have convinced him into believing he is sooo fiiinely dressed, he is in fact standing there, one hopes in his underwear. If not, he is exposed in his birthday suit for all to laugh at and ridicule. The sword of Islam has prevented this for many centuries. People in Muslim lands were under the rule of Muslim leaders whose authority and legitimacy was dependent on people being forced, by the threat of death to any apostate, to accept that, even though they saw the nakedness of their leaders, their leaders religious and political really were in place and backed by Allah himself. But now we have come to the age of the internet and Muslims from all over the world can learn from others all over the world who can see that it is all a fake tailor's con game. Now they can also pick up their smart phone and have access to not only the Quran to see the differences between the versions of Moses and the burning bush, or Satan not bowing to Adam etc and see almost side by side all the contradictions, but to all the tafsir that show how corrupt the events were behind little phrases like 'except those their right hands possess' really mean and can, at last, get to look at the collections of hadiths for themselves and see how many things their leaders have been hiding from them. then they see that all of Islam, the whole philosophy and legend is standing before the modern world in its underwear (they hope).
THIS I found on the internet and it DEBUNKS THE LIES AND RHETORIC OF JAY AND AL-FADI HERE IS A COPY AND PASTE from your bible study on Arabia. Take note that they ascribe many prophets in Arabia as well and even admit that Moses with the Exodus took his sheep to celebrate a festival to the LORD in Mecca. And I Quote from Bible Study Notes: The chief importance of the Hijaz arises from the fact that in it are situated the two holy cities of Mecca and Medina--the cradle and the grave of the Prophet. It is thus the religious center of the Islamic world. 2. Extinct Tribes: Of the extinct tribes the most familiar name is that of Amlak or Amlik (Amalek). By the Arabian genealogists he is variously described as a grandson of Shem and as a son of Ham. In Genesis 36:12 he is a son of Esau's son, Eliphaz, by Timna. They are said to be first met with in Chaldea, from which they were expelled on the rise of the Assyrian power under Nimrod. They migrated into Ar, occupying in turn the Bahrein, Oman, the Yemen, and finally the Hijaz, where they are said to have been the first settlers at Yathrib (Medina) and also to have occupied land round Mecca and Kheibar. In the time of Abraham they were expelled from Mecca on the arrival of two new tribes from the South, those of Jurhum and Katura (Genesis 25:1). Later, it is said, David, during the rebellion of Absalom, took up his quarters in Kheibar and ruled over the surrounding districts. According to another tradition Moses sent an expedition against the Amalekites in the Hijaz, on which occasion the Israelites, disobeying his orders, spared their king Arkam (compare Rekem, Numbers 31:8; Joshua @)--a reminiscence of the incident in the life of Saul (1 Samuel 15). In any case the Amalekites were supplanted in the northern Hijaz by Jewish tribes, who continued there until the time of Mohammad. North Arabian Tribes: Among the Arabs Ishmael holds the place occupied by Isaac in the Hebrew tradition. It was to the valley, afterward the site of the town of Mecca, that Abraham conducted Hagar and her son, and that Ishmael grew up and became the father of a great nation. The locality is full of spots connected by tradition with his life history, the ground where Hagar searched for water, the well Zemzem of which Gabriel showed her the place, the mount Thabir where Abraham would have sacrificed his son (Ishmael), and the graves of Hagar and Ishmael. The Jurhum, among whom Ishmael grew up, gave him seven goats: These were the capital with which he began life. He married a woman of Jurhum. He had twelve sons (Genesis 25:16) of whom Kaidar and Nabat are the best known, perhaps the Cedrei and Nabataei of Pliny; other sons were Dumah and Tema (which see). The subsequent history of the Ishmaelites is lost for several generations until we come to `Adnan, who is said to have been defeated by Nebuchadnezzar, when the latter invaded Arabia. All the Ishmaelite tribes are descended from `Adnan. They are the north Arabian tribes, as opposed to the Kahtanite or south Arabian. One of them, Koreish, under their chief, Kosay, became master of Mecca, driving out Koda`a. Later, as the tribe of the Prophet, they became the rulers of Arabia and the aristocracy of the Muslim empire; and the descendants of Mohammad remain to this day the only hierarchy known to Islam. 7. Foreign Elements: In Arabia there was and still, in spite of religious disabilities, is a large Jewish population. Before the age of Mohammad they lived chiefly in the Northwest, the two best known tribes--An-Nadir and Koreiza--occupying Yathrib (Medina). After the rise of Islam they were expelled from Arabia; but at the present time there are probably some 60,000 Jews in the Yemen alone 2. The Ka`ba, Pilgrimages and Fairs: Though there were many houses of God in the country, the chief religious resort even before the time of Mohammad was Mecca. The House of God (see BETHEL) here was called the Ka`ba, which is the English word "cube," the building being so called from its shape. It was believed to have been built by Abraham and Ishmael. The honor of acting as guardians of the House was a subject of rivalry among the tribes. The office was held consecutively by the tribes of Jurhum, Koda`a and Koreish, and last by the grandfather and uncles of Mohammad. These, therefore, correspond to the tribe of Levi in Israel. It is said to have contained a large number of images, but it is remarkable that the nearer our authorities get to the time of Mohammad the smaller is the number of images mentioned. The chief of these, Hubal, is not named in the Koran. The worship took the form of circumambulation (tawaf), running or marching round the sanctuary (compare Psalms 26:6). An annual visitation was and still is made by those living at a distance, and sacrifices are offered. This is the hajj or pilgrimage; the same name is used for the corresponding rite among the Hebrews (Exodus 10:9 and often). These religious assemblies were combined with fairs, at which markets were held and a considerable trade carried on. Before the time of Mohammad the great annual fair was held at Okaz, a place still pointed out about three days' journey East of Mecca and one day West of Taif. Here were not only all kinds of commercial transactions carried on--auctions, sales, settling of accounts and payment of blood-wit, but an academy was held at which poets recited their odes, and received judgment upon their merits. These fairs were generally held in the sacred months, that is, the first, seventh, eleventh and twelfth months, in which fighting was forbidden. They had therefore a great civilizing and pacifying influence. Ref BIBLE STUDY NOTES
@@zicozico6961 I have a copy. I have read it. It's full of evil and hate. It was compiled by perverts over centuries. Moe is a fictional character invented in 833 AD by a evil perv
Dear Muslims, the Quran is clear revelation and explains everything in detail. But you need tafseer, sunnah/ahadith and commentaries on the ahadith. And they all contradict each other. WAKE UP
@@zicozico6961 I have read the Qur'an. It is a satanic book attributed to a suicidal man (Muhammad). Sahih al-Bukhari 6982 I choose the perfect living Messiah, Jesus.
@@zicozico6961 I have read the Qur'an. It teaches an abomination before the Lord. Qur'an 2:230 vs Deuteronomy 24:1-4 It teaches the divorce of little girls Qur'an 65:4. It teaches teaches adultery Qur'an 4:24. Islam is a satanic cult of a pedophile. Sahih al-Bukhari 5133
just an observation. when i started watching videos debunking Islam about 8 years ago i would see many muslims responding with "lols" but now i dont see muslims responding. Could it be that they are embarrassed or that they have left Islam.
You have been watching videos debunking islam for 8 years!? Why do you keep watching them, what interests you? Maybe they don’t respond anymore because they are tired of senseless arguments that will get them nowhere, and the biased hate they get from ignorant people.
@@ahmed4397 i doubt that Ahmed, i believe it is bc many of them have stopped believing or bc they can no longer tolerate seeing videos that destroy their ideology like the ones that al fadi is producing. Are you a believer? If you are then here is a question i ask all muslims. ). Please show me where Gog and Magog are located. The Koran has given you some hints. It states that they are trapped between two mountains behind a wall made of iron and lead (18:94-97 Yusif Ali translation). Show me where it is on Google earth and i will forget about all the other nonsensical and immoral aspects of Islam and i will say the shahada. That will be a nice feather in your cap for converting such an infidel! But if you cannot find where they are located then will you leave Islam?
Moslems see no point arguing. Whatever float your boats at this point. Some ppl so threaten by Islam they have to make these videos to convince themselves. It’s very entertaining actually. We already have clear guidance straight from God. That’s all we need.
@@nunya54 Not an argument! This is something that someone writes when they are desperate without any other way to attack. Please give proof from the 7th century or before that Mecca existed. There is so many ways to prove that other cities existed in the 7th century or even much earlier. Cities like Petra and Jerusalem. Go ahead, i'm waiting!
@@nathanjohnwade2289 the trinity is a pagan doctrine in christianity people believe in 3 Gods, muslims and Jews believe in one God, Christians cunfused by the holly ghost
@@generaljg4373 We're not the ones that are confused and paganism had ABSOLUTELY NO influence over Christianity. And how do you know that paganism came up with their so called "trinity" first? Also, Judaism has had schools thought that the Old Testament shows multiple personages of YHWH. As for Islam, they commit shirk by ascribing "salvation" through Muhammed. They also commit shirk by stating that the Qur'an is eternal and uncreated. Also, in Muslim traditions, each chapter of the Qur'an will appear separately at the "Day of Reconpence". Sam Shamounian has plenty of videos proving Christ and debunking HERETICS & BLASPHIMERS like you. If you're not a coward, contact him.
Hi Al Fad et al, would you consider a series on Jesus is not Isa? Because my in my search and discussion with muslims I cannot find Jesus anywhere in the Koran and hadith. Isa seems to be a different character with different mother, birthplace and life. Thats fo your great work. May God bless you!
Mecca could not have existed as a large commercial caravan city in the 7th century. Main reasons for this fact are: 1) Mecca is not an oasis, so there is no surface water (only a well, known as zamzam which is clearly unsufficient and inappropriate for watering many caravan camels) 2) Mecca is not shown on any map or any document at that time or even previously 3) Mecca is located down of Hidjaz plateau and could therefore not be located on the caravan route which is located more than 1000 m above on the plateau (eg the city of Taeef is located at an altitude of ca 2000 m while Mecca is at 300 m) 4) there were no archeological remains or artefacts (coins, potteries, ruins, bones etc) discovered in Mecca dating from before circa year 700 It is impossible that a large city would leave no trace at all of its past 5) no agriculture whatsoever is possible in this wild rocky desert location, how could a large city survive in such hostile environment ?
Theory of qibla in Petra is totally absurd... Thousand year ago, we already have trader, sailor, astronomer, traveler, navigator, algebra and so on. It's impossible to replace one mountain to another even back then... How they travel to southeast Asian then get back to their homeland, or travel by silk road from China to Italy and then going back if they do not master the navigation. It's impossible they do not recognize their family, their homeland. What the heck is going on? 🤣🤣 Please mind your own religion, talk about yours only, otherwise we know you afraid of something. Wait what? Why afraid if your religion is true right?
Historians have established that there was no more polytheism in Arabia in the 7th century as most Arabs, especially in cities, had been christianized. Therefore the "mushrikuns" so often cited in the quran, often translated as "polytheists" or "associators" or "idolaters" refer in fact to christians who believe in trinity (meaning that they give "associates" to God, which is considered in islam to be the worse sin called "shirk") ... and not at all to so-called "pagans" or "idolaters" from Mecca (which did not even exist in the 7th century).
10:06 mahomet died from poisoning by a jewish women who's husband & family just had been slaughtered by mahomet & his gang, then where is his grave? and what about that story of him sitting on the flying donkey that landed at the dome of the rock?
I thought it was a cow, a flying cow. If my memory is correct, that cow had a human face. In any case, this story is nonsensical, hard to believe for that reason.
Isn't that narrative based on sunni traditions? Does the Shia traditions differ somewhat? There's also a muslim ad before your video started asking for donations to help fight islamophobia. I thought that was humorous.
Quran 4:157 says: "That they said (in boast), "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah";- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not:"- The person on the cross was Jesus' doppelgänger, Thomas who was known as the twin; Taowm in Aramaic and Thomas in Greek. Thomas was a Galilean as were all of the disciples.There are two gospels which mention Thomas' relationship to Jesus. The first gospel mentions Thomas' given name as Judah (Judas in Greek) and his nickname as Thomas, so he is referred to as Judas Thomas. According to the Gospel of Thomas: "These are the secret sayings that the living Jesus spoke and Didymus, Judas Thomas, recorded." Didymus means 'twin' in Greek The Gospel of Thomas dates to as early as the Epistles of Paul and is composed of the sayings of Jesus Likewise, the second gospel to reference Thomas' connection to Jesus also mentions that he was known as Judas Thomas. This gospel known as the The Book of Thomas the Contender, was originally written around 150 A. This book states: “The secret words that the savior spoke to Judas Thomas which I, even I, Mathaias, wrote down, while I was walking, listening to them speak with one another. The savior said, “Brother Thomas while you have time in the world, listen to me, and I will reveal to you the things you have pondered in your mind. “Now, since it has been said that you are my twin and true companion, examine yourself, and learn who you are, in what way you exist, and how you will come to be. Since you will be called my brother, it is not fitting that you be ignorant of yourself.” Thomas, aka Judas Thomas, was a very loyal follower who volunteered to take Jesus’ place so that Jesus could escape, and Jesus with the rest of the group could re-assemble in Galilee as was planned (Mark 14:28, 16:7). According to the Gospel of John:11, Thomas had earlier volunteered to die with Jesus when Jesus, upon hearing of the death of Lazarus, proposed to return to Judea where there was a previous attempt to stone him to death: Jhn 11:7 Then after this he (Jesus) said to the disciples, “Let us go into Judea again.” Jhn 11:8 The disciples said to him, “Rabbi, the Jews of late sought to stone you, and are you going there again?”… Jhn 11:16 Thomas, called the Twin, said to his fellow disciples, “Let us also go, that we may die with him.” The confirmation that it was not Jesus on the cross was given by the imposter (Thomas) who declared in Matt 27:46: And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? that is, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani is a misquote of Psalm 22 which says in Hebrew: ‘Eli ‘Eli lamah `azab’tani." Jesus would not have made such a mistake as he was preaching the Torah and the Tanakh in the synagogues.This misquotation is an affirmation that it was not Jesus on the cross. This misquotation may have been a subtle scoff to the chief priests, the teachers of the law, the elders as well as other jeering bystanders who were mocking him (Matt 27:41, Mark 15:31, Luke 23L45) that they had crucified the wrong man. According to Mark 15: 40 there were women followers who also witnessed the crucifixion. These women knew it wasn't Jesus on the cross. They were anxious to get Thomas down before the jeering temple authority found out the truth. The temple authority knew that Jesus was a Galilean and that he would have fled to his clan for protection. If they had discovered the ruse, these priests and pharisees would have sent the Romans after him and his disciples. According to Matthew 28:16 Jesus and his disciples made the journey safely to Galilee where he openly ate and drank with his disciples. According to Jesus' declaration in Mark 12:25, the resurrected body will be like that of an angel. According to Hebrews 1:14 angels are ministering spirits. According Jesus in Luke 24:39:"...a spirit does not have flesh and bones, as you see that I have." Jesus then proceeded to show his disciples his hands and feet which bore no wounds as he ate and drank without difficulty. So, Jesus himself demonstrated that he was alive and unhurt and perfectly able to enjoy a meal because he had not been crucified.
I have not come across any m0slem scholars that can do a presentation of similar caliber like this one. I saw ShabirAli refutation was merely sitting on his chair babbling.
Powerful series ... to celebrate the false SIN of 2022 Ramadan ... ironically. When critically questioned and examined ... everything is a lie ... including the holiest birth place of this cult that is so deceitful and devious ... to maintain its grip and hold over gullible minds and innocent hearts. May this very destructive and corrosive hold be broken ... for many and may they be brought to the light and liberty of the true gospel.
Maybe Islam was created to be a unifying factor for Abbasids just like Constantines desire to use Christianity as a unifying factor for the Roman Empire
I've read the Qu'ran (English). Oi vey! It was a hard read. Basically this book takes bits from Torah and Bible then Islamicised them. I was surprised how much Jesus (nabi Isa) is talked about. In Muslim eschatology says Muhammad and Jesus return to defeat the devil (dajjal). How many times is Mecca mentioned in the book? A few times with a few more references. Does the word "Makkah" mean Mecca?
You should do a show on Shipwreck off Israeli coasts which shows Christian symbols & Allah but no Muhammad. The name of the article is "Shipwreck off Israeli coast changes what we know about the early Islamic period - Archaeology"
SURAH 3:81 : AN ERROR OF ALLAH (ISLAMIC) - THE FALSE GOD ALLAH VS MUHAMMAD : ARE THEY IMPOSTERS OR ARE THEY FICTITIOUS CHARACTERS??? Surah 3:81: And remember when Allah took the Covenant of the Prophets, saying: “Take whatever I gave you from the Book and Hikmah (understanding of the Laws of Allah), and afterwards there will come to you a Messenger (Muhammad) confirming what is with you; you must, then, believe in him and help him.” Allah said: “Do you agree to it and will you take up My Covenant which I conclude with you?” They said: “We agree.” He said: “Then bear witness; and I am with you among the witnesses for this.” (Hilali-Khan) Allah took a covenant with the Prophets, saying: “Now that you have been given the Book and Wisdom; there will come to you a Messenger who will confirm that which is with you, you will have to believe in him and help him in his mission.” Then He said “Do you affirm this covenant and agree to take this heavy responsibility?” The Prophets replied, “Yes, we do affirm.” Allah said, “Very well, bear witness to this and I too bear witness with you.” (Farook Malik) A careful examination of Surah 3:81 reveals the following: (1) Allah made a Covenant with the Prophets who lived before the time of Muhammad. (2) These Prophets were called upon by Allah to pledge their support to a forthcoming Messenger who was to appear to them later. (3) The Prophets agreed and Allah secures their pledge to assist this forthcoming Messenger. (4) This coming Messenger will confirm the previous Book of Allah which is in the possession of these Prophets. (5) Since this Messenger will come during the lifetime of these Prophets, they will be on hand to personally witness his confirmation of their sacred Book. (6) Allah concludes the Covenant by bearing witness along with the Prophets to ensure the fulfillment of this divine agreement. (7) Therefore, Surah 3:81 testifies that Allah himself is a witness to this irrevocable Covenant which guarantees that there will be Prophets on hand to assist this forthcoming Messenger in his assigned mission. All Muslim scholars acknowledged that the Messenger mentioned in Surah 3:81 refers to none other than Muhammad. This conclusion is further substantiated in the above translation of the Qur’an by Hilali-Khan. This raises some very vital questions: Who were the Prophets who lived during the time of Muhammad to fulfill this Covenant of Allah? Who were the Prophets on hand to help Muhammad in his mission as the Messenger of Allah? Who were the Prophets present at the time of Muhammad to witness his confirmation of their Scriptures? None! Not a single Prophet, from among whom Allah allegedly made the Covenant with, was present at the time of Muhammad. Yet, Allah clearly testified to the presence of these Prophets during the time of this Messenger. In fact, Allah swore these Prophets into his Covenant for the sole purpose to support this forthcoming Messenger. And Allah bore witness in the Qur’an that these Prophets will be on hand to assist this Messenger in his mission. However, there were none - not even newly appointed Prophets to act as substitutes for these Prophets. This leaves us with two options: One: Allah was wrong in his claim regarding the presence of Prophets during the time of Muhammad. Two: The Messenger mentioned in Surah 3:81 is referring to someone other than Muhammad. Either option spells disaster for Islam. What is even more damaging for Islam is the fact that Muhammad excluded himself as the Messenger in Surah 3:81. Muhammad clearly ruled out the co-existence of any Prophets during his career as the Messenger of Allah. Muhammad openly testified to this reality when he proclaimed the following to his early Companions. Sahih Muslim, Book 30, Number 5835: Abu Huraira reported Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: I am most akin to Jesus Christ among the whole of mankind, and all the Prophets are of different mothers but belong to one religion and no Prophet was raised between me and Jesus. A well-known Islamic website was asked how many Prophets were there between the time of Jesus and the birth of Muhammad. Here is their reply: The only Prophet Allah appointed after He raised Jesus (a.s.) to Himself alive, was the Last and Final Messenger of Allah, Muhammad dur-Rasool Allah (saw). There are no Prophets between Jesus (a.s.) and the Mohamed ar Rasool Allah (saws). (www.islamhelpline.net) Muhammad clearly taught that “no Prophets” were raised between the time of Jesus and him. In other words, the only Prophet who came after the time of Jesus was Muhammad. This means that there could be no Prophets on hand to either welcome or assist Muhammad. However, Surah 3:81 clearly testifies that there would be Prophets available to assist this new Messenger. Since all Islamic scholars without exception recognized Muhammad as the Messenger of Surah 3:81, they must now explain why there were no Prophets at the time of Muhammad. Muslims cannot provide the name of a single Prophet who was a contemporary of Muhammad. The instant they come up with a name, they would be challenging the teachings of Muhammad. Here we find two conflicting teachings in Islam. Allah clearly stated in Surah 3:81 that there would be Prophets to assist Muhammad. In contrast, Muhammad taught that there would be none. Muslims have to choose between Allah and Muhammad. If Allah is right, then Muhammad is wrong. On the other hand, if Muhammad is right, then Allah is wrong. Either option destroys the legitimacy of Islam since this clearly demonstrates that one of them is definitely in error. As events unfolded, it became evident that there were no Prophets at the time of Muhammad. Thus, Allah was clearly in error. Man can make mistakes but not God. This fatal error of Allah in the Qur’an proves that he is a false god. As such, Muhammad was a prophet of a false god. Can a prophet of a false god be a true prophet? Absolutely not! This is an irrefutable evidence in the Qur’an that Muhammad was a false prophet. Muslims have to choose between a false prophet and a false god.
The clocktower got 7 towers, there is a door in mecca called bab illah, the beast in islam is the opposite of the one in the bible. 666 nautical miles from Jerusalem to Mecca
From the perspective of the emanated created realms, Creation takes place "Yesh me-Ayin" ("Something from Nothing"). From the Divine perspective, Creation takes place "Ayin me-Yesh" ("Nothing from Something"), as only God has absolute existence; Creation is dependent on the continuous flow of Divine lifeforce, without which it would revert to nothingness. Since the 13th century, Ayin has been one of the most important words used in kabbalistic texts. The symbolism associated with the word Ayin was greatly emphasized by Moses de León (c. 1250 - 1305), a Spanish rabbi and kabbalist, through the Zohar, the foundational work of Kabbalah. In Hasidism Ayin relates to the internal psychological experience of Deveikut ("cleaving" to God amidst physicality), and the contemplative perception of paradoxical Yesh-Ayin Divine Panentheism, "There is no place empty of Him".
Hi Brothers in Christ, great work! I recently came across a Muslim who asked me what about Imam Malik, and was criticizing you for not including him on the timeline, I showed him how even he is pretty late according to traditional dates for his birth and death (and also contains embarrassing info). Can you talk about him in one of your episodes, or if you have already, please let me know where :) Thank you. God bless!
Without lies the standard islamic narrative (SIN) collapses ... There clearly is a distinction to make between the initial meaning of the coranic text (which was originally christian, though anti-trinitarian) and the meaning that was imposed (and distorted) later (9th and 10th centuries) by the Abbassid caliphs (with the creation of the so-called "prophetic tradition" or "sunnah" with a multitude of hadiths, tafsir and siraa inventions). Their goal was to create a new religion serving their imperial interests of conquest and domination by the sword ... which still persists today as core islamic political ideology, such as the Muslim Brotherhood, Al Qaida or ISIS and other salafists. Without lies the standard islamic narrative (SIN) collapses ...
@@hdl135605 You will never hear the name of the city of Nazareth either in the Old Testament, in the Talmud, and in the records of Josephus. Even the new testaments never agree on Nazareth, The area currently identified as Nazareth does not conform to the description of Nazareth in the Gospels. There was no hill from which to try and throw Jesus.
*Baca - is it Mecca???* It is sometimes claimed that the Bible mentions Mecca. Where Does the Claim Come From? In Surah 3:96, Mecca is given the name Bakkah: Verily, the first House (of worship) appointed for mankind was that at Bakkah (Makkah), full of blessing, and a guidance for Al-`Alamin (the mankind and jinns). The Bible, in Psalm 84:5,6, mentions the valley of Baca: Blessed are those whose strength is in you, who have set their hearts on pilgrimage. As they pass through the Valley of Baca, they make it a place of springs: the autumn rains also cover it with pools. These two quotes, taken together, have been seen to imply that Psalm 84 is talking about making the pilgrimage to Mecca. One notable example is an article by Dr. M S M Saifullah. But the argument is made by many Muslim speakers including Dr. Jamal Badawi. Is the Claim Justified? There are several reasons why this claim cannot be sustained. Even without reference to scholarly works, a brief look at the passage itself makes the situation clear. The whole psalm focuses on God's sanctuary and how the writer loves to spend time there. The author is one of ‘the Sons of Korah’ and internal evidence points to it being written after the building of the temple in Jerusalem by Solomon. Because of the psalm's focus on the sanctuary, there are several phrases which describe features of it, enabling us to evaluate the claim that it is Mecca: v.1 - ‘How lovely is your dwelling place, O Lord Almighty!’ v.3 - ‘... a place near your altar, O Lord Almighty ...’ v.4 - ‘Blessed are they who dwell in your house’ v.7 - ‘They go from strength to strength, till each appears before God in Zion.’ v.10 - ‘I would rather be a doorkeeper in the house of my God ...’ These five points count heavily against the claim outlined above. Firstly (I am open to correction on these points), I do not suppose that Muslims would accept the idea of Allah dwelling in the Ka'aba. I certainly am not aware of this way of thinking in Islam. On the other hand, the Bible repeatedly mentions the temple in Jerusalem as God's dwelling place, even though he is not limited to a building. In 1 Kings 8:27, Solomon, on the completion of his great temple, said this: 'But will God really dwell on earth? The heavens, even the highest heaven, cannot contain you. How much less this temple I have built!' This makes it clear that the idea of God dwelling in the temple is figurative and not that he is limited to one building. However, it shows clearly that this way of thinking is found in the Bible. Secondly, there is no altar which is given prominence at the Ka'aba, whereas the altar was an integral part of the tabernacle and then the Jerusalem temple, necessary for the sacrificial system instituted by God. (Exodus 27:1-8, 1 Kings 8:64). Thirdly, the Ka'aba is empty and certainly no humans dwell in it. Yet Psalm 84 mentions those who dwell in God's house. This makes no sense unless it is the Jerusalem temple, which had rooms within its courts (1 Chronicles 28:11,12) for those who were responsible for its upkeep and ceremony. Fourthly, the pilgrims in Psalm 84 are certainly not on their way to Mecca, as their destination is given as Zion. Mount Zion is one of the hills on which Jerusalem is founded. In the Bible Zion is often used synonymously with Jerusalem (Isaiah 2:2). This point is made even stronger by examining the word used for ‘pilgrimage’ in Psalm 84:5. The Hebrew word used in Psalm 84:5 is from a completely different root to this and is usually translated as ‘road’ or ‘highway’. Thus it seems from a brief consideration that the phrase is literally like saying in English ‘those ... who have set their hearts on the highway’, meaning the way they must take to get to Jerusalem. So even the ideas of pilgrimage in the Bible and the Qur'an have a different emphasis. Just because the English translation of Psalm 84:5 says ‘pilgrimage’ we can't simply equate it with the Hajj to mecca. Fifthly, there is no recognised function of doorkeeper for the Ka'aba. However, this was an official job at the Jerusalem Temple (2 Kings 25:18). What Then is the Valley of Baca? Baca has been translated either as ‘weeping’ or ‘balsam trees’ (which grow in dry places). It could be a real place, in which case it was a valley through which the pilgrims passed during their journey. Alternatively, it could be figurative. In this interpretation, even the dry, arid places through which the pilgrims pass are brought alive by their expectant joy as they near their destination. In either case, their pilgrimage is clearly to Jerusalem, as evidenced by the rest of the psalm. Why on earth would Jews, living in Israel and on their way to Jerusalem, take a huge detour through Mecca? Whatever our conclusion as to the true identity of the valley of Baca, the only link between it and the Bakkah of the Quran is a superficial similarity in name. The further details about the location point away from the two being identical. Since that is the case, why should we not link the Bakkah of surah 3:96 with any other place having a similar sounding name? Here is a quote from the article mentioned above: ...we often find this word in the names related to rivers and wadis, such as Wadi al-Baka in the Sinaitic district and Baca on the wadi in the central Galilee area, W of Meroth. This shows that there are other places with similar names. Why then, do we not hear people claiming that the Quran is referring to these? It seems to me that it is because there is a prior commitment on the part of some to finding evidence for the Quran in the Bible. This, if found, would strengthen the claim that Islam is completely in line with all God's earlier revelations. However, in this case, it cannot be sustained.
Can you explain about the Maliki Mazhab , now that mazhab live in the north Africa , but that mazhab come from Madinah , their founder Malik IBN Annas was a student of a former slave of IBN Umar , he only have two chain to the prophet, Malik student of Nafi former slave of IBN Umar, Nafi student of IBN Umar and IBN Umar student of propeth Muhammad directly or from his father Omar IBN khattab a propeth companion , you should look on the biography of the ulema that love in hejaz like IBN Umar and other
Discovery of this chanel gives me boldness to witness to Muslims the more. I pity them and I don't hate them. It was so unfortunate they've been deceived for so long .
The prophet lived in bahrah.mekke valley is the valley of fatimah. In another verse, it is said that you were at the bottom of the valley, the enemy was at the top of the valley, and the caravan was at the bottom of the valley. This valley is the valley of Fatimah. .and the verses about the qibla show that the prophet is in bahrah. because for prayer you turn east and the kaaba is east of bahrah
Dr. Smith many believe Ur of the Chaldees. is actually the city of Ur-kesh is on the border between Syria and Turkey. See the work of Dr. David Falk, egyptologist.
