MLB The Show 24 Team Affinity Tierlist 

That’s fire

Hell yeah keep it up. Cj da goat 🚀

I struggled with him for some reason. I’m using the switch hitter from TA, I don’t remember his name.

@@logantaylor-cx1rrgrandal?

Probably not, but will do one on the top 50 ish cards so there will be a good amount of LS in that

B might’ve been harsh but when compared with turner i think it’s fair

@@CJ12KYT fair enough, that JT is an awesome bench bat against lefties. All I hope is that the pinpoint bug is fixed soon lol

yes you still can exchange him. Just take the arenado off your current roster. That applies to all game modes, taking him off dynasty but having him on a mini season team or conquest will still stop the exchange. If he is not being used in anything, the game will let you exchange for buxton

I’d try them out and probably keep your favorite of the two

Byron Buxton team captain. Set him as your hitting captain and he gives insane boosts to any player with under 60 vision.

do i get him from the captains pack or some where else? thanks for the reply@@anttfd

@@seangorman9516 it was the preorder reward when you first launch the game you got a choice of I think 4-5 different captains. If you chose the wrong one you can exchange it via the exchange set. I think the other choices were senga , arenado , buxton and one more!

ok nice! thank you didnt know i could exchange@@anttfd

He’s a pitcher

Usually like 8-10 est

David justice hits righties well? Could’ve sworn I said that

@Cjuck12 I should of elaborated more....I'm an average player in Ranked. 650 ceiling forever. David Justice is the only card in my lineup hitting above .500 (45 AB) and 22 HR. I haven't seen a card perform like this since Finest Winker in 21. You had Justice listed in 3rd tier and I want other average players to know that the card is an absolute monster. I'm assuming the majority of an MLB The Show RU-vid audience is that of poor to average online players.

Unlisted since it’s patched