F(x) has the biggest fanbase between all of them internationally and native because F(x) can pull of any dances and concepts......F(X) won this one!!!!!! F(X)
+MsShe4eva I don't think they did either because they always did unusual and experimental concepts XD XD XD but it would awsome to see them do either one :) :) :)
f(x) was the best, when it comes to adapting other groups choreo and song, and they give all their energy ... but in 4m performance, I think f(x)'s danger is too difficulot for them, and this only proves the uniqueness of f(x) than the other groups ! :))
+Jessica Dionisio I've heard that f(x) is considered an "experimental" group in that they can constantly change and try different concepts and totally own it, so it makes sense that they'd be able to take another group's song and make it seem as if it was originally theirs.
sistar pulled off that cute and wholesome performance. it's fun to watch f(x) performance didn't feel like a cover, it's like they're performing their own song. 4minute's just too sexy for a song like pinocchio i think 12.13
F(x) definitely killed it. They brought it, owned it, lent it to their future company sisters, and they brought it while 4minute was still trying to figure out the beat.
I know, people are giving them so much crap for not being as good as f(x), but it's just for fun and it's cool to see different groups doing different concepts
f(x) slayed! It was a cover but it had an f(x) feel to it and doesn't seem to be a cover at all. Sistar and Secret did great as well, imo. Sistar seemed a bit awkward for me because they don't usually do cute concepts, but I think they did pretty well for a group that's not doing what we're used to.
Zinger SLAYED sistars rap tbh. They are really good at doing to sexy concept! Sistar did good too as they tried hard but since they usually do sexy concepts, it looked awkward. F(x) was really good. The made the songs theirs for sure. 4minute also did well too its just that F(x) is really hard to imitate. Good job to all the girls!
this is the 100th time i have been watching this video i literally watch this everyday cant get over how f(x) just nailed it i literally thought this is their song when i first watched it. What can i say they have AMA-ZINGG coorperation
저 시절 케이팝은 본진이 있어도 다른 팀들 노래 다같이 부르고 같이 즐기던 시대였고 콘서트나 연말무대 본진 볼려고 가는 것도 있지만 모든 아이돌들 다 볼려고 가던 시절이였는데 난 아직도 다즐링레드랑 미스틱화이트에서 벗어나지 못한다..이때 노래들 들으면 저때가 생각나서 너무 그립다...ㅠ
f(x) did a really great job. It's like they were performing their own song! I love that they can adapt to other groups songs but other groups have a hard time adapting to theirs. :) SISTAR also did amazing!
f(x) really nailed the performance!!!!!! want to give some credits to 4minute,for trying their best to sing danger, sorry to say this f(x) songs can only be performed by f(x) themselves,the hard choreo and their unique songs,makes them NO 1....................................... f(x) fighting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I find that f(x) and sistar are so versatile and can cover any song like it's their own, like how sistar covered hush as well it sounded their own song!
I agree, but I think it's the same with all groups. Pinocchio isn't really 4minute's style, for obvious reasons, and f(x) didn't have the vocal ability (like Gayoon and Jiyoon) to pull off Mirror Mirror, but all groups did extremely well:D
Andrew Chen I am comparing them to the original song, and I didn't say Krystal did a bad job, because she did well, but not as good compared to the original group, 4minute. Like I said in my comment, each group did well, but the performance proved that every group is unique, and no one can perform their song as well as themself.
hyorin slayed shy boy high note, zinger slayed ma boy rap, f(x) slayed mirror mirror, jihyun and sohyun fitted in this 'f(x)' concept but the rest are too sexy for f(x) song. overall i missed this 3rd generation of kpop (2008/2009-2010)
wow f(x) killed it !!!!!! I love how they added their own style in it !!!!!! Sistar and Secret did a good job too , but 4minute..... they just didnt fit the concept, outfits and their dance is quite awkard too :-(
F(x) was probably really hard to cover as they're so unique...after watching this, I can see how completely different Hyuna's and Amber's rapping styles are...they're both really good, but so diffferent!
@@ShineBright506 yeah nah f(x) was hella popular back in the day, in the same bracket as Kara and Sistar - especially in terms of global fame. Pinocchio was f(x)'s first win too lol - Produce 101 used one of f(x)'s songs, another reason why fans sue that phrase. But many idols look up to f(x) and the members..
@@minkihhhgg4938 not hella popular just medium popular and the real hella popular are snsd and 2ne1. kara is so popular in japan and sistar is so popular in korea.f(x) is just like miss-A they are not that popular but they got a pretty fame bc they come from big 3
@@ShineBright506 medium popular? Hahah i think you are somebody that was born after 2003 so you were just a kiddo when they started to make experimental songs for Europe market. Read, it's for Europe, not USA. Even is US,they've been received the recognition. Talking abt popularity, i guess you haven't read and do your research well abt f(x). - Their song of Hot Summer has received the recognition as the original anthem for summer season. - f(x) was the only group that was listed for the best album in 2013 for international list. - international fans eager to know the song that SM bought from Ariana Grande to f(x). Can u guess whats the song? I think u couldn't. - f(x) were the first that introduce EDM elements in Korea, 2012. - f(x) and Rihanna were in top topic about the Red Light song in 2014. -In 2015, f(x) did big impact again on their song, 4 walls. -Do you know that starting from 2011 onwards, their songs were topped and in high charts everywhere and to list them here, Melon, Mnet, Genie, Monkey3 & Naver Music. - Do you know how many times when f(x) is the only korean pop group that made their name into the international awards? - Do you know that in 2014, f(x) is the second female group with the best selling album after SNSD? - do you know that in MAMA 2013, SNSD & f(x) were the rival where they both were competed between them for Best Female Group? - Do you know that digital sales f(x) in 2013 were higher than 2NE1 (Falling in love)? I don't like to drag 2ne1 here since this is my beloved group but we need to make comparison to show a proven data. - in 2015, it was listed that f(x) were the group for the best selling album in SM for the finale quarter of the year? - do u know that f(x) is the 3rd most famous group in China after SNSD? The first one was Wonder Girl if I'm not mistaken. -Do you know how many times f(x) ranked 1 and double in Hanteo & Gaon? - Do you know how many times, the best selling and top 10 best selling album is always about snsd and f(x) where the rest are male group? - Do you know, up until today, the songs of NewJeans (new group from Hybe) are reminding them of f(x) for their experimental & versatile concept? - Do you know how many times f(x) received critical acclaim for its own unique where their genre were just ahead of the time? - Do you know, journalists putting them as a legendary group where they are the first that become the experimental group along with shinee? - do you know that international fans recognise them as the Fashion Queen for every comeback? The tennis skirt, one side make up, the hair trend of their song, Nuabo in 2010 and many more? - Do you know how many times they received Perfect All Kill? Especially in the era of internet wasn't a main source to stream? Do you know that the contributors were the international fans? 😏 - do you know that many acclaimed f(x) is internationally popular for europe market while snsd was for Us market? Do you know how big is Europe? There were many that I couldn't list here. It's just,do your research again. More n more. Especially from those that had begun following 2nd gen group before 2016. I've bee following them since 2012 where at that time, 2ne1's song were my fav (I Love You track). Do you know this song? That's all.
+Lorraine Libatique I think f(x) is really unique and because of the diversity in their group they give a different feel to their songs that no other groups can copy. ^_^
Kaizer_22 so true! it will take years for them to finally copy their moves xD BTW, have you watched fx's 4 walls already? check it out! its beautiful and refreshing!
After playing this back for the nth time, f(x) did it really well becoz they owned it from the stage presence, outfits, backup dancers, dance, and song distribution. It sounded and looked that it was originally style fx. While the rest tried to copy. Sistar was saved by Hyorins lovely voice, Secret was saved by the body wave and that camera angles & 4minute by Gayoons note. 4minute had a hard time with Pinocchio because they each tried to copy a member from fx. I think Hyuna did her own and could've been okay if she rapped louder and gave more energy.
Secret could pull off ma boy better,and the song style n vocal range could suit them well:) f(x) just made the song with own with their interpretation, i thought it was their new song or smth that i've never heard before xD now i know... secret & f(x) wins &^
OMG!! Krystal's and Luna's voice really suits this song!! I want them to sing the whole song please!! no offense but i really enjoy them singing it more than the original one. they do sound better singing this esp Krystal
f(x) killed it!!! it was super awsome!! and Sistar was so good too I loved Hyorin's cute voice ;3 Secret did well but Hyorin's parts are to much to handle, but the rap part was impresive, 4minute was ok, but f(x)'s song don't suit them at all, but Gayoon's high note was awsome!! Hyuna's rap was weird :S She is one of the best reppers but her style is so diffrent form Amber. To me f(x) won!!!
Secret was AWESOME! They sang Ma Boy and they owned it! This only proves that they can do any concept not like other groups. No offense. F(x) totally killed it too! Their performance seemed so familiar and like Secret they sang like the song was theirs!
She was sick, promoting with 4Minute and preparing for Bubble Pop comeback (which she teased this same episode) and still having special stages must've been so tiring
well I know who won at least :P 1. SISTAR THEY WERE SO CUTE!! LOVE THEM :D 2. F(x) I am suprised! They did amazing :D and the song fits them well! 3. SECRET.. They could have done better.. And i think it was kinda wrong that they took a Sistar19 song.. :/ 4. 4 MINUTE....(they did really bad... I didn't like it ::/ ) Who do you think was the best ?? :)
![[Music Bank Special Stage] Sistar & Secret & f(x) & 4minute (2011.7.1)](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
