Тёмный

Muslim Eyewitness Describes Brutality of Crusaders and Richard I (1187 - 1191) // Baha Ad-Din 

Voices of the Past
Подписаться 1 млн
Просмотров 337 тыс.
50% 1

Get your special offer for MagellanTV here: try.magellantv.... It's an exclusive offer for our viewers! Start your free trial today. MagellanTV is a new kind of streaming service run by filmmakers with 3,000+ documentaries! Check out our personal recommendation and MagellanTV’s exclusive playlists: www.magellantv...
--------------
Extracts from The Life of Saladin by Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad translated by Claude Reignier Conder
(1897) Published by the Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund
Soundtrack licensed from Epidemic Sound/Artlist.
Footage from Videoblocks.

Опубликовано:

 

26 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,2 тыс.   
@Artur_M.
@Artur_M. 3 года назад
The fragment between 3:17 and 4:13 was very interesting and surprising, almost 'wholesome' for the Crucades. I love the wide range of perspectives this channel provides. It's always a treat when you upload a new video.
@yasiralipalh8306
@yasiralipalh8306 3 года назад
I wonder what language they used to converse with each other?
@bananaboy444
@bananaboy444 3 года назад
What a way to teach the youth how the men fight. All the way down to the taking of prisoners for ransom as opposed to just killing.
@DieNibelungenliad
@DieNibelungenliad 3 года назад
@@bananaboy444 taking prisoners for ransom was very common before the 19th century. This is because usually men will be wounded in battle and lying down, giving the victor the option to either strike a death blow or take captive for ransom. Ransom was an incredibly big source of wealth. The Aztecs, Turks, and Europeans did this; though I havent heard of the Japanese do this
@anon-iraq2655
@anon-iraq2655 3 года назад
Its pretty regular in war and shows up a lot in history Happened during ww1 too
@jaydwy8069
@jaydwy8069 3 года назад
I wonder how that would effect you mentally to share friendly words with someone then to have to switch to killing them. I wonder how many men had nightmares or a lifetime of pain and remorse because of these small acts of humanity during war. I couldn't imagine how that must have felt.
@brokeneyes6615
@brokeneyes6615 3 года назад
You know you’ve been at war too long when you’re on a first name basis with your opponent.
@patriciusvunkempen102
@patriciusvunkempen102 3 года назад
oof , very real, also well first names had a different konotation back then as last names were just coming into use
@pkerch00b1
@pkerch00b1 3 года назад
"Wanna get some kids and bet on who can win in a fight?"
@brokeneyes6615
@brokeneyes6615 3 года назад
@@pkerch00b1 “I’ve got a new move for the Dance floor, I’ll show it to you tonight after the battle.”
@nowhereman6019
@nowhereman6019 3 года назад
*"Hannibal."* *"Scipio."*
@patriciusvunkempen102
@patriciusvunkempen102 3 года назад
@@nowhereman6019 that was antiquity not middleages, and a different culture, you could aswell use an example from china, or the atztecs.
@Brahmdagh
@Brahmdagh 3 года назад
_"... This is getting boring fam, how about we arrange a kid fight?... "_
@donutsrgood4491
@donutsrgood4491 3 года назад
After I heard they would stop fighting to sing and dance with eachother I thought forsure they they would say "we need to make peace". But when I heard they brought kids out to fight wtf lmao, what were our ancestors thinking.
@Filo127
@Filo127 3 года назад
@@donutsrgood4491 They have merely reached such levels of Based our modern subdued minds are incapable of understanding
@MrBottlecapBill
@MrBottlecapBill 3 года назад
Kids weren't babies back then. They were just smaller adults.
@gaslitworldf.melissab2897
@gaslitworldf.melissab2897 3 года назад
@@donutsrgood4491 Things haven't changed much. Kids still live in peril, mostly from relatives and people willing to purchase them for ill purposes.
@jeremyromero2000
@jeremyromero2000 3 года назад
@@donutsrgood4491 hmmm well what else are you going to do? Go back to your farm and catch the Black Death? Professional soldiering (Knights) was just a badass reinterpretation of hunters but for a largely advanced agrarian society. Men divided it up between Food Providers and Cultural Defenders, our current governments function exactly the same. Interior and defense
@j0nnyism
@j0nnyism 2 года назад
“ the English soldiers have a strange habit of stripping almost naked in the noon day sun whilst drinking a foamy liquid which makes them very rowdy and rude chanting eng-ger-lun. These heathen are most barbaric”
@sugarray710
@sugarray710 3 месяца назад
😂
@fkjms73
@fkjms73 3 месяца назад
😂😂😂
@shadowstorm5261
@shadowstorm5261 3 месяца назад
this happens every day now that i think about it
@DefeatedRoyalist
@DefeatedRoyalist 2 месяца назад
The origin of the Football Hooligan
@Osama_Zyn_Laden
@Osama_Zyn_Laden 7 дней назад
😂
@kawadashogo8258
@kawadashogo8258 Год назад
That segment about the soldiers on both sides behaving in a friendly way with each other between bouts of fighting surprised me. Reminds me of the Christmas Truce in WWI. I didn't know there was such an event during the Crusades. It's pretty cool actually.
@عليياسر-ذ5ب
@عليياسر-ذ5ب Год назад
Seljuks: Wait, European heretic
@Liam-iv7wk
@Liam-iv7wk Год назад
The older I get the more I realize: Most times it's not people who like to fight other people, but specific men who want to fight very other specific men.
@NeesyPlaysGuitar
@NeesyPlaysGuitar Год назад
I find it funny how many people have no concept of day to day life in extended war. We don't stop being human.
@LeeB5
@LeeB5 Год назад
Friendly visits happened between Yanks and Johnny Rebs during our Civil War, also.
@ThEnlightnd1
@ThEnlightnd1 Год назад
The xmas truce….was considered treason…imagine…fratternizing with the enemy, because you find common ground…which supposedly is the goal of war…lol and being threatened with treason..in WW1
@stndunnam
@stndunnam 3 года назад
the imagery of a giant man throwing stones at people and then getting glass'd by a bottle of flaming naptha is just insane.
@thegodemperorofmankind7yea704
@thegodemperorofmankind7yea704 3 года назад
With even a conservative estimate of 20 arrows stuck into him. absolutely based.
@acharonim4659
@acharonim4659 3 года назад
That's probably the only way you can defeat the Mountain in GoT, but with jars of wildfire instead.
@bishop6218
@bishop6218 3 года назад
Goodness Gracious Great Balls Of Fire !
@WELLbethere
@WELLbethere 3 года назад
Just goes to show truth is stranger than fiction. How many heroic final stands were not recorded by history?
@bishop6218
@bishop6218 3 года назад
@@WELLbethere well there's that badass berserker at Stamford Bridge. That his name was forgotten is one of the great injustices of History too 😉
@Nantosuelta
@Nantosuelta 11 месяцев назад
"Mornin' Abdul" "mornin' John" "I believe I was in a high guard and you were striking down with your scimitar when we left off?" "sounds about right to me. Alright... and... go!"
@Mikebumpful
@Mikebumpful 2 месяца назад
Fun fact: Saladin's soldiers would have been armed with straight, double edged swords similar to the European arming swords at this point in history! The curved Mongol/Turkic-inspired “scimitars” are a later feature of muslim armies.
@Hagendaz97
@Hagendaz97 3 года назад
Just imagine, In the same time period Genghis khan was born on the other end of the earth whose hordes will be unleashed on the levant
@kingofdetroit358
@kingofdetroit358 3 года назад
If Saladin was alive, Genghis Khan would be nothing
@jonnyenough1531
@jonnyenough1531 3 года назад
@@kingofdetroit358 If not for Muslims, khan would have made it into Europe
@mnbvcxyyxcvbnm7946
@mnbvcxyyxcvbnm7946 3 года назад
@@jonnyenough1531 he did made it europe but clapped in russia poland crotia and coucasus
@hezekhoshea1961
@hezekhoshea1961 3 года назад
@@mnbvcxyyxcvbnm7946 “western Europe”
@eardwulf785
@eardwulf785 3 года назад
@@hezekhoshea1961 The gates of Vienna
@MChiave
@MChiave 3 года назад
“And then the Emir made the biggest mistake of his life; he read the comments!”
@flynnlivescmd
@flynnlivescmd 3 года назад
This is the 4th comment down and im going to learn from this and history and halt now.
@MChiave
@MChiave 3 года назад
@@flynnlivescmd A wise choice.
@jun2011jh
@jun2011jh 2 года назад
🤣🤣🤣
@no1fibersplicer525
@no1fibersplicer525 2 года назад
“Oh the flaming insults hurled by young men in their fathers castles basements. Playing chess. “ But the emir was not to be out done hurling his own flaming retorts. It was only when the emir finally claimed “I knowest thou are but what pray am I?” All discourse silenced!
@noconnection1839
@noconnection1839 2 года назад
@@no1fibersplicer525 10/10 🤣
@grungeguy97
@grungeguy97 3 года назад
Primary sources and videos like this are a big part of why I'm going to school for archives. Keep up the great work!
@jabbrewoki
@jabbrewoki 3 года назад
"I'm tired of religious war, I need a break, lets make the kids play war instead and we'll just watch and play along."
@azzamziply3039
@azzamziply3039 Год назад
Still true to this day, the only difference? Today kids are infants compared to kids 1000yrs ago💀
@shamanschlong
@shamanschlong 3 месяца назад
@@azzamziply3039 always the dumbest mfs saying the dumbest shit
@MohdHilal
@MohdHilal 22 дня назад
Its not a religion war, its a typical emperial war
@WinstonSmith6
@WinstonSmith6 3 года назад
Soldiers can usually relate better to the enemy than they can to civilians back at home. If both sides fight well you grow to respect one another.
@ViktoriousDead
@ViktoriousDead 11 месяцев назад
Yea, no
@DG-iw3yw
@DG-iw3yw 10 месяцев назад
@DukeOfTennessee117 Probably less so in modern warfare...
@crozraven
@crozraven 7 месяцев назад
not really for the indoctrinated soldiers who has superior weaponry, use planes & drones to bombard children 24/7.
@rizkyadiyanto7922
@rizkyadiyanto7922 2 месяца назад
​@@ViktoriousDeadyoure the civilian mentioned in the parent comment.
@ViktoriousDead
@ViktoriousDead 2 месяца назад
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 no, actually I’m not
@meneither3834
@meneither3834 3 года назад
3:15 this is somehow fascinating. Reality is stranger than fiction sometimes.
@sipsofhell9018
@sipsofhell9018 3 года назад
everybody wants to be loved by their enemy, kinda Gay if you ask me
@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404
@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404 3 года назад
@@sipsofhell9018 lol.
@meneither3834
@meneither3834 3 года назад
@@sipsofhell9018 I think "respected" would be more accurate.
@sipsofhell9018
@sipsofhell9018 3 года назад
@@meneither3834 sure lets go with that
@anon-iraq2655
@anon-iraq2655 3 года назад
Its not really all that rare in prolonged wars
@davidbilu1166
@davidbilu1166 3 года назад
Fun Fact: King Richard lived the majority of his life in France and spoke little to no English.
@MRYIMEN
@MRYIMEN 3 года назад
Wasn’t French literally the língua franca of the Angevin empire tho? (His dynasty)
@jonnyenough1531
@jonnyenough1531 3 года назад
They're all inbred and related
@Internut1985
@Internut1985 3 года назад
He was Norman wasn’t he ? And wasn’t French sort of his first language?
@miracleyang3048
@miracleyang3048 3 года назад
@@Internut1985 No he wasn't a Norman He was french
@johnathanharris888
@johnathanharris888 3 года назад
No he wasn’t! Stop perpetuating this falsity. He was directly related to William the conqueror who was a Norman. Normans have been fighting French from their very birth of existence they came from Vikings. They did not speak French they spoke Latin. Romans also spoke Latin does that make them French? Richard also bore the coat of arms of the three lines which is coincidentally the flag of the Normans stop pulling stuff out of your ass
@SiriProject
@SiriProject 3 года назад
I'd love to hear stories from the Baltic Crusades, in the North of Europe. Please, consider it someday!
@Creativethinker12
@Creativethinker12 3 года назад
I’ve got a very short interesting one. As you may or may not know animal sacrifice is completely forbidden in Christianity and is regarded as something strictly pagan, but it seems like the Teutonic Knights picked up some pagan practises from the Baltic natives while living alongside them and there’s a little bit of evidence that they started to sacrifice animals and give ‘offerings’ to the Christian God like the pagans do for their Gods. *When the battle was over, the brothers [Teutonic knights] and their allies all dismounted onto the grass and their hearts were happy. Their rage rightly disappeared when they found they had lost no one, and for this they praised Jesus Christ, Savior of the World, Who was worthy of their honor. They divided the weapons and horses equally, and a share was set aside for God in heaven. The whole land benefited from this expedition.* This practice is mentioned in greater detail in a description of a sacrifice of booty performed after a successful raid in Samogithia *The Christians took all the booty they could carry, and then devastated the land with fire and returned home. When they came back to Riga and when the townspeople heard how things had gone well for them, they all immediately praised God in heaven for having mercifully defended Christendom with this expedition. With the counsel of his brothers, the master gave a part of the booty to our Lord, because he had given them a safe journey. He had earned His share, and they gave Him weapons and horses.* It’s a matter of what they mean by ‘they gave him weapons and horses.’ It sounds like they sacrificed horses to Jesus or something.
@Creativethinker12
@Creativethinker12 3 года назад
@@luxinvictus9018 But they’re not literally offering those sheep as a sacrifice to Jesus, right? Cause that would be wrong. You don’t give offerings or sacrifice to Jesus in Christianity since Jesus is meant to represent the last and ultimate sacrifice (so there’s no need for sacrifice). In fact, the first thing Christians did to undermine paganism in the Roman Empire when they got into power was to ban animal sacrifice. You have to remember that the main reason why Christians were so heavily persecuted in the Roman Empire was because they refused to make any animal sacrifices. You can only pray to God in Christianity or do charity. As for sheep entrails, it’s actually considered a kind of delicacy in many parts of the world. The entrails are usually stuffed with rice and other stuff from what I know.
@antonikudlicki1100
@antonikudlicki1100 3 года назад
The history of Church ban on taking pagan natives' land as a product of a debate between Poland/Lithuania and Templars/HRE
@bensenders4716
@bensenders4716 3 года назад
@@theuniverse5173 no doesn’t it comes out of the Jewish faith which is monotheistic the pagan element comes from Christianity being introduced to pagan Europe by the Romans.
@Creativethinker12
@Creativethinker12 3 года назад
@@bensenders4716 I think the trinity might derive from Hellenic influence, especially Greek philosophy like Plato.
@zaboomafool1911
@zaboomafool1911 3 года назад
It is interesting that Acre would actually outlive not just Saladin but the sultanate he built as well. It was the Mamluks who overthrew the Ayyubids that finally conquered it.
@trying3650
@trying3650 3 года назад
Ayyubids regime authority is only around Baghdad. Fatimid regime the ruler of Egypt, jerusalem not ayyubids.
@zaboomafool1911
@zaboomafool1911 3 года назад
@@trying3650 That's the Abbasids you're thinking of. The Ayyubids, founded by Saladin, overthrew the Fatimid Caliphate and were eventually overthrown by the Mamluks
@samy7013
@samy7013 2 года назад
Indeed! Siege of Akkah (1291 CE): The Mamlukes of Egypt and Syria defeated the Latin Crusaders, taking the last remaining major Latin Crusader stronghold in the Levant, and decisively put an end to the Latin crusading endeavor in the region.
@Saladid
@Saladid Год назад
The ayyubids pretty much collapsed after salahuddin's death, so that's not really than great of a feat.
@zaboomafool1911
@zaboomafool1911 Год назад
@@Saladid that's like saying the mongols pretty much collapsed after Ogedei. They were weaker but not insignificant. Plus when you consider the difficulties supplying a city in the middle east back then when European magnates often had more important interests, it wasn't a cakewalk
@NEEJER
@NEEJER 3 года назад
I'm so happy to have found this channel, the content is outstanding. So engaging, with these first hand accounts that are narrated brilliantly Bravo sir 🙏
@NEEJER
@NEEJER 3 года назад
@Nocoinersbtfo Thankfully our jidadi brothers didn't live on these Isles during the crusades. They would all have been crucified and fed to pigs. Praise be we live in more civilised times now and our Muslim friends join us to drink wine and be merry.
@長谷川恒男
@長谷川恒男 3 года назад
@Nocoinersbtfo You're stuck in 2016.
@長谷川恒男
@長谷川恒男 3 года назад
@Nocoinersbtfo My username is literally "Tsuneo Hasegawa" how is that anywhere close to Zhang?
@youvebeengreeked
@youvebeengreeked 3 года назад
Caesar and Saladin watching themselves become salad memes in the 21st century: *"Am I a joke to you?"*
@zawwin1846
@zawwin1846 3 года назад
Caesar- also a JoJo reference
@youvebeengreeked
@youvebeengreeked 3 года назад
@ملقرت ملك صور Caesar salad is an Italian salad dish. Saladin sounds like we're saying "salad in". ... man, typing right to left Arabic-style is odd for me! XD
@youvebeengreeked
@youvebeengreeked 3 года назад
@ملقرت ملك صور It's just an Anglicised, shortened way of saying it - happens with a lot of historical names, like Caesar being pronounced "See-Zur" instead of "Kai-zar". In the grand scheme of things, it is just a mis-pronunciation and doesn't matter too much. I'm not sure where the Greeks specifically being to blame come into that if I'm honest.
@gaslitworldf.melissab2897
@gaslitworldf.melissab2897 3 года назад
However they learned it, it was the lingua franca just as English today and guess what - lots pf people struggle with the language, but still use it to get by.
@roryteal5940
@roryteal5940 3 года назад
@ملقرت ملك صور 😂
@muslimcrusader3085
@muslimcrusader3085 3 года назад
It's absolutely astonishing the sheer number of Christians angry in the comments that an 11th-century Muslim historian who had literally fought n war against Christians wouldn't portray a perfectly accurate and unbiased account of history. Like.. no shit, buddy? Did you expect a lecture on the complex nuance of middle ages geo-politics?
@PasteurizedLettuce
@PasteurizedLettuce 3 года назад
They’re not random christians, they’re angry white supremacists and nazis. Like, half of them don’t even hide it.
@henrymiller5833
@henrymiller5833 3 года назад
@@PasteurizedLettuce Why does the maker of this video never cover lesser known but more interesting accounts like the Muslim invasion of Egypt by John of Nikiu? EDIT "Secondly, how do you feel about the other video that this channel also made that was explicitly covering the crusades from the point of view of the crusaders?" It was a highly deceptive work that carefully chose quotes while leaving others out. "Also, since you provided a question, I'll provide a possible answer: 1. They just haven't yet." Then they should get to it "2. They only wanted to do these videos to cover the crusades which are a more well known chapter in history so that they can get more clicks." Somewhat true but content on the earlier muslim attacks should garner attention "3." A guys belief about events from over 500 years ago should differ in quality from what happened just yesterday. "4. Since the account of John of Nikon is not eyewitness, it is generally speaking not consistent with the overall theme of this channel including journals and eyewitness accounts from particular eras." They have Herotodus histories on here, your argument is completely invalid. Lets not even get into the point that John was not an eye witness in the same way as many of the accounts here aren't direct eye witness accounts.
@PasteurizedLettuce
@PasteurizedLettuce 3 года назад
​@@henrymiller5833 Interesting question, but I'd need to establish a few things first - what evidence can you provide that it is more interesting?
@PasteurizedLettuce
@PasteurizedLettuce 3 года назад
@@henrymiller5833 Secondly, how do you feel about the other video that this channel also made that was explicitly covering the crusades from the point of view of the crusaders?
@PasteurizedLettuce
@PasteurizedLettuce 3 года назад
@@henrymiller5833 Also, since you provided a question, I'll provide a possible answer: 1. They just haven't yet. 2. They only wanted to do these videos to cover the crusades which are a more well known chapter in history so that they can get more clicks. 3. Assuming they know about this account, and that they explicitly chose not to, perhaps they have some reservation about the content, not limited to the fact that the one you're referring to is acutally infamous for containing some peculiar historical assertions, such as that Julius Caesar's mother received a caesarian section. 4. Since the account of John of Nikon is not eyewitness, it is generally speaking not consistent with the overall theme of this channel including journals and eyewitness accounts from particular eras.
@fedecano7362
@fedecano7362 3 года назад
11:55 damn son, can you imagine to witness that scene? In any case this is the closest that we can get to that experience, and for that you have my like and appreciation!
@thegodemperorofmankind7yea704
@thegodemperorofmankind7yea704 3 года назад
Absolute unit of a bloke
@johntheplumber5958
@johntheplumber5958 3 года назад
Probably an angel
@stealthyshiroean
@stealthyshiroean 3 года назад
It is pretty amazing. However, while there are definitely feats that are beyond belief that happen, we also need to keep in mind that primary sources, even if they are eyewitness, doesn't necessarily mean they are the truth. Not saying that people are purposely lying but things could be exaggerated or misremembered.
@fedecano7362
@fedecano7362 3 года назад
@@stealthyshiroean wise words !
@SuckerFreeGear
@SuckerFreeGear 2 года назад
I believe it was a man with the same genetic disorder or disability that "Andre the Giant" had as it was from French/Frank lineage that it occurred.
@user-hh2is9kg9j
@user-hh2is9kg9j 3 года назад
4:03 if it is not obvious, "making him prisoner" is just a rule in wrestling games back then.
@blackbartlaborro7882
@blackbartlaborro7882 3 года назад
As it is today. We in the west call it being “pinned” or “pinning” these days.
@MrEHD-fj1bz
@MrEHD-fj1bz 3 года назад
And the loser will pay 2 gold to buy his kid back aka if you lose you pay
@zaboomafool1911
@zaboomafool1911 3 года назад
I see Gregor Clegane fought at the siege of Acre too
@ManiacMayhem7256
@ManiacMayhem7256 3 года назад
I wonder if Muslim Martell ever got his revenge
@reeyees50
@reeyees50 3 года назад
That was Sandor,and that how he got his burn scars
@Fiam53
@Fiam53 3 месяца назад
​@@ManiacMayhem7256 he is the one who threw the naptha
@KlingonGamerYT
@KlingonGamerYT 2 года назад
the knight who stood on the wall then got hit 50 times and still didnt go down till he got molotoved ....just amazing bravery
@foolishstrudel2689
@foolishstrudel2689 2 года назад
"'tis but a flesh wound!"
@fredsilvers1427
@fredsilvers1427 9 месяцев назад
A giant
@gravityreaction3334
@gravityreaction3334 7 месяцев назад
The stories on this earth
@JimmyHandtrixx
@JimmyHandtrixx 6 месяцев назад
meanwhile ppl are crying over pronuns...
@salwaaj1356
@salwaaj1356 Год назад
I'm glad that The english translation beautifully managed to hold the poetic nature of the text's original language.
@evershumor1302
@evershumor1302 3 года назад
12:25: dudes had fire specialists.
@pkerch00b1
@pkerch00b1 3 года назад
Pyromancy > Poise
@Tempusverum
@Tempusverum 2 года назад
Pyrotechnics specialist on call for dealing with chads
@emceha
@emceha 2 года назад
7:00 Crusaders getting rekt because they started looting alcohol tent, and gave enemy time to counter, timeless classic.12:10 - a man struck by 50 arrows and stones, finished finally by pyrotechnicals who threw molotovs at him and burned him with nafta. Some impressive armour right there.
@deadlyham5127
@deadlyham5127 Год назад
The crusaders were assholes ngl, they raped every woman they could find after they entered the city and set the city on fire.
@kellydalstok8900
@kellydalstok8900 Год назад
Rekt? Do you mean wrecked?
@emceha
@emceha Год назад
@@kellydalstok8900 y thx
@ferretyluv
@ferretyluv Год назад
@@kellydalstok8900It’s gamerspeak for thoroughly beaten.
@烏梨師斂
@烏梨師斂 3 года назад
I don't doubt the brutality of the crusaders considering what they did to Constantinople
@nowhereman6019
@nowhereman6019 3 года назад
They could only do that to Constantinople because of what the crusaders did to it first.
@republicradio431
@republicradio431 3 года назад
What did they do to constantinople?
@烏梨師斂
@烏梨師斂 3 года назад
@@republicradio431 they were supposed to help them, but instead the crusaders sacked the city, raped civilians, desecrated churches, tombs, and did countless unspeakable unspeakable acts. The Byzantine (Roman) Empire fell to the Muslims because of what the crusaders did.
@nowhereman6019
@nowhereman6019 3 года назад
@@BlackpilledNihilist you can apply that logic all the way back to the beginning of humanity, blaming one person or group for instigating another until you come to one caveman hitting another over the heat for his meat. It doesn't justify anything, certainly not blaming an entire group of people for something their ancestors did.
@republicradio431
@republicradio431 3 года назад
@@烏梨師斂 who was raped and what unspeakable things?
@doobiestudios1107
@doobiestudios1107 2 года назад
This channel is criminally underrated.
@bishop6218
@bishop6218 3 года назад
And that Pyrotechnist just showed y'all miscreants why a well-placed Fireball is ALWAYS a viable option...
@pyrojunkyz510
@pyrojunkyz510 18 дней назад
I was probably a pyro in a past life too 😂
@Newjerseyblows
@Newjerseyblows 3 года назад
I was hoping you would do an episode on Baha Ad-hin. This made my night ✌
@jordansagar3836
@jordansagar3836 3 года назад
Dude, I have seen so many of these Muslim accounts. All by some guy who's name starts with "Ibdn-" and they are all so BEAUTIFULLY written. They are so wise it pains me to see what the middle-east has become now.
@Allvirt
@Allvirt 3 года назад
Terrible, what decades of foreign invasion does to a people. Most of them were doing so good in the mid 20th century :(
@yaz2928
@yaz2928 3 года назад
All thanks to American-backed Saudi wahhabism. Both ISIS and Al Qaeda have the same ideology as the Saud family which is a critical US ally. America is the worst thing to happen to the Middle East since the Mongol invasions.
@profile1172
@profile1172 3 года назад
@@yaz2928 Ignores the fact Israel is their ally as well
@ish8891
@ish8891 3 года назад
@@bonnie7898 those were the spawn of western institutions that they left behind
@noddlefoodle5691
@noddlefoodle5691 2 года назад
@@bonnie7898 it doesn't take a genius to realize that the reason the middle East now is such a shit hole is because of constant American invasion and interference. Not only have they sent shit like the C.I.A to fuck up governments but they also back terrorists to destroy shit.
@catcrapinahat
@catcrapinahat 3 года назад
Absolutely riveting, on the edge of my seat every other sentence. Now this is what I call podracing.
@mike7652
@mike7652 3 года назад
The podracing reference was really stretched there, almost like you had to *Force* it...
@greggeverman5578
@greggeverman5578 2 года назад
@@mike7652 Good one.
@dmacrolens
@dmacrolens 2 года назад
You have all unlocked ultimate cringe. Pat yourselves on the back accordingly!
@kriegsmaschine4050
@kriegsmaschine4050 2 года назад
King Richard arriving to Acre is a certified "The Slayer has entered the facility" moment
@Alex-tx2em
@Alex-tx2em Год назад
I just wished he shared the same lifetime as Baibars so we could find out who the real slayer is.
@RadicalCaveman
@RadicalCaveman 3 месяца назад
Heart of lion, heart of stone
@_semih_
@_semih_ 3 месяца назад
​@@RadicalCaveman The civilians and innocents: 💀
@starfox300
@starfox300 2 месяца назад
They were lucky that Barbarossa didn't also arrive.
@jeczaja5347
@jeczaja5347 3 месяца назад
To be fair, lots of victims of the Ottoman empire (Muslim) could also provide brutalities perpetrated by them.
@hassanjamalmoussawi7001
@hassanjamalmoussawi7001 3 месяца назад
from when Turk are muslim they were not Muslim ,they killed their own brother enslaved people and even killed other muslim
@haraldisdead
@haraldisdead 3 года назад
Imagine being Saladin. You have to fight the professional warrior class of an entire continent.
@RandomNorwegianGuy.
@RandomNorwegianGuy. 3 года назад
Not the entire continent. Not by far. Mostly Franks, Germans and English men. Imagine being a Frank, German or English man travling so far on boat to a whole different world, fighting soldiers from the entire Muslim world (which is much much much larger then the tiny continent of Europe as a whole).
@haraldisdead
@haraldisdead 3 года назад
@@RandomNorwegianGuy. you're making shit up
@ranro7371
@ranro7371 3 года назад
Not to mention the wealth of a continent. France bankrupted itself.
@BESTYEAROFMYLIFE
@BESTYEAROFMYLIFE 3 года назад
@@haraldisdead You’re the one making shit up dude
@terro3842
@terro3842 3 года назад
@@RandomNorwegianGuy. they were not fighting entirety of a Muslim world, I hope you realize...
@muneebahmad7887
@muneebahmad7887 3 года назад
Great video. Insta-subscribed!
@youtubeexpert2441
@youtubeexpert2441 3 года назад
Please make an episode about Usama ibn Munqidh and his account on the crusades in his book: "Kitab al-I'tibar: ("Book of Learning by Example")
@snickle1980
@snickle1980 3 года назад
@@HAYAOLEONE Why not?
@Sedgewise47
@Sedgewise47 3 года назад
🤔Wow. What a title…
@samy7013
@samy7013 2 года назад
I have an English translation of Usama bin Munqidh’s book, and it is a rollicking good read! Perfect materiel for this channel.
@imrankh68
@imrankh68 2 года назад
@@samy7013 Nice
@abdel-qudus1143
@abdel-qudus1143 10 месяцев назад
What really intresting with arabic books of middle age is that European are describe as polytheist and barbarian that sack the noble christian of the Roman Empire (so a clear differentiation between pre-barbaric invasion european and the frank-wisigoth….)
@rai2423
@rai2423 3 месяца назад
The Islamic world’s respect for anything roman is always so interesting to me 😂
@ks-qu4kj
@ks-qu4kj 2 месяца назад
well Europe was a seen as a barbaric society compared to the lands of the East.. the European armies didnt honour treaties, massacred prisoners abused cvilians etc etc The Romans were respected as an ancient civilisation and rich culture
@saidtoshimaru1832
@saidtoshimaru1832 3 года назад
"God had chosen them for martyrdom" PRISIONER: Wait, ¿whaaaat?
@oghuzdynasty777
@oghuzdynasty777 3 года назад
Martyrdom in Islam is actually good as it guarantees reward of the highest level of paradise.
@KristinkaAranova
@KristinkaAranova 3 года назад
@@oghuzdynasty777 yea the many many suicide bombers have shown us that 😐
@ajuuran2890
@ajuuran2890 3 года назад
@@KristinkaAranova martyrm is for one who fought in a religiouse war. Suicide is a sin in islam and therefore you will go ro hell if you do it.
@RoboBoddicker
@RoboBoddicker 3 года назад
*Small Brain:* You're getting executed *Big Brain:* You're being relieved of your earthly duties. *Galaxy Brain:* God has chosen you....for martyrdom.
@TsarOfRuss
@TsarOfRuss 2 года назад
Never!!! Muslim Martyrs do it with pride, for Islam
@Preppy_Delicious
@Preppy_Delicious 3 года назад
The Lion arrives
@mikegreen5502
@mikegreen5502 3 года назад
The Lion Arrives at 3:32
@stormysmurf
@stormysmurf 3 года назад
Really worried about the pagan Vikings arriving ;) ;) ;)
@Preppy_Delicious
@Preppy_Delicious 3 года назад
@@stormysmurf they already did. And then converted.
@coimbralaw
@coimbralaw 3 года назад
What does that mean?
@gerdmiller7996
@gerdmiller7996 3 года назад
@@stormysmurf pagans was Arabs and still they are
@MrPoupard
@MrPoupard 3 года назад
Funny how God was on everyone's side.
@WiseOwl_1408
@WiseOwl_1408 3 года назад
Ya hilarious even.
@kadensmike8190
@kadensmike8190 3 года назад
Two-faced so and so?
@Jim-Mc
@Jim-Mc 3 года назад
Trick question: they're different gods.
@sabreTXC3
@sabreTXC3 3 года назад
@@Jim-Mc technically no. Same God, different "prophets". Like Mohammed for islam or the Son of God himself Jesus Christ for Christianity. People back then didnt argue if there was a God or not, they argued about which religion wrote it down correctly. Obviously I'm no expert so take it with a grain of salt, that's just what I've loosely learned over time, could be wrong
@S3aCa1mRa1n
@S3aCa1mRa1n 3 года назад
@@sabreTXC3 yeah exactly
@troyrussell177
@troyrussell177 3 года назад
I just found this channel, and its exactly what my consumption of historical content needed. I love throwing on something educational, while I carve or do what not, and this is Perfect for that👏 .
@fukpoeslaw3613
@fukpoeslaw3613 3 года назад
it's great ey?
@youtubecansukkadik
@youtubecansukkadik 3 года назад
11:51 is my favourite part. Big dude with 50 arrows sticking out of him, single-handedly holding off the Saracens 'til he's incinerated. Bad arse.
@TheCraziestFox
@TheCraziestFox 3 года назад
Saracens had fairly weak bows. A knight in maile and with a good gambeson would literally have arrows sticking out of him, but none would have penetrated, often giving impression of an unbeatable beast. (which don't get me wrong, they absolutely were, just not for this reason)
@ranro7371
@ranro7371 3 года назад
Arrows were probably sticking to the armor I’m guessing
@asmrnaturecat984
@asmrnaturecat984 Год назад
These are arabs, whom just starts fighting again as militia after saladin upsurped his turkic master The real proper army of muslim are turkic, they have proper bows and armour
@pyrrhus3445
@pyrrhus3445 3 месяца назад
​​@@asmrnaturecat984the arab civilization and technology was a thing way before the coming of the Turks nomads from the steps beginning from the Umayyads to the Abbasids who used the Turks as slaves and officers your comment isn't accurate at all and it's obviously racially motivated from a turk I guess
@robertbertagna1672
@robertbertagna1672 Год назад
always good to hear from all sides of the subject good presentation.
@lordenkidu1876
@lordenkidu1876 2 года назад
I just finished reading the biography of William Marshal by Thomas Asbridge it covers his short journey in the holyland before the fall of the leper king Baldwin, one of the kings kin butchered the Beduins who were under protection and also provided service helping lead to the decline. When Richard came it was the horrible siege of Acre, later Saladin took everything back.
@maxzak5310
@maxzak5310 3 года назад
3:55 have you noticed these "side quests" always ends up in the victory of author side
@user-hh2is9kg9j
@user-hh2is9kg9j 3 года назад
Yes, a historian would interpret this as follows: there probably were kid wrestling games happening rarely and the author chose to talk about one of these matches where the kid from his side own. This kind of biases is the norm, especially in older texts, but they still invaluable to our understanding of history.
@Creativethinker12
@Creativethinker12 3 года назад
He also doesn’t talk about how Saladin was defeated in every battle against Richard.
@user-hh2is9kg9j
@user-hh2is9kg9j 3 года назад
@@Creativethinker12 The irony of criticizing someone 1000 years ago for being biased while being biased as hell in 2021, something for historians 1000 years from now to study.
@jerres9585
@jerres9585 3 года назад
@@Creativethinker12well he had been fighting constantly for years by then, and had got back Jerusalem, much of its kingdom, and started the reversal that eventually saw the crusaders lose every part of the levant that they had invaded and become disillusioned with the whole idea at the end.. the big picture that we can see after all these centuries, looking back? The crusades, considering death count , resources , effort & time , was a huge failure in every way possible, I mean it literally was all for nothing, just a sh*tload of people dying. much like many of the western "interventions" and "invasions" we see today
@Vicus_of_Utrecht
@Vicus_of_Utrecht 3 года назад
@@jerres9585 Hmmm, and yet the Jews have Jerusalem today.
@Brahmdagh
@Brahmdagh 3 года назад
Dude... The comment section of this channel sounds, different, than last time I checked it.
@SiriProject
@SiriProject 3 года назад
There only needs to be one of these guys sharing "crusade content" on one of their Discords or anonymous Imageboards for the herd to come here in full force.
@alb6161
@alb6161 2 года назад
Oh yeah the muslims were so nice with the jews and christians,especially in spain for 800 years
@crazy1azy
@crazy1azy 2 года назад
Yes indeed, so amazing how jews and Christians existed in Andalus until the reconquista happened. Hmm... I wonder what happened to muslims and jews when christians took control there..?
@alb6161
@alb6161 2 года назад
@@crazy1azy it was a catholic country to begin with and the muslims conquered it,once control was taken over by the rightful people they chose to do whatever they wanted in their own homeland
@johoreanperson8396
@johoreanperson8396 2 года назад
Fortunately yes. Jews and its theology and culture thrive under the Ummayads. Heck, there are some famous jewish scholars like Musa from that era.
@tohamahawk4570
@tohamahawk4570 Год назад
@@alb6161 Iberia didn’t begin as cathokics
@alb6161
@alb6161 Год назад
@@tohamahawk4570 no shit ! , it was when the turdlums invaded,and so what is your point ?
@HotZetiGer
@HotZetiGer 3 года назад
8:18 Frankish female fighters 11:55 Giant Frank
@Greg-yu4ij
@Greg-yu4ij 3 года назад
What about the slaughter of 4000 captives? It is never a good idea to break a promise much less murder in cold blood.
@HotZetiGer
@HotZetiGer 3 года назад
@@Greg-yu4ij Meh like in The Battle of Agincourt - killing useless captives must be an English habit.
@SegaDream131
@SegaDream131 3 года назад
Sounds like a title for a xxx film ....
@aub3365
@aub3365 3 месяца назад
​@@SegaDream131☠️
@andoapata2216
@andoapata2216 3 года назад
10:48 BOSS MUSIC
@Saladid
@Saladid Год назад
Comprehensive breakdown of the title "Saladin": Sˤalaħud-deen (the consecutive pronunciation of sˤalaħ aldeen) sˤalaħ meaning 'righteousness', 'al' meaning 'the', and 'deen' meaning religion/path, and so when they come together they are pronounced sˤalaħud-deen, and the closest anglosized version would be: Salahuddeen *Note: this is of course in Arabic, even though Salahuddeen was Kurdish.
@gadthefunny
@gadthefunny Год назад
It's a nickname, not his actual name.
@Saladid
@Saladid Год назад
@@gadthefunny yes I probably should've made that clearer
@lastword8783
@lastword8783 Год назад
​​​@@gadthefunnyhis actual name was Salah al-Din Yusuf ibn Ayyub. I wouldnt say nickname was Salah al-din but more like an honorary title name that many rulers took up at that time.
@gadthefunny
@gadthefunny Год назад
@@lastword8783 Yes, title is more correct. Though, it's not exclusive to rulers.
@jlvfr
@jlvfr 3 года назад
Why does the writer call the christians "polytheists", at 0:34? Is it perhaps a reference to all the saints christians have?
@ronans9680
@ronans9680 3 года назад
I think it is because the trinitarians worship the trinity as equals. I could be wrong.
@MrAaaaazzzzz00009999
@MrAaaaazzzzz00009999 3 года назад
its rightly so. christians view Jesus as a God and God as a God but seperate. It is confusing because of polytheist melding. Islam is a true monotheist religion.
@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404
@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404 3 года назад
@@ronans9680 nah that's it
@bryanmcclure2220
@bryanmcclure2220 3 года назад
It references the trinity. Islam rejects the idea of the treaty and claim that Christian must be polytheist.
@Maperator
@Maperator 3 года назад
Ignorant of christianity
@SARHistories
@SARHistories 2 года назад
Great to hear the other side of the Crusades. It gives you a very different take on it.
@Karebear9001
@Karebear9001 3 года назад
I'm a bit hard of hearing, is there a way we can get subtitles for these? Any which way, thanks for all your work!
@watson494
@watson494 3 года назад
Hi Karen, I would help subtitle as much videos I could work on, but I believe that the owner of the content must allow people to help with it.
@Karebear9001
@Karebear9001 3 года назад
@Andreas Ivanovich There were no auto-generated CC's when I watched. Also, the auto-generated subtitles aren't usually very good for these sorts of subjects/vocabulary.
@ferretyluv
@ferretyluv Год назад
There are subtitles if you click CC.
@jbweld6193
@jbweld6193 3 года назад
11:52, Muslims must have finally ran into "The Mountain".
@faithfullukodureg2140
@faithfullukodureg2140 3 года назад
The franks have brought a war machine of terrible... implication.
@jbweld6193
@jbweld6193 3 года назад
@@mrfact03s when your enemy has a 100:1 numerical superiority and you're fighting off home turf its not likely they would win.
@Alex-tx2em
@Alex-tx2em Год назад
@@jbweld6193 Wonderful safety net to cope with defeat. Crusaders fucked around and found out.
@jbweld6193
@jbweld6193 Год назад
@Alex-tx2em 1000yrs later.. the middle east still lives in the middle ages. Who really won..
@OkyanusKarSen
@OkyanusKarSen 3 года назад
Wow, this comment section is depressing.
@MrSafior
@MrSafior 3 года назад
Always happen when islam or africa is the subject.
@TheHouseSpeciaI
@TheHouseSpeciaI 3 года назад
Not surprising given the current state of affairs and politics. Wannabe revisionists as far as the eye can see.
@doobiestudios1107
@doobiestudios1107 2 года назад
I’m so thankful to you for making this amazing content. I’m not even that much of a history fanatic but this is just too good to dismiss. Just beautiful. Bravo, sir. Bra-f*ckin-vo! 👏👏👏👏
@GregTom2
@GregTom2 3 года назад
10:50 The franks were rejoicing that the English king had arrived. You know you've got to be a pretty good Lord when you get a 100% approval rating from the french lads.
@khaleddekar2188
@khaleddekar2188 3 года назад
You know king Richard is French, he just king of England, not English man, he didn't speak English, he speak old French,
@Gliese380
@Gliese380 3 года назад
They were all basically Franks, i.e West Germanics. The Franks of that time included many more cultures than the French of today.
@MrSomebodyyyy98
@MrSomebodyyyy98 3 года назад
@@Gliese380 "Franks" were pretty much just a generic term for all western Europeans
@lesdodoclips3915
@lesdodoclips3915 3 года назад
@@khaleddekar2188 he was born in England therefore he’s English. By your logic Napoleon isn’t french.
@y200sub
@y200sub 3 года назад
@@MrSomebodyyyy98 Correct, up till this day the word for a westerner in arabic at least levantine dialect is franji (frankish), on the other hand Franks made a large percentage of the crusaders army so..
@aribahmed3893
@aribahmed3893 2 месяца назад
Grab some popcorn and read the newest comments lol.
@frankiephenomanal
@frankiephenomanal 3 года назад
Bro let's get an account of Ibn Battuta's travels
@george94065
@george94065 9 месяцев назад
Praise be to Allah rhe greatest of deceivers
@remz7619
@remz7619 7 месяцев назад
God almighty the best (planner)☝️ you stink of cope little georgie the infidel so cry more 🤣🤣
@aymanparvezsherani5988
@aymanparvezsherani5988 6 месяцев назад
'allah' means god in arabic it doesn't matter if you are a Christian or jew the meaning is the same
@mikemiller1646
@mikemiller1646 3 года назад
I think you mean jihad, not "counter crusade".
@samy7013
@samy7013 2 года назад
In this context, the terms were synonymous. The jihad _was_ a counter-crusade, and met with success, all praise being to Allah the Exalted.
@barryirlandi4217
@barryirlandi4217 2 года назад
Smae difference
@mikemiller1646
@mikemiller1646 2 года назад
@@samy7013 the presence of Israel and the easy with which western military defeat MiddleEastern country would suggest you rethink this
@tidlywank
@tidlywank 2 года назад
@@samy7013 I think the issue is that it makes the muslims look (relatively) innocent, as though they were minding their own business before being forced to defend themselves when in reality there were centuries of muslim invasions all over southern europe, with even northward countries being subject to raids and slavers. Eventually, when the church and the peasantry shared a common enemy, you got the crusades. Over time there would be a lot of bloodshed from both sides but lets not forget for a second who started it.
@TruthSeeker8834
@TruthSeeker8834 Год назад
​@@tidlywankIf that's the case then u should look before way past of birth of Islamic states. How did the european paganism end, how did during Muslim siege of Jerusalem there were no jews in the holy city, who did burn down the scholars and the library of alexandria in the name of religion....all these has one answer christianity. U guys were started it 2000 years ago.
@adamgroton3620
@adamgroton3620 Год назад
Incredible. Simply miraculous that this account survived the ages.
@AS-vq3wt
@AS-vq3wt 3 года назад
More proud to be Muslim after watching this. I will now refer to Christians as polytheists in honor of this long lost martyr. La ilaha ilallah
@AS-vq3wt
@AS-vq3wt 3 года назад
@@bonnie7898 no thanks. I can't prove that God exists but you can't prove he doesn't. You atheist folks accuse us of believing in fairy tales but you only believe what you believe cuz some professor said it. I'd rather be proud of my Islamic faith and know that I'm better than you than be equal to you. I don't see any virtue in being equal. The point of all humans throughout history has been to separate themselves from the pack. That's what being a Muslim does for me. It separates me from you. I like that :)
@---oj1zj
@---oj1zj 3 года назад
I remember when you had less than 50k subs :,) They grow up so fast
@anshuldwivedi1919
@anshuldwivedi1919 Год назад
While one sect reformed over time, the other continues to be just as barbaric as it used to be 1400 years ago
@Paddy.C
@Paddy.C 3 года назад
1:56 Imagine being the only warrior there to have his shield emblazoned with the terrifying image of... A... HAMSTER 🐹!!!
@E1N101
@E1N101 3 года назад
So adorable
@Canisestlupus
@Canisestlupus 3 года назад
ahaha, but what is it really, a lion?
@degroot9914
@degroot9914 2 года назад
Never seen monty python did you, never trust a small animal
@mariakelly1059
@mariakelly1059 2 года назад
During the Crusades, even the hamsters were badass!
@DieNibelungenliad
@DieNibelungenliad 3 года назад
11:51 Dark Souls moment
@antonikudlicki1100
@antonikudlicki1100 3 года назад
lol
@deviousN
@deviousN 3 года назад
Still lost to Pyro build lmao
@savvynumbskull15
@savvynumbskull15 3 года назад
@@deviousN dude got chaos bed vestige to the face 💥
@yaz2928
@yaz2928 3 года назад
More bad ass than Dark Souls.
@volancydogs
@volancydogs 7 месяцев назад
berk reference
@ntluck1592
@ntluck1592 3 года назад
You can tell that the writer is Arab (Kurdish) because of how much poetry he sews in his words. Brilliant video and an excellent perspective to one of the most important figures in history
@TheSharingarMaster
@TheSharingarMaster 3 года назад
What do you mean Arab(Kurdish)? Kurds are not Arabs.
@miracleyang3048
@miracleyang3048 3 года назад
@@TheSharingarMaster he mean his writing is arabic
@TheSharingarMaster
@TheSharingarMaster 3 года назад
@@miracleyang3048 Yes but the way he wrote it if someone doesn't know will think there is no difference.
@hxyzazolchak
@hxyzazolchak 3 года назад
I don't know about Kurdish but definitely Arabic
@miracleyang3048
@miracleyang3048 3 года назад
@@TheSharingarMaster Well mentioning his Kurdish origins is wrong if you ask me and totally irrelevant. His work is Arabic he never wrote a single word in any language except arabic Not to mention that his Kurdish origin is doubted as best he himself was known as an Assadi (from the Arab tribe Banu Assad)
@mathieuleader8601
@mathieuleader8601 3 года назад
imagine if this was the plot for the prequel to Disney's Robin Hood
@TheHouseSpeciaI
@TheHouseSpeciaI 3 года назад
The more RU-vid comments I read, the more I realize how little humanity has changed. Some of the ethno/religious zealots in here would fit right into the medieval time periods described in these videos. Edit: And as if on cue, here they are. The salt is delicious.
@osamabindiesel3389
@osamabindiesel3389 3 года назад
Lol they definitely wouldn’t, these clowns think themselves as modern day crusaders, “reclaiming” the west. IRL they’re terminally online neckbeards, conquering the chicken nuggies and choccy milk in the fridge, spewing their bile in the YT comment section. This is what no female attention does to a guy
@cleantree439
@cleantree439 3 года назад
@@osamabindiesel3389 projection: the post
@PicklePickle7
@PicklePickle7 3 года назад
no need to look down on people who lived in the middle ages like that. you're not inherently superior just because you were born in the era of the middle class and the republics. humanity seems to have changed a little because we are still human. and people that lived 1000 years ago were human just like us. your human dna isn't different from theirs because you live today. so don't act inherently superior for no valid reason and just try to understand the reality of the world back then.
@cleantree439
@cleantree439 3 года назад
You say that as if it's bad to be devoutly religious or caring about your race Remember, the great musicians like Beethoven Mozart etc, scientists like newton Planck , philosophers, inventors were deeply religious meaning they would die for their faith than to be half hearted. Atheism is intellectual laziness for the prideful egotist.
@nicholasgalluzzo6307
@nicholasgalluzzo6307 3 года назад
Unless you have quotes you have no idea if any of those men would of died for their faith. Stop being ridiculous
@GarlicOasis
@GarlicOasis 3 года назад
The level of butthurt in the comments/dislikes... I know a lot of you are invested in the whole notion of the crusaders being the "good guys", but this channel is about first-hand accounts from contemporary people. OBVIOUSLY the Muslim historian is going to be biased, just like every person quoted in those videos.
@Eumanel12
@Eumanel12 2 года назад
I'd like to say there's no "bias". Why should there be? Becaue he's Muslim? He's writing what he experienced.
@novazemlja2921
@novazemlja2921 10 месяцев назад
So when those Mūslims were pillaging, killing, rāping, kidnapping for centuries it was all good, but once violence is answered back they are terrified by the brutality. Just like Vlad learned from his Mūslim captors and paid them hommage, crusaders just did the same.
@waylingtons
@waylingtons 3 года назад
I love these videos. Fascinating stuff.
@j.b.4340
@j.b.4340 10 месяцев назад
It must be remembered, that the crusades were a defensive action, against Islamic aggression.
@thenoblepoptart
@thenoblepoptart 10 месяцев назад
The crusades weren’t any one thing. For the people fighting it was an opportunity for absolution. For the pope it was an opportunity to get warfare out of Christendom and focused elsewhere. For alexios komnenos it was a chance to regain anatolia from the seljuk dynasty.
@uriustosh
@uriustosh 3 года назад
Context is king, history is full of suffering and misery of the poor for the games and play of the states and overlords.
@syed1431
@syed1431 3 года назад
The plebians still think wars were fought over religion. Religion was always an excuse and a veil to hide the true ambitions of kings.
@Konoronn
@Konoronn 3 года назад
People don't know this?
@Ζήνων-ζ1ι
@Ζήνων-ζ1ι 3 года назад
Nha, these statesman and overlords were fighting and dying as well. It was something else entirely.
@XVRMEDIA
@XVRMEDIA 2 года назад
When you are threatened with extinction, you have to fight.
@Lion718
@Lion718 3 месяца назад
That part of the world has never seen so much chaos and carnage until it became dominated by worst religions ever conceived. Ty Jesus and Mohammed..
@KristinkaAranova
@KristinkaAranova Месяц назад
Only Islam. Under Christianity it was peaceful
@mitchellulrich930
@mitchellulrich930 3 года назад
Any chance you'll do a video about Peter Hagendorf? He was a German Mercenary who fought in the Thirty Years War and wrote a book of his experience.
@metalfuk69
@metalfuk69 3 года назад
Yes!!!
@kingwilliams8393
@kingwilliams8393 3 года назад
Hello how are you doing today I hope you’re having a wonderful day
@currypablo
@currypablo 3 года назад
Just love how people get along here and don't spew garbage at each other behind a keyboard. As always another fine video.
@IbnBahtuta
@IbnBahtuta 3 года назад
His name was Salahuddin Ayyubi.
@RJStockton
@RJStockton 3 года назад
Umayyad, bro?
@ThePhoenix109
@ThePhoenix109 3 года назад
@@RJStockton no
@Vingul
@Vingul 3 года назад
@@RJStockton lol
@jasondsimpson
@jasondsimpson 3 года назад
That is incorrect. His name was Yusuf ibn Ayyub. He was granted the title of Salahuddin which essentially means the light of faith or the righteousness of faith.
@muslimcrusader5987
@muslimcrusader5987 3 года назад
Ah yes my two favourite religious groups Muslims and Franks ☺️😊😊❤️
@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404
@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404 3 года назад
Franks are a religious group ?
@عليياسر-ذ5ب
@عليياسر-ذ5ب Год назад
​@@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404 Pagan European Berbers 😊
@damonarndell2902
@damonarndell2902 11 месяцев назад
Richard Coer de Lyon 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 king of England. An English king, despite what others might say. "But he didnt speak English." Who did? It was the 12th century. He spent most his life outside England, but he did spend most his life within English territory, which needed defending from the French king. His ancestors included Alfred the Great as well as William the Conqueror.
@redemissarium
@redemissarium 11 месяцев назад
He grow up and weird family though, his father jailed his mom and he and his bros keep usurping his father 😅 Im curious what the church says about all this stuff...
@dylanmilne6683
@dylanmilne6683 3 года назад
11:55 Bannerlord moment
@DAwdar
@DAwdar 3 года назад
Wonderful! How can i find this as a podcast?
@SéaFid
@SéaFid Год назад
Ah so not one criticism of Islam again, only criticism of Christianity. One acronym: ISIL
@marvwatkins7029
@marvwatkins7029 Год назад
The Cause was and remains noble and good.
@HistoryOfRevolutions
@HistoryOfRevolutions 3 года назад
"No kingdom has shed more blood than the kingdom of Christ" - Montesquieu
@arsenii_yavorskyi
@arsenii_yavorskyi 3 года назад
that is blatantly false.
@DieNibelungenliad
@DieNibelungenliad 3 года назад
"Montesquieu is wrong" - me
@Creativethinker12
@Creativethinker12 3 года назад
That’s an oversimplification. Montesquieu actually thought very highly of Christianity and was among one of most pro-Christian enlightenment writers. In his 1751 book (The Spirit of Laws) he even wrote a defence of Christianity against its critics: “The Christian religion, which ordains that men should love each other, would, without doubt, have every nation blest with the best civil, the best political laws; because these, next to this religion, are the greatest good that men can give and receive. The Christian religion is a stranger to mere despotic power. The mildness so frequently recommended in the Gospel is incompatible with the despotic rage with which a prince punishes his subjects, and exercises himself in cruelty. As this religion forbids the plurality of wives, its princes are less confined, less concealed from their subjects, and consequently have more humanity: they are more disposed to be directed by laws, and more capable of perceiving that they cannot do whatever they please. While the Mahometan princes incessantly give or receive death, the religion of the Christians renders their princes less timid, and consequently less cruel. The prince confides in his subjects, and the subjects in the prince. How admirable the religion which, while it only seems to have in view the felicity of the other life, continues the happiness of this! Let us set before our eyes, on the one hand, the continual massacres of the kings and generals of the Greeks and Romans, and, on the other, the destruction of people and cities by those famous conquerors Timur Beg and Jenghiz Khan, who ravaged Asia, and we shall see that we owe to Christianity, in government, a certain political law; and in war, a certain law of nations - benefits which human nature can never sufficiently acknowledge. It is owing to this law of nations that among us victory leaves these great advantages to the conquered, life, liberty, laws, wealth, and always religion, when the conqueror is not blind to his own interest. We may truly say that the people of Europe are not at present more disunited than the people and the armies, or even the armies among themselves were, under the Roman empire when it had become a despotic and military government. On the one hand, the armies engaged in war against each other, and, on the other, they pillaged the cities, and divided or confiscated the lands. From the characters of the Christian and Mahometan religions, we ought, without any further examination, to embrace the one and reject the other: for it is much easier to prove that religion ought to humanise the manners of men than that any particular religion is true. It is a misfortune to human nature when religion is given by a conqueror. The Mahometan religion, which speaks only by the sword, acts still upon men with that destructive spirit with which it was founded.”
@MAX-tw3qz
@MAX-tw3qz 3 года назад
"Hold my non alcoholic beer" Muhammad.
@saltygrandpajoe6375
@saltygrandpajoe6375 2 года назад
The stupid ... it burns 😆
@williamromine5715
@williamromine5715 3 года назад
I know this is a pretty small complaint, but that was a donkey, not a mule.
@revivalist355
@revivalist355 3 года назад
That's a small complaint
@williamromine5715
@williamromine5715 3 года назад
@@revivalist355 Very small, but with the quality of this channel, quite surprising.
@CuttySobz
@CuttySobz 3 года назад
Lol forcing the kids into a giant fight hilarious. Being ransomed for 2 gold coins xD both dads laughing and one kid crying lolol
@Caesar88888
@Caesar88888 3 года назад
2 gold coins were probably like 20 000 $ now, so prisoners dad wasnt laughing I think
@philippa5004
@philippa5004 3 года назад
🙏for posting
@MikhaelEsterez
@MikhaelEsterez 3 года назад
Superb as usual ! Thanks
@kingwilliams8393
@kingwilliams8393 3 года назад
Hello how are you doing today I hope you’re having a wonderful day
@ZacharyClause
@ZacharyClause 2 года назад
Your welcome
@simoncarrier9910
@simoncarrier9910 3 года назад
Let us stop bashing ourselves. Westerners need to regain a will of strength and all will be well.
@simoncarrier9910
@simoncarrier9910 3 года назад
@Killin Sparker very true, but some of us need to survive intact.
@christophersnedeker2065
@christophersnedeker2065 2 года назад
We should tell the truth.
@randykirkland3927
@randykirkland3927 3 года назад
As a gay man, it’s a bit hard to swallow the “ Muslim describes brutality “ line.
@cestkaiser
@cestkaiser 3 года назад
The Crusades videos are the best!
@EnergeiaRhythmos
@EnergeiaRhythmos 3 месяца назад
I'm officially addicted to your channel thanks 😊 ☪️
@UCvow2TUIH0d2Ax2vik9ILzg
@UCvow2TUIH0d2Ax2vik9ILzg 3 года назад
Oh no, people engaging waging a defensive war and protecting their homeland were brutal! Man, why does Islam always play the victim? Every time.
@MrHumanforlife
@MrHumanforlife 3 года назад
Moronic argument.
@PasteurizedLettuce
@PasteurizedLettuce 3 года назад
Their homeland, lmao what? In what sense could Jerusalem be called the homeland of the Franks
@DomRivers67
@DomRivers67 3 года назад
Err, it is the Middle East, the Islamic homeland Frank's by the way was a catch all name for westerners
@Dannnyyy129
@Dannnyyy129 11 дней назад
​​​@@DomRivers67middle East was mostly christians ,Jews and pagan before Islam forcefully converted them.. it's not Islamic homeland, It's stolen a land
@evershumor1302
@evershumor1302 3 года назад
3:24: how did they talk? In what language?
@user-hh2is9kg9j
@user-hh2is9kg9j 3 года назад
I think it was Arabic maybe Greek, read it somewhere in Usama ibn-Munqidh accounts (contemporary), it is interesting been just very recently translated to English.
@stegotyranno4206
@stegotyranno4206 3 месяца назад
​@user-hh2is9kg9j could you tell me where i can find the exact copy/section
@rai2423
@rai2423 3 месяца назад
Probably in Arabic.
@jaipreetsingh6566
@jaipreetsingh6566 3 года назад
Do one on sikh history
@harmanjotsingh7429
@harmanjotsingh7429 3 года назад
Bilkul syee...I totally agree on sikh misls ...banda bahadur ...maharaja Ranjit Singh...khidrana battle
@waylingtons
@waylingtons 3 года назад
That would be amazing. He does need the source material to make the videos though.
@Sprite_525
@Sprite_525 3 года назад
That’s be great. I’m not Sikh but I’m fascinated by the idea that a religion of dharma can embrace a warrior class & combat imagery , hence their sword symbol.
@harmanjotsingh7429
@harmanjotsingh7429 3 года назад
@@Sprite_525 Sikhism composed of two ideas...we have 10 gurus ...First 5 are saints... second 5 are called Saint Soldiers....which means believe in one god .. respect all religions..follow the path of Dharma...but when someone is doing tyranny to inferior... doing injustice...don't be a bystander ...come forward to defend that the victim even if it costs ur life...never fight for anger or revenge..but for righteous cause...even learn to forgive those who wronged you.... In medivial times Sikhs used to let go the enemy if he had lost his weapon on the ground...spare enemies' women and children..which was a contrast on enemies part when it comes to their turn of dealing with Sikhs...u must read a lot about 6 th guru and 10 th guru
@CCJJ160Channels
@CCJJ160Channels 3 года назад
10:47 - Muslims: “Why do we hear boss music”?
@BeYeSeparate
@BeYeSeparate Год назад
Great work, thank you!
Далее
Help Me Celebrate! 😍🙏
00:35
Просмотров 10 млн
Офицер, я всё объясню
01:00
Просмотров 1,6 млн
The Abbasids: Islam's Golden Age (All Parts)
47:21
Просмотров 1,6 млн
The Bronze Age Collapse (approximately 1200 B.C.E.)
23:52
Help Me Celebrate! 😍🙏
00:35
Просмотров 10 млн