y’all cannot look at this girl and say she’s “naturally this thin” nah. even idols like rose, lisa, and even gaeul who are all naturally slim don’t have their entire bones poking out from their skin. something’s def wrong.
It's so sad because I feel like a few weeks ago I saw pictures that she had gained a very healthy looking weight. Still skinny, but visibly healthy. Looks like these song promotions have made her thinner than ever even after what looked like progress. They need to adjust her diet to all of the exercise and mental stress she's going through
yet she has more energy performing than all of them?? while having that many brand deals as a 4th gen idol??? she also has abs, an anoerxia girl does not have abs like this. It's not ok to fat shame, just like it's not ok to skinny!
제 키가 원영님처럼 딱 175인데 20대 초반에 50키로까지 빠졌다가 생리불순걸리고 만성피로,빈혈 땜에 반 죽을뻔 했어요. 그때 걸렸던 건선과 식도염은 정상체중을 되찾은 지금도 종종 재발합니다.건강은 한번 망치면 절대 원래대로는 돌아오지 않아요. 이 영상을 보는 10대분 여성분들이 저건 가학적인 거지 아름다운게 아니라는걸 아셨으면 좋겠어요.
@@user-ir7nj4om8v 그건 옛날 얘기고 지금은 2024잖아요;; 그때는 중학생/고등학생이 시집/장가 가고 가정을 꾸리는 나이였는데 지금은 적어도 20살은 넘어야 가정꾸리는데 현실감각이 없으신건지.. 그리고 고딩이면 아직 성장기인데 맛있는거 많이 먹고 건강챙겨도 되죠 저정도는 팬들이 봐도 말랐는데
원영이 팬입니다… 다들 저렇게 마른 게 진심으로 괜찮다고 생각하진 않을거라 믿어요… 이런 댓글쓰면 안티냐고 그냥냅두라고 얘기할 사람이 있을 것 같지만 정말정말 팬으로서 너무 걱정돼요 저 정도로 말랐는데 건강할 수가 없어요 진짜 뼈밖에 안보일 정도인데. 물론 너무 쪄도 사람들이 욕할 테지만, 다음 활동때는 살이 조금 붙은채로 나와줬으면 좋겠어요ㅠㅠ 건강이 우선이니까! 워뇨가 상관없다면 뭐 할 말은 없지만… 항상 건강해야돼!!
아이즈원 때부터 말랐었고 활동 막바지인 파노라마만 봐도 지금이랑 다리 똑같음. 근데 장원영 아파서 활동을 못 하거나 그런 걸 본 적이 없음. 물론 저기서 살이 좀 붙으면 훨씬 보기 좋겠지만 본인이 저런 몸매를 좋아한다거나 체질일 수도 있는 거고.. 원영이는 완벽주의 성향인 느낌이라 아마 자기에게 조금이라도 해가 된다면 알아서 안 할 거임. 그럴 거라고 믿어 원영아! 가뜩이나 억까 심한 원영이 되도록이면 걱정보다는 칭찬만 해 봅시다 :)
I'm so worried, you can literally see her spine sticking out at this point. She is so dangerously underweight. I don't understand how you can look at her and say she's perfectly healthy and at a normal weight and not feel guilty. This isn't hate I'm genuinely so concerned for her. Edit: I'm so glad this comment is getting attention but please remember that insulting wonyoung will not help her. She's is very beautiful and I just wish her good health so she can have a long and happy life. And to those saying it doesn't matter, if enough fans say something then they have to address it. Starship has a bad past of forcing idols to diet and has failed to provide food to their idols on multiple occasions (many examples in WJSN's past). From someone who has personally suffered from an eating disorder, wonyoung reminds me of myself and my inpatient friends in many ways BUT at the same time I wouldn't be surprised if the company is pushing her to do this. Whichever way, it is a fact that she is dangerously underweight and this has severe repurcussions that will affect her for life, on both an emotional and physical level
yeah, she's so thin. dangerously thin. her arms are right to the bone, legs too. just must not be eating or eating too little. worries me because she's so young. companies need to take care of their idols more.
@softhearted lmao yes we are..? if the fans start getting worried starship will have to do something... we all love wonyoung, she's literally the sweetest person and it's really talented but you can't deny she is clearly sick, coming back even thinner every comeback.
@softhearted I hope you realize she is slowly killing herself. I'm not saying she's anorexic or a skeleton or anything stupid like that, I'm just very concerned because you're seeing bones you shouldn't see in normal skinny people. She is still growing and is going to have lifelong problems because of this. I had anorexia when I was 16-17 and I'm still recovering from it. Im at a huge risk of developing osteoporosis and heart issues, my immune system is still awful despite being at a normal weight, I had a friend who looked just like wonyoung does and she regrets it because she can't have kids now, she literally ruined her body. The fans should be vocal and make starship intervene but you all want to ignore this and allow her health to continue to suffer. I love wony very much, she has been my bias since izone days, and I just want her to be healthy and happy
First time seeing a fancam of hers and omg her being worringly underweight is highlighted when it's just her. I was shocked at 0:04. Her spine is SO visible even up to her neck. You can tell it's all bone and very little muscle underneath her skin - virtually no fat. As others have said, this is beyond being naturally thin. I hope she gets well soon. She's so young and already beautiful.
I'm watching Wonyoung since her debut with IZ*ONE. She was so healthy back than. Wonyoung sshi, please take care of your health. Fan's over the world are worried.
I feel her weight is even more noticeable next to her members who all have full thighs and are similar in shape. Gaeul being the second skinniest in the group. Though only her upper frame and waist are very slimming. She too has fuller thighs. Wonyoung has actually started to gain her weight back it seems. Her thigh gap was more spaced and her knees were way thinner than they are now. Plus her ankle bone was way more noticeable. She's actually gaining her weight back.
i wish people would stop pretending this isn’t a problem.. we’re all worried for her, being this skinny will come with health problems even if she does pilates and works out. fans calling people hater/jealous when people are worried for our girl is also not helping at all and are part of the problem by praising her thinness - i wonder why her parents/the company aren’t doing anything
Because they are profiting out of her they don't care about her they just want $ and as long as she keeps making money for them they are not going to contradict her.
I think this comeback people finally realized she's not doing okay, i've seen a lot of comments on this issue ever since After Like came out, just a few weeks before a lot of ppl were pretending everything was alright and any slight of concern was labelled as "body shaming". I am genuinely worried a lot and i hope the company will let her take the rest and recovery she needs :/
원영이 멋지고 노래 무대 다 잘하는 갓기인데… 운동도 열심히 하고 먹는것도 잘 먹는다고 하는데 보여지는게 그게 아니니 걱정돼… 원래 말랐었어도 잘 먹는데 이렇게 점점 더 빠지는게… ㅠㅠㅠ 영어 댓만 읽어도 다들 걱정하는데… 걱정된다는 한글 댓에 반박하는 한국인들 보면 우리 사회가 뭔가 문제가 있는건 확실함
원영인 사랑스러워 근데 그게 원영이가 모델처럼 날씬하고 말라서 그런게 아니라 네 성격이, 노래부를때 밝게웃는 표정이 사랑스러운거야 원영아 건강하게 오래 활동하는 모습 보고싶어 맛있는거 많이먹구.. 스쉽은 진짜 정신차려라 개빡치게 하지말고 10대 애가 저렇게 마르면 아동학대수준임 부모님도 회사 믿고 애 맡겼을템데 저게 뭐임 내가 부모님이었으면 울었다 진짜 ㅅㅂ 원영이 이쁘다 이쁘다 소리만 해주고 싶은데 자꾸 걱정하는 말 나오는건 니네가 관리 잘못한거임
I can't believe how she even has the energy to perform this beautifully... Wonyoung please take care of your health you'll be pretty even if you weight over 50kgs just be healthy please
@@ilickgrandmas2854 i highly doubt she has a bmi of 12… if she did she likely would have zero energy to be an idol, regardless of if her company gives nutritional supplements. she’s more likely around 40kg, still a bmi below 14, which is when many health problems begin including organ failure. i do hope if anything bad does happen that shes able to take a break. jinE of oh my girl was diagnosed with anorexia, and was unable to leave inpatient treatment due to no progression of recovery. she had to leave the group. hopefully wonyoung would at least be given a hiatus if she does experience severe health risks.. the scariest part is seeing people concerned more than likely fuels her disordered thoughts if she truly is struggling..
Wonyoung, if you ever see this... we love you so much. We want you to be healthy. Please eat, you didnt need to lose weight. You will still be pretty. Don't worry about what people on the internet say. If even one person calls you fat of you gain a bit a weight, I will come after them myself. Please be healthy ❤️
@@Useri77u7u7 You don't know, you think idols don't have cellphones, secret accounts or something to watch whatever they want? Also this topic is very popular, I don't think anyone in Starship or IVE knows about it.
all of the other members have not lost as much weight as her i wonder where she gets the energy to perform with her amazing dance skills im really worried even her spine showed i mean not even i can survive a day without eating or i would cry, hope she finds the strength she needs and the food. Im really worried wish her all the best.
Wonyoung you don't have to be like this just to fit the beauty standards. You're really pretty just the way you are....stay healthy.... It's really alarming..and idk why people are saying that this is normal...this isn't ..
제가 본 마른 여돌 중에서 장원영이 제일 심해요 이때까지 봐 온 마른 여돌들 약과일 정도로 심해요... 영상 초반부터 보면 원영이 등에 척추뼈가 다 보일 정도예요 ㅠㅠ 타 팬이지만 걱정 되고 너무 기괴하고 무섭고... 무대 위 표정 보면 밝고 괜찮아 보이지만 혹시나 실제로는 안 괜찮을까 봐 걱정걱정... 원영이 이제 살 그만 빼도 되고 건강이 최고니까 몸 관리 더 잘해줬으면 좋겠는 바램 ㅜㅜ
뼈보여건강괞찬아나 아프지마세요 그리고 너무 이쁘세요 이제 그만이뻐져도되요 살도 그만빼세요 너무 말랐어요 건강챙기세요 언니는 이제걱정마시고 건강한 장원영으로 살아요. 언니척추뼈가보일정도록뼈만보여요 언니밥 꼭 3끼 챙겨먹어요꼭이요 오늘무대도 완전최고로 이쁘네요 모든무대도요 언니화이팅
@@user-mx3lr7im9j 척추뼈가 보일 정도로 뼈만 보여요 이걸 좋게 보는 사람이 있을까. 이쁘단 소리로 안 들리는데? 저 말을 다른 말로 좀 더 순화시켜 말 할 수도 있을텐데…글고 니가 뭔데 인생 꼬였다는 말을 주제 넘게 하는 거임? 주제 넘게 남 인생 들먹이는 너는 수준 떨어지는 짓 아님?
성이름시바님들 원영이싫어 하면 안보면되잔아요 꼭봐서 악플다는거는뭔데요 어이없어요 님들이 유명인이라고 쳐 봐요 그러면 악플 달리면좋아요 아니면 은님들을욕하면은좋아요 네네??? 원영님 은열심히사시고 노력하는사람이에요 근데왜 님들은 이러케 노력하는사람을왜 나빠지게만들어요 건강을 님들이 뭘잘 못해는지는알아요 그리고 저도 지금 악플을 보고 있는데 저도 기분안좋아요 님들이 얼마나 악플을 달았는지 찾아볼게요 그리고 한 사람이 먼저 악플을 달았다고 똑같이따라서 다는거는뭐죠 한사람이 달아서 자기는 안잘못한줄알아요 둘다 잘못했어요 그리고님들은 장원영보다이뻐요 아니면 뼈가 보일정도록 말랐어요 아니면 장원영 보다 공부잘해요 아니면 영어유치원나왔어요 아니면 장원여보다 유명해요 그게궁금하네요 그리고 뭐꼬엿다고요 인생이 그리고 장원영이 님존재 알아요 몰라요 님도 똑같이면서 그런애기하지마요 인생이꼬엿다고 요 그건님들아니에요 저는잘 살고있어요
I can tell you from experience that you can trick yourself into having energy. Like a game of catch up between your mind and body. "I'm completely fine and healthy. I have the energy to do what I want". But sooner than later she'll run out of energy. I bet her mind is all foggy already. It's almost impossible to concentrate when malnourished.
So worrying... at this point, I doubt IVE would be able to do a tour due to Wonyoung's health. She probably has almost no energy. It's incredible she is performing at this level... someone help her. :( I don't want anything bad to happen.
you can be skinny , but it is not healthy to be that skinny,especially when you have an agenda like wonyoung , her leg and arm look like there is nearly nothiung left but the bone , i hope she will be okay , it can really damage her body
i used to be this skimny and although i wasn't healthy at the time and i'm not sure she is either, it made me feel so bad when people made mean comments about my appearence. wonyoung is beautiful anyway, so let's make sure she knows that she is loved and talented and deserves to live in a body that gives her the energy to be herself, a body that can support her, because the focus is health and not beauty
Poor girl, her company sucks for letting a teenage girl get to this unhealthy level. The worst thing is that nobody says anything, and they defend that she is like that naturally. I hope they don't react when it's too late
Every comment on every video is about how she looks unhealthy, so idk what you mean by "no one says anything". I agree that it's gotten to ridiculous levels, but the majority of fans have been pointing this out for months...
@@Bakemer94 Agree, I have really seen few comments on this video justifying it, before (for example) in Eleven there were more comments justifying Wonyoung's status but now there are fewer.
You can’t watch this and not see how emaciated she is… I really hope she or somebody around her gets her the help she needs. Her energy on stage remains as strong as ever somehow.🤔
@@user-pt5mu8vn3s 세상에 칭찬이랑 욕밖에 없음..?이분법적으로 생각하지말고 정상적으로 좀 생각해봐....칭찬이 문제가아니라 진짜 걱정하는거잖아... 니 부모님이 저정도로 마르면 걱정 안되겠냐... 난 우리엄마아빠형누나동생이 저정도로 말라도 몸 심각하다고 할듯...
몸에대해서 왈가왈부하는게 원영이한테 안좋을거란거 알고있지만 이정도의 마름은 단순히 운동열심히 해서 그런거야의 선을 넘은것같아요 이정도면 건강이 걱정됩니다 식이장애아닌지.... 팬이라면 지금 몸에 왈가왈부하는게 기분상한다고 입막는게아니고 건강을 걱정해야돼요 지금 진심으로 저게 건강해보인다고 생각한다면 본인도 병원에 가야됩니다
원영아 맛있는 거 마음껏 먹으면서 스트레스 받지 말고 활동 이어나가줬으면 좋겠어!! 지금도 너무 예쁘지만 너무 마른 것 같아서 나도 걱정되긴 한다ㅠㅠ 너가 원하는 몸매일수도 있지만, 다이어트 때문에 스트레스 받지 말기 바라!! 건강 관리 잘하고 항상 행복해야돼🥰🥰 많이 응원행
You guys need to STOP talking about her body like it's her fault. It's STARSHIP who gives Wonyoung busy schedules and does not care about her heath condition. Sarcastic how you guys pretend to care and then suddenly put all the blame and responsibilities over Wonyoung. She is just 17 and is suffered from INTENSE and HEAVY schedules.
I understand ny'all telling her to eat but we can't assume it's FULLY this teenager's choice or responsibility to change!! She needs outside help and support too!! Her COMPANY better prioritize her health!! A nutritionist, doctor, someone!!
this! also all the people on the Internet are also to blame, people were hating on her one clip of eating that strawberry and for some people those kind of renarks making fun of the way they eat can be a trigger to not eat anymore.
My dear girl we love you so much please take care of yourself. We want you to be healthy because health is the most important thing in life. We love you regardless anything and you don’t have to loose weight to be pretty. You are beautiful and talented and charming. You are a good person. You deserve only the best just because you exist. We love you and please stay healthy ❤️
WONYOUNG!😩 What happened. Their company should never be too strict about maintaining their weight which leads their artists to get more loss. This is so risky. And don't be too hard on yourself Wonyoung, you're doing perfectly fine🥺🤍
Wonyoung is the only one with this body frame in IVE. If they have a certain weight goal then all of them should look like her especially Yujin who is also tall like Wonyoung.
Her company or a family must do something NOW. How is she even able to perfomr in such a state, how can she even stand up ? She need to be place under the care of professional urgently because this isn't just unhealthy anymore, it's getting seriously dangerous. This is sickening, the poor girl is barely 18 and she or someone behind is destroying her, it needs to stop. How can we, strangers see it and be worried but her family and compnay who are in charge of a minor aren't able to take actions. She should be put out of promotion right now and receive proper treatement. How is this even legal, this is child abuse.
Being fat is healthy and being skinny is unhealthy??? Everyone has different body shape and healthy weight. Plus, she said that she is perfectly healthy. U can worried about her and take care of her condition BUT just saying that she is "UNHEALTHY" due to her body sape, that is nothing more than INSULTING. As people accept being fat doesn't mean unhealthy and start loving their body as it is nowadays, please accept that skinny people can be healty and it is just her "BODYSHAPE" just like her face is her face. Don't equalize her external thing to her internal health.
@@gimuniong The thing is wonyoung is extremely skinny not just “skinny” .If you compare her to her IZONE days you can clearly tell she has dropped a lot of weight to the point that it’s not very believable that this is her natural “bodyshape” . it’s evident that wonyoungs case is beyond “normal” especially considering she’s still a minor and is still growing. Being extremely skinny can be just as dangerous and unhealthy as being extremely fat. Plus it’s very disrespectful that you assumed the commenter was being “insulting” when really they were concerned and didn’t seem like they had any malicious intent but was just shedding light on the issue besides, in no way was the op implying that being fat is healthy that is a different concern which was not even mentioned by the commenter
@@gimuniong Also isn’t it obvious wonyoung would say she’s fine? Not very many celebrities would risk their brand deals and ruin their perfect image by admitting that their struggling, vulnerable and need help especially with the way that the kpop industry works, it’s disgustingly normalized
@@gimuniong your comment just show how ignorant and naive you are. Yes, Wonyoung is unhealthy, and no amount of videos of her eating will change that. No one on this earth can maintain such a low weight and body figure without starving themselves, it's scientifically impossible. If wonyoung was indeed getting enough calories per day but still loosing weight, that would mean that she had some sort of illness because that's the only reason as to why someone keep on loosing weight while still eating normally. Stop with the body shaming and natural body nonsense, Wonyoung isn't naturally skinny anymore and probably never have been. We first saw her on our screen when she was 13 years old and her body was still that of a child. So we don't know what her actual naturally body looks like but what we can say for sure is that her actual figure is anything but natural. Besides, being naturally skinny doesn't mean being healthy. Being born with a fast metabolism and a petite frame overall can be the source of many health issues and is as unhealthy as being overweight. You have to realize that no matter the reason behind her weight loss, no one can be healthy when they barely weight 40kg and are over 173cm. You really took the problem on the wrong side. In our society, ppl who gain weight are regarded as unhealthy and unable to manage themselves while we praise the one who loose weight, even when it's too extreme. I don't know how much time you spend on social media but Instagram or tiktok are basically the only place where fat ppl are encouraged and seen as healthy. In real life, they are usually discriminated and get plenty warning from their doctors and family about their health. On the other hand, underweighted ppl are usually never noticed as loosing weight is mostly see as positive and healthy in most culture. Korean Media and fans have been praising and glorifying Wonyoung extremely skinny figure for months, which is the wrong thing to do. You can decide to stay blind and keep on encouraging Wonyoung to maintain her unhealthy state, but don't be surprise when you hear about her getting admitted to the hospital or worse. Wonyoung needs help, it doesn't take a genius to realize that. I only hope that her family and company care about her more that the money she brings and put her under the care professionals
진짜 심각하게 마름 저정도로 말랐는데 ㄹㅇ로 건강에 이상 없을거같음? 팬들이라는 것들이 말랐다는 말을 악플로 받아들이고 비정상적으로 마른거 얘기못하게 입막음하니까 점점 심해지는거 아니겠냐고 ㅋㅋㅋ 물론 뼈다귀같다느니 이런말은 악플맞지만 이런거 제외하고 ㅋㅋ 걱정은 못해줄망정 이뻐ㅠㅠ 이러고있으니까 가수입장에선 아 사람을이 내 이런모습을 좋아하는구나 싶겠지 그러니까 계속 말라지는거고 ㅋㅋ 아무도 이 괴이함을 못느끼는게 소름돋네 남돌이 저정도로 말랐으면 내새기 왤케 말랐어 밥좀먹어ㅜㅜ 했을텐데 ㅋㅋ
@@MenShouldBeYoung 원영이 먹는 거 좋아하고 마른게 체질인 거 그리고 자기관리 잘하는 거 찐팬중에 모르는 사람이 있을까요? 키크고 마른 거 직업 특성상 장점이지만 하도 비교 당하고 말 나오면 스트레스 받아해요.. 언급 안 해주길 바라기도 했구요 원영이가 운동도 꾸준히 하고 있고 밥도 잘 챙겨 먹는다고 늘 말하는데 잘 알지도 못하면서 건강 걱정하는 척하지 마세요
The energy is ASTOUNDING for someone who looks like they were dug out of a Victorian grave. She still smiles and has full, rosy cheeks, and performs like she did when she was healthy in Iz*one. StarShit has to be giving her stimulants. One bad fall or one infection or even a common cold and her body WILL NOT be able to handle it. She genuinely looks like she's dying, moreso than any case of a starved idol I've ever seen. More than Wendy, more than Lisa, more than Sunmi. And she's not even a legal adult yet. A growing teen needs nutrients more than anyone. If her bones aren't brittle, her growth will be stunted. If her growth isn't stunted, she'll develop heart/organ problems. She'll be affected long term by this weight if it doesn't change soon. I fear for her. I hope StarShit Ent. burns down for letting it get this bad
Its truly horrible seeing her fancam I’m so worried for her bc I rally like wo… I been in a incident that let me unable to eat bc I had paranasal problems. I didn’t eat almost nothing during 15 days and my body ofc went more slim than I am. And you don’t know THE PAIN THE PAINNN my whole muscles disappeared. And I couldn’t even walk without feeling like falling. I couldn’t sleep from the pain.
![[MPD직캠] 아이브 장원영 직캠 4K 'After LIKE' (IVE WONYOUNG FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2022.9.1](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
