its weird seeing all the other group encores then coming back to this. other groups seems so nervous from their singing to their expression. aespa are just so confident with their skills.
I heard for some idols encore stage is almost like a punishment. this actually makes sense because like you said, some of them just seem nervous when it's time to sing their parts.
@@texhnlyze6892 I only saw the one that one of the girls had her mic off and it was too sad for me to keep going. She looked so heartbroken. Between the performance lipsyncs and the boring choreos and concept, these girls were done so dirty by SM. I'm glad they are moving towards a more organic direction because their talent is undeniable
to be honest, they were singing not all parts live... only Winter was signing fully live, that's why you can hear how she move her mic closer or far...
@@MadinaDzhumabaeva 3:09 Giselle laughs clearly in her mic so that gives it away that they’re all singing live bc even their laugh and adlibs sounds just as clear
no it's just that sm care mostly about singing so trainees are required to look fixable (for surgeries) and good at singing while HYBE's.. you just need to be lucky tbh (katseye are the only one's good at singing and dancing at the same time although according to koreans they look ugly but it doesn't matter since they'll be promoted in the west) yg kind of care about rap and how long you are willing to be a trainee there cause they never debut people or have comebacks and jyp care about star quality and dancing and you either really know how to sing there or you just straight up suck (but I guess you'd have to have something else you're good at)
@@Meggi962 aha. Those are two. Now put those two against Wendy, Seulgi, Ningning, Winter, Taeyeon. Can they be put on the same level? Nmixx can but the rest of JYP is a no. We can add Jihyo too.
what a high level standard of live encore stage.. my ears are CLEANSED from all the other crappy encore stages that we've been subjected to. Can you hear their stability and confidence? I love this so much!
엠카 앵콜이면 완전 아이돌들의 무덤으로 악명 높은곳 아니냐?ㅋㅋ 진짜 가수인지, 아닌지 판단하는 단두대인데. 심지어 지민도 이 엠카 앵콜 하나로 "노래 잘 부르네"에서 "정말 노래 잘 부르는거 맞나?"로 10년동안 쌓아온게 한 순간에 무너져버렸는데ㅋㅋ 라이브인데 얘들은 뭐 음반 틀어놓은거같노ㅋㅋ
@@liak.-mh2kkit's really obvious when they don't sing live, just look at their face and attitude then you will know. Winter litterally laugh half way of her savage performance XD
they only sing live in paid events like off air events, festivals and award ceremonies lol why do they need to waste their voice in tv promotion, they have a lot of events to attend lol
U know its bad they nay hurt their vocals if they sing live often . They need also to rest their voices they're singers they still need to take good care of their voices
I wouldn't really call myself a MY but omg these girls are insane, their encore stages really surprise me, they sound so good. so talented and pretty!!
Now this is how you sing. tbh idk why most idols who do encores looks like they're dying and they struggle too much. it's the agencies fault too tho bc they choose visual more than talents. cry but aespa literally ate a whole chilli and still sings amazing.
SM artists never disappoint when it comes to live vocals! And aespa as their newest artist continues that tradition. Recently I saw so many people praising/hyping their fav's live singing (even for encore) but it's not as what I expected. I guess some people's definition of good/great/amazing live vocals is different. Anyway, congrats aespa for Spicy's 3rd win today, including 1st win in mcountdown!
@Mina M yes and no. They're praising their fav artists (not aespa, but I also enjoy their songs) for singing live & saying how amazing their live vocals are, but when I watched the said videos, I can hear how pitchy/out of tune they are although they were not dancing. I don't mean it as comparisons to aespa, but my comments are based on those particular videos of the said artists. Probably it's just the artists' bad day.
aespa has all my respect bc imagine being THIS good live and having kpop stans making fun of you for years because your own company forces you to lip sync 🙁
Truth. I am not a hater of the girls, just that I am mad they never sing live and they were given that much praise for lipsync. After Coachella they gained my respect and this time I am here supporting them.
진짜 이번 신곡은 감동이 있다... 그동안 해왔던 광야 잠깐 쉬어가면서 기대했던 청량 여름곡을 들을 수 있게 된 것도 좋고, 항상 음방 첫주만 뛰느라 음방 라이브는 들을 수가 없었는데 이번에는 라이브도 하고 앵콜도 하고 대학 축제에서도 라이브 잘하고... 그동안 못 했던 것들 과소평가 받았던 것들 다 사라지고 애들도 편안해 보여서 더 좋은듯
본인들에게 잘맞고 좋아하는 노래라서 더 잘하는거 같다. 사비 부분이 결코 낮은 음이 아닌거 같은데 모든 멤버들이 정말 잘부르는거같음. 무엇보다 잘한다 못한다는 상대적 기준일 수 있는데 듣기가 편하다는게 에스파의 강점인듯 컴백기간도 길게 걸리고 많은 맘고생했는데 더 빛을 보게 되는거 같아 응원합니다.
as a MY, i'm literally CRYING! Finally an encore where the track audio isn't too loud, we can hear their voices, they're so relaxed and having so much fun... I'LL LOVE THEM TO DEATH ❤
Actually all encores except Music Core only play the instrumentals so any vocals are from them. We just need to make them win on Inkigayo, Music Bank, Mcountdown 😂
확실히 보컬은 진짜 스엠이 넘사다..1세대 때부터 전통있는 보컬의 명가..진짜 걍 음원 튼 줄; ㄹㅇ 네명 다 성량이 빵빵하네. 거기에 음색까지 너무 좋아서 듣기가 편안함. 스엠은 보면 모든 팀이 엄청난 보컬스킬, 성량, 음색을 모두 완벽하게 갖고 가는 게 참 신기해...
@@user-iu2hi9cr1o 솔직히 잘한 건 아니긴 함ㅇㅇ 또 블핑이랑 비교대상 되서 더 부각됐었고... 근데 그렇게 죽을만큼 까일만큼 못하지도 않았는데 대한민국 망신이라고 진짜 욕 너무 먹어서 안타까웠음 솔직히 신인이기도 했고 생애 첫 라이브를 그렇게 큰 무대에 데려가서 시키니 당연히 긴장하지... 가기 전부터 블핑이랑 비교당하면서 욕 오지게 먹었고... 참
these girls don't seem to be afraid of singing live even in encore they hit every high note , i wonder why their company was making them lip-sync...? like what is the reason , they can sing and they r not afraid so let them sing ffs...
To preserve their vocals, they'll be singing live during concerts, year end music shows, other paid stages etc I really dont mind idols who can really sing do this lip sync sometimes. Coz when they need to do live, they are capable and not a scam 😂. Others are using AR just to hide their flaws, not these girls
@@alalani_r3i hahaha, they're always trying to prove something just like how jype market them as the best vocal group, live singing etc, I mean ok good for them but still atleast make a hit song so people could catch up with their "greatness"