michaeng moments analysis: no one missed Mina more than Son Chaeyoung🕊

Подписаться 4 тыс.

Просмотров 175 тыс.

50% 1

michaeng moments analysis: no one missed Mina more than Son Chaeyoung🦋
------------------------------
Where Silence Is Nonexistent by A Himitsu / a-himitsu
Music by A Himitsu (ru-vid.com...)
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/where-s...
Music promoted by Audio Library • Where Silence Is Nonex...
------------------------------
© Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statutes that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
#RAINBOW #TIMETOMICHAENG #MICHAENG

Опубликовано:

7 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 281

@gogothies.8061 3 года назад

The fact that Chaeyoung looks so sad at so many events makes us think she was missing Mina. This video was the most beautiful video I've ever watched about this shipp. The channels that talk about michaeng always show us what we've already seen, but this video was amazing. I had never watched anything like this. Please, bring more videos like this. Thanks for the video, @RAINBOW🧡🧡

@Pepalamarrana 2 года назад

I really love her friendship

@chaeyoungtattoo_.8280 2 года назад

Let's set a side the ship. But no one would question how chaeyoung and mina's closeness to each other and how they care for each other

@jayjune6 2 года назад

chaeyoung always want to look strong in front of mina. thats why mina feel safe around her and always rely on her. i do remembered during ttt tdoong's school season 2, mina choose cy to be partner in a game, but turn out cy is easily scared by a jumpscared. the credibility chaeyoung give to mina is just amazing

@yumi9685 3 года назад

Those were the best 20 minutes of my life. My eyes are full of tears. Chaeyoung was sad that Mina wasn't with them on the Feel Special promotions. In the last clip of the video, this was even more in evidence. While Sana was smiling, Chaeyoung was wearing such a serious, sad expression. I had never seen Chaeyoung like this... Chaeyoung truly missed Mina💕

@user-jl2gt9fx2o 2 года назад

Jihyo looks out for all her members. The amount of times she looks and Chae when about to speak about Mina, it’s almost like she doesn’t want Chae to cry or feel sad when Mina is talked about. What a great leader.

@steakoncearmyengene9326 2 года назад

The Halloween fanmeet, I cried along seeing Mina broke down into tears and all the members start to hug her, Michaeng always touch the softest part in my heart. But then look at Dahyun... You will smile again.

@alstar12 3 года назад

Honestly I feel 'Handle it' is specifically written for Mina..the lyrics hits hard..

@lukasstones5119 2 года назад

chaeng said that she wrote it on the way to US tour on the plane to be exact and if i'm not mistaken, that was after Mina can't join the wolrd tour. TT

@alstar12 2 года назад

@@lukasstones5119 yes...that's why I strongly feel it is for her

@lukasstones5119 2 года назад

@@alstar12 oh my gosh, let's pretend to be surprised when they officially announce it one day >

@liveuRlife2thefullest 2 года назад

@@lukasstones5119 omg thank you for saying this bcs I thought its not for mina because it was during different era and not the fancy one.. Here I am again thinking michaeng is real

@snlockey3375 Год назад

She's so gfable and sweat😭

@INCROADTO110 2 года назад

This is what im talking about. The friendship and of course the moments and closeness in which it takes us to question the status of the two. Delusional or not. I really really love the relationship between these two.

@michaelellis4935 2 года назад

The fact is she cherishes Mina. The anguish and pain of seeing her and not being close to support her clearly took its toll. Love doesn’t need qualifiers to be real. Whatever their relationship is, is their business. Things like this are why I am a once, all 9 members love each other and show it in unique fashion. I cried for Mina and Chaeyoung during this time too because they were hurting.

@sun-oc7dr 2 года назад

The relationship between Mina and Chaeyoung grows year after year. I'm glad to see a channel making this video. I hope to see more content like this and hope this video reaches more Onces. Great analysis💕💕🙃

@yoongii6719 2 года назад

We all know Chae has always been smiling, laughing and loud when she's with the members but after Mina's hiatus she was quieter and serious more than usual. Mina's hiatus really impacted her a lot :( I also believe that her inspiration in wroting Handle it was Mina. This is the 1st video about Michaeng that makes me sob endlessly.

@chaeddalgi0324 2 года назад

In the Feel Special era..Chaeyoung really exudes a different aura, it's not the bright aura she had before. She even got sick, there's really something about this time when Mina wasn't around.

@sketdan 2 года назад

this is like one of those japanese melodramas, it'll hurt you for the most part but will definitely leave you with a unique feeling. I couldnt stop smiling when Mina joined the stage, Chaeyoung waited long and it was all worth it. so strong MINA!!!

@turtlerabbit-jisoopenguin-1688 2 года назад

Mina is most precious, imagine how much I cried for this video 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

@chaeyoungslovie 2 года назад

You know it’s serious when Chaeyoung cries and feels this way. Chaeyoung will always protect Myoui Mina :)

@akin7664 2 года назад

In the first video clip with the interview I believe Momo, Jihyo, and Jeongyeon were looking at both Chae and Sana, Sana was heavily saddened with Mina’s incident as well and didn’t speak much in this interview

@user-ti7km9eq49 2 года назад

agreed!

@sun-oc7dr 2 года назад

20:02 😮 I had never seen Chaeyoung with such a serious expression on her face.

@pinkvenom6586 2 года назад

Not me watching this at 4 in the morning and not being able to stop my tears.

@jerichocababa6115 3 года назад

I can literally die if one day we found out that MiChaeng is real 💕 btw, thank you for this new compilation ❤️

@chaengkyot5844 2 года назад

no words needed, just looking at how sad her eyes explains everything she felt in that era. :(( i'm in tears..

@chaengiecublover8201 3 года назад

I wait for a long time. Finally someone make this. Im crying 😭😭

@user-sm2wl2pm3r 2 года назад

I felt so heavy in my heart everytime i see Chaeyoung and Mina cries T.T.

@CuriosityVlogging 2 года назад

I was doing alright until the Hallowween clip, that one gets me everytime. They were all so happy to have her back on stage again.

@bangtwicesib4281 2 года назад

This is a beautiful relationship, honestly not even just chae and Mina but all the 9 girls. I hope they can be friends till old age ✨❤️

@Hellokitty_391 2 года назад

And the fact that chaeng took mina's part in feel special..... 😔

@lukasstones5119 2 года назад

RIGHTTT!!! I COMPLETLY DROP MY JAW AFTER SEEING THAT:" ett orang Indo juga awokawokawok

@Hellokitty_391 2 года назад

@@lukasstones5119 APALAGI PAS DI MVNYA SALING TATAP²AN Iya nih 😆😆

@chiewolf1935 2 года назад

16:30 even the camera man cried 😅

@night9902 3 года назад

It's michaeng's video that I cried the most. This video was lovely and further reinforced the connection that exists between Mina and Chaeyoung. I never realized that Chaeyoung had such affection for Mina until I watched this video. Congratulations, @RAINBOW💜 Hope to see you bringing more content like this🦋 I subscribed to your channel❣ PLEASE PART TWO OF THIS VIDEO!!!

@diyranee1199 Год назад

Me too I cried when I was watching

@sun-oc7dr 2 года назад

13:12 OMG, the tears in Chaeyoung's eyes...

@minafan3719 2 года назад

When they won the Feel Special award Chaeyoung really did look so sad

@juls9927 2 года назад

I love this video!!!! I hope you can also do another michaeng analysis on how chaeyoung helped and took extra care of mina when she came back from her hiatus. :)

@lukasstones5119 2 года назад

agreed! i would love to watch it

@clay_themultifan 2 года назад

same, i hope the editor sees this and react to the suggestion..

@user-hh5rb4ks1z 3 года назад

this is the first video to michaeng that made me cry so bad

@gimmee94 2 года назад

This is the reason y i stan this group. The bond they have among each other is just awesome. But I can't stop thinking about the member when Jeongyeon is on break. Oces lets wait fo r however long we need to. Lets not force her to come back early without the full recovery. Hwaiting !!!!!

@Misty_92 3 года назад

I really love all Michaeng videos that fan made but really yours are different I always wait for your Michaeng vid and You never fail to amaze me.. I love them so much now and then .. and we respect and love them both and individually we know our limits and all we are is loving and caring and protecting them.. Michaeng moments always makes me feel good.. my heart happy cause of them Please make more Michaeng moments Thanks saranghae

@user-zl2dy9ln9k 2 года назад

미나 목소리 감동ㅠㅠ 채영언니 눈물마 화이팅!!

@revaxion8688 2 года назад

i really like this kind of video. seriously, this is the BEST VIDEOS EVER about kpop ship. idols are also a humans. they can feel happy and sad too. but mostly i found videos that shows only the happy moments (MOSTLY). great job for RAINBOW to make a wonderful videos about my bias, son chaeyoung. just be ur self, son chaeyoung. i will support u as always. do whatever u want to. for RAINBOW, keep making videos like this. i just found on my yt recommendation and i fell in love with this videos. thank you. one more, thank you so much.

@ueki0078 Год назад

I'm a baby Once - just became one last Sept 2022. Thank you for the explanation of that timeline. Everyone's too broken hearted 💔 I thought it was only a love at first sight thing with their song "what is love" but Mina made me stay. Mina and I had anxiety disorder on that year. She became my reason for being a Once. Seeing her break through it, made me think of living again❤ I'm glad to see all 9 happy now with Sharon 😅 will celebrate my ONcE year this September and they'll be here in our country❤ I'll be waiting❤

@sun-oc7dr 2 года назад

17:01 just thank you so much for this review. I had watched this video so much, and I had never noticed these interactions between Mina and Chaeyoung.

@seulrenemichaeng2632 2 года назад

This is so beautiful and amazing moment of Michaeng, I love it 🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️

@amyGrand129 3 года назад

Отличная работа.. 😿😿😿🐯🐧 надеюсь вы сделаете анализ, когда Chaeng стала счастливее после возвращения Mina

@booboo6045 2 года назад

Can't get enough of Mina and Chaeyoung special love for each other. Twice have one of the most special respected love for each other as a group. Which makes them so special in the Kpop industry. Blackpink, ohmygirl, itzy and girls generation . In that order in my own opinion of course everyone has the own views .

@alexandraherrera7248 3 года назад

Buen video que gran análisis ya muy pocos canales se toman el trabajo de hacerlo ,me conmovió chae no sabía lo mal que lo paso sin mina que bueno que ya es diferente ahora Espero más vídeos así 😀👍

@delygpf6675 2 года назад

Yo lo que quisiera es que me lo traduzcan 🥺

@Sammy-tf6sz 2 года назад

@@delygpf6675 si quieres te lo traduzco JAJSJAA

@delygpf6675 2 года назад

@@Sammy-tf6sz si no es mucha molestia 🥺 pero tendrías qie hacerlo video para qie sea más interesante jee 😅

@Sammy-tf6sz 2 года назад

@@delygpf6675 ahh nunca a hecho video 😖 intentaré hacer algo, no me quiero copiar pero tendría q ser mUy parecido😅

@delygpf6675 2 года назад

@@Sammy-tf6sz le podes pedir permiso al autor del video para copiarlo y hacerlo a español🤔 obviamente dándole crédito.. Cualquier cosa ne avisas🥺

@Dan-wg8mr 2 года назад

I haven't finish the vid yet but I paused it cause I feel the pain and sadness in this vid💔 It added the pain I feel when thoughts come in my mind the rumor about one of the member in TWICE don't want to renew her contract, and Imagine if it's Chaeyoung. OT9 PLEASEEEE😭😭 And also praying for Jeongyeon fast recovery, and of course the 9 girls I wish they will always be healthy in physical and emotional

@yoongii6719 2 года назад

Dont overthink too much okay? They are like family ,they always say they can be in a group forever and performed till their hair becomes grey. Lets trust that they'll renew as a whole:))

@Dan-wg8mr 2 года назад

@@yoongii6719 Yes, thank you.

@Soufriere84 Год назад

@@yoongii6719 I'm from the future and sure enough ALL members renewed their contracts -- OT9 will be with us for a few more years

@saphirthom7197 2 года назад

it's amazing how this halloween 2019 moment will always make me cry

@bukidhangouts7466 2 года назад

She's sad because the person that made her feel special was not around

@ruru9742 2 года назад

I swear, im crying... Ouh god 😢 michaeng forever ❤️

@yarisverons.pitogo3694 2 года назад

This is my new Fav video about michaeng now

@kaesfavwav 2 года назад

aye that one fan that screamed "Mina Thank you" in Korean really made me cry.

@zeroseven14007 2 года назад

Thank you 😭😭 You made the best video about michaeng 😭😭😭

@mingyu1383 2 года назад

mina + chaeyoung = michaeng is real

@sun-oc7dr 2 года назад

14:18 Chaeyoung was almost crying...

@clay_themultifan 2 года назад

i swear, how many times i watched this in every different angle, baby beast was really different when Mina was gone for awhile, she wasnt that hyper, smiley, laughing with any member, shes been so out like her body was with them but her mind and soul was somewhere else.. It is true that Sana and Momo were way closer to Mina (Sixteen days) but its a whole different world when she's with Chaeyoung.. vise versa ~ you could literally see it in her eyes how sad she was even though she's smiling. Her sparkling round eyes wasnt showing at all.. the sparkling eyes that you notice everytime she stares at Mina ~ You could ship them to any other member, but these 2 being together is something else.

@mariodasilva8729 2 года назад

I've never seen anyone from Twice so visually unhappy! Someone give Chaeyoung a big HUG!

@chrono_random_num 2 года назад

I was sorry Abt Mina's condition and this video made me cry 😢. I don't want anyone of Twice to suffer like this anymore. Twice is phenomenal, we won't get them twice.

@Nothingamusinganymore 3 года назад

I just literally cry after watching this video..😢

@neverland4309 2 года назад

You made me cry i have never seen any other MiChaeng shippers make a video about how sad Chaeyoung was when Mina was gone love your video hope many onces see this❤️

@natureguy0_1ca41 Год назад

this is the real example of what true love looks like, and two hearts that long for one another

@penguinminari0324 3 года назад

Huhu remember when TWICE concert without Mina, ONCE cry a lot. I think TWICE member too. 🥺🥺🥺

@aliciahigginson1867 2 года назад

there is literally tears in my eyes right now no joke my eyes are blury my heart

@k8hi903 2 года назад

when chae was crying and jihyo saw it and even mina they didnt go to comfort her so i felt like chae would be a person who silently cries in the bathroom so no one can notice i feel like she wants to comfort them and be strong for them and thats how selfless and stobbern she can be and i love her so much i hope she can cry all she wants in from of us and in front of them too

@dydi00 2 года назад

even it already past it is still sad especially to see chaeyoung hide her tears

@tommyo2450 2 года назад

All right, im 5 minutes in.. I'm really glad you put the disclaimer at the beginning cause holy cow...

@Itsprobablynotme 2 года назад

This video is the most beautiful I’ve ever seen of michaeng videos

@sweetieryujin7335 3 года назад

13:10 her tears...

@haroldk724 2 года назад

I feel so bad for Chaeyoung I have watched this many times ...But she really needs her Mina back, They depend on each other if nothing more than support, and I would guess no matter what group your in there is always one special person to you in it. Know was that way for me in baseball...and singing groups are no different I am sure Glad now that Jeongyeon is back now in 2022 ...OT 9 is Complete again....

@ellamaepondivida4048 2 года назад

Chaeyoung realy misse's mina dahil salahat ng nakuha nilang awards malungkot sya lagi nyang inaalala si mina btw ang ganda po nung video :> nice one;)

@isya0906 2 года назад

Many people said chaeyoung just be came like this cuz mina take a break..... But if you look at 2020 and 2021 jeongyeon also take a break but chaeyoung doesn't seem to sad like this......

@Sogeking995 2 года назад

I get the sense that Jeongyeon took time off before her mental state escalated too much. I think Mina was in a full blown crisis at the time her hiatus announcement was made and the level of concern was higher as a result.

@Soufriere84 Год назад

@@Sogeking995 Jeongyeon's issues -- starting with her weak neck needing surgery -- had been building up for a long time so it wasn't really any surprise when she finally went to the hospital and then developed anxiety -- probably first worrying about injuring herself again and then the weight gain that's a side-effect of her meds

@fayelopez3804 2 года назад

all i know is that michaeng is special to each other to the extent that they want to marry each other maybe in another life? (*jessi showterview).

@amygeorge5106 2 года назад

chae and mina truly have a strong bond. mina is not complete w/o chae and chae isn't complete w/o minna

@jorgevaldivia7482 2 года назад

hope michaeng is real from the bottom of my heart!

@chaengbestie6636 2 года назад

The best video I ever seen in my whole life, thanks for it..

@yourname9699 2 года назад

This is not only about michaeng but i just wanna say fighting onces. Soon we will have ot9 dance practice, contents, pictures no more stickers and stuff toys♥

@yumi9685 3 года назад

12:10 Momo, what do you know...?

@kungTyeona. 10 месяцев назад

ok even tho chaeyoung was sad i couldn’t take my eyes off sana literally none even noticed her expression in the radio

@Holybible3366 2 года назад

Did i cry during the whole video? yes.

@user-ij5eo8tk8x 2 года назад

Love is michaeng… without them we can't live 😔

@dshinc 2 года назад

I can relate to Chaeyoung especially when it comes to anxiety... cause im like that too😕

@jerryhagler3916 3 года назад

That was hard to watch, cause you can see chea pain. They all love mina but not like chea

@crazyfish4651 2 года назад

In my opinion or whatever. I think, This is the time Chae came out clean to park. I mean, her feelings and gender expression/sexual orientation. And it takes time to adjust. After the feel special era. And mina came back, minachae became braver on their affection to each other. And mostly in their vids/vlog they're mostly paired up.

@Soufriere84 Год назад

_Which_ Park? Jihyo or JYP? I assume Jihyo since JYP would probably have fired her… I don't know Chae's orientation - no one outside their circle does - and it doesn't matter. What I _will_ say is Mina is the one who gives off more "gae" vibes to me (she makes Sana look arrow-straight) even though Chae is a known ally

@mayachan4430 2 года назад

I miss this kind of content 😭

@bananapie11 2 года назад

u make cry🥺 this is really hurt to me

@sheilamariehumilde364 3 года назад

Bruh I'm crying

@peanutbutter2369 2 года назад

After watching this video this totally convinced me that handle it was made for mina.

@Into-The-Light Год назад

JYP nim wrote the Feel Special for Sana. To encourage Sana while she was going through a hard time. (Revealed In Nov 2022). Now, the fact that Sana was sitting next to Chaeyoung in the video. Members probably gazed at Sana. Assuming they all knew this at that time but decided not to talk very openly about the song's source of inspiration. Off course, members were sad towards the situations faced by Twice, including Chaeyoung in particular. And off course, she missed Mina as well as the other members did.

@suzyyui2697 2 года назад

I want to crying Nobody's know chae is the one person who sad She is never seeing that

@Suraiyabano685 2 года назад

Michaeng love ❤is infinite I also appreciate jihyo, she knows every moment between mina and chae. Also takes care both of them. Thanku 🧡

@tonce4735 3 года назад

Thank you for this video🤟🤟

@owl9704a Год назад

First this was one of the best videos i have ever watched. And shipping aside, we all wish we could just once in our lives have the special relationship that Mina and Chayeong have. They truly care for each other as humans!

@teomorandante8327 2 года назад

Thank you so much for making this video😊😊😭

@user-co1hf9vi6p 2 года назад

Why this clip make me cry😭

@rosa8694 3 года назад

🥺🥺🥺🥺😭😭😭😭😭👏👏👏👏👏MUY BUEN VÍDEO!!! EXCELENTE !!!😢😢😢😢🇦🇷🇦🇷💪ARGENTINA

@aleyvyu 2 года назад

i teared up watching this

@SirDrinkalot78 2 года назад

1:29 Sana looks miserable here like she is having a real hard time

@valeriekayeenriquez3033 2 года назад

She is,when K-netz attacked her because of IG post she posted about era..

@valeriekayeenriquez3033 2 года назад

Sana, from girl band Twice, posted a comment about the Japanese emperor’s abdication that angered Koreans She is accused of insensitivity towards Japan’s colonisation of Korea

@valeriekayeenriquez3033 2 года назад

It was also in 2019

@SirDrinkalot78 2 года назад

@@valeriekayeenriquez3033 That was at the same time? wow thats tough Yeah saw the video were they won at a music show and Sana was nearly crying. Sana really thought the dream was over

@valeriekayeenriquez3033 2 года назад

@@SirDrinkalot78 Yeah,she loses her smile that time because of the bashed she got and bad comments about her and most of the girls having a hard time that time too and JYP wrote "Feel Special" for them after TWICE had dinner with him.

@jameyvanelderen8 Год назад

i did''t cry like this in so a long time

@MaximumLightning23 2 года назад

6:26-6:30 Momo's Mood Changed So Quick

@nhorylvlogger3302 2 года назад

Thank you so ouch... In fact she remembers her that

@reginafasanandosanchez9796 2 года назад

Esto me puso muy triste 😭😭 por qué se cómo sufre cheon es una historia de película

@kailaneoliveira2087 2 года назад

I'm crying sm

@dianetamayo2138 2 года назад

im crying😭

@marilinmeza3794 2 года назад

✨😍❤️😩MiChaeng😩❤️😍✨👏👍

@amygeorge5106 2 года назад

i think the members know thaat chaeyoung was upset about mina, that's probably why jihyo looked at chae before mentioning mina and that's also why (Probably) momo held chae's hand tightly and smiled at her when mina was mentioned