These are some of the most powerful statements I have ever heard. His Eloquence, articulation, and use of words had me mesmerized , May Allah bless his man,
I had never heard of this man before last week. Now I’m hooked and man do I love him. You are the kind of voice and leader Muslim countries need and should praise in today’s society.
There are many instances that prove slavery in the Muslim World was brutal. Here are just a few: 1) Arab-African Slave Trade. Male African slaves taken to the Arabian Peninsula were sometimes castrated to serve as eunuchs. Women became sex slaves. 2) In the Middle Ages, Barbary pirates from North Africa routinely raided coastal cities in Europe and sold captives into slavery in North Africa. 3) When the Trans-Atlantic slave trade was in full swing, some of the slaves came from the interior of Africa, along trade routes where they were sold by Muslims. 4) The Zanj Rebellion in Baghdad (869-883 CE) proves him wrong. Those Muslim slaves rebelled because whatever regulations Islam put on slavery were not good enough to make them content with being slaves.
@@Russ--R Of course he is. He’s brainwashed like all these idiots. Imagine if an American said that sometimes slavery was okay because the house slaves were treated well. That would still be terrible, because they were still slaves. They couldn’t just quit their jobs and go pursue another occupation.
As an Algerian I disagree, most slaves were blacks and black Arabs still struggle to find a decent job. White women ended up marrying the richest men and were even considered superior to us Arab women. Few slaves were white men. Almost no arabs or ottomans were slaves after 9th century. We have to be honest, we Muslims did not follow the Islamic slavery at all. We still do not treat them as our equal and Allah SWT will punish us for that. If you read our littérature you'll see the huge difference between Islamic slavery and what Muslims did.
Thank you for your honesty. I have a great respect for Islam but never went through with Shahada. Seeing the sheer racism of many Arab and Persian Muslims. I couldn't call them my people. They lie!
@@ETENewsAndViews it is a 'human' condition not a religious or philosophical error, the most perfect ideal's can breakdown into a shambles and utter disgrace in a very short span of time by the wrong hands navigating the fate of humanity.
@@sollykhan2385 I fully support your words. Humans will always pervert what God brings to earth. But seeing many Muslim commenter making excuses doesn't bode for me.
Brother, whether more white slaves marry rich men than black slave, in muslim world is really irrelevant case. Racism is talking about inherent value within people skin color, not talking about which is more attractive or not. the second one, you are wrong, Turk it self are slaves before Seljuk empire exist. And why not many Arab slave exist is because Islam came from Arab race, and they are the one in power. Remember most of slave from early expansion of Islam was from war. And I disagree with your words about we did not follow islamic slavery at all to some extent. Because they fact that Turks can comeback and become Ottoman, I know it was a long procces, but it proves that Slave in Islam have some power even if when Arab enslave Turks. Just imagine, affrican slaves in US owned US in the end from white people.
As a Muslim i was confused why Islam has not abolished slavery once and for all but today you cleared my confusion. Jazak Allah for being so much clear on all subjects
Truthful? That depends on how naive you are. I would rather call him erudite or learned - his flinching doesn't show any calmness; rather that he is in defense mode.
I wish you would have also mentioned the prison system that’s practically a modern form of American slavery, if not arguably far worse. Not to mention generating billions of dollars worth of labor for a pittance, it is designed in a way such that it makes rehabilitation almost impossible if you’re not rich enough and further criminalizes the people there. Yet most folks seem to be either blind or indifferent towards this phenomenon. Some even view prisoners as not deserving of any rights at all, irrespective of the severity of the crimes they committed. It’s beyond barbaric and disgusting.
@@duibheasaoreilly167 Cutting off a thief's hand is infinitely more humane than taking his freedom away. Even the Jewish legal system doesnt include incarceration as a punishment because its inhuman.
@@abuzolfiqar2122If the hand wasn't cut off, the theft crimes rates of muslim world and the west would be the same. It's not about being cruel and inhumane, but about setting an example to others. The future theives wouldnt even think about stealing. That is why the crimes rates are so low in the muslim world.
@@wurds509 The day we start accepting value judgments of people who kill hundreds of thousands of babies in utero every day and let men dressed as women dance for children is the day I eat my shorts. Morality that isnt derived from an ultimate authority is by definition arbitrary. That being said, almost every hadith you quoted is a fabrication of Bani Umayya. Sunnism is a perversion of Islam. Its judaism by proxy.
where has this man been all my youtube life. we need to share this with as many people as possible, the way he speaks on these subjects is immaculate and 1000000% sense making.
People need to learn about the type of slavery that was present in the period of the 'Zanj Rebellion'. Brothers and Sisters hate talking about that particular type of slavery. They talk about it in a way that makes excuses rather than admitting it was a very barbaric and un-Islamic practise carried out by Muslims within the Abbasid Caliphate. I despise the lack of honesty and lack of historical accuracy.
😂😂I couldn’t stop cringing at Thomas sowell saying, he would prefer to be enslaved in the americas than in an Islamic country! Coming from a black professor at Harvard !
As an ethiopian with a proud rich history and the only African nation that managed to preserve its alphabet(ፊደል) as well as the only African nation that has NEVER been colonized. Thomas sowell analogy makes me CRINGE!
He is not, though. Malcolm spoke from the belly of the beast. This individual came out of nowhere and he is in,, hell knows, what country, mirroring Malcolm. Odd.
I share a Daoist/Buddhist philosophy. I enjoy listening to your videos about the Muslim philosophy and the life of Muslim followers. Your message is simple and clear. Keep shining and sharing your light, the world needs more people like you.
There are many instances that prove slavery in the Muslim World was brutal. Here are just a few: 1) Arab-African Slave Trade. Male African slaves taken to the Arabian Peninsula were sometimes castrated to serve as eunuchs. Women became sex slaves. 2) In the Middle Ages, Barbary pirates from North Africa routinely raided coastal cities in Europe and sold captives into slavery in North Africa. 3) When the Trans-Atlantic slave trade was in full swing, some of the slaves came from the interior of Africa, along trade routes where they were sold by Muslims. 4) The Zanj Rebellion in Baghdad (869-883 CE) proves him wrong. Those Muslim slaves rebelled because whatever regulations Islam put on slavery were not good enough to make them content with being slaves.
Damn. Just guys not just drop in truth farms, he’s dropping truth nuclear warheads. As an American, I do admit some of this is hard to hear But it doesn’t make him wrong. He’s speaking the truth. It might be a hard truth, but it’s the truth nonetheless. And it needs to be said. I am really glad that I found Shahid’s content
What truth? There is a reason why there are little to no black people in Arab countries. They all died. Black Americans are the richest blacks in the world. We abolished slavery and within 40 years 90% of blacks became literate, incredible. The Quran literally condones slavery and being able to have sex with your slaves. It’s evil and disgusting. Do you think it’s ever ok to be able to buy and sell others and own them?
"So when you went around the world, telling everyone how evil slavery is, They didn't know what you were talking about, THE SLAVES didn't know what you were talking about" Facts said beautifully
Islamic “slave owners” apparently have the right to have sex (rape) with the women they deem to own. They often castrate the male captives. That is pure evil no matter how you slice and dice it.
@Hillman_Faiz: The slaves didn't know...Really? Please feel free to study the long history of slave rebellions against all forms of slavery all across the world from ancient times to the present.
@@dpeasehead It would make sense if he meant in the islamic world, i searched up rebellions only one i could find was the zanj rebellion (only one in over 1000 years, perhaps there are others idk but they were not as big to be called an event in history from my googling lol). slavery in islam and the muslim world is quite interesting. slaves ended running a whole sultanate, the mamluk, it lasted over 200 years.
@@hassane368 There were lots more than that.. Slave masters had no interest in advertising slave revolts, whether they were successful or not, so the only ones we know about were too big for them to conceal. Ex-slave states in the Americas like the US and Brazil still push the narrative of the happy slave and loving master while at the very same time, condemning the slave states set up by the likes of nazi Germany and Stalinist Russia. And they do so without even a hint of irony at their vast hypocrisy. Apparently islam shares the very same moral vacuum when it comes to slavery.
@@Russ--R He gave the answer to your allegation but I guess you never listened and it's not surprising lol. Those like you who are resolved to slander Islam are ONLY making it worse for themselves and their agenda hahaha. Preserved by God, Islam will prevail, like it or not.
@@computaqzambialtd2946 Nope, it's the truth. God says in the Qur'aan that the likes of you will deny, and it's normal, but He also gave you a choice to do the right thing as long as you breathe!
A protege is in an inferior position to his mentor, that's not saying anything. A worker is in an inferior position to his boss. The fact is indisputable that slaves in Islam were given rights that no other slaves in history were given, including the opportunity for manumission, the freedom to earn their own incomes, and to have upward mobility, with many surpassing even the social and financial status of their "masters".
@@MiddleNation thanks for the feedback. I liked all your videos and I’m a big fan, but it felt like you’re defending / justifying Islamic / Arab slavery in here, I could be wrong but that’s just my honest opinion on the subject. Thank you Mr Bolsen
"A slave in Islam has to have the same material lifestyle as his master, he can't be overworked and he can't be abused" This is very true, read Al-Adab al-Mufrad. Literally share their clothes... And obviously this isn't to say Muslims were perfect of course.
@@muslamicknight9621from what the master eats and wears, meaning there would be no problem if the master ate or wore the slaves share, what am I missing here? Its not from what the master owns... its what the master eats and wears
@@muslamicknight9621 so you would win a war and welcome the enemies you fought against into your land, neighbot with your leaders as free men and women? What kind of war kills all the men, there will always be thousands left. Look at the state of israel today, banning palestinians from entering. Back in the day, exile would mean death. Edit: and dont forget jizya. Options are given
@@muslamicknight9621 on the contrary it has everything to do with Islam,,,,, the Mamelukes had the opportunity to take over an empire and hold it for centuries has to do with the fact that islamic form of slavery provided them with an education, knowledge, training, food, weapons, health care, wages and power to infiltrate politics at the highest level and the skills to keep power and keep the country prosperous and stronger while at the same time they were not stigmatised or looked on as inferior by the Muslim population they ruled and were absorbed seamlessly into it....... contrast that to 1865 emancipation where the Atlantic slave trade left the slaves with zero knowledge/skills to build any future, even if they had the skills how long would it have lasted in a hostile environment, where the citizens of good ole Dixie would revile at the idea they could mix with them let alone ever rule over them. This none acceptance went on through John crow and are still felt till today amongst those communities.......
@glencecil293: Exactly. Most slaves in the Americas were ill fed, ill clothed, ill housed, poorly medicated and they died young..Yet, New World slavery was one of the most profitable enterprises that has ever existed. Institutions as diverse as Yale and the Catholic church benefited from it.
@@u2sharp I'd be far more impressed if the same people who spend so much time illuminating the silver linings of race-based cradle to grave chattel slavery expended the same amount of effort and energy when it comes the slave labor of the nazis and in Stalin's gulags. Their failure to do so, gives them and their agendas away.
Umm and your point is what? Yeah according to some plantations most of their profit went to the slaves themselves that’s not hard to believe and it’s quite sad how you missed all the amazing facts he mentioned just because he didn’t reference one argument he made.
I find this to be extremely biased and untruthful, unfortunately. Islamic slave trade was every bit as barbaric as any other slave trade. There's numerous accounts from slaves in the muslim world that speaks of their abuse and harsh treatment. There were also very regular slaver raids into nearby regions to capture people and force them into slavery. No amount of his excuses makes that a particularly nice experience for the innocent people getting kidnapped. So in short, slavery was bad. It was bad in the west, it was bad in the Islamic world and it was/is bad everywhere else too.
I learned of this man two days ago. Outstanding! I am sharing his video. Not surprising that we don’t hear much about him, he speak the truth. What I hear him say is logical and reality. 😊 Maybe that’s why it’s logical because it’s reality. 😂
Yep, Sandra the West made the entire world believe they were gonna save the world with their so called democracy. In the meantime they knew exactly they were selling the world a lot of hogwash and they labeled it the American dream, only to have Shahid Bolten to bring them down to earth and show them reality. He exposed their demonocracy.
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good and by looking at the comments he seduced you with his way of talking and you didn't realise how many lies he said, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
I didnt listen to your posts because I found them too complicated for me but seeing titles of some of the topics has intrigued me to click and I find that much of your content can be understood by simple minded people. The ghairah you show is the very thing most needed and most lacking amongst the Muslims today. Including the intellectuals. JazakAllahuKhayr Wisdom is not complete without humility but humility need not mean one has to humble before the ignorant or the evil. Thank you for being a representative of the Muslim ghairah in the worldwide web environment which is polluted with ignorant or evil content.
Unfortunately, a lot of Muslims feel down when facing western ideologies. When it should be the opposite, that is why we have an obligation to learn and be firm to our religion!
Narrated Abu al-Khudri: "We got female captives in the war booty and we used to do coitus interruptus with them. So we asked Allah's messenger about it and he said, "Do you really do that?" repeating the question thrice, "There is no soul that is destined to exist but will come into existence, till the Day of Resurrection." Sahih Bukhari Vol. 7-#137
Genius response. Honestly the best response I have ever heard to the topic of slavery. Funny that modern “scholars” have the audacity to say it’s a problematic issue and try to hide in shame
those "scholars" are generally in the west. they can't they anything otherwise, they'll be called extemist by the gov and their lose their job(that's west "liberty"🤣). true scholars(from saudi...) don't hide from it, they even laugh at western logic, hypocrisy and lack of knowledge.
@dogeyellowfunni3961 if you understand the whole topic you won't be asking this question. It is the same as someone asking if there is no shame in killing a person. When you leave all the backstory and the validation for these things ofcourse it is gone sound ridiculous. Or are you gonna also say that killing in war is barbaric so you should just let the enemy do whatever they want to you and your family?
Peace and Blessings Shahid Bolsen, you are very powerful and fearless when you speak, you calm me down, I feel safe when I listen to you.. Peace be onto you Sir Thank You..
So you belive paying people is as bad as slavery? Also note how he left our how muslims torture their slaves both back then and today. Claiming how Islam does't allow this inspite of all evidence to the contrary. 10,000, 000 black slave taken, but where are they now? Castrated, and dead, to prevent their numbers from increasing. All under Islam. He is full of shit.
Like many arguments that start with "let's compare the west to Muslims" this man is a sophist and is basically providing a what about-ism of an argument to support his own ethnocentrism. While his point of debt and wage slavery as deregulation of slavery is well taken, his notion that the Middle East is somehow above this is laughable. One could make the comparison of western slaves being treated less humanely than the Middle East's "protégé slaves" from hundreds of years ago but that, like all bad faith arguments from Muslims, compares only ancient history or history from 150 to 200 years ago in the U.S. The modern city of Dubai wouldn't even exist without modern, inhumane slavery of exactly the type he describes as western. Nearly every laborer or barista in the land is an import from Egypt or Syria or other less fortunate neighboring countries. Bahrain's F1 track is a perfect example of egregious modern slavery perpetrated by modern Muslims. A land of royals too good to serve themselves needs exactly the kind of slavery that he described so well, as deregulated. Only it's even worse than that. In fact, I would argue the Chinese took better care of their Foxconn workers in Shenzhen. All examples of non-American countries utilizing an even more extreme version of western wage/ debt slavery, as described by this man. Seeing some educated Muslim man make bad faith arguments when comparing the west to Muslim culture is practically a meme at this point. Let us not forget that the last 20+ years of war in the region were kicked off as a DIRECT RESULT of educated, wealthy Muslim men deciding to act out their own twisted version of their religious and cultural beliefs in the form of a violent attack on U.S. soil. So virtuous. Pied pipers, all of them. So sad that many uneducated and ignorant Muslims flocked to men like that to give everything.
@@DePeaceHunter "Ethnocentrism: evaluation of other cultures according to preconceptions originating in the standards and customs of one's own culture." This man is a self-proclaimed Muslim and well known propagandist who calls out for violent attacks. Your attempt to write off what I've said based solely on his genetic makeup is just as ignorant and dishonest as this man's rhetoric. Go face west.
In fact, let's take this a step further. When I say "educated Muslim man" I feel I'm being FAR too generous. This man is a college drop out. Even Osama bin Laden had a more impressive background, both educationally and financially, than this turncoat. He barely speaks Arabic, and he's never been to Egypt - a country he keeps recommending violent protests to.
We can talk about Dubai and modern wealth dynamics that enact wage slavery in many cultures and parts of the world. Fair enough. But the religion is clear, even (and especially) if it’s not implemented well in governance. And please don’t ascribe 9/11 to Muslims without taking a really clear-eyed look at American barbarism in the Middle East.
And while we’re talking about Dubai, a touch of context on that system - I’m currently in Pakistan living with relatives. My brother in law, a Pakistani, spent over a decade working in Saudi Arabia in a system such as you criticize. His earnings supported his wife and four children in Pakistan - four amazing children, who got an outstanding education, and three of them are now fully practicing physicians, one working in the UK. The fourth is a wonderful mother of three beautiful sons. Those wages, however small compared to the wealth of those countries, made a tangible difference in the upward mobility of multiple generations, here. In the US, small wages disappear in the face of cost of living. But when there’s an exchange rate factor and cost of living difference, it can still be meaningfully beneficial - much like migrant workers in the US sending wages back home that support multiple generations of their family.
As a British born history buff who has visited the USA many times, I agree with so much this man says about the race elements within the American systemic slavery trade. Slavery has always, and still does exist in many forms. Indentured servitude within the British system has affected my own family, both in the coal mines of Wales and the penal colonies of Australia. They were all white peoples. I’d like to hear him talk about why so many Africans who were sent to the Muslim world were castrated to become eunuchs? Many Americans I have spoken to wonder why they don’t have a diaspora in the Middle East. Their whole perspective is race based. I have read it was the Portuguese who were the first to frame slavery in a racial way in order to subvert the laws of the day. I would love to hear the perspective of Muslims on this particular point. Much love to all of you x
I realise this gentleman mentions the castrations of young men in the European context of castrato singers, but I’m curious about the reasoning behind castrations on board to the Arab world? American slave owners forced these poor people to mate in order to create ongoing generations of slaves, which they would also “own”. We can all see that as a financial decision. What was the reasoning for creating foreign eunuchs? Genuinely interested 😊
@@lynseyhughes8313 also, I'm pretty sure in islam, slaves will never give birth to a slave. If you get a child, the child is free. And I'm pretty sure the mother becomes free as well.
First of all, “The Muslims countries” today are just secular countries….People are Muslims but laws and anarchies are not (they are Muslim by name only, they don’t follow Islamic teachings and rules) Also, in Islam, there is no discrimination between Arabic and non Arabic, a black or white, except by piety. The Jews used “usery” throughout Europe, as a plan to start spreading their slavery by making people being owed to them, which we know today as “interest fee”. Then, westerns came up with taxes and capitalism ( One is rich, 99 are poor among each 100) Whereas Islam has what we call “Zakat”, it’s a tiny amount of money you pay annually. Simply, it is that you only pay 2.5% of your total money you have (whether it’s cattle, or gold, or money) Oh, and as a counter to “interests” Islam has this simple yet effective solution, which is trading…For example, you want to buy a house for 20K dollars, if you go to a normal “interest based” bank, you just get a loan of 20K, then you will have to return them 21K, and the price goes higher every month or a certain amount of time, right? And if you can’t afford, you lose the car. However, in Islam, (if a bank uses the real Islamic economic system, you simply ask for the house, the bank buys it, then sells it to you higher than the original price, but you pay by monthly or yearly installments, the price won’t go up, you won’t lose the house unless you decide you can’t pay. Islam is a way of life, it has answers for everything, but people working in the dark day a night to blindsight people from the truth for their own purposes. Read about Bilal bin Rabah, the first one to declare the prayers’ calling (Athan or Azan in Arabic) and he was a black and a slave to an evil guy. Go read about him! Hope it helps.
Intelligent and eloquent explanation indeed! Thank you for standing up to speak against the hypocrisy of the west. I just want to add that in Islam it was one of the highest deeds to free a slave as well.
but the muslims countries 'abolished' it one the lasts - Slavery in Iran was abolished in 1929. In the Persian Gulf, Saudi Arabia and Yemen abolished it in 1962, while Oman followed in 1970. Mauritania became the last state to abolish slavery, in 1981 so in in 60s, 70s 80s people were still enslaved and had no fredom, but they definetly did more on slavery abolishment than the the hipocritical west🤦♂
@@yuriisamoliucYou don't seems to understand the video. Recently abolished doesn't mean they're in practice. Do you have actual statistics or just dull deduction base on your prejudice?
One of the highest deeds is likely a reference to the Quran. In actually this passage was used to justify the keeping of many slaves historically if you freed few. I don't understand why Muslims cannot just denounce slavery. Our loyalty is to ALMIGHTY GOD, he would not will for such atrocities, that was the will of men.
Sura 5:89, “Allah will not call you to account for what is futile in your oaths, but will call you to account for your deliberate oaths: for expiation, feed ten indigent persons, on a scale of the average for the food of your families; or clothe them; or GIVE A SLAVE HIS FREEDOM. If that is beyond your means, fast for three days. That I’d the expiation for the oaths you have sworn. But keep to your oaths. Thus Allah makes clear to you His Signs, that you may be grateful.” Sura 4:19, “O you who believe! You are FORBIDDEN to inherit women against their will.” Bad people do whatever they will, even fake Muslims of His-story/history. Quran has strict guidelines, however. It was also acceptable to marry slave women -as they were considered by Allah to be “better” than any unbelieving woman-men had to treat the slave woman with the same rights they’d acknowledged to a regular woman, as Brother implied. Sura 90:12-15, “What will explain to you the path that is steep?-It is FREEING the bondman (slave); Or the giving of food in a day of privation to the orphan with claims of relationship, or to the indigent down in the dust…..” Prophet Muhammad’s saying, “”Those who do not give Mercy to others are not from us.”
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good and by looking at the comments he seduced you with his way of talking and you didn't realise how many lies he said, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
Hi you free not to buy stupide shit and invest your money nobody puts a gun to your head and tells you to take a loan you can 1 be responsiball 2 fall for the trap dont be mad at the fox that he know how to trick you be mad that you fall for it
Mashallah I am hooked now just found you recently but I need to subscribe to learn more from such a knowledgeable man like yourself. I have always felt guilty about slavery as an arab but hearing you has completely changed my perspective such an eye opener for me to learn about it in the way you explained, thanks and May Allah Azw., blessings be upon you all the way 🙏🏼
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
Wonderfully articulated. May Allah expand your chest with His HIKMA. You exposed West for their cruelty and inhumane history and their lies about present human rights claims. Brother, you forgot to mention how slaves in Muslim lands were successful in establishing massive and powerful dynasties and these dynasties were MAMLUK in Egypt and GHULAMAN (Urdu translation of slaves) in India. Both these dynasties were instrumental in defeating Mongols. Mamluk defeated them in Ain Ul Jaloot and GHULAMAN along with later Delhi Sultanate (Muslim dynasty of Delhi, India) fought with Mongols for over 100 years and never allowed them any success in India Today Indian Muslims are at receiving end at the hands of Fascist Modi and BJP, while it was Muslims who established and formed India into one single entity. Before Muslims India was divided in 100 small kingdoms fighting each other. Long ago in BC, Ashoka and Chandragupta were great Kings but they too didn’t rule southern India.
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good and by looking at the comments he seduced you with his way of talking and you didn't realise how many lies he said, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
It was only the other day I read hadith about treating the slaves kindly by giving them what you have example food, clothes, good treatment and kindness.
True words, we never abolished slavery, no one did. They just stopped using the dictionary word. Imagine people living in debt because they could not pay it back to the banks with interest. Students with loans. Workers with no rights to leave the country without their master's permission and others who can't see their families for 3 years because their boss didn't feel like it. And finally those who aren't payed their salaries on time and they can't ask for it because they are second class citizens (poor country foreigners).
A slave in Islam would be like an employee WITH room and board AND healthcare! If you remove the term slavery, this would sound like the dream job of a lifetime. But they harp on the term because they exercised unregulated slavery and think we do the same.
@@ETENewsAndViews A slave can, actually. They can buy their way out of bondage (since slaves aren't prevented from earning money). You dropped your cap, kind sir.
That’s disgusting and evil what you are saying. Slaves cannot choose to simply leave their master. They can be sold at any time. That’s evil. That’s completey different than someone taking out debt to get an education to make more money. The fact you make this comparison shows how ignorant you are.
I am a Muslim myself, and I have some understanding of how slavery is addressed in Islam. However, I firmly believe that slavery is inherently immoral, and debating which slave is better is senseless. No human being desires to be a slave. It's important to note that even under German law, if the government orders a person to go to prison do not receive a lesser punishment if the person they ordered attempts to flee. This is because the innate human desire for freedom should not be disregarded. Slavery should be forbidden.... period ....in any form what so ever.
Would you be homeless and poor and subject to gangster abuse or would you be under the wing of someone at their expense they take care of you and provide a livelihood on the condition you do what they say?
@@uta9944 Once again, as a Muslim, I stand firmly on the issue of slavery. So, in your understanding, is it morally acceptable for me, you, or anyone to own slaves if they are homeless, impoverished, or vulnerable to exploitation by criminals? Additionally, I have a question regarding Zina: Does it qualify as Zina if you consider the following rules: 1. When a slave has initiated the process of purchasing their freedom through installments (via mukataba), the master is prohibited from engaging in sexual relations with them. 2. A master is not allowed to have sexual relations with a slave who was already married before being acquired or was married by the master to someone else. This prohibition is outlined in Qur'an 4:2. Slavery is inhumane and has no place in our world in 2023. Anyone who attempts to justify having slaves should consider being a slave themselves for a couple of years.
@@Ili_chilli I thought brother Shahid is explaining *what slavery is* under Islam *if there is a time to own a slave* in this case, the past historical example. *Not justifying* slavery in itself. Just because our prophet s.a.w abolished slavery doesn't mean that other people at that time will abide by that rule especially one that abhor Islam. Also not justifying some middle Eastern rule of how they do things too since I also didn't understand why they do what they did. Brother Shahid is explaining Islam, not Muslim who did wrong.
May Allah (SWT) reward you and bless you. What a great work you are doing especially to teach the Shabab their Deen properly unlike the apologist and hypocrites.
This guy would have you believe there was never mass castration or harems full of sex slaves (including young girls) in Muslim countries, and there isn't anyone in Yemen, Somalia, Sudan or other poor Muslim countries who has it as bad as people in Chicago and Detroit. And the majority of his viewers think he's brilliant.
As much as I agree with you on so many issues, slavery was still slavery in any form, there was nothing charitable about taking black Africans from the interior of east Africa, by arab slave traders and marching them to the coast, where they were castrated and put in shops to be sold....castration was a means of pacification, where untested theory of taking away manhood, would make one more docile and subservient.....slavery practiced by arabs was just as brutal, and there's no sugar-coating that will make ot less brutal.
This coward is a liar and a deceiver like his fake god, he pikes and chooses the history that makes him look good, all he said is easily debunked in the following: 1."as if anyone is the world have been as savage as you (westerners)" He says that when the muslims were cutting off their slaves pen!ses and left them to die once they got old or sick, in the west like you said they would take care of their slaves for financial reason (still no morally right), but muslim didn't spend a cent on their slaves, once he is to no use he is cast out, and let's not start talking about what muslims did to the women, past 23 years old she is to no use, not even a human anymore. 2. "there wasn't some sick quasi scientific rationale claiming that they were inferior humans being (in the islamic world)" no but there was a quasi religious 'prophet' that did allow muslims to treat non-muslims like they're not human, and in actuality the Europeans got their theory of race from islam, because islam says that it's the role of the descendants of Ham (sub-saharans) to do the dirty 'low-life' jobs, and when the fake-Christian Europeans wanted an excuse to practice slavery like the muslims that have been doing it for centuries, they just remixed islam's theory of race. 3. A slave in islam has rights AS LONG AS he is muslim, so basically he would be forced to convert to that religion in a way that no loving God would want, and of course if he converted he would be sent back to a sub-saharan country if he wasn't castrated before he converted because Arab muslims are the greatest race according to the quran and they didn't want to take the risk to mix their population's gens. And the slaves would get high ranked position as long as it's for the benefit of the Arab muslims, but if the non-Arab muslims became independent and only serve themselves (which happened multiple times) the Arab muslims would wage war against them. 4. Yes we do have more slaves today than centuries ago, and yes the USA and Europe is the primary target of sex-traffickers (because they are addicted to the looks of white children and women), but it's not the white westerners doing it, the ones that kidnap white western kids and women the most are muslims, the highest concentration of today's slaves are in muslims country, why? Because they are still doing what the have been doing for centuries which is using them as s ex slaves, even in the UK 96% of the people running under-age s ex trafficking rings are muslims. 5. Yes the western Christians force the muslims to stop their slave trade, the British force the Ottomans and all of west Africa to stop, with the help of the USA they forced the Moroccans to stop. 6. No the westerners didn't make slavery more brutal, it's the brutality of the muslims slavery system that was hidden for so long and every time that we discover the disgusting and horrific dirt under your rug you blame everyone but yourselves like cowards, satan must be proud of you. 7. Yes the USA of today that is run by jews is horrible, but you're still worse, what you muslims do in Dubai eclipse what is going on in the USA, what you do to the real slaves in Dubai is just the tip of the ice-burg of what you used to do in the past centuries, on average 3 slaves a day dies from starvation alone, not taking into account the other reasons they die (get murdered), and they will never see their families and loved ones again, and that's in the United Arab Emirates only, if you want to know how much more dirty muslims are to slaves look up what they are doing to them in Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Sudan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Somalia, Mali and ofc Saudi Arabia.
@@amuthi1 Untrue, because most people in Arabia could not financially afford to own slaves and because, unlike in European owned colonies, there were no plantations in Arabia or other parts of the growing islamic empire and therefore, there was no need for a large labour force.
@@amuthi1 Enslaving someone for the sake of having a slave is haram. The only way someone could become a slave was through warfare which is common throughout history.
@@jesan733 Haram is haram even if the whole world is doing it and halal is halal even if nobody is doing it. "All mankind is from Adam and Eve. An Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab, nor does a non-Arab have any superiority over an Arab; a white has no superiority over a black, nor does a black have any superiority over a white; [none have superiority over another] except by piety and good action."- The Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)
In the Muslim world many different practices regarding buying and selling slaves took place because it was such a large territory and yes some people abused the practice and people were definitely harmed let’s not beat around the bush about it- but yes what the shariah says is what this brother is saying.
Him saying African slaves weren’t treated sub human in the Arab slave trade is an absolute joke & demonstrates his clear Islamic bias. Black Africans are STILL being treated subhuman in the Arab world. You can speak against Americas mistreatment during slavery but that doesn’t change your mistreatment which is also historically documented.
Where did he even talk about Arab slavery? He was talking only about Islamic slavery. This is your prejudice that Islam = Arab. 80% Muslims are non-Arab. Islam limited the intake of slaves and enouraged their emancipation as matter of divine decree. You could only take slaves if they were combatants in war against you.
Black Africans being treated as slaves in ARAB world is not clear Islamic bias! This is where you go wrong. Just because you are Arab does not mean all your actions are according to Islam. You need to understand the concept of slavery on Islam was completely different to what you call slavery. Slaves had rights, they ate the same food, they lived similar lifestyles. There can be no abuse. Many of the slaves under Islam were set free and then became leaders of the Muslims. Your lack of knowledge on this topic is frustrating. Please don't comment on what Islam says about slavery unless you know what you are talking about.
Sir you are just awesome, how u demystify every Western positions on issues...I learn a great deal from your deep understanding of issues and the way u articulate and presents them
You said””Slaves were more like PROTEGES. Slaves had the chance to purchase their way out of servitude and they had the freedom to pursue earning independent income while there were some slaves in the Muslim world who had more money than their masters “” Please could you share some sources that can prove what you saying? Just need sources nothing else. Thank you.
A captured African with an Islamic master was coerced into converting to the Islamic faith. They could refuse, but if they did not convert they had to pay a tax, and were treated differently than those who did convert. I'm not asking anybody to flinch, but I am saying to be honest about your institutions like slavery.
The slaves in the Muslims world even became the kings/sultans in the Muslims world, some even made massive empires, can the world show any examples like it..
Because Islam did not force slaves role to only unpaid farming, slaves allowed to earn their own income while still serving their owner, some even earned allowance from their master if talented in a specific role be it warfare, writing, administration, and so on. Some slaves once they bought their own freedom with either their own money, contract made with their master end, or their master freed them because of a religious obligation such an oath to God for His blessings or done a certain sin that can be redeemed by freeing his slave, can climb higher social ladder because of their past experience working for their master. Many mamluks was once enslaved, trained for battle, then freed under a deal that they should serve their master no longer as a slave but as a soldier while getting paid handsomely and given a land in exchange for their service. These warrior slaves tend to ended up as kingmakers later on because how deep they integrate themselves into the administration. This could not be done if the slavery system was based on pre-islamic pagan Arabs because it was heavily unregulated and gives no room for slaves to earn their freedom easier and therefore to climb the social ladder. Islamic civilization may not have survived if they outright ban slavery, this was proven with the defeats of the Mongols by the Mamluks who prevented the Mongols from touching the rest of the Arab world and the entrance to Africa, so slavery was reformed by Islam from treating slaves as tools that will expire to a system of temporary guardianship where the slaves may free themselves later on. I may made mistakes in my writings and spellings. Allah knows best. @@ETENewsAndViews
@@jafaralmahbub Mamlukes were white slave soldiers. Show me the equivalent with Black slave soldiers. Better yet let me sell you and use you for slavery.
This guy's audacity knows no bounds, bloviating unchallenged, I need to take him under my wing to experience the Islam regulated slavery. His argument boils down to my slavery is better than your slavery. The fact some Muslims align with his POV is all you need to know how faulty his logic is.
I grew up in the west appologising for my Islamic hostory. You are teaching me a new narrative. Please can you include more sources and help me to stand up strong when faced with these questions.
Profound explanation..I’ve been saying this ..I couldn’t have said it better myself . Slavery/ Servitude is a reality the US has made a good thing bad and made a bad thing good ..
Barabaric, Savage and Cruel! He is painting a picture of a romantic slave owner, operating under a romantic ideal of slave ownership while blasting american slavery practice with his american accent and calling the americans “you” The african slaves in today’s Libya live under terrible conditions all because they were esteamed by Gadaffi. Where is the human kindness there? Where is the human kindness in Christianity? Feed the Hungry, Clothe the Naked, Tend the Sick, House the Homeless…….etc. It may be written in their little books of fairy stories but ultimately, as humans are very good a twisting things, money rules and profit is their God!
Did he just try to justify a certain form of slavery? Surely i did not here this video right? He has adopted wholesale Malcolm X's mannerisms and affectations. Pity he did not adopt Malcolm's disdain and condemnation of all forms of slavery period. I would be curious to see how much he would have liked being a slave in the the Christian world or Islamic world or on the moon or on the asteroid belt.
This guy is justifying slavery by saying "we did it better than the west" taking somebody away from their home and family by force is disgusting and inhumane no matter what part of the world your from!
Wow, never had it explained to me like that before. I'm going through some entry level Maliki fiqh texts with respected teachers and even they haven't explained it to me in such a clear way. Theres an awkwardness among the students and teachers when slavery is brought up. Now i realise that im looking at it wrong, thank you sir!
@@Hassan-uh1so Bida lead to division & disunity, they even call away from Quran misusing Quran 3 :7, division became so bad it lead to secularism like in Uthmanis, who at peak in 1680 studied ebn Taymiyyah. Salafis need to build manhaj or priorities, teach usul to link aqida & fiq & show Islam's virtue as a structure & in contrast! The apologist shaykhs are usually on bida and secularism as Islam is wholesome and is virtuous in contrast!
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 is it an obligation to do rafa yadain after rukoo/standing again or do i get sinful if i dont do it? and only do it at start of prayer//
This is the first time someone explained it so eloquently that makes perfect sense. Our contemporary scholars have failed to explain the slavery systems in Islam as you did. May Allah increase you in knowledge and reward you abundantly.
You definitely found your niche with these types of videos. May Allah reward you for all your efforts and may Allah continue to guide you with sincerity.
If Islam is the religion from the one all mighty who is infallable then slavery should NOT exist. Comparing "muslim" slaves to "western" wage slaves and trying to sugarcoat it is just an unecessary distraction off the real topic.
Also you can have sex with slaves without having to marry them, hell Islam even has such a thing as sex slaves also known as concubines. This itself should tell you how much "rights" slaves had.
Yeah, he is absolutely wrong about the how much it cost to keep a slave. You know, he's so wrong, I'm offended by it. Slaves got rags for clothing maybe once a year. Slaves had to scavenge for food for their families. Slaves got no medical care. If a female went into labor while working in the field, she would have that baby right there, and keep on working, (&, that wasn't by choice). Oh my gosh, I don't know much about slavery in the middle east, but his justification for slavery by comparing the west to the middle east causes an uneasiness in me that makes me want to learn. So, I'm going to learn, and come back to this later. Be Well
Talk to the Hindus and Sikhs about the the most appalling cruelty vistied on them by the Muslims. The slave has to have the same material lifestyle as his master - minus his testicles. Got to give it it to this man -- he is a master of taqqiyah.
Very much needed video, my non-Muslim parents just were telling me this, and how can I support slavery, I already knew it was like this, and it's not like they have 0 rights... at all.... We need to really study Islam, otherwise other people colonize the terms, and that isn't good at all, because it isn't true...
Amazingly I listened to a history podcast about slavery in the 18th century and was surprised to hear the Ottomans actually had the correct concept of slavery almost all of their slaves were captured sailors or soldiers and most bought their freedom with 15 years. Slavery and Servitude in the Ottoman Mediterranean Episode 362
Surah nur;33 فكاتبوهم إن علمتم فيهم is a verse much ignored. Umar ibn khattab viewed this ayat as a command. That all capable slaves should be given the chance to buy their freedom. Although jamhuuur are of the view that it is desirable. Also umar ibn khattab’s famous statement in support of the Egyptian copt whom was assaulted by his soldiers. “How can you enslave a people whom their mothers have bore them as free individuals”
Enslaving prisoners of war is not allowed at all. Enslaving anyone is not allowed. The Qur'an directly gives the only two options for them; freed graciously or ransomed. Don't be so easily taken in by rhetoric ... as often, if it sounds too good to be true it usually is. He is portraying a fantasy here ... taking the theoretical ideal and making it out as if it were the norm. Making it sound as if slavery is better than freedom "when done right". The actual reality was used by God as an example in the Qur'an; { ضَرَبَ لَكُمْ مَثَلًا مِنْ أَنْفُسِكُمْ ۖ هَلْ لَكُمْ مِنْ مَا مَلَكَتْ أَيْمَانُكُمْ مِنْ شُرَكَاءَ فِي مَا رَزَقْنَاكُمْ فَأَنْتُمْ فِيهِ سَوَاءٌ تَخَافُونَهُمْ كَخِيفَتِكُمْ أَنْفُسَكُمْ ۚ كَذَٰلِكَ نُفَصِّلُ الْآيَاتِ لِقَوْمٍ يَعْقِلُونَ } [Surah Ar-Rûm: 28] **He gives you this example, drawn from your own lives: do you make your slaves full partners with an equal share in what We have given you? Do you fear them as you fear each other? This is how We make Our messages clear to those who use their reason.**
The problem is not islam. Its the humans who actually treated slaves worse after the time of prophet Muhammad. Its not the problem of the prophet or the religion. Its the problem of humans. The Almighty will judge them rightly on the last day. Leave alone the religion here. Anyone who knows its morals know the ethics of slavery
You're helping me immensely to shift my perspective that was clouded. It will help me greatly in the future when my daughter asks questions and I can answer her confidently. Thank you for spreading common sense. I needed it.
I hope your daughter asks you when it is ok to own slaves, and you have to defend it. Pathetic. Maybe she will ask why women are allowed to be beaten by their husbands. And you will defend it. Then she might ask, why did the prophet abolish adoption. And you’ll have to explain it due to your fake prophet being embarrassed.
What you’re saying is ridiculous. Slavery was practice on both hemispheres of the world by Muslims in by Europeans throughout Europe in the United States, and it was brutal slavery in slavery in the money in the Muslim world. As far as I know, they were very brutal. They committed acts sodomy with some of the men from the man had to Indore access, sodomy and other calories. I thought you knew what you were talking about now I realize you Don’t don’t😅
The ignorance, evasions and excuses this man makes are really creative, I give him that. How many of the male slaves from Africa were castrated without anesthesia or aftercare? How many bled to death or died of infection afterwards? How many female slaves from Africa were sexually tortured, raped over and over again? How many slaves from Africa were force marched through the desert to the Middle East? The slave market in the Middle East was just as cruel if not more cruel than that in the West. 11-14 million people were bought and sold in the Middle East. This man is just trying to wash clean a bloody and cruel history. In Saudi Arabia they still have slaves, in Sudan too, etc.
