+lolipopscandy62 Art invokes emotion and no matter the peculiar lyrics is made it unique. Don't listen to others who otherwise. They didn't connect with it and that's fine.
This performance made me cry, specifically the part where she starts screaming. I know that recently the screaming part has turned into a TikTok trend but this song is so sad. The screaming part I feel accurately represents how we all feel grief sometimes that doesn’t make any sense but makes us just want to scream at the universe.
hana fatimah it was originally written about the cat, which is why the pic in the middle of the piano is the biggest and of the cat. The song about Floyd is called "The Floyd Song (Sunrise)"
The screaming in this song is the best part of it , it shows her raw emotion, something she has never been afraid to show , and that is why I respect her so much, girl has so much talent
It's not raw emotion if it's planned and always sang that way. I think you don't know what raw emotion actually means. It's not raw emotion if it's always part of the performance, then it's acted emotion.
@@TheLastCol way to disregard an opinion to don't agree with. But yes I'm she feels the same emotions when she performed this song for the 100th time. Not including rehearsal. Everytime it's the same. Maybe learn something called PERFORMANCE. Do you think singers feel the emotions Everytime they perform a song? Seriously? Remember, they do it 100's of times before they do it on stage. Maybe then you'll understand how it works.
@@kevindagod are you kidding? I cry every time I watch a certain movie, does that mean my emotions aren’t raw? Lol same with singing an emotional song that means a lot to you. She performed this song a handful of times. When wrecking ball came out she said she couldn’t sing it without crying and she cried the first few times. After not performing for a few years she cried singing it again in 2019 and 2020 after her divorce. Don’t tell someone their emotions aren’t real
I cried with her. not because I knew why she was crying but because she felt pain and confusion. we all do sometimes. where is the love in this world? extend your compassion.
Miley is a beautiful soul. She loves herself and doesnt gave a fuck if someone doesn't like her. I love when she screams because you can truly hear the agony and sorrow in her vocals. You can tell she poured her art into this song. This is definitely artwork, and if you don't think so, then you obviously haven't opened your heart to various types of artwork. Secluding yourself to only types of artwork you think are art or think are beautiful, is just going to keep you in the same damn place for the rest of your life. Live a little and expand your mind
My syndrome may be down but my hopes are up Well said. I guess I am one of the few people on here that loves all of Miley's stuff. Her self expression is very creative and its pushes the boundaries about what people usually define as socially exectable. I wish I had 1/10 of the artistic integrity she does. People just don't get it and thats absolutely fine, she is openning up a door for creative interpretation. If all people see is twerking, than that speaks more about them than her.
One of her best, most underrated songs. And this performance is outstanding. The vocals, the emotion. Absolutely incredible. She’s hands down one of the most talented vocalists of her generation.
@@basti7771 You're boring. Plus, if people find this performance/song "boring" then I guess some of y'all just don't appreciate true art where it's at. Nuff said. 💁♀️☺️
+Julia Twiford I think it's sick how people throw around words like that, a girl in my class, "im so depressed I lost one mark on my french test" and when we went camping somebody said im so hungry imagine if we wake up tommorow anorexic!
BooksEatKitty I agree, especially considering in both of those contexts the word is clearly not even being used correctly exhibiting a clear lack of knowledge in the subject anyway.
I think even if her tears were for show, which I don't think is the case when she sang her heart into this song. You can hear so many emotions in this song confusion, sadness, anger, happiness. if people don't think this was good then you need to open your hearts and not your ears I'm afraid. the lyrics were beautiful anyways, never mind her singing if you really don't like it (thank you everyone for the likes!)
Crawfords Army very true. I used to respect her a lot when she was playing as Hannah Montana because of the song about her grandpa "I Miss You". I feel like these two songs could relate (I know the pronouns are different).
+Thùy Dương I wasn't bashing on her in any way. If you want to hear my honest opinion it's that I think a lot of her songs are made with good intentions, okay?... but some (just like all other artists) are just to make profit. I still respect her, don't get me wrong, just not as much as I used to because I'm more into modest artists that were big in the 50's-60's. It's just my preference mkay? And she is better than me at singing, but at least I've been in choir for 10 years (not to mention an arts school) and know what sounds good to me ;) tl;dr: I wasn't bashing so no need for defending her. I respect her. I've been in choir for 10 years + an arts school so back the fuck off in my opinion on deciding what's good music or not. :)))))))
+Thùy Dương this person is saying that she truly has feelings unlike the other singers, and that the people who are hating need to open their ears bc she really is talented. aQuayQuay wasn't bashing:)
There's zero meaning to this. Like what the fuck are these god awful lyrics? Did she try? Or was she just high as usual? And what was she crying about, the fact that this song was just beyond terrible? Like fuck. And that's not even mentioning her ear piercing vocal performance.
Tbh, ive been a Miley fan for 4 years now, and Ive always loved her, when she had long hair, short hair, idc its always Miley. What I liked the most about her was when she just cut her hair, her style. She had nice clothes and stuff, classy but sexy. And her hair was on point. But then she got like this, idk how to describe it, arty? I was like okay.. But I love it so much now, its Miley, shes herself and I respect that and I love her for that. My timeline on instagram is always happy cause of her. But when I saw this video, I cried. As she said in interviews, shes more comfi when shes naked, than when she shows her emotions. And she just showed alot of emotion and damn I respect her even more than anything right now. I love her so much, she has a big heart.
I loved this song when it first came out, but I lost my mom this year, and suddenly it is the only song that I feel so connected to. Every word is just like shes speaking to me and my mom, I know she's not really but it still means everything
this is another song that is like that (emotion wise), after having lost my best friend and then a month later my godfather too (and they were two people who knew and understood me the most, and loved+supported unconditionally outside my direct family) - this song has been my harbor, it was breaking my heart so much but simultaneously healing it, now 5 years later i still cry along with it ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EoV4seyWs8k.html sorry i'm not good at explaining it, like it will break you so dont listen to it if not ready to bawl your eyes and soul out, but eventually i swear it will help you "glue your heart back together"
Miley Cyrus and her Dead Petz may look like a mess, but it's honestly an artistic gem. She poured her hear in it, and the album is basically a glimpse of her radical mind. She is one of my favorite artists. Very underrated as an artist, due to her image and child star past. Hope one day she gets the respect that she deserves.
i cried listening to this and now i feel like crying again just reading the lyrics, they don’t remind me of something specific but i can feel the grief i’ve had in my heart and i can feel her pain, this performance is so powerful in its weakness, what she did was incredible, people barely know how to talk about their feelings or cry in front of someone else, she sat on a piano and sang her heart out to a crowd
Who has a heart like Miley? She is crying over her dead pet and it is really melting my heart. The world needs this kind of heart. This is what love sounds like. 😍
Except it was a blowfish. Now a dog or a cat I can definitely understand but a fish? She should’ve expected it to die quickly! If she got this emotional over a fish dying, then she really must’ve been messed up in the head back then
The screaming is beautiful. It brings out emotion. It shows character in the singer and brings out a feeling in the audience as well. It is absolutely marvelous and pulls out such strong feeling. She couldn't have done any better
Man.. this song hits so hard. I can’t believe I hadn’t taken the time to actually listen to it. I lost my son 9 months ago and this song hit me right in the feels.. I miss you tiny face 😭
I lost my brother to suicide almost ten years ago. The sweet voice throughout, the very tender and sad lyrics, and the screaming just undo me. I can't listen to this without missing my brother and crying.
People who laugh at this don't have the empathy it takes to know this kind of pain. You can truly hear it when she says she wants to scream. And we all do sometimes.
She explained the song had been inspired by dreams on the night her friend’s cat died, saying, “I feel like her cat kind of told me what I was supposed to say to get her through it… It was more therapy to me than anything."
+hiccstrid love When I first listened to her record the night it came out, that part made me jump so high and scared me to death. It just wasnt something we would expect in that slow of a song.
Daniel Woodz IKR!? But I think that was the whole point for us to not see what comes next which is one of the reasons I admire her. I might not agree with everything she does but I can still see a bit of the old Miley in her interviews.
I didn't know any Miley songs and my kids were watching her on SNL, I overheard this song and I said "this song is about loss" and I started crying. She gained a fan. I'm not going to go to any concerts or anything but I've since listened to other songs she's come out with. Very talented.
People says that this song make no sense but, does dreams make sense? I've never had a dream that is close to something real. For me this song is not only about trying to find a meaning behind a simple dream but a meaning behind life it self because sometimes it just make any sense at all, and maybe the meaning behind all that is just love or maybe it just doesn't exist , I don't know. A lot of people qualified this new album as "shit" and maybe is not a master piece but I experiment lots of different feelings and emotions with it, anger, joy, sadness and even disgust but at the end of the day that's what art is all about. My first impression after seeing what Miley did in the VMA's and after listening the free album was disappointment, but after I listened carefully the lyrics of those "shitty songs" and after I tried to understand just a little bit what it meant my opinion changed. Sometimes times all you need is open your mind and not just guide you by what you see with your eyes. I know that not everyone thinks the same but that's just my opinion and for me this song, this album and Miley deserves an opportunity to be listed but with your heart. Peace! And that's just MY OPINION.
Are all your comments so deep and amazing? You are so right my friend, it's just sad how people judge without even knowing anything. To be a good musician and have music consider as good or with soul you have to write about breakups and love issues or you are just "crap" at least that's what people think and that's so disappointing. In my opinion Miley is doing something organic, real and that can't be appreciated for everyone sadly. They are just guide by what they see in the outside, a crazy girl smoking weed and being naked, but not the amazing person she's on the inside. I love this song, that performance was so emotional and she has a great voice!
+Jesús Bandala Esta es mi explicación de la letra (a mi entender como fan de Miley) si te interesa leerla............ La canción se inspiro inicialmente, según contó Miley, en un sueño que tuvo en el que aparecía la gata muerta de su amiga. Eso la habrá inspirado en hacer una canción que trate de sus mascotas muertas pero como ella siempre que intenta escribir una canción, sin darse cuenta termina escribiendo una balada de amor sobre dedicada a sus mascotas y a Liam. Lo de andar en skate, se refiere simplemente a eso... cuando ella estaba de novia con Liam, solían andar en skate juntos, era una actividad que les gustaba compartir. Lo del helicóptero debe tratarse de alguna salida que tuvieron, o tal vez me equivoque. Pero, tal vez todas son experiencias que tuvieron ellos dos en sus 4 años de relación. Lo de que la otra persona estaba muriendo, tal vez ahí si se refiere a sus mascotas muertas. El estribillo puede tratar de que los extraña y se pregunta por que todo termino y por que los perdió tanto a sus bebes (sus mascotas) como a Liam. Lo que dice acerca de los aliens, lo repite también en otra canción que ya se confirmo que fue dedicada a Liam, por lo que obviamos el echo de que los aliens tendrían un significado especial en su relación con su ex. Lo del karate también puede referirse a Liam ya que el un tiempo, mientras salían, tomo clases de karate, entonces tiene sentido que en ese entonces Liam le diga por primera vez a Miley que la ama, como dice la canción.
you said eveything! thats it, we dont gotta judge her just because of what we see, but try to understand the meaning of what she does. this song, per example, im almost sure thats about floyd, her dead pet...
V. Patty Hi V., my cat Ricky died two weeks ago and I am grieving hard! Doesn't this song remind you of your loss? I can't wait to see Ricky again........he was my baby boy who always looked to me to protect him; I only want to go to a heaven where he is at!!!!! ❤ 😭🙏🐱🍼 I hope that you are doing well........I think of my baby boy every minute every second of the days.
I still think about him. I miss him so much. I feel lonely in my house .I believe he is in a better place with God♡ Toby was a playful and a cute cute, cat. He's life was short but I will make sure that me and my family won't forget him. Be strong!
+ComocosonoEWL this album is her best to date whether you like or not I prefer this over bangers any day she is not trying to be lady gaga no one wants to be her andi love her to death. let Mikey make the kind of music she wants we all know thus girl can sing her head off. she's very talented and I'm glad she's happy making this kind of music it's timeless not some of the stuff we hear today. if you don't like her music then don't listen stop trolling and trying to dictate what you think she should be making it's her life. and I am pretty sure she knows exactly where her voice is it hasn't gone anywhere hell you could even hear her vibrato in some of the songs. I love this album.......even if most don't sounds just like when people trashed art pop but that was one of gagas best work.
volume really high and when she screamed I was like: "HOLY SHIT MY EARS!!!!!!!!!" and my sister screamed because I screamed then my brother started to cry
I started crying when she started screaming, and then she started crying and I lost it. The TikToks do not give justice to the whole story of the song and non to the absolute raw emotion.
