With this exhausting and explosive choreo, i'd be actually fine if they prefer lip syncing. They were panting in the middle of the performance but they still decided to sing live and slayed it. I could never be more proud.
Idols would actually film a few times during stages to capture angles, so probably it was already their 3rd or 4th time when his was recorded. if you check other members fancams, he was still fine there.
Jay's vocal is so underrated. He's voice is so stable and man can hit high notes. I hope belift will notice and appreciate it. He deserve to have more line.
Jungwon has so much lines and the choreo is exhausting. How the hell did he managed to be so stable? Like all of them are actually really great for a rookie and considering the choreo.
well i think it also has something to do with sm's training,, jungwon was an sm trainee b4 and i heard from an sm idol (i think it was a shinee member) that when someone is late for practice theyd make them sing while running on a treadmill,, also sm (altho theyre shit at managing artists) focuses on stamina and stability training alot so i can see why jungwon can be so stable even in iland
@@alyannastanford3178 not when you're clearly sunoo biased, i will praise jay and jungwon if i want to and you can praise sunoo the way you want, just mind your own business
@@jungwonyang2886 lol im here for a healthy conversation tho. yes im a sunoo biased but im stanning the whole group. you should've just said "in my opinion" because if you really love enha you will love their flaws but at the same time wishing them to improve. gahhd. and what's the problem if im a sunoo biased? I'm also criticizing his lack of voice color.
@@jungwonyang2886 lol what does being stable have to do in skipping a three word line? hear his verses. and just as i said even being a stable one he lacks color. oh my god i thought people here are open with this thing. gfriend's mr removed video comments can't relate. sorry if i invaded your comment. my bad 🥺
@@alyannastanford3178 he only have little lines with easier choreography but still skipped it, calling him more stable than jay and jungwon who sang all their lines with hard choreo loud and clear is not right if we're being objective
Wow Jay is so stable. This is really hard.. Jay's part is so high but still he pulled that off. Its no joke to sing stable while dancing. All of them did a good job
Jake was having a hard time breathing that can be seen on his fancam but he still did his best, professionalism yeah. Imagine hitting those notes while doing that gestures and action and also kneeling down.
I really like Jungwoon, but as a professional musicien I Can hear that he made a few blue notes during his parts... Shift is fine since thé choreo was so difficult.
this proved why since iland, Jay's voice and tone attracted me the most, hence he is my bias. not that i don't like the others but i find Jay's voice color, tone and power more pleasing to hear. indeed he is underrated. he hits high notes with no signs of struggle and he hits them sharp and clean
OMG YESS!! People didn't appreciate his vocal enough tbh, I mean that tone, that vocal colour, stability, why aren't anyone bragging about it. He's the only one that sounds exactly as the CD ver tho he didn't sing all his part live which is understandable woth that kind of choreo.( ofc the rest sound great, esc Jungwon Heeseung, but their vocals was more autotuned with electronic sound in the recording that's why Jay was the only one that sound exactly like the cd)
@@maddiphen2538 bragging. Yes that's the word we need to do with Jay's vocals. i become an engene bec. i found his vocals unique and really smooth like no shaking, if it needs to be soft it is soft and if it needs to be powerful then it sounds also powerful i mean, he hits them so sharp you can't even say anything negative about his voice.
Let's be honest here. They're not sing all their line which is so normal and understable (Jungwon mostly sing his line even with hard choreo and it's awesome) But the fact that they're working hard to singing live itself so good. Yeah after all they're singer, of course has to singing.
They're mics are on and they're not using autotune and that is already something to be proud of. Plus, their choreo is very intense but they still slayed this performance
@@tzuyuishereforyourkneecaps7110 no his mic is fine. He just sounds so similar to the original that the software tried to remove his voice because it’s confusing it with the original. Usually background removals like this use the original track as a source. Whatever is the same as the original is what gets taken out (or in this case, the volume decreased)
For me the most stable are jungwon, jay, and sunoo. Their live vocals are on another levels. Feels sorry for heeseung cause he had to sing hard part with hard choreo. Despite those condition, he still really good at singing live. His live vocals still amazing. And tbh, i'm surprise with niki's vocals. He improves a lot. Proud!
@@zidannabyan So, you said Hs lipsync too?? But Heeseung is the Main vokal. When he was a bighit upbringing trainee, he couldn't possibly lip-sync on his part So i'm pretty sure mr removed is not 100% accurate
@@zidannabyan Yeahh. While it seems that he doesn't, you are mistaken, he does sing Sunoo is really the closest one to their studio version. He is the most stable. He does his part less 'breathy', he have the strong control of breathing
@@meiyang1039 yeah and i saw him during his High note part while sitting down he's out of breath 😭 but he still doing his best to show his Professionalism 💜
i'd like to point out here that heeseung has insane vocals in this - we can clearly tell they're singing live but heeseung's voice is almost similar to the audio for drunk-dazed, and he's so precise in pitch, rhythm, tone quality and stability that he doesn't miss any note at all and is almost identical to that of the audio
Jungwon & Jay are on another level. others did well too & props to Jungwon for singing all of his line. Despite the hard choreo his voice really are so stable & powerful.
jungwon is insane to sing so stable like cd when he is on freaking floor ! but we all cant deny they ARE AMAZINGG FOR SINGING THIS LIVE AND NOT LIP SYNCING
I don't care about people talk about them being "unstable" or something cuz imo real and raw vocals with mistakes and panting is much more better than lipsyncing.
Jungwon deserves the chorus. He did so well despite of the hard choreo (jump and lying on the ground!?!hello) Im beyond proud of him. This boy has been stable since into the i-land :"")
the way y'all aren't praising heeseung because you thought he lip synced his part when in fact he sounded the same like the studio version and he was able to control his voice not to be louder than the backing track. and his voice wasn't loud probably because his mic volume isn't high too just like sunghoon's. sunghoon and heeseung both sang live their parts but because their mics were not as loud as other members, just because their voices arent as loud as others, yall said they lip synced lolll.
This!!! Omg I can literally hear their breath during their parts but in mr removed, they just disappeared. I was sure I heard them right. Heesung as usual, aced his lines. And, Sunghoon, other stans are dragging him down just because they want to prove their bias stability with singing all their lines while saying SH didn’t. SH in actual got the most lines in d-d and he managed them all with his stamina control. He was incredible but toxic fans has to drag him down saying nonsense
Our charismatic Yang leader vocal is really stable.. He already proved it in I-land way before.. making big moves and hard choreo while signing is not a joke.. EN- is doing their best. Fighting!
The software used can't even differentiate between Heeseung's live vocal and Studio version because they sound the same. That's why Heeseung's voice isn't loud as we are expecting.
how can heeseung’s voice be so similar with the studio version?????? Jay and jungwon are stable too🤯🤯 they all did so well, i’ll probably pass out before the first chorus:-)
I would like to appreciate jay and jungwon. Jungwon sang clearly and actually even when in the chorus, he had to jump and there was so sign of struggling. It’s a difficult,exhausting choreo so kudos to them. Enhypen is always improving.
@@hoonluvs7225 i think stable is not the right word hun. because they tend to go off key and breathing loudly sometimes. but that is every understandable coz the choreo is super hard. and they must've took a lot of takes that's why they have been exhausted. but yes, just like the op said, they should improve their stamina and i believe other things will follow.
Jungwon really knows how to pace himself with dancing when it's not his line so that he can sing and breathe well during his parts that, mind u, requires excessive movements and breathing. I'm so proud of him. Even during Given and Taken and Let Me In when he has flowy lines, he's still able to sing them properly.
Once more Heeseung did an amazing job : his voice parts are always withing the most difficult choregraphy parts... They all more or less did a good job ( special mention to Sunoo !).
im shocked they can still sing live with their exhausting choreo. they should have lipsynced instead there is no problem with that especially with that hard dance and props to jungwon for singing all of his lines
jaywon being stable kings, ni-ki vocal is soo underrated, sunsun slayed as alwyass and heejake the professional performers. i will never regret calling myself as an engene 😔
Jungwon, i am extremely proud. He sang most of his parts. Even on the ground. What a leader. And Jay, you are so stable. Good job to all the boys for singing even tho the choreo is insane.
Jungwon is SOOO UNDERATED as we can see he is very stable, i barely see comments about him in their videos😢people sleeping on him should see how talented he is plus all of them did great im soooo proud!!!
Ni-ki is still undergoing puberty and his voice is still changing and it must've been hard for him to stabilize. As u can notice, his voice became deeper but he has good and wide vocal range. Listen to the 2nd chorus of Fever and you'll know.
How can Jungwon sound like he ate CDs for breakfast, lunch, dinner and his midnight snack during his parts, especially when he's on the floor, on his stomach, turning 😭🙌🏻 So talented!
when heeseung sing staaayyyyyy---- it's so good huhuhu Heeseung is so stable, you didn't hear his voice struggling at all, his voice is not shaky, his angelic voice is the same even he is dancing a hard steps and choreo. i'm so proud of Heeseung. truly a masterpiece and a main vocal
@@katansel422 what's really your point? they delivered the song so well while doing hard choreos tho. its not that hard appreciate efforts, and yes we care for ni-ki
@@zidannabyan it's not easy to sing the whole part of yours when dancing to this hard, dense and tiring choreo! and IT'S NORMAL TO NOT SING THE WHOLE LINE while DANCING, at least they've tried their best to delivered it to us to show how they have been improved!
@@katansel422 solo stan? yeah not surprise... We did care abt him! I must say that Ni-ki has really really improve his vocals! and I'm very proud of him! All of them did good! They are all improving day by day!
Kim Sunoo is making me so proud. Even he got the least lines, he executes his parts in the most stable way, and some ppl right there in the comments already praising him. What more if belift gives him the lines he truly deserves?