बिना पढ़ें कुछ भी बोल देने या लिख देने से कोई हमारे धर्म शास्त्र का ज्यादा नहीं हो जाता; पटनायक जी। आपकी पुस्तकें कभी संग्रहीत नहीं की जायेगी। हिन्दू धर्म के विरोधियों के धन पर छप जाने वाली पुस्तकें को बेचकर मौज कर लें , यश नहीं मिलेगा।
One suggestion to people who wants to read devdutt's book if you sanskrit or the root language of the scriptures then you can read his books... Bcz devdutt knows no sanskrit at all usses english and hindi translation of the scriptures include his imagination into it and then right his book he sensationlige everything so keep it in mind.🙏
A very enlightening knowledge sir keep it up u have actually correctly analyzed the mindset of characters of ramayan-you have truly figured out each one's psychology sir
आई प्राउड ऑफ यू सर रामायण को समझाने के लिए आपने कितनी सरलता से कह दिया कि वेद को समझे बिना हम रामायण महाभारत विष्णु पुराण शिव पुराण ब्रह्मपुराण देवी पुराण को नहीं समझ सकते
Could you please provide an English translation of your speech wherever possible as my knowledge of Hindi is very limited to understand the nuances of your exposition! Thanking you in anticipation.
does this hold true that the person whoever is reading whichever ramayana or mahabharata the truth or the conclusion he/she comes to is actually what he/she had been looking all his/her life;ramayana and mahabharta totally depends on the believe of the person who is reading them...lyk u always say jaisa vishwaas waisa vyavhaar;...framed by me .jis cheez ki pyaas uski khoj
The world is not limitless, nation states are not limitless, companies are not limitless, we are not limitless. For Devdutt, anything that is not limitless, is myth?
How about your own knowledge, that is also limited!!! To whom your limited knowledge is being expressed!!! Words are used are from english and hindi language, whereas there is no accurate translation for hindi words into english. Law vs Rule. Laws are not understood by everyone, hence rules are created. To appreciate the law behind rules all stories or so called mythologies are created. Again these stories only will not educate you about laws. To understand you need longer time to introspection. That is why knowledge gathering required longer isolation.
Really can't understand... The trailers of Bollywood movies songs gets 100 million views race videos like these doesn't even cross 100k..its ok to watch trailers and songs.. But everyone needs to look at these also which has lots of knowledge relevant to world till eternity
@@vishnutibra4444 to get to the point i was making you dont need bramhagyan, use your common sense. I have read Srimad Bhagvat Geeta. And its enough for me.
devdutt sir ....mai janna chata hu ki agar ram bhagvan h to unhone sita mata ki agni priksha kyu lee ma janna chahta hu ......pls ap ek lacture de hindi me
In a democracy, the government has to take everybody's wishes , therefore democracy does not allow a country to move forward develop if there is too much diversity, as in India. This is a price we r paying for having so many activists in a country trying to develop.
Have you heard of relative truth? Do you believe in facts like we are never in absolute rest or absolute motion! We are always in relative rest or relative motion. Same way every aspect of human understanding is relative.
have you read all vedas and purans to understand ramayana ? and why it is necessary to understand devi puran we need to first understand tantra gyan ,what is the relation between tantra and devi ?
Nothing is new. He is only interpreting. The concept of Sanadhan is not the religious fanaticism...don’t mistake him to any extremism. Just enlightening that’s all especially for all those who sit within glass doors...driven by their ambitions and not knowing their role
There's a popular saying ' A little knowledge is very dangerous' and this man whole speech is a perfect example. From the very beginning, his whole words and stories are false. If you go and confirm his knowledge with a person who has read vedic scriptures will straight say this man is a whole book of misinterpretation, misinformation and cheater. He doesn't even know basic concepts of hinduism. Devtas don't mean bichaar, and the story of indra is whole level of misinformation. Actually it was krishna who told Brahma that there are millions of universe in this cosmos and each universe has its own Brahma. Go and learn basic hinduism first and then preach you scam.
Sorry to say it is hopeless explanation, because it can only attract those who don't know the scriptures. Only the ignorant can concentrate with this. Spirituality is not that complex. Need is to read the Bhagvad-gita again and again.
Excellent interpretation and some idiot sends the nonsensical video called demolishing Devdutt Patnaik What he says actually makes a lot of sense Cause yeah who the hell decides what is right and wrong.
Tumne jiski photo lagayi hai naa woh bhale hii bahut bade yodha the lekin woh yeh decide nahi kar paye ki duryodhan ka saath de yaa phir shri krishn ka.
devdutt patnaik sees Indian history with foreign lens and he is a gay so he has typical obsession to see sacred things as gay sex, lesbian sex and violence. Its his vulgar dreams and fantacies which he than tries to write with distortion because his knowledge of Sanskrit is ZERO. So he is typical who is confused between words like Karm and karam.
Sirji Pahle achche Guru ki Khojo Jo ye sab apke sika sakte hai. That's why We need Guru's krupa to get Hari krupa. Sirf padne se Puran aur Ithihas samaj mein nahin aata hai. That's why Bhashyams are written. Seek a Sadguru, you will understand everything.
It seems you never read purans but still interpretting it.. I have started reading shiva puran and devi puran at the same time..!! I still understand them with out reading vedas.. Liar!!!
My God he lies so much!!! To cover up his lack of knowledge he will make up any imaginary fact he can think of and blurt it!! And I can't understand why he abuses everyone so much on Twitter... Changing our historical religious books and figures just to make money is seriously evil. Shame on you!
Tab to apko Sanskrit, Prakrit, Saurseni, Brahmi ,Awadhi,Braj , Tamil, Malayalam, Bengali, Telugu etc sabhi ke vyakaran ka gyan lena hoga Sir, hamare Shastra ek bhasha tak simit nahi.
खूप सुंदर वाटते....देवदत्त पटनायक यांचे ऐकायला.....रामायण , महाभारकाल,वेद,उपनिषद,वरील भाष्य....आपल्या आजच्या जीवनाशी निगडित कसे आहे ते स्पष्ट सांगतात....खूप अभ्यास असल्यानेच हे शक्य आहे
@@pratibharane3903 सगळ्यात मोठी हास्यास्पद गोष्ट ही आहे की याने न कधी वेद अभ्यासले, न रामायण वाचले न महाभारत! याने केवळ समाजात मिथ्य पेरले. ज्ञान नाही!
If you have not grasped the content of the Vedas, you can't understand Ramayan, Mahabharat and Puranas. But after you have grasped the meaning of the Vedas, Ramayan, Mahabharat and Puranas begin to appear so silly & superfluous. Then why not to throw Ramayan, Mahabharat and Puranas into the nearest gutter and focus your attention on Vedas & Vedas alone!! Yes, do it, you'll not regret it. And stop wasting your time on such clowns as this crafty guy.
Ur hindu frnds don't like him bcoz they know some hindu scriptures.. U dont know any so u love him. He dont even know sanskrit, he just read it from some sources.. And describe it with fiction created by him. He is wrong in so many lectures.. Know hinduism through hindu scripture not from a self proclaimed mythologist
@@LotayConstructions u r surely an ignorant man i guess bcoz u r listing to a mythologist and u wanna live in present. All he is saying is not from scripture few ignorant people like u, and sonam kapoor listen to him.. To know hinduism. Like sonam kapoor said to know hinduism read devdutt pattnaik.. And we all know.. Whts her knowledge.. But sanatan dharm has no problem with ignorant people like bcoz its so great that a few stupid people cant harm it. U basically like devdutt's line of thought bcoz he is somehow insulting hinduism.. Ur frnds r true hindu thats why they have a problem.
@@phaddu7737 there is no religion called like hindu... It may be bunch of different sects now being headed by the Brahmanic system of division of humanity... and financial loot in the name of rituals and superstitions... RU-vid channels like science journey can burst most of your myths...