During rafi saab and lataji battle rafi saab got three filmfare award for best singer Dosti,Brabhachari,Suraj and that time only one award given for male and female singer.So no question of rafi saab to given latter to lata ji.It must be lataji who requested to rafi saab to sing together....Greatest voice ever and ever will be...The one only Great Rafi Saab
सुमनताई कल्याणपुर और रफी साहब की युगल बहुत बढिया थी.... सुमनताई बहुत ही भाग्यवान है जो रफी साहब के साथ गीत गाये... बहुत उमदा व सटीक वीडियो वीडियो हेतू बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद
Mohamed Rafi still the greatest singer of all time and will always be remembered.He only started singing with Lata Mangeshkar in the film Jewel Thief because SD Burman brought them together
अगर लता रफी में झगडा नहीं हुआ होता तो सुमन कल्याणपुर जैसी कई गायिकाओं के बारे में लोगों को पता ही नहीं चलता। इस झगडे का फायदा ही हुआ जिसके कारण कई गायिकाओं को उभरने का मौका मिला और उनकी प्रतिभाएं सामने आ पाई।
@@appolophoenix3788 sir ji lata ji kisi ka hath pakadkar rok liya tha kya ki inhe gana mat dijiye Lata ji wo sangeet ki devi ma hain jinke gale main hi nahin charno main bhi sangeet ka baas hai hum aur aap jaise sabhi log na unke samne tinke brabar nahin hai jo bat ap bol rhe hain ki unhone kiso female singr ko aage aane nhi diya
Once one has taken his/ her fee thats all ,a sing may hit or may flop so this is a gamble for music director so Rafi saheb was right and just.Lata might be a looser aftee breakup with rafi saheb.
Jin mahan gayak ki soch ki baat aap kar rhe ho na sir ji unhe sangeeg main devi maa ke naam se samman mila hai Rafi sahab aur lata ji ke beech jo bho jhagda hua na wo jhagda khatm ho gya lekin hum aur aap jo unke baal brabar bhi nahin hai. Itne mahan gayila ya gayak ke baare main bolne se pahle soch lijiye fir kahiye ki soch unki kaisi h ya apki
If royalty is demanded by singer then music directors and lyricist also demand on same line. Song is not property of singer alone. Producer is person who pay to all and is legally owner as per natural justice.
Vinod Viplav ji.. Aap Rafi Arun Ghautam ji ko jab bhi interview karein, unko interrupt na karein... Aap beech mein bolte hain to unki awaz interrup hoti hai.. woh itni bareek se bareek baatein apne observation se bata rahe hain aur hum unko bohot dhyan se sunna chahte hain.. Please bura mat maanein lekin itna zaroor keejiye.
Fake news tu apane pas rakh jese hume kuchh pta hi nhi he rafi shab or lata ji ke bare me lata ji 1942 se abhi tk gaati he or rafi shab 1975 me berojgar ho gye the ok rafi shab great he but lata didi sarswati he ok lata ji ke award dekho or rafi shab ke award dekho ok
Rafisahab har baat me hamesha upar rahe hai,chahe vo gaane ke bare me ho ya unki sakhavat ya imaandari,,,,mere Rafisahàb ko koi bhi nahi pahunch sakta,,,, Love you Rafisahab,zindabad Rafisahàb....
The actual truth is out . THANK FOR THIS MOST INTERSTING TOPIC..MAZAA AAGAYA...WHAT AN ANGEL RAFI SAHEB WAS..HE HAD NO GREED GREAT MAN,GREAT PERSONALITY GREATEST AND BEST SNGER/ LEGEND EVER..❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bahi,anjanemein lata ne sumanji ko kitana fayada pounchaya.Rafi sab never dependent on lata, this he has proved by giving greatest hits with other female singers
Lataji k karan suman ko koi fyda nahi hua.film m sare geet lata he gati thee keval 1 ya jada se jada 2 gana rafi suman ka rahata thha.suman ko apni pratibha k karan is jhagde k pahale he bade m.d k sath gane mill rahe thhey.film miss bombay 58 m thirtha yatra 59 m sama k sare gane 61 m.fir sardar malik mohinder singh bulo c.rani ne sare gane summan ko diye.suman ko ghata hua ki usey bade banner bade producer ki filme na k barabar mili.aur bina bade film k koi b singer publicity nahi paa sakta.kyonki producer paisa kharcha karwa k sadi piti flop film k gane b heat karwa deta thha.radio m jhooti farmaish ko adjust karke.
No doubt, Lata ji suffered heavy loss due to dispute with Rafi Sahab. Because Music directors replaced her and she lost lots of very melodious songs, like ajahuna aye balma sawan beeta Jaye, itna hai tum se pyar film Suraj, muje ye phool na (film Ghazal) and songs of Bheegi Raat and Duj Ka Chand etc.etc.
This is not a fight , this is only a difference of opinion, but some media people has given a different colour to that matter, but Rafisahab was a lean man ,he was not a greedy, he helped thousands of people in his life, he was right ,
Asal mudda royalty ka nahin tha. Mamla ye tha ki rafi sahab naye gaykon ke saath gate the jabki lataji ko ye pasand nahin tha. Asuraksha ki bhavna lataji mein thi. Lataji ne ye socha ki anya gaykon sang gaadi kheench loongi, lekin hua ye ki doosre gayak ganon mein wo baat nahin bhar sake. Phir rafi sahab apne saathi gaykon ko behtar karne ko utsahit karte the. Ashaji aur suman kalyanpur ne mauke ka laabh uthaya jabki lata ke duet aage nahin badh sake. Paise ko lekar lataji ka record badtareen hai, baaki sab itihaas hai-ratan singh
आप शायद ही सुने होंगे कि कोई सिंगर किसी संगीतकार से पैसे ना लिए हों लेकिन रफी साहब ने कई संगीतकार के लिए फ़्री में तो कई से 1 रुपया ही लिए है, और सब से बड़ी बात कि इतनी अच्छी बल्कि सब से अच्छी आवाज़ होने के बावजूद भी उनको रत्ती बराबर घमंड नहीं था, ये आप को किसी सिंगर में नहीं मिलेगा।
Rafi sahab ji great un jesa koi nhi Rafi sahab ji ke gano se Jane walon ki kami aaj bhi nhi jalte rho or marte rho I love rafi sahab ji 👃👃🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Suman kalyanlur benefitted. The issue was not royalty but it was about Lata not happy that Rafi was getting new female singers in the industry and also singing with him. Even Madan Mohan worked with Suman. Rafi was, is and always be king.
We admire Rafi who was Divineness , Gentleness and Melody personified. We do rever Lata , Goddess of Melody. Let us not compare these two great Souls . They together have given us invaluable gems. Divineness should prevail over discrimination .
लता से जयकिशन जो कहा उससे लता डर गई थी सही में मेरा पत्ता साफ न हो जाये इस लिए सांग बहुत हिट हो रहे थे इस लिए लता मान गयी लता बहुत पैदा हो जाएंगी मगर दूसरा मोहम्मद रफी साहब नही पैदा हो सकता है।
सुमन k बहुत ही बेहतरीन गायिका थीं,लता जी से किसी भी मामले में एक नंबर भी कम नहीं थीं,लेकिन भाग्य बहुत बड़ा होता है साथ में राजनीति जिनकी वजह से सुमन जी को वो सम्मान और प्रसिद्धि नहीं मिली जो मिलनी चाहिए थी।
Sahi farmaya.....film DIL NE PHIR YAAD KIYA ... Ka title song...RAFI SAHAB & SUMAN K. kaafi waqt KE baad malum HUA ki female voice SUMAN KALYAN PUR, ki thi Lata ji ki Nahi. ..same as. . BRAHAMCHARI. Ka song. AAJKAL TERE, MERE PYAR KE CHARCHE....even after a long time 1979. Hit film DADA a song actually. a naat ALLAH KARAM KARNA, MAULA TU RAHAM KARNA ....a hit people thinks a Lata ji voice, but it's SUMAN ji...
While recording was going on for " junglee film " song " ehsaan tera hoga mujhpar " Lata Mangeshkar complain to Shankar Jaikishan that they are giving more priority to Mohammad Rafi then her. As shankar is known for his straight forwardedness Shankar replied and said to her that in 80% of films Heroes like to have Mohammed Rafi as their singing voice so Mohammad Rafi cannot be avoided. So choice is yours either you patch up with Mohammed Rafi or we have to find your substitute in Suman Kalyanpur or Asha. it becomes a lose-lose situation for Lata Mangeshkar because in 60's Ravi, SD Burman, khayam and of course Op nayyar these all were doing great without Lata mangeshkar but shankar jaikishan preferences for another female singer was a big jolt and clear Alarming bell for her because shankar jaikishan were the most popular music director of that period. Shankar Jaikishan were so popular that they gave back to back 25 Jubilee hit between 1960 to 1965 and they were comfortably engaging new singers like Suman Kalyanpur, Shamshad Begum and even sharda. situation become so difficult for Lata Mangeshkar and she became restless. Jaikishan was quite close to her and she never expect from them to consider second feedle. Jaikishan and understood the expectations and an evident pressure on her. he keep insisting Lata Mangeshkar time and again, whenever they meet, to patch up with Mohammad Rafi otherwise she is bound to bear the burnt in long run, let me clarify here that during this particular period jaikishan and lata were going thru "A VERY SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP" and jaikishan also persuaded Mohammed Rafi because shankar jaikishan had very co ordial relationship with Rafi saab.This separation of lata and rafi was indeed become talk of the town and everybody wanted to see them sing once again together and this spat also costing the music industry darely. In the above given background, Fifty years celebration happened and Nargis ji took initiative to patch them up once again. Mohammed Rafi was a great singer and even greater human being and a gentle soul as well. He forget everything then and there but.............................. Chalo chodo Yaar why to break the head. Still I am sorry to differentiates here though lataji also very very great singer in her own right but misfortunely she is not considered as a so great human being, her traits particularly jealousy, unforgiveness, unkind behaviour with her compititors, insecurity make her even less ordinary person. when Shankar Jaikishan refuse to toe her line she made up her mind to teach them a lesson and the time came soon after 1966 during the making of suraj when SJ introduce another new singer call Sharda and then after Lata and her strong lobby left no stone unturned to ruin Shankar Jaikishan career in Bollywood and to some extent se succeed too when jaikishan died all of sudden, but by then shankar jaikishan and their music became immortal and still music lover like me considered them the best and legendary music director of all time.
Naresh Dabas, ... Impressed. One of the biggest or. toooo long..... comment I ever read . .. about..... good Samaritan...like. MOHD RAFI SAHAB.......why the noble men still alive in the hearts of trillions.. even after his sad demise..long four decades...ago..... RAFI SB true sad....HAAN TUM MUJHE YUN BHULA NA PAAOGE.....jab Kabhi bhi sunoge geet mere.......
Lata Ji was correct to fight for Singer's right. Hats off to her. It takes spine to stand for the right. Lata Ji wanted all singers to get royalty, not for her alone.
Ek Baat Bahot Dukh Ke Sath Bolna Hai Lata ji Ne Suman Kalyanpur Ko Aage Badhne Nahin Diye Jab Ke Unki Awaaz Bhi Bahot Acchi Thi....Raj Kumar...Film Aaja Ayi Bahar Dil Hai Be Karar O Mere Raj Kumar Tere Bin Raha Na Jaye ...😭😭
Aaja aai Bahar was sung by Lata not Suman Kalyanpur. Suman's sang a duet "Tumne pukara aur" with Rafi. Her solo songs are rare, in "Jaanwar" she sang a solo "Mere sang ga""
Most of discussion is on correct lines. In interview also Latabai had agreed about quarrel on points of principle. Both were JUST on their place. On little wider sense...... if one particular new singer becomes popular and before he/she earns to live on singing prowess by band destiny looses power to sing, then such royalty money can help such singer to earn bread.
Everyone is right in their own place - that's why they do what they do. It's a personal moral stance. You can call it greed. Or you can call it honesty.
Both Mohd.Rafi and Lata Mangeshkar were all time great. It is not correct to blame Lata Mangeshkar for royalty controversy. Lata Mangeshkar was asking Royalties for all singers,music directors and lyricists. She was more worried about her coworkers. She was never money minded. But once royalty issue was resolved,Rafi was among first persons to accept it. Jaikishan was instrumental in their patch up. Both sang together first song after patch up with Jai Kishan in Sitaron ki chhaon mein,it never released. Lata Mangeshkar is the only artist who is running most charitable trusts.
Both are best yet.Male singer Rafi Sahab n female Lata ji but as a human being, every heroes of that time up to Rishi Kapoor he was alone voice of all, that's make different between the two. Salam 🙏🙏🙏to Rafi Sahab.
Bateye ketne Achche Soch the "Rafi Sahab" ke ke Music Director ke grade ka bhi khayal ke bechara ager koi new Music Director h to wo kaise paise deta hoga aour ager movie Hit na huwe to.. Ayese me gareebo se Royality lena ek tarha ka pap hi hai aour Rafi Sahab jaise Nek insan koi pap kaise ker sakte the.. Zara se bhi lalach na thi unmen.. wah wah "Rafi sahab" ap bht bht nek Dil insan the .. Bht se Music Director ko Rafi Sahab ne Stablish kiya ..
रफी साहब बहुत सज्जन और ईश्वर में गहरी आस्था रखने वाले इन्सान थे। वे अत्यंत विनम्र स्वभाव और शांत प्रकृति के व्यक्ति थे । संगीत की बुलनदियों को छू लेने बाद भी उन्हें अपनी अविश्वसनीय और उत्कृष्ट सफलता पर लेशमात्र भी घमंड नहीं था । वे बड़े सीधे सच्चे और ह्दय के पवित्र भाव के इन्सान थे । पैसे का लालच उन्हें कतई नहीं था। हर प्रकार के व्यसन से दूर थे। उनके लिए संगीत का रियाज अल्लाह की इबादत थी । जरूरतमंद लोगों की यथासंभव मदद करना उनका स्वभाव था। कई बार बिना पारिश्रमिक लिए भी गीत रिकार्ड कर लिया करते थे । उनकी इसी विनम्रता का परिणाम था कि गायन में उनकी विलक्षण प्रतिभा और जादुई आवाज के अनमोल खजाने से बडे से बडे दिग्गज संगीत कार और दूसरे गायक भी हतप्रभ रह जाते थे । अब शायद ही दूसरा रफी दुनियां में जन्म ले ।
