The tail is all black. I have the same reissue of Bebop and I was fortunate with the tail but suffered the same exact right hand issues that you had with your figure.
I certainly can't vouch for those QC-issues, (I mean... REALLY, Playmates?) but here's a little collectors-hack for the tail; try dipping a paintbrush in some acetone (nail-polish-remover) and painting the inside of the tail-joint around the tail, carefully working it back-and-forth with a prying-tool and repeating the process until, hopefully, the tail works its way out. IDK if it'll succeed, but it's worth a try. =)