#eastidahonews #daybell #trial Melanie Gibb testified at Lori Vallow Daybell's trial on Thursday, April 13. Here is an audio recording of her testimony.
@@tracyrobo7606 It was intended to be sarcastic or funny although this is a very serious matter. Glad you understood I was being sarcastic. Some people do not understand my inputs but thankful for you today.
Hey EVERYONE: If you have a friend who starts stating that people you know are zombies and that they are dark and will die soon CONTACT your local police department immediately. Thats a no-brainer for most of us; just had to put that out there.
This is insane to me that 2 children were missing and 2 adults killed at the point of the 20 minute phonecall and these people are arguing about who's most righteous!! Nuts!!!
I was thinking the same thing! It felt like a cringey real housewives of the doomsday cult fight scene. There are actual bodies buried in their backyard and they’re fighting over who reads their scriptures more? Gross.
If my friends ever started talking this crazy shit, I would distance myself. Melanie believed everything they were spewing. She's as crazy as Lori and Chad.
Come on, the LDS church is responsible and needs to be held accountable! Lori and Chad are doing the same thing Joseph Smith was doing minus the murders. They just took it to another level. Who knows what Brigham Young did out in the West, he could have been doing the same thing will never know. But they met in the temple, they plotted in the temple, their Bishop who's supposed to have a bead on God as "revelation allows," these murderers and adulterers traipsed on inside the House of the Lord! No problem! The Bishop's let them right in! No big deal ... Well, the church is responsible and they're just as responsible for the flds and should take care of those folks too!
How is this woman not guilty of aiding or conspiring for not alerting authorities? She clearly knew about much of the planning before they were killed.
Melanie G: For a person now claiming she had doubts about Lori's claims, Melanie did not behave as if she did not believe Lori. Her "doubts," seemed to emerge at exactly the moment Melanie was contacted by police, or learned of policy involvement. This woman is such a liar.
This woman is infuriating! How on earth could she even listen to a mother say her child had a dark spirit? How do you listen to such crap without saying anything? She should be locked up with the rest. It’s shameful that she did nothing said nothing while this was going on. And now sits there telling all this without shame or guilt. I hope she lives w regret everyday of her life.
And she is still a prepper and married to that nut David Wawrick I would have run as fast as I could from that LDS cult. And she says I don’t think I believe that about zombies you don’t think ?? Normal people with say BS straight up smh
I hope she go to jail for conspiracy if her mouth is open she's lying new husband needs to think about himself not being above the law also he can't be that dumb
This is one jury I would love to be a fly on the wall for once deliberations starts lol many media outlets have already said that the jurors are treating this like a science project! Also loris defense is now using the tactic of “call a objection outside of the presence of the jury” I can only imagine the looks they been giving the defense and Lori…it’s honestly a ki!
I lived in Utah and Idaho for thirteen years; except for the murders, there are many people like Chad and Lori who believe that God has given them special revelations. Several men just swore that God had told them that I was their eternal mate, for example, even though we had not dated and I was not a Mormon.
These people have delusions of grandeur. I hate to break it to you Lori, you’re just not that important. I can barely keep myself within the Community Guidelines in these comments re these sick selfish narcissists. How dare they decide who is “dark” or light, deserving of life and death, all in accordance with their disgusting egos?
She said something about being concerned for her soul if she did any wrong I can’t believe she thinks God didn’t see what she did to her children and she thinks that’s not going to “tarnish her” in gods eyes.
How do any of these people not has knocks at the door checking on who’s dead and whose alive in the lineage? They think killing is justified and called for.
She needs her own trial because she is one of the co-conspirators. Correct, I feel, I believe, I would say.... she is a terrible witness, and the defense team is going to regret having her as a witness.
She only told the truth once she was directly involved, prior to that she had no problem with these people being murdered. She knew those kids were dead and said nothing.
David 100% true. All these people are trash. Castings, elements, warriors, gathers - these people been playing too many video games. They need to try and read the real Bible. Teenage child taking care of an autistic brother and they wonder why she is rebellious? Maybe Lori should have tried being a wife and mother instead of a whore.
Melanie Gibb Lori Vallow Trial CO-CONSPIRATOR PROOF. Melanie Gibb testifies at Lori Vallow Daybell trial: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-UHQRpc9Lukk.html TRANSCRIPT: believed that they had been married in multiple probations on this 11:12 I'm gonna object has to hearsay judge what's the response from the state 11:18 your honor it's the statement of a party opponent not this opponent 11:25 it's a statement of a CO-CONSPIRATOR all right I'm gonna overrule the objection under rule 801 d2e that does 11:33 allow statements of CO-CONSPPIRATORS and furtherance of evidence of a CONSPIRACY 11:39 that's how that's allowed Miss Blake I would indicate though that I think there 11:45 may be some additional Foundation before getting further into this issue as to 11:51 whether those statements are allowed thank you governor 11:58 Miss Gibb did you have conversations about their first meeting with Chad 12:04 dabel 12:11 have conversations with him I'm sorry I'm not understanding could you ever speak to Chad about the first time he
It amazes me how involved in religion they claimed to be, yet committing adultery, lying, manipulating people, scheming, and plotting and planning multiple murders. It's sickening! After all they have done there is no shame or remorse.
What's the point and why is that so amazing without actually prosecuting.its actually disgusting that she refers to her as that and admits it but doesn't do anything disgusting
so this lady knew that “dark” translated to “were going to kill them, or at least try”. And Lori told her that jj and Tylee were “dark” and she didn’t call the police or interfere in any way while the kids were still alive? So where tf are her charges? She could have saved them 💔
Do you really believe that police would take such information seriously? I agree that she should do something but I doubt that they would do anything. There was no crime
The way Melanie speaks about Tylee is so disrespectful to me. My God, she was a teenager who had an insane mother. Maybe she was defiant or disrespectful but my God, to speak about a murdered child that way just does not sit right with me.
Andrea Melanie was just being honest about their relationship. Tylee is in some ways responsible for her life ,JJ life, Tammy life and possibility for Alex life. Not to mention the attempt on Brandon Boudreaux life. To be honest Tylee lied to investigators and to the police officers on Charles murder. Which if she hadn't lied JJ, and herself (Tylee) and Tammy would be alive today and Brandon wouldn't had to go thru his trauma event. Tylee also had issues in her own behavior. Lori, Chad and Alex are pure evil and justice will be served because of Melanie Gibb.
Melanie was very well aware of what Chad and Lori believed. The fact that Lori was telling her about spouses dying so then they can be together, all the people related to Lori, Chad's wife , Lori's ex, all are dead and she tells no one? She doesn't go to police? If only someone would have , the kids could possibly have lived. These two serial killers were just able to keep killing. Not one person talked to the cops and said, hey you might want to check out what's going on?? Pretty sad.
Melanie was buddy buddy to try and get laid. When she lied to the police about having JJ and then she changed her mind and recorded that phone call that was just cracked up crazy. Hook up King Chad Daybell.
LISTEN TO THE INTERVIEW WITH NATE. THIS WOMAN SHOULD BE IN PRISON. SHE KNEW THOSE KIDS WERE GONNA DIE AND DID NOTHING. THEY WERE ALL SWINGING AND HAVING SEX WITH EACH OTHER! 🤢🤮
So, Lori is saying JJ went to live with Kay, but practically in the same sentence saying Kay is dark...? Does this lie make sense to anyone that heard it?
Lori said jj went to live with Kay? I remember it was Alex saying that and Lori said Mel had them then wouldn't say where they were but that they are safe.
Gee, Melanie. Judging by now things ended, don't you think that Tylee was MORE than justified to not like being around her mother or her mother's insane friends?
I watched her early interviews, just as screwed up with church, I wonder if she’s found her head now. I’d be furious and divorce her! She’s just a liar. Totally complicit!
Charles went to M Gibb, he was crying and asking for help. Gibb did not help him even if ehe knew the children was missing. Gibb covered for Lori and is deeply involved.
Your friend calls you to tell you to lie to police about their missing child and you don't pick up when the cops call because you 'didn't know what in the world to do'. And this woman thinks she's morally superior and intelligent.
Mel G had the opportunity to back Charles up when he went to the police questioning his and the kids safety due to her mental state. She was with Lori and Tylee at the police station while Lori was wriggling and giggling her way out of a mental assessment based on what Charles had said. SHE made a CHOICE to just go along with it. She is guilty and has blood in her hands indirectly at least.
LISTEN TO THE INTERVIEW WITH NATE. THIS WOMAN SHOULD BE IN PRISON. SHE KNEW THOSE KIDS WERE GONNA DIE AND DID NOTHING. THEY WERE ALL SWINGING AND HAVING SEX WITH EACH OTHER! 🤢🤮
Zulemma was friends with lori, did these CASTINGs, marries alex, 3 weeks later hes DEAD. Witnesses to loris plans tylee, jj, alex all DEAD. I believe zulema is involved in alex death for lori, alex being alleged involved in the kids, Charles, Brandon's shooting, chads wife had gun in her face 3 weeks before chad murdered her, my pinion. Melanie gibbs did nothing to save those kids, knowing lori said they were zombies. Knowing about lori chad saying zombies bodies need destroyed. Melanie knew those kids were in danger she's complicit
@@suzitee8225 yes they were I have been following this story since day one . I could not believe that no one came forward to protect those kids when they were missing for over eight months .
She was involved in several 'castings' for Charles Vallow and others after Charles was murdered. What did she think was going to happen to all the others... especially the children?? She could have contacted someone and reported that there were castings and afterwards some of those people died.
@@susy590 and what do you think would have happened? Her own husband was begging the police to intervene and help him do something. His son was missing, and nothing. The children were missing for how long and nothing happened? The Vallows did try and warn them and nothing. Melanie is lucky she isn’t dead, and we are lucky that she is alive to help explain all this craziness bc Lori and Chad sure as heck won’t.
I think she believed the LDS stuff, which has a lot of prepping for the end-of-days stuff AND which is so disempowering to women, it probably felt amazing to be part of the elite dream team who could know things before the church leaders (all men) and who had the power to cast out demons (who inhabited only persons she didn’t know or like). She’s probably a lot less naive and proud now!
Not only that he was sent to Kay, but that Lori was so clever she was going to tell Kay she had cancer to trick the Woodcocks into taking JJ and that it worked. If only she had done that. 😢
- it is very obvious that the phone call was self serving, and it's very interesting that we all remember more about what gibb has said and done than she does
Why is this woman not on trial also ? She was at or around every death, she admits to talking to Lori about Charles Life insurance , She helped Lori clean Charles out of all his possessions ( in the jail interview ) was at or around on the date Tylee went missing , Also was the last to see JJ .
Yes. Feel the same way about her. How easy it'd be to recall all those interactions as this instead of participating in the destruction of all these people. She gets to pretend to be innocent and have no repercussions
LISTEN TO THE INTERVIEW WITH NATE. THIS WOMAN SHOULD BE IN PRISON. SHE KNEW THOSE KIDS WERE GONNA DIE AND DID NOTHING. THEY WERE ALL SWINGING AND HAVING SEX WITH EACH OTHER! 🤢🤮 She was given 100% immunity to Testify.
Police believed her and didn't find something quilty on her interview, her behaviour,in her telephone records etc. She is a moron of religion like millions they are too but all the cultists aren't murders. Chad and lori aren't religious people, they believed that they were but both were sociopaths and narcissists. Melanie was the only one who helped police to find the truth about all this mess of deaths and lies.
Only Catholic Priests are ordained to perform an Exorcism. They have many years of training. The cult mom thought she was a Goddess already. Can you imagine that two adulterers could seal themselves to each other inside the Gilbert Temple? To the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, please know these heretics do NOT give the church a disparaging name. I’m hopeful Temple Workers more closely monitor individuals when in the Temple as to their goings on. Everyone of these Co-Conspirators should be excommunicated, pronto! Melanie Gibb sounds like she still believes all the PTP pseudo hogwash doctrine. SICK!
@@AdaraBalabusta BS She knew that if someone was considered a zombie that it was a death sentence and did NOTHING to stop killings. She helped Lori hide Charles belongings and thought it was funny. Melanie Gibb was neck deep in all of it. She should be prosecuted as an accomplice. She saw Chad and Lori acting in a sexual manner while he was still married. She knew Tammy was considered a zombie and would be killed..
Melanie Gibb 'I'm always kind except when I'm appealing to my sky wizard for the death of little children, and obstructing a police investigation in those children's disappearance'. What a despicable creature.
Melanie was in our massage school, i just happened to see her on RU-vid once shared it with a classmate who knew about This crazy story but didn't know she was involved. I dived down the rabbit hole and with small experiences with Melanie at school and watching more videos, i tried to avoid her like the plague and she knew it and it pissed her off haha. I told a few classmates about it but told everyone once i heard her trying to convert a girl to Mormonism in class. She is such a hypocrite, says she never lies and doesn't know how to manipulate, but from what i saw in person and RU-vid she does both often enough.
@@Lau_rynn yes she did. Watch that big interview she did. She says it a couple of times. Her and her partner are creepers. I watched it with my own eyes heard it with my ears. So your wrong wrong wrong
@Cynthia Carter I think you're probably right! Because she knows way more than she's saying. Even when she did that long interview, it was obvious she was lying and hiding things.
i don’t know what she knew before or after the fact, but i DO know she only came clean to law enforcement when she was worried about her own ass being thrown under the bus. In all honesty, if she DID (or does) know something, she was probably terrified she might be next on the list to be snuffed out. I’m totally suspicious about her 3rd husband’s and Alex’s death. They both look like classic poisoning cases to me, which is the most common way women kill
I loved the cross examination! When Melanie said something incriminating he would pause. I don’t think the jury missed what he was trying to convey to him.
This defense attorney is up against an unwinnable case. There is just no way on this earth that she will be found innocent. There are too many witnesses to her insanity. He can all he wants to discredit the witnesses, but the preponderance of the evidence will win out in the end.
The way Lori Sits up in Court, Smiles, Chats &. Laughs with her Attorney's, whilst All this Horrific Evidence is being Presented, is just Astounding.☹️
Lol😂 on top of that, she didn’t want to be there for the second half of one of the days because of her ‘mental health’ 😢 I think the mental health argument is far gone at this point, mental or not, look at what you did to these children, look at it and wallow in your own self pity. I liked the idea of tying her to the chair and gagging her…. 🎉
Right. It was all good that spouses were dying & kids "went dark" & went missing with b.s. answers from her supposed "best friend". She was only worried about herself when Lori wanted her to lie to police. Nice church lady.
The defense attorney asking for Melanie's testimony to be stricken reminds me of Jim Carrey in Liar Liar: "I object!" Judge: On what grounds? Jim Carrey: Because it's devastating to my case!"
Had he done his homework, he could have blown her credibility to smithereens but I don't think he had the time with Lori not waiving her right to a speedy trial.
Her testimony...if we can call it that, was pointless. The number of times she just forgets really pisses me off. Melanie was complicit the entire time, as was Lori, Chad, Alex and Lori's niece Melanie. We are mere humans in this world and nothing more. We don't have magical wands or special powers. No bags of tricks that will handpick life for you.
You just wouldn’t believe how many people religious preppers many of them Mormon there are out there. Preparing for the ‘end of times’. They listen to people like Julie Rowe who says she is a prophet and predicts earthquakes and disasters. They talk about refugees from California, not overseas, walking from Cali to join the 144,000 for the return of Jesus. It’s insane how many people follow these ridiculous so called holy leaders. It is time for churches Mormon and regular Christians spoke out against this it is not harmless when people get duped into parting with their savings and sometimes families to join these people.
Melanie was there step by step knowing each thing was happening. She could have stopped all 4 deaths. All them occurred with her knowledge. How does she not get prosecuted?
Agreed plus lori got money from Tylees dad (Joseph Ryan) social security and jj got it too from Charles. Lori continued collecting her kids benefits after she had them murdered
There are so many videos of her telling this over the years to police and news reporters, so yes, it was practiced. I’m watching this to see how different, if any, it is from the one I watched that was just before the kids were found (that was with Nate Eaton from East Idaho News).
LISTEN TO THE INTERVIEW WITH NATE. THIS WOMAN SHOULD BE IN PRISON. SHE KNEW THOSE KIDS WERE GONNA DIE AND DID NOTHING. THEY WERE ALL SWINGING AND HAVING SEX WITH EACH OTHER! 🤢🤮
Melanie is a prolific liar. Her lies have caused a sudden loss of memory. Remember her interview with Nate Eaton? She acted so innocent and unknowingly of what was going on with the Daybells. She even, imo, tried to be seductive in that interview. The devil wears many guises eh? Let us not forget that Melanie doesn’t have custody of her children.
@@michelleroche7655 naw she just saw every ‘dark’ person dropping like flies yet didn’t say a word to anyone about it. Maybe if she had, those two kids would still be here.
@Courtney Gaertner...In my opinion that's giving Melanie G too much credit. She only drew the line at potentially being accused of having something to do with the kids' disappearances/murders. She is completely self-serving.
she didn't draw the line at the kid's disappearance - not only did she take a couple weeks to alert police after JJ disappeared, but she also only did so after her then husband convinced her she had to (resist giving him credit for that - he's as much a whackadoodle as the rest of them, he just may have realized she could be legally implicated if she didn't talk first). Plus, she didn't draw the line at the kids being deemed 'zombies' even though she knw *full* well 'zombies' have to be killed, according to these twisted freaks. If MelG had any conscience, moral compass or even just an adult-level sense of responsibility, she could have acted to stop *all* those poor people being murdered - kids and adults alike. She's a self-serving, lying, manipulative, spineless snake
I'm shocked with this cross examination. The attorney should have been more intimate with the questioning especially after in a police interview melanie accidentally said that before charles was murdered he was supposedly going to get into a car accident and " Brandon was going to hide the body" which makes no sense. She miss spoke but the fact that she even mentioned anything about conversation regarding hiding bodies shows her involvement or dishonesty.
They could have blown Gibb's credibility out of the water had they done their homework. I believe they didn't have time though as she never waived her right to a speedy trial. I expect Prior won't be so gentle though. Edit: by she I mean Lori
Chad took JJ upstairs and when they came back down JJ's neck was red from him allegedly scratching himself. My god, that made me sick to my stomach to hear. That poor child must have been absolutely terrified of Chad.
Lori Vallow’s entire philosophy is: “Jesus loves me more, so any person who disagrees with me deserves to be terminated. I am allowed to lie, deceive, poison, dismember, cheat, incinerate and steal…for Jesus.”
How is Melanie Gibbs not arrested as a co-conspirator? She knew everything, did nothing to stop it. She was fully onboard with everything Chad and Lori were doing and with Chad's new religion. She's just as guilty as they are.
Oh Melanie...U were so in on this whole non sense...that Lori and Chad fed to u.U Melanie Gibb and a few others were totally on board and involved.U were on ur way to forming ur own sect of oddballs.Melanie Gibb was involved with this lot , for a pretty long time...to now say , that she never bought into their odd behaviour.If Melanie Gibb thought ,they were so odd...she would not have travelled cross country to go and visit and attend this odd religious meetings.
@Nonme, exactly! She ranked 3rd in their higharchy cult! The only reason she desired to snitch is because she didn't want to go to prison for accessory ! She is as guilty as the other 3! I bet the LE told this witch that if she didn't testify for the state that she would be charged with accessory!
I've heard that absolutely hysterical recorded phone call of Mel and Lori slinging scripture at each other like battle rap bars so many times and it's one of the most ridiculous, passive-aggressive things I've ever heard, lol.
It's hard to believe that this is the same Melanie that testified about Chad. My God it's like she's a different person she's acting like she can't remember anything. There's something very fishy going on here. This woman was knee deep into everything there's nothing Lori didn't tell her. I also think that Chad planned on Melanie being his second wife.
Yea Melanie G is not giving the same testimony that she did in Chad's pretrial hearing. Can they get her for perjury? Bc she's acting like she doesn't remember as well & we all know she was a busy body....talking about this to anyone that would listen
She stole the phone out of Charles car. I never heard that before this. The story before was that Charles left his phone inside and had to go back inside to get it.
You're absolutely right but it was mostly lies of omission. Using her lack of memory as an excuse. She is also talked to a lawyer who has told her what she can say and cannot say without being drug into this herself.
Yep. She may act like the skeptical friend but she was actually right in these magik witches circles. They each thought they had superhero powers including causing earthquakes and storms and such. What a gullible person.
Mel is still on it!!!! Now she is saying Lori knew about the change in life insurance before Charles died. That is not what she said before. She is still in on it!!!!
Thanks for pointing this out because I thought Lori only knew about Kay getting the life insurance money AFTER Alex murdered Charles and Lori tried to collect Charles’ life insurance payout. I wonder if Melanie made a deal with the government to tell the truth in court or be prosecuted for being part of the murder of Charles.
This court artist is actually very good, and I’m glad they were chosen. It helps me to visualize some of what is going on with the lack of cameras in the courtroom. It’s also really nice to have audio so we can hear the whole proceedings as they’re happening.
@eastidahonews Thanks for keeping us up to date. You’ve covered this case far more than any other news station. I started following back in 2020 when story broke. Watching/listening from California.
Is this grown-arse woman witness or the other 1 who walks into a situation where 2 other adults are fighting, one has a gun, there is a teenager with a baseball bat and an autistic child who may be confused and scared by the noise and chaos, and her 1st response is not to get the children out but afterwards doesn't even know where they went.
@@mcsmith732 People follow like sheep. No mind of their own. Not one person to stand up and shout the king has no clothes on. We keep voting for the same people in our government!!!!
Look at this evil woman lying through her teeth she knew what was going on she knew what it meant to be a zombie she did nothing to protect the children she's just as guilty.
It makes me wonder? If , Lori still loved Melanie Gibb after hearing her testify? And Chad completely gave himself away by saying what he did ,Rwo grown Xss females arguing over Scriptures while in the meantime 2 beautiful children are missing! No time in where are they? Melanie Gibb recorded the call to save her own lily white butt!😮
Yes, because the ALL important issue for them is sexuality, not murder. She's such a hypocrite! Why didn't Gibb cite her scriptures when she was holding the lamp to them while they were being intimate behind their spouses' backs?
Lori starts her affair and the kids starts acting up......kids are super perceptive......they knew Charles was wonderful to Lori and she was bashing him. They were trapped, but angry.....shows up in their behavior.
I've thought the same thing. I've thought of better questions I could have asked her if I were him. He must believe she's guilty as well even though he has to defend her... Maybe he wants to see her stay in stand jail.
I think he's doing the best he can. The only thing he can do with the Prosecution's witnesses is try to discredit them. With U.S. law, every person indicted and taken to court is entitled to the best defense they can get. And this poor guy was assigned to Lori. He never has looked very happy about it, even when Lori gets chatty and smiley with him.
Watching him I keep thinking of that old lawyer adage of “never ask a question you don’t know the answer to.” And I agree that it must be rough to try to defend this crazy bee-atch with anything like enthusiasm.
It’s also scary to think how many of Chad & Lori’s followers are still living amongst us, like sleeper cells.😳😬 It makes me a little nervous to think that one of them might see me as dark since I’m not one of their TBM. Kidding not Kidding. 🥴🤦♀️
I have a childhood friend who is not LDS (or maybe she is now) but she believes in zombies and posessions now it’s absolutely terrifying because she believes that anyone who received the Pfizer vaccine is a zombie. 🤦🏻♀️
Why is this woman allowed to walk around freely? She also isn't crying or upset . Too calm & smiles /laughs in past interviews? Very unemotional & wierd
She is talking to Lori the day before Charles died about life insurance than Melanie leaves and the next day Charles gets murdered ! Was present during JJ last night alive . Now She was with Lori around Kylee death . Wow no wonder this woman went into hiding . She is one guilty woman .
My heart breaks every time I see the beautiful faces of those children.💔 When I was a teen, I was labeled defiant and disrespectful. Because my mother went to church every Sunday & bore her testimony. The LDS community never even considered the fact that I was being emotionally and physically abused at home. So much for the power of discernment! Maybe that could be a good reason for defiance other that just being a normal teen.🤔 I could have used a good mentor but my mother actually taught me everything I didn’t want to be. 🤦♀️
Sorry to hear that and to be honest the religious beliefs in America are always connected to power and money . Just stay out of it ! Wish you healing from Greece ❤
