Тёмный

"Netanyahu’s war is a year old, and Sinwar’s war has only just started" 

Middle East Eye
Подписаться 2,4 млн
Просмотров 82 тыс.
50% 1

In this op-ed, David Hearst, the editor-in-chief of Middle East Eye, reflects on the first year of the Gaza war, stating: “Netanyahu’s war is a year old and has no reverse gear. Sinwar’s war has only just started.”
Hearst argues that while Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s declared goals-crushing Hamas, securing the return of hostages, and reordering the Middle East-remain unmet, Hamas leader Yehia Sinwar’s strategy has ignited widespread Palestinian resistance. He adds, “This scale of suffering has never been visited on any previous generation of Palestinians,” yet despite the devastation, the spirit of resistance has only grown.
Hearst examines the regional and global consequences of the conflict as Israel finds itself increasingly isolated while Palestinian resilience drives the war into a new phase.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEas...
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye

Опубликовано:

 

8 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 625   
@zamokwakheluvuno5715
@zamokwakheluvuno5715 15 часов назад
Old school journalism... factual, straight to the point and unbiased
@media1166
@media1166 14 часов назад
Well said by this old man
@BabyIshii
@BabyIshii 11 часов назад
U mean fractured and misleading Yes it is
@saabajoe
@saabajoe 10 часов назад
​@@BabyIshiiTruth can be antisemitic at times.
@BabyIshii
@BabyIshii 10 часов назад
@@saabajoe yes it's antiSemitic becouse Israel said yes to two states and Palestinians never said so Maybe u growup n understand peace is two way process
@Bett344
@Bett344 10 часов назад
@@BabyIshiiyou make me laugh. So it’s then the Palestinians who don’t want a Palestinian state Don’t know wether you are fooling the whole world or yourself. Natanyahoo himself said he will never accept 2 states solution
@Sam81146
@Sam81146 16 часов назад
This man is one of the few good men left in the world thank you sir 🙏
@heinrichvon
@heinrichvon 17 часов назад
I always look forward to Hearst's analyses. He always clarifies where others obfuscate.
@OneSixSun
@OneSixSun 13 часов назад
💯
@valeriel9783
@valeriel9783 17 часов назад
Excellent analysis as usual. Facts. Causes and consequences.
@patrickbarry6335
@patrickbarry6335 17 часов назад
I support the people of Palestine and their right for justice and peace not ruled by Israel or the United States or anyone else!!!!!!!!
@elgrifolorian
@elgrifolorian 16 часов назад
From a native american always fight the power , free Palestine 👊
@afrobian1
@afrobian1 12 часов назад
Canadian here. All my First Nation friends had no idea about Palestinian issue. When I discuss it with them, they genuinely feel disgusted and express support to Palestinians. They can relate
@gregkle9384
@gregkle9384 9 часов назад
@@afrobian1you ve got to tell your friends that there isn’t specific Palestinian people,there are Palestinian Arabs,Palestinian Jews, Palestinian Christians etc. If Israel lost 1948 war these co called Palestinians would be Egyptians,Jordanians,Lebanese or Syrians and together with Jews,Christians and others who lived on geographical territory called Palestine would be citizens of these countries . 48-67 Egypt and Jordan controlled Gaza and Judea and Samaria and Palestinian Arabs didn’t establish Palestinian state.Why? Waiting for answer if you can manage
@Notveryimpressed
@Notveryimpressed 9 часов назад
Your apologism for Israel's genocide in Gaza exposes only your lack of morality.
@User-laiejwo5381
@User-laiejwo5381 6 часов назад
@@gregkle9384 "2018 marks 51 years since the occupation of the Palestinian Territory and 11 years of the Gaza blockade. Both the occupation and the blockade affect every aspect of life for Palestinians - *they dictate where they can live and study, and whom they can marry.* *The blockade has devastated Gaza’s economy, caused widespread destruction and left most people largely cut off from the outside world.* Today, one million Palestinians in Gaza don't have enough food to feed their families, despite receiving food assistance or other forms of support."
@User-laiejwo5381
@User-laiejwo5381 6 часов назад
@@gregkle9384 " *Israel’s residence permit policy amounts to prohibited discrimination* under Articles 2, paragraph 2, 23 and 26 ICCPR, and Articles 2, paragraph 2, and 10, paragraph 1, of the ICESCR - *Restrictions imposed by Israel on movement of Palestinians in the Occupied Palestinian Territory amount to prohibited discrimination* *Israel’s practice of demolition of Palestinian properties in the West Bank and in East Jerusalem, including punitive demolitions and demolitions for lack of building permit, amounts to prohibited discrimination* Israel’s legislation and measures impose and serve to maintain a near-complete separation in the West Bank and East Jerusalem between settler and Palestinian communities Israel’s legislation and measures constitute breach of Article 3 of CERD."
@redded7957
@redded7957 16 часов назад
What an analysis!!!! Hats off!!!
@mattroper7214
@mattroper7214 12 часов назад
I'm not wearing a hat. But if I was, I'd definitely follow your lead 😂
@mohammedosman2459
@mohammedosman2459 16 часов назад
After listening for 2 minutes, I have subscribed this channel.....A genuine analysis....World still has good human beings....
@auroralopezconsuegra4744
@auroralopezconsuegra4744 12 часов назад
Me gustaría escucharlo en español está gran persona ,y a otros muchos grandes personajes que veo en estos reportajes de Youtuve
@mangopapaya6376
@mangopapaya6376 9 часов назад
@@auroralopezconsuegra4744 You can try and use the automatic translation in the subtitles: Step 1: Open the RU-vid video you'd like to translate. Just at the bottom-right corner of the screen, you'll find the ‘CC/Subtitles' option. Click the ‘CC/subtitles’ button to turn on the closed captions, and RU-vid will automatically generate English captions. Step 2: Now, select the ‘Settings’ option - which is typically located next to ‘CC’ and then choose ‘Auto-translate.’ Step 3: Here, you'll see over 100 translation languages. Choose the one you wish and RU-vid will automatically translate the captions.
@ru76224
@ru76224 16 часов назад
*I don't know what's scarier.* _What's happening in the world right now, or the number of people who are okay with what is happening in the world right now._
@TI.T.O
@TI.T.O 16 часов назад
The dirty secret is the police and the military are heavily politicized and they have remote neural surveillance and use synthetic telepathy to influence everyone around you. Like minority report pre-crime is now a thing. They will do you dirty if you get on their corrupted shit they pull. We don't have any privacy anymore it's all to keep this false sense of worth and human rights are ignored by all militaries across the globe that outright lying to your face about everything. Your phone is a biometric device. It can read your mind and no one is even aware of it. Classified shit. It's why we need 5g. They are doing me so dirty and worked real hard for years to get me where they wanted me. They set me up in their apartment building. Fuck my life.
@stopitnow7762
@stopitnow7762 15 часов назад
😢
@MrRobsn89
@MrRobsn89 14 часов назад
This indeed.
@auroralopezconsuegra4744
@auroralopezconsuegra4744 12 часов назад
Definitivamente ,las personas que están de acuerdo ,dan terror ,
@Naomi-de2ps
@Naomi-de2ps 11 часов назад
Yes the living dead are amongst us.
@Wealth_Focus
@Wealth_Focus 16 часов назад
The global community stands in solidarity with the people of Palestine.
@Yunitoony1107
@Yunitoony1107 16 часов назад
No, it doesn't
@adriennestjohn4383
@adriennestjohn4383 15 часов назад
​@@Yunitoony1107 Want to bet?
@ChristopherHitchens3.14
@ChristopherHitchens3.14 15 часов назад
@@Yunitoony1107 It does, and one day you will find yourself standing on the wrong side of history!
@shahzikhan5132
@shahzikhan5132 15 часов назад
​@@Yunitoony1107everyone knows Israel is sinister
@s.m975
@s.m975 15 часов назад
​@@Yunitoony1107you're irrelevant as your comment
@jaywalker3087
@jaywalker3087 15 часов назад
Palestians have been trying to defend themselves since 1948 !!! How is that acceptable.... 🇬🇧❤️🇵🇸✌️
@BabyIshii
@BabyIshii 11 часов назад
They losing since 1948, and now they r eating ur hard earned money 🤡
@zehravesile
@zehravesile 9 часов назад
​@@BabyIshiilol....it is isra who is EATING their money ....!! Us sends her all tax payers money to isra😂😂😂😂......are u 4 real....
@BabyIshii
@BabyIshii 3 часа назад
@@zehravesile sinwar living 5 star hotel in Qatar ,Hamas has rockets to fire for over year And who is suffering? Palestinians civilians U literally think Palestine authority needs help ???
@sitirosnah7510
@sitirosnah7510 16 часов назад
Tuesday night in Malaysia. I am listening and watching David Hearst's analysis on netsnyahu one year old war with Hamas. This is my 4th lesson on geopolitic for today. Thank you Mr David for sharing your knowledge on the middle east conflicts with us.
@davidnagi5099
@davidnagi5099 15 часов назад
Why does everyone who speaks for the Palestinian cause seem so calm, so credible, so honest Yet anytime anybody defends Israel they're flustered, angry, scatty? Anybody with reasonable intelligence can watch any debate/podcast/UN speech, and clearly see which side is being honest without knowing a single thing about this conflict.
@auroralopezconsuegra4744
@auroralopezconsuegra4744 12 часов назад
Por qué tienen ,la fuerza de la razón ,no la razón de la fuerza ,como los opresores
@Iknowknow112
@Iknowknow112 12 часов назад
Same is true for MAGA supporters , always full of hatred against someone.
@Gwnniem1
@Gwnniem1 11 часов назад
Well seen.❤
@carridonn4149
@carridonn4149 9 часов назад
Thieves are always defensive and hasty
@kamaruddin9172
@kamaruddin9172 5 часов назад
Impossible to fake honesty.
@HassanAli-xl8kr
@HassanAli-xl8kr 17 часов назад
Long live Palestine
@ayeshatasneem7671
@ayeshatasneem7671 17 часов назад
From river to the sea, Palestine will be free, Inshaallah ta'ala...
@jcbw9975
@jcbw9975 10 часов назад
that is genocide remark wanting 9.9 mil people dead is mroe extreme. pro palestine are levelled with BLM
@lsrlsr7524
@lsrlsr7524 6 часов назад
That will never Happen your head is in the clouds. If the definition of that saying means Isreal and all inhabitants are dead or gone . That will never happen . By never it will not happen in anyone's lifetime that is alive on Earth today
@aamironline
@aamironline 16 часов назад
Indeed, perfect analysis!
@iqbalebrahim3318
@iqbalebrahim3318 16 часов назад
Superb analysis . BLESS YOU
@Peaceman1.
@Peaceman1. 17 часов назад
True Palestine people and Palestine children are winners 🏆🥇
@omarahmad9397
@omarahmad9397 16 часов назад
Thank you for all your efforts Mr Hearst
@ahmadrofiqi742
@ahmadrofiqi742 16 часов назад
Mr Hearst became my favorite analyst. Simple, strong and sharp explanation but hit very hard.
@falaknazzia
@falaknazzia 17 часов назад
May Allah bless this man for his analysis. Our prayers will be answered. For Almighty Allah is the all knowing who sees and remembers everything.
@genevieve4418
@genevieve4418 17 часов назад
The world stands with Palestine!!! Palestine shall NEVER die!!! From the river to the sea, Palestine shall be free!!! Viva la Resistance!!! Viva Palestine forever!!!
@oldphrt
@oldphrt 16 часов назад
In your dreams.
@adnamallerom4137
@adnamallerom4137 16 часов назад
@@oldphrtnah, it’s a reality! And it’s closer than you think!
@bambukoinnovations
@bambukoinnovations 16 часов назад
​@@oldphrtzioz are the ones dreaming that they're gonna remain as a 'state'
@namei8967
@namei8967 15 часов назад
​@@adnamallerom4137 even not in your wildest dreams!
@harrybaulz666
@harrybaulz666 15 часов назад
Hahaha hahaha
@mkh_alo
@mkh_alo 16 часов назад
Why the mainstream media are not doing the same analysis : Facts > Causes > Consequences.
@mimicocto
@mimicocto 15 часов назад
They are not paid for that. They are existing to share propaganda for highest bidder.
@dottester3039
@dottester3039 13 часов назад
Not their job anymore. Questions lead to no job in that industry owned by several people.
@afrobian1
@afrobian1 12 часов назад
Because they are bought and silenced by Zionists. In other words they sold their conscience for printed paper bills.
@auroralopezconsuegra4744
@auroralopezconsuegra4744 12 часов назад
Por qué están vendidos o son sionistas
@BabyIshii
@BabyIshii 11 часов назад
Palestinians gonna live lavish life in other countries After all this end And whoever paid them gonna work 24x7 This is biggest scam in history
@abahafandi8675
@abahafandi8675 16 часов назад
Objective and absllutely right
@myrtillesm3532
@myrtillesm3532 16 часов назад
Thank you so much for your humanity Self- determination and sovereignty for all Palestinians amen💝🇦🇪💝🇦🇪💝
@loneranger4469
@loneranger4469 16 часов назад
Beautifully said...👏👏👏
@Myliberationbaby
@Myliberationbaby 17 часов назад
I always appreciate your insights
@abrahamsasa3439
@abrahamsasa3439 16 часов назад
Thanks for the brilliant report
@faizaambah
@faizaambah 16 часов назад
Amazing summary. Thank you 🙏❤️
@ibtesamhussein1821
@ibtesamhussein1821 17 часов назад
Well said 👍
@abdjamil5287
@abdjamil5287 15 часов назад
you are 100% right
@azizahsattar444
@azizahsattar444 17 часов назад
Excellent analysis ♥️
@sabrinayounisaden7238
@sabrinayounisaden7238 17 часов назад
Thank you sir.
@OneSixSun
@OneSixSun 13 часов назад
As always, Mr Hearst, a sound, reasoned and strong analysis. MEE's reportage this past year has been a beacon of integrity, reason and clarity. I thank you, as always, for staying the course. Godspeed and more power to you and the team.
@bettyboop-xg6jo
@bettyboop-xg6jo 15 часов назад
Bless you Mr Hearst for your clear words.
@HassanAli-xl8kr
@HassanAli-xl8kr 17 часов назад
Excellent analysis
@naderanwary3912
@naderanwary3912 6 часов назад
So perfectly said. Thank you 👍
@kailashpatel1706
@kailashpatel1706 17 часов назад
The key element is Syria...Its armed forces and strategic depth that Russia is helping to rebuild is critical here..
@sonyjoseph5426
@sonyjoseph5426 14 часов назад
Thus explains the dirty war in the Syria since 2014
@wessoz
@wessoz 16 часов назад
Always spot on. Thank you
@drmuhammadmoazzamkhan7989
@drmuhammadmoazzamkhan7989 17 часов назад
According to Ur analytical words u have expressed on the comparison of goals achieved by Netanyahu and Sinwar,s strategy clearly shows that in this long lasting battle Yahya Sinwar is the ultimate winner whether he is dead or alive in this path full of thorns....
@abc-mf8rr
@abc-mf8rr 16 часов назад
Bravo❤
@najwaalsadi
@najwaalsadi 6 часов назад
Beautiful words and logical, thank u!!
@SDarkVader
@SDarkVader 14 часов назад
A wise and unbiased voice in the age of lies and deceit. Who else is tired of "Narratives" vs truth?
@vemusiapitjiumbua2348
@vemusiapitjiumbua2348 9 часов назад
Well articulated and unbiased
@harishjoshi7610
@harishjoshi7610 12 часов назад
What a wonderful analysis. Bravo👍
@AliDogoto
@AliDogoto 11 часов назад
Top notch journalism.... Havnt heard it in awhile
@afghaneagle9255
@afghaneagle9255 10 часов назад
very honest journalism, Thankyou sir z
@anorthedge4422
@anorthedge4422 12 часов назад
Excellent. A very nice clear analysis of the situation from Hearst.
@Astro78196
@Astro78196 15 часов назад
Thank you for your analysis. Be able to finish. It is a very good review of the current situation.
@farukkarim9558
@farukkarim9558 15 часов назад
I'm always impressed with the in-depth and overarching analysis by David Hearst. Incredible! I hope the continues for a long day 😊🙏🏿
@nerimarasool6836
@nerimarasool6836 16 часов назад
You underestimate the person who has nothing to lose except their lives and faith.
@jicarsltd
@jicarsltd 16 часов назад
Brilliant analysis !!
@fatimanishat196
@fatimanishat196 14 часов назад
This is journalism and it gives a hope to humanity and peace Salute you people for your profession and dedication to fight for the truth, God bless you with guidance and strength
@TPSforlife
@TPSforlife 11 часов назад
They spent 75 years building a lie and 12 months dismantling it.
@MIchaelDaniels-q3c
@MIchaelDaniels-q3c 4 часа назад
True
@akbarhussain8249
@akbarhussain8249 10 часов назад
Exactly. You have spoken the truth Sir
@rennkoop7317
@rennkoop7317 16 часов назад
👌stated, clear & spot on !
@yussufabdulhameed2558
@yussufabdulhameed2558 9 часов назад
What an astonishing analysis
@SaidQuarashee
@SaidQuarashee 13 часов назад
You are the real humanity supporter God Bless you
@smschwab
@smschwab 11 часов назад
Outstanding!
@massabmiharbi7931
@massabmiharbi7931 16 часов назад
I've always read David Hearst writings from the times he wrote about the invasion in Lebanon 1982 to now. He is always right, a none zionist jew has my admiration 😤 👏
@afshanfatima5104
@afshanfatima5104 13 часов назад
Thats the best analysis of this assymetrical war on it’s anniversary
@moldymush
@moldymush 17 часов назад
A 1 year temper tantrum
@michaelanukam3314
@michaelanukam3314 13 часов назад
Well said without propaganda.
@emilysilver9844
@emilysilver9844 6 часов назад
I loved your analysis thank you so much
@datumonircalim2116
@datumonircalim2116 15 часов назад
Thank you Sir for fair analysis
@divergent2thinker
@divergent2thinker 15 часов назад
1000000000000000000000000% accurate analysis
@RRaae-e6f
@RRaae-e6f 9 часов назад
Experience outweighs delusions of grandeur
@Ummati40
@Ummati40 9 часов назад
Sounds very right.
@islandknight6105
@islandknight6105 2 часа назад
I just listened to a very smart man. Time well spent. ☮️✝️☪️
@leevanderlans6854
@leevanderlans6854 16 часов назад
Thanks
@WendyCobb-kl7ns
@WendyCobb-kl7ns 13 часов назад
So well said ser. TY for the hopeful and informative update!
@moow950
@moow950 15 часов назад
100% right analysis!
@puyorcuyor
@puyorcuyor 14 часов назад
Beautifully put!
@mavrinyhta
@mavrinyhta 15 часов назад
Well spoken, sir!
@halahamam7617
@halahamam7617 16 часов назад
A voice of truth, God bless you
@masoomsanadi
@masoomsanadi 14 часов назад
It seems Nethanyhu has no intention of getting hostages back.
@haslindaismail9948
@haslindaismail9948 16 часов назад
Exactly 💯
@rocketshoot3027
@rocketshoot3027 15 часов назад
Mossad took 32 years to assassinate Nasrallah, who resided just a few km away.
@seanpol9863
@seanpol9863 14 часов назад
Is it also odd that they can locate Nasrallah and Ismail Haniyeh but not the hostages? 🤔
@Athos0817
@Athos0817 16 часов назад
Good analysis
@mohammaduddin966
@mohammaduddin966 10 часов назад
Verily well explained
@sandrajensen497
@sandrajensen497 16 часов назад
Brilliant analysis!
@andypeutherer4218
@andypeutherer4218 16 часов назад
Bang on.
@CuriousBorg
@CuriousBorg 10 часов назад
Excellent as always. Thank you.
@imaduddeen4269
@imaduddeen4269 13 часов назад
Good analysis.
@mazharbhatti1294
@mazharbhatti1294 16 часов назад
Mashallah Very good analysis
@AmirhoseinZolfaghari
@AmirhoseinZolfaghari 15 часов назад
Hope for a world clear from Apartheid
@Life78472
@Life78472 15 часов назад
Brilliant analysis 👏 👌 👍
@MD-qy4fo
@MD-qy4fo 16 часов назад
Your each words. Respecr❤
@r3sistorserve939
@r3sistorserve939 16 часов назад
Make duaa for all of our brothers and sisters that are resisting the devil and his amry. 🤲
@naziirani2773
@naziirani2773 16 часов назад
Brilliant!!
@sparkle06
@sparkle06 9 часов назад
Perfect analysis
@candelariadelazar4390
@candelariadelazar4390 14 часов назад
Al hamdullah. Great analysis, with which I agree 100%.
@stevejoro7339
@stevejoro7339 9 часов назад
Facts
@usamalhr
@usamalhr Час назад
Long live the resistance against oppression
@Bennybeef2
@Bennybeef2 12 часов назад
Well said!
@enasali5354
@enasali5354 5 часов назад
Facts Pray for Palestinians not to lose their hope and strength
@kamaruddin9172
@kamaruddin9172 5 часов назад
They should think twice before declaring a war with someone name SinWAR.
@Nanny53
@Nanny53 12 часов назад
May Allah make the Palestinian stronger than ever before and give them saber🇵🇸❤️🤲🏾 Yaa Allah the Palestinian have no one except you ☝️make their iman stronger Yaa rab .
@Quranclinics
@Quranclinics 2 часа назад
The only video on RU-vid i've watched from beginning to end for the first time....god bless you!
@mohammadjassim6973
@mohammadjassim6973 6 часов назад
Long live the resistance!
Далее
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41
Israel Hamas war: how Oct 7 changed the Middle East
37:32