Both are gorgeous but if I had to pick one, it has to be the Vantage. That design looks better every single time I see it. I didn't care about it at first but the spec I have seen some people come up with. Honestly, I think it's one of the best looking cars in the past decade maybe even.
I built a beautiful one on their site. Dark green with bronze livery, wheels and calipers. Dark green and bitter chocolate leather with the dark green carbon fiber inside. Looks amazing!
I love how Aston Martin had a full configurator for it the day it was launched, meanwhile the AMG was announced like 3 months ago & you still can’t do a build & price in North America
Mercedes website utterly sucks! So many of the newer vehicles can't be configured yet. Some that are even on the lots! Plus, the interface is horrible. They need a full redesign of the site.
Glad I’m not the only one who has been thinking the same thing… It’s wild that not even the CLE coupe is on its configurator! Even BMW had the new X2 and 5 series on the their configurator within a couple of days of their announcement (even if configuring the new 5 series burns my eyes)
Not a big deal, a serious buyer goes to the dealership and badaboom done in a minute. Configurator is a nice to have, makes no impact on buying decision.
You can go on other countries' website, although you won't get accurate pricing and some, if not most, options won't be available or will already be on the car.
While both cars look amazing, the choice isn't even close. The Aston Martin has more road presence in looks and by name. When someone says Aston Martin it's almost as if a monocle arrives. 🧐
@@OldSkoolUncleChris "the Aston drives Like a truck compared to the Mercedes" - And you know this how?? The new vantage has a lot of improvements in electronics, chassis etc.
Based on the interior alone I much prefer the Aston’s more traditional design and more restrained infotainment screen. Based on exterior design both are gorgeous but the Mercedes is more sinister while the Aston is sexier, so again I would have to go with the Aston.
Probably the easiest choice ever...Vantage all day. Without question the most beautiful car in this segment (911, AMG GT, R8, etc.), and just more "special" than the AMG GT. It's even better looking than the Roma and POSSIBLY the DB12 (I'd have to ponder that one, though)
No it doesn’t. They’re using a mercedes engine bc they can’t produce one. Nothing special about an English brand using a German engine. Quality wise Brits suck and shamelessly ask ridiculous prices for their scam cars.
Aston Martin any day of the week...the Mercedes is certainly a good looking car but it can't touch the Aston Martin for road presence, not to mention the kudos and prestige that comes with the Aston Martin brand ...stunning redesign...well done Aston Martin 👌👏👏👏
I would prefer the Aston in this example although I like the Mercedes just as much and I own a Mercedes. And it’s just because of the branding that’s all. Aston is just something a little bit special where as the Mercedes brand is known for exotic cars yes but also little hatchbacks and trucks or in other words they are everywhere. Where as an Aston is only known for one thing being a thoroubred sports car
Same here. I have an AMG S63 Cab which is an amazing car: S-Class quiet and smooth when things are mellow, but a beast when you wake up that motor. Love it, but I would have the Aston for its design if I could get away with that politically in my family (can't explain further on the internet). The Aston is the best design of any car on the road now. None of the Ferraris look as good.
Aston knocked it out of the park with the styling. They always do. But I would never buy one new. They depreciate so fast unless its a super limited model. I almost bought a V12 Vantage S with a manual gearbox. I just love the timeless Henrik Fisker design. Its just elegant, yet sporty. Ultimately, I went with the Gen 1 R8 V10 instead but would love to add a Vantage to my stable at some point!
"looking at the side view..." Aston Martin - no contest. Why? Because my eyes are connected to my brain. The Aston is significantly purer and more cohesive in its overall proportions and - just as importantly - in its details! This is the best Aston yet, in my opinion - and one that won't age like the pretty but less resolved, and much less pure in it's detailing, Mercedes. And don't get me started on the disco-ball, screen-disaster, interior of the Mercedes - yeesh!
I live in south Florida and I see the AMG GT everywhere in every color including Solar-beam yellow, yes they are all outstanding looking. I rarely see any Vantages or any model by Aston driving around with the frequency I see AMG’s. As long as the reliability is similar, you should absolutely go with Aston. Secondhand resell market confirms this choice when it comes time for resell. If you reside in a winter snow climate maybe you should consider the awd AMG option.
Hello I just discovered your channel and I think it’s awesome. Very educational. I wondered if you want to shed some thoughts on the Octavia facelift? The lightning change is very controversial. Cheers!
The Mercedes probably compares more closely to the DB12 rather than the Vantage due to the rear seats as they're bigger GT cars with longer wheelbases.
@@eatonleo He never mentioned the actual wheelbases, but here's the data: Wheelbase(W) | Length(L) 2024 AMG GT (Coupe): W = 106.3" | L = 186.1" 2025 Aston Martin Vantage: W = 106.5" | L = 176.9" 2024 Aston Martin DB12: W = 110.4" | L = 186.0" So it looks like the wheelbase is the same but the overall size is more comparable to the DB12. The Vantage is about a foot shorter than the other 2.
The Aston is amazing looking and design wise, I agree with you both exterior and interior are better, but a GT is supposed to be good for road trips. With only 12 cubic ft of storage in the back, and no rear seat, you won't be taking more than a couple of overnight bags in the Vantage. Even the new DB12 boot is about the same size, but at least it's got back seats you could throw some bags into. The AMG GT has 25 cubic ft of storage and the back seats fold down. So I'd rather have the AMG just because you could actually take luggage on a trip.
the rear looks better on the Mercedes because the Wing on the Vantage destroys a little the rear , I agree. but other than that, I like the more aggresive sporty design lines on the Vantage
I think I'd pick Mercedes. I loved previous Vantage, but I can't get over how they restyled the front. I simply don't like it as much. AMG GT is kinda in the same vein, but it's design works more for me, and interior feels less cluttered.
It’s crazy how we both have different outlooks. I said I would get a vantage if they redesigned the front and brought back those circular headlights like a traditional Aston should have which is like there trademark instead of those small ugly headlights that make it look like a fish ! Literally a month ago I was telling a buddy “ they change the front and keep that sexy rear and Redesign the interior because it’s dated I got a new dream car” . 😮
I prefer the distinct, yet comparatively subtle, design of the Mercedes. The lines all work together in a way that won't potentially look gimmicky in 20 years. I can just imagine an AMG GT Black version. 🤤 Honestly though, I don't the need to tribalize one over the other. The Aston is growing on me each time I see it. The grill still looks BIG. The past 10 years feels as if we're prisons experiencing Stockholm Syndrom with this unfortunate industry trend. I also don't care much for the duck tail. More specifically, the lockstep taillight treatment. The tandem seem out of place with the rest of the long bending lines? Maybe just too present, and if toned back and made a touch curvier, it would be more cohesive? IDK. Still, it's a stunner.
I would pick the Aston. 3 years ago I would’ve picked the Merc due to the bad infotainment built into the Vantage. With the new huge and kinda ugly screens in the Mercedes it is just too much.
When I saw the new Vantage I instantly thought about a baby One-77, which is my favourite design of Aston so far. Now with the AMG in comparison, I now also know why I very much liked that one when it came out. Both have similar cheeks. Such timeless beauty :)
Mercedes changed the long hood /sitting on the rear axle design for AWD but it’s missed ..Vantage in comparison skipped leg day from the side and back IMO & is too small for tall drivers 💯
I am just about to take delivery in April of the Mercedes AMG GT. The cost is £176k. Having looked at the Aston this week, and comparing the spec like for like. To have the Aston in a similar spec baring in mind the Aston does not have ceramic brakes as standard the cost of the Aston would be ££226k.
Front grill and headlights: Mercedes Side view: Tie Rear view: Mercedes Interior driver steering area: Mercedes Interior screen panel: Aston Martin Name cache: Aston Martin
Has to be the aston. Both amazing cars, both have great features, good looking, and will ultimately make you happy. But knowing you have an aston, when people ask what you drive, and even a 95 year old woman knows the power of that badge. The interior finish. I personally own a 2014 aston martin vanquish. it's amazing. With my personal plates, it genuinely looks brand new. I went for skyfall silver because bond. Had it 12 months, and I still struggle to walk into any shop without turning around for another quick glance before i go inside. I can only imagine how amazing driving a brand new aston would feel. These cars definitely attract 25-80 year old men, btw. Every time you go for fuel, you will have to answer questions and show someone the interior. All part of the fun.
Also the headlights on the Benz look WAY better. What a BEAUTIFUL machine. looks like a sculpture. Im done venting lol. The Aston looks like an expensive vacuum cleaner.
The Aston is 100% the better looking car. There's something weird about the Mercedes that I can't put my finger on, but It feels like the same kind of weird as the terrible coupe SUVs they insist on doing.
LOVED my 2017 Jaguar F-Type R coupe as it's AWD system was really, really, REALLY good and made me a much better driver than I am inherently. Given the choice, I'd probably opt for the AWD Merc GT Coupe ...
The fact that people can just get that AMG grill from eBay and put it on any old C class really is a problem for Mercedes because it makes the AMG GT a lot less special.
Both great looking cars, but the boot on the Aston Martin looks like it has sad eyes. I prefer the boot on the Mercedes. The Aston is my preference everywhere else.
Cool comparison! I will choose the Aston as well! Just need some inspiration how to spec this car! Can you give me your idea? The configurator is so much overloaded! Thanks so much!
I could give you some ideas! I’ll share some configurator codes: My personal spec would be this: 0982KBCNB3 With a little bronze twist in it: 4JTBJ51NMW (this one would work in nearly any color, just change the stitching to something similar to the paint, for example Magnetic Silver with light Argento or titanium grey stitching) This would be as classic as it gets: ZU7WUXXEPW I’m guessing most will spec like this or similar: A9TWEZQ4PR (could also change to Seychelles blue which is more elegant, as well as pretty much any other color. But here as well, change the stitching and the carbon then!) I hope I could help you. Please let me know what you think!! It would be a dream coming true to see my own specs of such dream cars coming into reality
Speaking design, the back end of the Merc looks like they were spending too much time looking at crosstown rival Porsche. Of course the Aston b-pillars on recent cars and this one particularly look like they had a classic Mustang or Aussie Falcon in their studio (or a recent Camaro), though perhaps they think they’re referring to the Zagato
I have a problem paying over $200k for a car from a manufacturer who produces others models that are a quarter of the price. Very few people will look twice at the Mercedes. This factor alone makes the Aston Martin more desirable. Put this to one side and look at it purely from the point of view of which car looks better and the Aston Martin still wins. The front of the Mercedes suffers from the drooping snout appearance that the previous Aston suffered from and the haunches look much more athletic on the Aston.
Jeez dude, am I not seeing something in the Aston? It doesn't look anywhere near as sexy and elegant as the Mercedes. It just looks more put together, classy and sexy. I am not saying this as a fanboy, but truly from the bottom of the heart, within a heartbeat I take the Benz.
The AMG actually dynos at much higher than 577. My SL63 dynos at 620HP with the same engine configuration. I would love to get the Aston but all wheel drive is a must for Canada to be a true daily. A shame
This time I disagree. The Vantage looks too busy. There is too much going on, all kinds of lines, especailly at the rear, the accent color in yellow, plasticy (gloss) interior. The AMG looks much more mature, especially outside of the racing track, and is more refined. My two cents ofcourse.
Shame that Mercedes did not do something better to the engine since the AMG GTR restyling. It is a shame that AMG is letting a brand like Aston Martin show how to actually do an engine that has power and fun factor. Why the anemic 585 hp? Why?????
the new amg gt is good in a vacuum, i think it's a very beautiful car by itself. but compared to its predecessors, this is NOT an amg gt imo. the major selling point for the amg gt in the past in terms of deisgn was the elongated hood. the new gt losing that lost its value for me. vantage is just better in every way in terms of design as well imo.
This facelift just cemented everything I wanted out of the Vantage. When they released gen 2 I immediately fell in love with everything about its aesthetic but in particular - the rear end. Those lines of the duck lip and brake lights was totally new and I felt it to be such a fresh option compared to the DB which was also too large for my liking. But the front end is what let it down. It lost that AM vernacular which speaks so much heritage through the lights and grille. So all I wanted was for them to bring on this more traditional face and they just did. I think I’m half a decade from being able to afford a used one which will be my first ever dream car. It’s gonna happen!
Aston Martin without a doubt. Design,Interior, RWD.. AMG looks a bit like a (cheap) copy of the 911 which- as a turbo variant - starts at a similar price tag & comparable performance. Sadly I am not convinced about the AMG,and thats coming frome a german guy...
