@@user-od5zm3li2nShane held back and defeated Rick by knocking him down 4 times during their fight in season two. Negan would have no chance against an angry and uncontrollable Shane, whose punch knocked Rick down. Add to this Shane's hand-to-hand combat skills, which were much greater than Negan's, Negan has no real chance, even in a shootout where Shane had an extremely good aim.
@@randomeditor01 nah he would kill as many as he can before going down. all the times negan exposed himself to death but no1 took a shot because they knew they were out numbered and would pay the price shane wouldnt care about that
@@randomeditor01Shane would’ve shot at Simon and the first roadblock😂 Rick was way too cocky and paid the price. Carl and Abraham wanted to take the roadblock out but Rick said no
being a bad leader doesnt means it would slow him down in s2 rick was hesitant to clear the barn full of walkers which is a threat shane was the first person to immediatlely take action seeing in this case if shane wouldve lived the war with negan wouldve ended much faster @@user-ni2lo9di9z
@@user-ni2lo9di9zbad leader? you don't know what you are, you're just a stupid little kid who doesn't understand a man like Shane Shane adapts very quickly, and if Rick Daryl carol was asked in season 5 what Shane's actions were, what those who have seen and know what Shane is like would answer Yes, because just look at Rick, he doesn't hesitate to kill someone just to save one woman's life, namely his wife, and Shane breaks and kills a child to save everyone.
Negan durability >>> Rick Durability >>> Shane durability So Negan AP >>> Rick AP >>> Shane AP Negan is taller, has Lucille, Rick has a more powerful punch than Shane, and Negan hits much harder than Rick, also in season 10 Negan grabbed a boy and shook him like a bag of feathers, he even killed him, he broke Simon's neck , picks up Rick as if he were a dog, the only bad thing about Negan is combat, but Rick S2 is slightly inferior to Shane, so Rick S8, who is the one who faces Negan hand-to-hand, is stronger than Shane, and Negan beat this Rick, so I highly doubt Shane can handle Negan.
Rick in TWD is literally the same every season in terms of H2H considering he never trained in the span of the seasons 💀. Shane consistently overpowered Rick up until Rick offguarded him while Negan only got the advantage over Rick cuz he offguarded him even with a weapon almost all the time Shane >> Negan
@@evanmil0minefly Your only defense is that rick is bad at h2h combat which is very untrue he beat tyresse who is a nfl player and knocked a guy out in just a few punches, but your not going ton explain that meat rider
Negan ın abartildigina kesinlikle katiliyorum,Simon sirf plot twist ten yendi ve rick le adil karsilastigi zamanlar yenildi,ve shane cidden negan i 1v1 fight da yok eder.Negan sıska bir beden ogretmeni shane ise bir tank,kaslari var ve cok cevik.Ama bence shane olsada negan in ekibini o kdr cabuk dagitamazlardi.500 kisinin ustunde bir gucten bahsediyoruz sonucta.
I feel like Negan would destroy Shane just because towards the end, Shane was literally only thinking of Lori was jealous and angry, and durability?? Excuse me, but Negan is the one who's still alive...that might just be my opinion though.
@@Astroximoif he is right, durability is the fact of still standing after having experienced difficult choices or after having suffered violent blows and the feats are numerous for Negan he has survived lots of things including an ext motorcycle crash. ....
@@RlCKGRIMES_TWD it's not my opinion for me negan can win hands down because he is bigger maybe less strength but more resistant has more experience is faster and agile and he knows how to destabilize his opponent so negan wins easily it's my opinion if that pleases you don't keep your dreams with shane to yourself because he is no match
None of these pointless categories matter. The only thing that matters is adaptability and negan was far better at that and that's why he survived so much longer
All of these categories matter, especially in a 1v1. Just because someone survived longer doesn’t necessarily mean they’re better, I mean, Eugene managed to survive for seasons because of Abraham, just like how Negan’s Iq and Battle Iq led to a whole sanctuary with thousands of people to protect him. However, I don’t think Shane would most likely win, but it could be a good matchup.
Everytime Negan fought Rick, unkess Rick had a gun, Negan had Rick crawling away, and TALKED down to him as he fought him. Last I checked. Season 5 Rick would've OBLITERATED Shane. But Negan broke Rick atbhis STRONGEST. Negan clears.
Negan offguarded and used a weapon against Rick almost all the time but still got wailed on by Rick several times. Shane consistently overpowered Rick up until Rick offguarded him Shane >> Negan
@@evanmil0minefly No Rick beat shane in a fair fight I don't think rick caught him off guard a single time and shane is so overrated i genuinely hate all these shane meat riders
@@grizzlychad284 bro shane litteraly had Rick on the ground 2 times but instead of punching him again he just went for the gun, giving Rick the opportunity to stand up again. The only time Rick had shane on the ground was when he sneaked from behind. Dont say Rick beated shane its so wrong
Negan would destroy Shane, Shane season 1 and 2 feats are pretty water downed compared to negan, who’s faces a much stronger, faster, smarter, more durable, skilled Rick than Shane faced
Negan is not stronger than Shane. Negan was only able to beat down Rick by offguarding him even with a weapon. Shane consistently overpowered Rick up until Rick offguarded him
Porque hay tanta gente que le gusta lamerle los pies a un personaje plano como negan, da igual su rol que tuvo en la historia, es un villano que no se sabe valer nada sin los demás, nadie debía obedecer lo, una persona normal lo mataría antes de catar órdenes de un don nadie
@@chameseddine4682 says you bro your a shane fanboy, I don't even like negan as my favorite character, shane is overrated as hell that's why, negan isn't super powerful as a character on his own but shane is just an average guy that has pretty good aim, that's LITERALLY all
I'm completely on team Shane here, but for durablility, I still think Negan takes that one cause he seems to have been q gym teacher that WASN'T fat- 🤣
😂😂😂 Stenght Shane Durability Negan, survived all show Speed Negan, ran while rick shot Agility Negan, in 1vs1 with Maggie in Dead City he avoided all the stabbings Endurance Shane IQ Negan Wepons < Lucille Expérience Negan, experienced a lot more than Shane even though he was a cop Battle IQ Negan made a very good plan in season 8 Combat Shane 1v1 Negan Negan Wins easy
Obviously Shane would win beacuse Negan is only a threat when he has the Saviours and people like Dwight and Simon with him but without them he's not really much powerful sure he can do some damage but him facing people like Shane, Rick, Daryl or Abraham he would lose
Negan has social skills and charisma, but defenitely there are many other better fighters in the show. Negan’s strength are metal games and convicing capacity. The guy made many stronger man do the worst shit for him.
Do the kingdom, Woodbury, the saviors, Alexandria, hilltop, oceanside, the whisperers, and the commonwealth together vs the crm and please use the sweater weather audio you use for the vs edits please 🥺
When you think about it, experience would still go to Shane, as he has years of experience being a cop, while Negan was just a teacher. Though, apocalypse experience goes to Negan.
@@Ongezellig_AmericanHe wasn’t military. He spent 15-17 years as a cop and some time as a football player. However, Negan spent years longer in the apocalypse, so it depends on if you think surviving in an apocalypse is more difficult than being a sheriff or not.
@@matthewwilliams6514 spent years in the apocalypse doing what though? If you cant understand Shane would sweep then you just aint that bright brother 😭
More like doing checkups and paperwork which is what most cops primarily do especially one in a county like shane while Negan spent YEARS surviving in a zombie apocalypse.
@@grizzlychad284 I see what you mean but this is in a fight, so the zombie experience isn't that much in a 1v1. Shane has had training for fighting and using guns. And even with Negan’s experience, (At the time this video was made) when has Negan won a 1v1 with someone? In the abandoned house vs Rick, he slips, he was so unaware he let a freshly blind guy, stand up, and then punch him, better yet, in almost every gunfight Negan sprayed a few bullets and then runs.
