And look at 2:56, the way that whole verse looks overwhelmingly good. Also they even highlighted seulgi's adlib and hit the strong bass at the same time.
This was strangely the sexiest performance ever?? The vocals, the dancing, their expressions? SM made a GREAT choice putting them together. I'm so proud
To those saying that they are lip syncing, we will taking it as a compliment, thank you for admitting Rv are sounding so flawless that you can't even believe they're singing live.
Well even if they did lip sync here( wich I don't think so) It doesn't mean that they don't have a talent or can't sing If it was true I don't think that they would be in SM Company like that need real talent and are strict so it's funny to me that people think you can be in big company just like that without talent
those people know nothing about Red Velvet, and irene's vocal has been always soo underappreciated probably because the other members were just too good. I mean they have such angelic and stable vocal since DEBUT. Their live stages of their debut song Happiness was already soo stable and that song was hard to sing while dancing too. They are really well-trained and have been always working hard to deliver good performances to us.
Those knet (🤡) said Irene is just pretty face and now the queen has slapped them in the face with her dancing and power vocal 👏👏👏 Seems like we have found one of those knet 🤡
와이지빠이지만.. 이런 면에서 sm이 참 좋음.. 전형적이고 약간 유치하고 정형화된 아이돌 그 자체 같으면서도 이렇게 실험적인 음악을 해주니까 도태되지 않는 거 같음.. 예전에 비하면 한물 갔다고 하지만 그래도 와이지,에스엠이 건재한건 스스로 자기만의 스타일과 실험적인 음악을 계속 시도해서인듯
Irene is not just a Visual. Haters really underestimate people born with beauty bc thats the only thing they can hate on Irene.. When she is an all out performer
Yes that’s true but don’t talk like Irene and Seulgi are actually singing live here because they are definitely not. Some ppl really believe they slaying their vocals here but this is pre recorded. No way they would actually sound this clear .
nur at 1:04 you can hear irene continue the « heee » but her mouth is closed (no hate i love them and support them no matter what) and also the mr removed doesn’t excluse prerecords so it sounds like they’re singing
true that! i hope to see the rest of rv's member to shine as well, because they are equally talented as a group and as an individual. I hope SM treat the girls better in the future
Seulrene's chemistry, talent, visuals along with Monster's choreography and stage is skyhigh. Korea's girlcrushes Seulgi and Irene dominates our hearts, girls, guys, gays alike
Imagine being a 6yr old group but still be disrespected for your abilities over disputes of live vocals, that’s sad to see...whether it’s lip-syncing or pre-recorded you can’t deny their talent...RV are known for being one of the more vocally gifted groups of their generation and the entire kpop community knows that so there’s no need to argue just appreciate
what do you mean by this: "Imagine being a 6yr old group but still be disrespected for your abilities over disputes of live vocals" Are they disrespected in korea? I thought they are super popular. RV has the best vocal skills since I know kpop actually.
They’re very well-respected in Korea, since on top of being talented they’ve been relatively scandal-free and have done a lot as representatives of the country. Haters will, as with every group, try to disrespect their talents even when their vocals and performances are generally agreed to be some of the best.
This stage is truly a masterpiece. The stage design, the editing, the camerawork, the outfits and overall style, and of course Irene and Seulgi's performance with the dancers. It's all perfect!
@@mollybloblue7891 I don't think they meant that. What they were trying to say is that Irene is mostly appreciated only for her beauty, but never for her talent. On the other hand, Seulgi's talent is always recognized (vocals and dancing). So I think they were cheering because Irene's talent is being recognized but without overshadowing Seulgi's talent and appreciating her greatest talent. (I don't know how many times I repeated the word "talent" but ok)
@@matheusdemarco3559 yes this is pre-recorded..but they are singing too it's just the backtrack is too loud that we can't hear their raw vocals and one more thing..sm artists are always focusing on the performances in their first week promotion so that's why they are not using their live vocals cause dancing too hard while singing will damaging your vocals more..so they usually singing live in their second week promotions..
ok so all of you are fighting whether this perf is lipsync or not....like come on...rv has *6* *years* experienced and they are many proves that they can sing live..even we can hear their *raw* *vocals* loudly cause there is *no* *backtracks* during their perfs..you can just searched and i'm sure you can find it..but because of that too they need to rest their vocals sometimes...how many times do we need to remember that.. *idols* *are* *human* *and* *they* *need* *energies* *so* *that* *they* *don't* *get* *sick* *bec* *of* *overworks* *by* *their* *fans* *that* *want* *them* *to* *be* *PERFECT*
moon child no hate on you or rv, but this is pre recorded even if it sounds live, example most of twices recent performances. but when they’re on mbc, they can’t lip sync so wait for that. they are talented in vocals don’t get me wrong, but this is pre recorded. not rlly a big deal tho
@@moonchild3106 yes if you noticed in this comment section esp reply section some of reveluvs are defending red velvet from the haters that said rv was lipsync in this perf..so yes they are not 100% lipsnyc.. but it's a live pre-recording..usually all sm artists are more focused to perf during their first week promotion and the vocals for their sec week promotion to prevent damages vocals..yep that's how sm works but this haters always blaming and hating everything not only on them but other kpop groups too that sometimes i wondered..why they are very into kpop idol's life??
@@moonchild3106 and yes that is their raw vocals but as i said this is a live pre- recording which is a recording for their other live stages and they used it again for the other stages..i hope u understand it..i'm not good at english btw..so usually idols recorded their perfs many times to see which one is the best to be aired and ofc they will use the best live vocals for the perf so they will recorded every perfs and choose which one is the best..but rv is still singing in this perf it's just that the backtrack is so loud that we can't hear their voices plus they are being performing for many times for the recording so they must be tired r and maybe this is the reason why the backtrack is so loud so we can't hear them catching breath too much??lol idk exactly..but r u ok??i'm sorry i can't explain to u more cause i'm actually so confused rn on what should i type 4u haha...
@@miles62546 you can hear them breath and how different it sounds from the audio. On Irene's solo singing part the voices dont over lap and you can hear how husky her voice is.
@@miles62546 they sing so well that you can barely notice it 🤣. Just focus on when they take a breath between sentences. You can't usually hear that in a pre-recorded video unless done on purpose. And some small mistakes in entonation and/or volume caused by dancing and singing at the same time. I'm no expert though.
Seulgi always slays. Whether it be a sub-unit or the whole group comeback. Whether we admit it or not. Seulgi always slays and is on top when it comes to performance.
This is another big slap to Rv's haters who complains about their "lack" of stage presence. Edit: Yes, there are still "haters" who are blind to see RV's greatness. Dragging RV to satisfy their insecurities but we, luvies, knows the best our cake girlies doesn't lack anything except proper management. (but this era, girlies got some real schedules.. keep it up sm)
guys in the reply section, many people called out rv for bad stage presence like looking bored during some eras. now, im a reveluv and i think rv has amazing stage presence but there are people who say that so dont say that nobody says it.
I've never read that, and I honestly think no one ever said that. RedVelvet has everything to be one of the biggest GG in the world right now, sadly their company keeps making them sing about fruits, cakes and lollipops. Im pretry sure if they had a better management they would be HUGE WORLDWIDE. The 5 girls are super talented.
좋게 말해서 순한거고... 좀 더 솔직하게 말하면 안어울리는거죠~ㅜㅜ 차라리 동방신기나 태민, 디오같은 유영진류가 가능한 보컬들이 하는게 더 잘어울렸을꺼 같아요~ ㅜㅜ (아린슬기를 욕할려는거 아님) 곡 마다 자기 주인이 있는데 이건 원주인이 있는데 억지로 빌려가서 내꺼라고 내놓으니 성에 안차는 그런 느낌입니다~
No wonder why RV has haters. They just cannot handle all their beauty and talent! Their MVs are so aesthetic and the songs are simply WOW. And they all just slay all their concepts!!! More power to I&S subunit and RV together! Go Queens! You rock!!
They don't sing live : They can't sing They sing live: it's not their real vocals or it's pre recorded. BRUH you can literally hear the difference between the official audio and this performance. This stage or performance is pre recorded but they sang live during that recording. So it's obviously their live vocals and the girls slayed it despite the hard choreography. And yes kbs might have done a bit a editing but their live singing can still be understood if you don't have ear problems
Pre recorded performance isnt that bad. It is clearly pre recorded, irene's part before seulrene duo dance part at the first minute wasnt that good. The vocal went on, but she stopped "singing" I mean, red velvet are well-known singers. Their vocals were acknowledged by literally everybody. No one dares to say red velvet cant sing even if they dropped a pre-recorded performance like this. So, people that might stopped by this comment, admit it... it is not live performance. Maybe they'll sing live the next stage since SM always do pre-recorded stage in the first week so...
![Monster - 레드벨벳 - 아이린&슬기(Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI) [뮤직뱅크/Music Bank] 20200710](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
