My ranking (Including Season 2): 13. Season 1 Episode 2 - The Magnus/Ellegaard recruitment is fun and the Ivor fight at the end is cool, but other than that this episode is kinda laid back imo. 12. Season 2 Episode 5 - The final battle against the Admin was cool. Other than that, In my opinion this episode was a little disappointing for a couple reasons. First of all, I was hoping that this episode would give a little more focus to some of the older characters(Axel Olivia, Ivor, and Lukas) and while they were brought back for this episode, they were barely in it and barely had any lines. Second of all, I honestly feel like some parts of this episode honestly felt a little rushed. 11. Season 2 Episode 1 - Overall I actually really liked this episode, it was fun being reintroduced to the story and characters, but in my opinion, the first half of the episode was a little boring and the episode was a lot longer than it needed to be. 10. Season 2 Episode 2 - This episode was overall really enjoyable, it introduces more about the admin and how powerful he truly is. My only complaint about this episode is that the Ice Tower and the puzzles/games feel a little like a repeat of The Sea Temple in Episode 1. Other than that this episode is a lot of fun, (ps. If you’re playing this episode for your first time, I recommend joining Lukas and Radar when you choose who to join on the 2 different paths) 9. Season 1 Episode 3 - This is a really fun episode to play. I enjoy seeing Jesse and his group explore The End in order to find Soren. They did Soren’s recruitment a lot better than they did Magnus/Ellegaards in my opinion and the Formidibomb battle at the end was also very fun to play. Overall this was an amazing episode. 8. Season 2 Episode 4 - This is definitely one of my favorite episodes of Season 2. It was fun learning about the backstory of the 3 Admins and Romeos Challenge was definitely one of the best parts of the episode and exploring their cabin. This episode also reveals the Ninja/Masked Character to be Ivor, who I was super happy to see again the first time I played this episode. 7. Season 1 Episode 6 - I know this is kind of a filler episode, but I actually like this episode a lot better than a lot of people do. I think The White Pumpkin is a really cool villans and it was also super cool seeing some of my favorite RU-vidrs in this game. I also love the murder mystery concept of this episode and it was really fun trying to predict who the murderer was, even if I did guess correctly early on in the episode. 6. Season 2 Episode 3 - This is definitely my favorite episode of Season 2. I had fun exploring the Sunshine Institute and the maze. The Admin trying to make Jesse and Petra/Jack fight is definitely my favorite part of the episode and the 3 headed Ghast was also a really cool showdown. This episode also starts Stella’s redemption(If you make the right choice) which I also think was done well. I also liked being introduced to Xara and learning the Admins real name (Romeo) and finding out that Xara was once an Admin. My only complaint about this episode is that The Warden was killed off, which I think he should’ve teamed up with Jesse and the team after the Admin fired him instead of trying to blow everyone up. Other than that, great episode! 5. Season 1 Episode 8. The concept of the mini games was fun to play through along with learning the truth about the old builders(The fact that their not nice people at all!(In Hadrian and Mevia’s cases)) and meeting the competitors as well. The return of Alex and Olivia was fun to see in this episode as well and the final battle against Hadrian and Mevia is one of my favorite fight scenes in this game. My only complaint is that the ending of this episode felt a little rushed once they got home. Other than that, Great Episode! 4. Season 1 Episode 7 - Great episode! I had fun being introduced to Harper who turns out to be an old builder and PAMA is a really cool villain and I enjoyed fighting PAMA at the end as well. Ivor has some character development moments in this episode as well which I think is really awesome! 3. Season 1 Episode 1 - I immediately fell in love with this game after playing episode 1 for my first time. I loved the characters and the wither storm was a very awesome monster that I want added to Minecraft to this day! I also had fun being introduced to all these characters and learning about The Order of the Stone. 2. Season 1 Episode 5 - This episode is the beginning of the old builder arc and is my second favorite episode. I love the Sky City adventure and I really like Milo and The Founder. This is also the episode where Ivor starts to become a more lovable character and by episode 7, Ivor became my favorite character in this game! This episode also has The Ocelots(Apart from Lukas) as the main villains which I also thought was interesting to see too. Overall, one of the best episodes of the whole series. 1. Season 1 Episode 4 - This is easily my favorite episode. This is probably the longest episode in the series, but they handle that really well. I loved exploring the farlands and adventuring there. We also learn the truth about The Order of the Stone which made me lose respect for Soren and gain respect for Ivor which at the time was a huge plot twist in my opinion. The final WitherStorm fight was really awesome as well and Reubens death had me crying for days when I first played this episode. Overall, this is an amazing episode and definitely my favorite episode of the series.
My ranking (including season two) 13: A Journeys End? (S1E8) 12: Assembly Required (S1E2) 11: Order Up! (S1E5) 10: A Hero in Residence (S2E1) 9: The Order of the Stone (S1E1) 8: Access Denied (S1E7) 7: Giant Consequences (S2E2) 6: The Last Place You Look (S1E3) 5: Above and Beyond (S2E5) 4: Below the Bedrock (S2E4) 3: A Block and a Hard Place (S1E4) 2: Jailhouse Block (S2E3) 1: A Portal to Mystery (S1E6)
My list from worst to best: 8th: Assembly required 7th: Order of The Stone 6th: The Last Place You Look 5th: Order up! 4th: A Portal to Mystery 3rd: A Block and a Hard Place 2nd: A Journey’s End? 1st: Access Denied There is nothing I don’t like about them, I just think that some are better than the others, and I respect everyone’s order, because there is literally no right and bad order, all of the episodes are amazing and unique!
My List 1. Episode 5 (Isa Is Just Sassy and Aiden Was Just an Broken And Tragic Villain) 2. Episode 1 (Good Opening) 3. Episode 3 (I Don’t Know What to say) 4. Episode 2 (The Only One Good Thing About Of It) 5. Episode 6 (Kinda Okay) 6. Episode 7 (The Desert Like Feeling) 7. Episode 8 (Good Enough Ending and Nell Steals The Show In That One) 8. Episode 4 (Because The Maze Part Really Pissed Me Off)
My list worst to best (subject to change since I played episodes 3-8 like 3 months ago) 1. Order of The Stone 2. Assembly Required 3. The Last Place You Look 4. Order Up! 5. A Block And a Hard Place 6. A Journeys End? 7. Access Denied 8. A Portal To Mystery
My list from best to worst: 1: The Last Place You Look 2: A Portal to Mystery 3: Access Denied 4: A Block and a Hard Place 5: Assembly Required 6: The Order of the Stone 7: Order Up 8: A Journey's End?
My Ranking/Ratings for the Episodes: 8: Episode 2- Assembly Required (5/10) 7: Episode 1- The Order of the Stone (6/10) 6: Episode 5- Order Up (6/10) 5: Episode 4- A Block in a Hard Place (7/10) 4: Episode 3- The Last Place You Look (7/10) 3: Episode 6- A Portal to Mystery (7/10) 2: Episode 8- A Journey’s End (8/10) 1: Episode 7- Access Denied (8/10)
I have actually never played or seen episodes 6-8. I want to find out for myself. But I know something’s, in episode 6 I’m pretty sure it’s like a murder mystery. Episode 7, there’s this computer person, and something happens with Ivor and Petra. And episode 8 is a complete mystery to me.( don’t tell me in the replies)
Least favorite of Season 1 (and my least favorite episode): Assembly required. Great first half, clearly rushed second half. Least favorite of Season 2: Episode 5. Also felt kinda rushed, the climax felt underwhelming outside of the terminal zone section, although the final choice was well done Favorite of Season 1: A block and a hard place. The episode that best explored the lore of the series with the command block and the order, while also being exciting and emotional in a way that only one other episode which I will mention has been. Favorite of Season 4: Episode 4 While I do wish it was a little longer, what it’s length provides is BREATHTAKING. The world beneath the bedrock has FANTASTIC atmosphere, from cinematography to soundtrack, the characters are well acted and developed, the golem fight is tied with the ghost fight for best action scene in the series… But the best scene in the episode (and in the entire series) is the scene in the cabin between Jesse and Petra. Everything great about that scene has already been said, but I’ll put my two cents forward and say that this is what gives a game a soul, a vision.
rankings 13. Order Up(S1E5) 12. Giant Consequences(S2E2) 11. Access Denied(S1E7) 10. Order of the Stone(S1E1) 9. Assembly Required(S1E2) 8. The Last Place you Look(S1E3) 7. Jailhouse Block(S2E3) 6. Above and Beyond(S2E5) 5. A journey's End(S1E8) 4. Below the Bedrock(S2E4) 3. A Portal to Mystery(S1E6) 2. Hero in Residence(S2E1) 1. A Block and a Hard Place(S1E4)
My Ranking 8. Assembly Required 7. A Portal to Mystery 6. A Journey's End? 5. The Order of The Stone 4. The Last Place You Look 3. Order Up! 2. A Block and a Hard Place 1. Access Denied
when you agree with the last place ranking but at the same time love the episode you know this was a legendary game (that i will never not be pissed got removed from stores)
8. A portal to mystery Not bad, but obviously hasn't aged the greatest, and feels somewhat filler-y. 7. Assembly required I like that there are two versions of the whole first half, but in reality they're not super different and it's overall just a bit uninteresting compared to others. 6. The order of the stone A great introduction, the only issue is that characters like Ivor or Lukas aren't developed to their fullest yet. 5. Order up! A cool start to the portal saga. The Aiden battle is great and sky city is a cool location. Also love Ivor in this, and the whole portal arc. 4. A Journey's end? Really great finale to the first season. Hadrian is a great villain and I love the final battle and the concept of the games. 3. The last place you look Going to the end is cool but I especially love the "final" wither storm battle. Ellegard or Magnus' death is legitimately surprising thought it's cool to get their armor. 2. A block and a hard place A great end to the first arc of the witherstorm. The real final battle and going inside the storm is just so awesome and creepy and Reuben's death is of course a sad and iconic moment. Getting to learn the true nature of the order is also a great twist. 1. Access Denied I just love this one. The horror elements are great and choosing between Lukas or Petra is a legitimately hard decision. PAMA is a great one off villain and the location is perfect for this kind of story. It overall is really underrated and my personal favorite of s1.
My personal list 8. Assembly required 7. Order of the stone 6. Portal to mystery 5. Order up 4. Last place you look 3. A journeys end 2. access denied 1. Block and a hard place
Ep 4 and 5 because they are my favorite episodes because i can't play any other episode between 5 (i used the netflix version because i was broke for that)
My ranking for the S1 episodes 8th place:Episode 3(Too boring not enough action) 7th place:Episode 5(Don’t like the setting) 6th place:Episode 2(It’s good but we only stay there for a short time either redstonia or boom town) 5th place Episode 4(Rubén’s death😢) 4th place Episode 8(I don’t like the plot and it’s boring 75% of the time) 3rd place Episode 1(Love the wither storm and music and action but Petra or Gabriel has to get infected) 2nd place Episode 7(I love pama and the mechanical stuff and the VR headset) 1st place Episode 6(I love the white Pumkin and the RU-vidr cameos and the White Pumkin)
1) Order Up! (S1E5) 2) A Journeys End? (S1E8) 3) A Portal To Mystery (S1E6) 4) Access Denied (S1E7) 5) A Block & A Hard Place (S1E4) 6) The Order Of The Stone (S1E1) 7) The Last Place You Look (S1E3) 8) Below The Bedrock (S2E4) 9) Above & Beyond (S2E5) 10) Jailhouse Block (S2E3) 11) A Hero In Residence (S2E1) 12) Assembly Required (S1E2) 13) Giant Consequences (S2E2)
8.Assembly Required (S1E2) 7.The Order Of The Stone (S1E1) 6.The Last Place You Look (S1E3) 5.A Block And a Hard Place (S1E4) 4.A Journeys End? (S1E8) 3.A Portal To Mystery (S1E6) 2.Order Up! (S1E5) 1.Access Denied (S1E7)
My ranking #8: Assembly Required #7: A Portal to Mystery #6: The Last Place You Look #5: Access Denied #4: The Order of the Stone #3: A Block in a Hard Place #2: Order Up #1: A Journey’s End
My tier list from best to worst 1. The Last Place You Look 2. A Block And A Hard Place 3. Assembly Required 4. A Portal To Mystery 5. A Journeys end? 6. Order of the stone 7. Access denied 8. Order up
My ranking(best to worst) 1. A block and a hard place 2. The last place you look 3. The order of the stone 4. A portal to mystery 5. Assembly required 6. Order up 7. Access denied 8. A journey’s end Overall I liked the wither storm episodes the best
My ranking (based on story and fun stuff since the gameplay is basically the same) it's pretty similar to this list. 8th - Assembly required: honestly i like the insane magnus part. This episode is really underachieving tho, it's short, and magnus, ellegard, and ivor are annoying. 7th - A journey's end: if you make some good choices, this episode can seem good. But this episode has the most un-minecraft characters and everyone is stupid and annoying, especially Hadrian and Harper. Neil is cool tho. 6th - Access denied: this episode is fine, and the redstone is unique, but it's really boring and once again, very un-minecraft. Petra is angry for no reason and Pama is slightly cheesy imo. 5th - Order up: this is a pretty good episode, but it should've been Minecraft story mode season 2. Aiden is a serial killer for no reason (if you let lukas save him in episode 4, the nonsense will double). Ivor has been turned into a laughingstock which I don't really mind, but let's not forget he tried to slice Jesse's head off in assembly required. The episode is fun and cool overall. 4th - A portal to mystery: i enjoy this episode the most and find it the most replayable because of the youtubers and murder mystery genre (and im surprisingly not a fan of murder mystery). However, this episode doesn't need to exist, the youtubers are there just because, and they are annoying and they don't defend lukas. But it was just too hilarious seeing the interrogation with stampy, dan, and lizzy (because the order you interrogate them in gives you different blames) for me not to put this up higher. 3rd - the last place you look: this was a truly suspenseful episode with the mob grinder, the stakes, the ending, and lukas character development. However, most of them need the correct choices to be a really good episode, like if you tell lukas to stfu then he'll be a jackass instead which is pointless. 2nd - The order of the stone: This is the one that actually felt like it could be minecraft as story mode (other than steve and alex being replaced by jesse and petra). For example, the wooden sword to stone sword by crafting is what i want to see. This had the best story set up, and characters introduced. 1st - A block and a hard place: This is the perfect one. The finale, the resolving story issues, the stakes, the character development. The crafting of the weapon and choosing your armor is probably the most unique choosing part of Minecraft story mode, since it isn't story affecting but it looks cool. The ender dragon thing made sense and Reuben's death just hits you in the face.
A little late on the ranking train but here is mine: 1. A Block and A Hard Place 2. Access Denied 3. The Last Place You Look 4. A Portal to Mystery 5. Order Up! 6. A Journey’s End? 7. The Order of the Stone 8. Assembly Required
I havent beaten the whole game Yet, when i do i will edit this comment 8- Episode 8 (not sure yet) 7- Episode 2 6- Episode 7 (not sure yet) 5- Episode 3 4- Episode 5 3- Episode 1 2- Episode 6 1- Episode 4
My ranking (season 1) 8: episode 2 (assembly required) 7: episode 6 (a portal to mystery) 6: episode 5 (order up) 5: episode 8 (a journey’s end) 4: episode 1 (the order of the stone) 3: episode 3 (the last place you look) 2: episode 7 (assembly required) 1: episode 4 (a block and a hard place)
My personal ranking (Season 1 only as including Season 2 would make it too inflated) 8: The Order of the Stone (episode 1). Super hot take, I know, but the humor for me REALLY didn't land, the writing wasn't great, lots of illusion-of-choice issues, and Axel was the most dislikable guy this side of Season 2. 7: The Last Place you Look (episode 3). I don't actually dislike this one all that much, it was just so forgettable. Very little actually happened, and while I did enjoy what did happen, it still felt a bit fast. 6: Assembly Required (episode 2). I love the function of how you choose the entire structure of the episode, but it was... meh. It was just meh. It was a very quick episode if you knew what you were doing. 5: A Journey's End (episode 8). This was one of my favorite episodes when I was younger, but upon replaying it, the writing wasn't that good, it felt unnecessarily long, and a lot of its characters weren't great. I loved Hadrian and Otto though, those two were great. 4: A Portal to Mystery (episode 6). Another one I loved as a kid, and I still do like it- but I feel like they were using the celebrities as a bit of a crutch. What I mean to say is that if everyone there were just completely random people, nobody would care all that much about the chapter. I liked the mystery and investigation though. 3: Access Denied (episode 7). Aside from being a bit quick, this was an incredible experience for me. It showed a nod toward the extraordinary contraptions people make with Redstone, and PAMA was among my favorite villains since it was so unique with just wanting to make people "useful". Truly a great episode. 2: Order Up (episode 5). Really hot take, I know, but I loved this episode. You get a choice mid-story that- while ending with the same result either way- each had their own story and things. Also, you get to beat up Aiden and his gang, plus we get peak Ivor stuff. I don't get why so many people hate this episode. 1: A Block and a Hard Place (episode 4). Is there actually anything I need to say here? ...I don't think there actually is. Best episode by a long shot.
This is my rank 8.A portal to mistery. Too much youtubers and bored episode, i think that a killer punkmin is not impressionant 7. Assembly required. We found magnus or ellegard, visit redstonia is a bit bored, i think that magnus battle is better 6. Order up! Not is bad, only that its a bit bahh 5. A journeys end? The Hadrian and Mevia battle is so cool and have good villians. 4. The last place you look. Escaping the enderman its so funny, and there is when the wither storm reach his most destructive stage 3. The order of the stone. This is when wither storm grows and destroys all endercon city 2. Access denied. The best villian for this story, its pama, he controlled an entire world and its terrifying to explore 1. A block and a hard place. This is the best episode because we defeat the wither storm and we convert in the new order of the stone, the most sad is that reuben deaths😢, but its the final
My opinion episode 5 and 6 are best because they had good enemy’s and plot IVOR WAS SO GOOD season 1 episode 4 would be first if REUBEN WOULD LISTEN AND STAY PUT AND NOT BE A PORKCHOP IN AN ITEM FRAME
These are the reason i hate epsuode 4 rubenm dies plan bordom mostly on the maze start and end of the epsiode i only liked and epsiode 3 i only like the end
I have actually never played or seen episodes 6-8. I want to find out for myself. But I know something’s, in episode 6 I’m pretty sure it’s like a murder mystery. Episode 7, there’s this computer person, and something happens with Ivor and Petra. And episode 8 is a complete mystery to me.( don’t tell me in the replies)
