MY FIRST TIME HEARING Bee Gees - Tragedy (Official 4K Video) *REACTION* 

Yes!

with shadow dancing....

Lay it on me, wildflower, Suddenly, there's a bunch of songs Maurice has the lead in. Yes please listen to Maurice Pronounced (Morris)

How about Chuck Berry 's song 'Johnny B Goode'... featuring the Bee Gees 😊

@@carolb1104 I never heard of that one!!

It's on The Midnight Specials new YT channel!👍

@@kthor Thanks. Will check it out

Mo & Barry may have agreed Robin had the best vibrato, but certainly not the best voice.🎤On Too Much Heaven (a top #1 hit showcasing their vocals), all three "share" 9 of the 27 vocal tracks (lead, high & low harmony 3 times). The other 18 vocal tracks are all Barry....falsetto lead 3 times, falsetto high harmony 3 times, falsetto low harmony 3 times, natural voice lead 3 times, high harmony 3 times & low harmony 3 times. Simply put, Barry's voice dominates that international chart topper....among most of their other massive hits!🎼

@@kthor - Interesting that my lengthy response disappeared. Did someone flag it because it was contradictory and because I provided quotes with their sources? Whoever did so please stop. It's childish. I'm retired so I have lots of time to repost. Barry and Maurice BOTH said Robin had the "best" voice, not just the best vibrato. That is a fact. In an interview when asked who had the best voice both pointed to Robin. A quote from *The Daily mirror, May 1969 - as quoted in the book "The Bee Gees day to day story" by Andrew Sandoval (page 88) - Barry said "He still has one of the greatest voices I've ever heard. He has a FAR BETTER voice than I have and he's a great songwriter too" and that was during their split! In an interview after his death the interviewer said Robin had the "best" (there's that darned word again) voice in recent recorded music. Barry's response was "You'll get no argument from me". Note the word "best". When they sang together at Barry's home just a while before Robin's death Barry said "Nobody sings like you do". I believe that was on a CBS Sunday segment. From *Tales from the brother's Gibb* a quote from Barry, "Robin's voice was killer". After Robin died he told Al Roker on Good Morning America he should have let Robin sing more. Critics called him "The Pavarotti of pop" (*David Leaf) and "The best white soul voice of his generation" (*Paul Gambaccini). Barry's friend David English said he didn't know how talented he was. Sure Barry sang on their biggest hits, no argument from me. Absolutely TRUE! That is because that was the most successful era of their career. His voice was the most "popular" and "best known" trade mark for that reason but that does not necessarily equate with being the so called "best". The falsetto made them tons of money and popularity for a time but eventually got them blacklisted because of 1 - overexposure and 2 - over use. It was OK in some songs but was overused and really tarnished songs later in their career when inserted in classics where it didn't belong. Radio stations treated them like the plague as did much of the public. Critics called them "mechanical mice". Barry again said "A lot of people could mimic and even mocked my falsetto but nobody could mimic Robin". These are quotes from the horse's mouth. No debate possible. "Popular" is a term according to personal taste. "Best" is a term based on other parameters. One is subjective, one objective. Enrico Caruso had a great voice but it was not for everyone. Robin's voice was not for everyone and that's OK. I just used the term that Barry and Maurice used themselves. Who can argue with them? Whoever deleted my post is being petty. I said nothing offensive.

@@susieq9801 I never flagged anything & no clue what you're referring to.💁‍♀️In fact, this is the first time I've been on YT today!

@@kthor - OK. My entire comment disappeared so someone did. I never said who. Was not happy to have to repeat it. Would love to know why and who.

🥰