MLB the Show 24 Franchise Team Finalists 

Angels would be entertaining

Giants with Jung ho lee try and build around him would be fun and a challenge

Either the royals or the reds

My vote is for the Reds. However, I do think the Rockies for a worst to first build on the channel could be fun.

SEATTLE PLEASE I have been waiting for someone to do a Mariners franchise

Please do the mariners, I think it’s time for us to have a World Series!!!

Giants, Tigers or Red Sox

Blue Jays need a winning culture, out of the 30 mlb teams, they are the only international team, and would be THE team to represent the entire world in baseball, alternatively the Giants would make for a fun series

I vote Angels or As

You gotta consider the Nats they have so much young talent and arent afraid to spend

The Red Sox or the reds would be the most interesting

I can’t wait for this series. I want either Mariners or Padres.

I would love to see the Giants or the Blue Jays! 🔥

Either rockies or giants for me

Red Sox would be so interesting to see what toy would do and who y out would keep it cjange

Excited to see your 24 series👍🏻😊greetings from switzerland

reds they are my favorite mlb team

rockies i think would be a ton of fun

I’d like to see a Blue Jays franchise! Not many of them on RU-vid, if any.

Please do the White Sox

Giants or brewers

Reds get my vote

We want GIANTS

100% the reds would be dope. Good young talent

Rockies, Brewers, Reds, in that order

I’m going with my Dodgers so ready for this game

I think my top 3 would be reds, royals and white Sox. Each of those 3 bring different levels of difficulty and it would be interesting seeing what you do with them

I say brew crew or Rockies just because the brewers are not only my favorite team but are in the midst of a rebuild and have a perfect starting point with Chourio but also some okay pitching. Having the number one prospect in the league after Holliday got called up, but also being just bad enough where it’s a challenge is a good view imo

I went with the Redsox 😂easy choice for me that’s favorite team

Angels or As. Either try to win mike trout a ring or rebuild the worst team with the lowest budget. Although Mr hurricane just did the As so maybe the angels would be better

Blue jays would be fun because none of there young guys have long term contracts and there in a very competitive teams around them and being the only team in Canada

I’ll play a one season franchise where I win the chip with my team (the Yankees). Then I’ll either go with Seattle or LAA

Looking back at this, it was obvious the Giants were most likely top dog at the time with the excitement in your voice. “Let’s hit some splash shots into the cove with the Giants!”

Mariners, bc my fav player ever is Ken Griffey JR

Giants please

i can’t choose for me between the nats royals and the pirates

Red Sox or Colorado would be cool

My favorite team is Mariners but ima go either Royals or Soxs

I would say the Reds, but I feel like they have too much young talent which would ruin the fun in drafting. I think Rockies, Blue Jays, and Giants would be cool.

I say angels, royals, or Rockies. those are gonna be insanely challenging but it would be dope to see you work some magic for either . I say royals 1, Angels 2, Rockies 3

Giants bring the World Series back to the Bay Area

I would do the rockies makes a difficult challenge but not too difficult than the as

Brewers is my vote

Dang it I wish the guardians were on here 😢

The Dodgers. You got to enter the villain arc and defeat the power friendship in the postseason. Lol.

Athletics or Giants

Jays for sure

Please White Sox, they have just gone through so much crap

Giants, Building with Jung Hoo Lee Webb and their underrated farm system would a be a fun watch, also crazy good stadium

Please run with the worst ran team in Baseball my Whitesox we need so much help after our fall from grace this year to disasterclass

I’ve been doing an Oakland athletics Franchise recently and it’s been a fun time. I will say if you do use the athletics they have lots of fun young talent and I suggest you experiment with that young talent if you use them. In just 2 season I got them back into the playoffs around 85 wins after winning around 60 games in the first season and 70 in the second.

The reds have such an exciting team this year, there’s so much young talent and potential on that team to build a dynasty if you ask me

Red sox please i need something to give me hope

royals,reds,rockies

I will always consider the Giants because I love their ballpark but they've had a dynasty already in the last decade so it hasn't been long enough other teams need help I like the Royals too Bobby Witt is a great building block and I like the waterfall in center field Seattle would be fun too with Julio I would say don't use Oakland though Wait until they move to Vegas I'll probably run a franchise with them when that happens too

I vote for the Jays, not just because of Vlad being the cover athlete, but mainly because our current front office has no clue on how to properly construct rosters

Did the As last year so maybe the Giants this year

As a Padre fan, I take offense to our tagline 😂 but I’d go with the reds. EDLC is so fun.

Giants

Red Sox

I vote Brewers or Mariners

Angels. With Shohei now gone and with Trout's future in certainty, it would be interesting to see where you would take them. There's a lot of solid and young talent on that team to build around.

You should do blue jays. As a jays fan they are a mess...

Every team would be a fun series ❤

I’ll also make the case for my Red Sox. Really awesome stadium obviously. Big budget so you’ll have more flexibility with how you make them a contender. And a really fun division. Yankees, Blue Jays, Orioles, Rays, all good teams that would be challenging to compete with

i would like the reds because they got a lot of young good playrrs

Either Red Sox or Angels, I think it'll be really fun to see the AL east go at it

Seattle!!

Red sox ❤

Love this video

I would say Reds just because I’ve been a long time fan. Can’t remember when is the last time reds went into opening day with such hype and excitement. My guess would’ve been the 2010 or 2012 season

I did Angels in ‘23. I made it to the 2026 World Series and in the 11th inning of Game 7 Zack Neto hit a walk off. It was fuckjng crazy. I don’t think I’ll ever see anything like that ever again, even in real life.

Rockies is my pick. Taking down the Dodgers in the division will be fun!

ANGELS

I’m rebuilding the padres rn and we’re absolutely disgusting, best rotation in the NL, top tier sluggers, best trades, crazy skilled bullpen, all underrated players.

Would love to see Kc rebuild would definitely love to see bobby’s career really played out with your story lines.

I’m going to do reds bc of course I’m a reds fan and it’ll be super easy bc of all the young talent but definitely going to do the A’s with a Moneyball style rebuild bc it’s just so much fun

MARINERS PLEASE!

Reds please they are my favorite team

I’d like to see an Angels rebuild

Mariners

Angels!!

Reds please

The mariners would be so electric cane!

SF Giants or KC

Angels would be cool. Cause they have interesting young guys while having little to no major league talent outside of Sandoval and maybe trout

DO THE GIANTS PLEASE!!!

Reds

The Reds with all their young hitters for sure

The reds would be really fun

Giants or Reds would be super entertaining

Orioles

A’s, Angels or White Sox would all be 🔥🔥🔥🔥

When id play Chise mode id do 2 different save files. For AL: Seattle (favorite team). For NL: Arizona (like the ballpark).

My vote is Red Sox ! Second vote is go get trout a title his loyalty deserves it.

angels!!!

Ohh come on white Sox!!!!

Use the giant please that would be so fun to watch

Braves

An Angels rebuild would be so cool with Mike Trout putting the team on his back and carrying