My clawhammer banjo sounds 100 times better after i made this one simple change! 

Wow, I just learned that the middle finger is not just for driving anymore.😀

Night and day difference. Pretty darn good for only a short time learning, good job...

I started as a middle finger player but went to primary index. I now switch between both during playing to get different tones during the songs for different accents. Makes it alot of fun too!

I tried the index but always found my middle finger to be more accurate, stronger, and easier to play with. I guess it’s to each his own, but everyone should try both to see what feels right for them. Great video!

Thanks!! Makes clear sense!! There is a difference!!

How interesting ! I've always used my middle finger, but i now can appreciate the difference - Great catch there !

Interesting assertion here. I think the STYLE of music you play will have more of an impact than purely mechanical skill. The reason a lot of contemporary clawhammer players sound "smooth" is because the style of music they play is (referred to as "round peak). It is highly melodic with a faster tempo and not heavy with rhythmic syncopation. Here's a thought experiment. Try to imagine playing Earl Scruggs music exactly as it was composed, with perfect clawhammer technique. It would likely result in a "typewriter" sound, and come off very choppy. That's because the style of that music leans into that sonic profile. If you want "smoother " sounding music, look for music that leans into what you want. Sure, mechanical skill can have an impact, but not to the degree you'd think. You can achieve the same level of smoothness with either the middle or index finger. Happy playing!

Great video! I wonder then since my ring finger is longest curled up should a fella go with the longest finger?

How long and difficult was the transition to middle finger. I too am a beginner and index striker

You bought a gituar ?

Will try. I play with tbe index finger right now

Huh 🤔 You just have to give it the finger? Interesting…

Remember everybody,, It's your banjo 🪕 You play it how ever you want too, as long as you play it, right.... If you like the sound and you are having loads of fun, well keep jamming... 😊😊😊 Every player is going to have their own sound and playing technique...✝️🇺🇸🤠🪕🪕🪕