New One Piece Fans REACT to ONE PIECE Netflix Live Action Trailer! 

The author is heavily involved in this project. Considering how the other live actions went.

Regarding the author, Oda is heavily involved in this production, from the casting until now. The production team has promised that they would not release this show until Oda gives an okay. And Oda cares very much for this. Prior to this live action, he was already approached by others but he rejected them until Matt Owen, a huge OP fan and the showrunner of this live action pitched his idea to him, which Oda finally agreed. So in terms of the story being ruined, I think we don't need to worry. Some things need to be changed to fit the medium but they will be very faithful to it. Matt Owen would never ruin the story that means a lot to him. He wanted to produce this live action because he loves OP so much. As an OP fan since 2010 and have been following the news on the live action since it was announced in 2016/17 without fail, I need to spread the positivity, correct the misinformation if any, and let the new people know that the people who are involved in this production, including Oda, are very passionate with this project. And about the Nami scene, it was already changed in the anime by heaps. In the manga, Nami was first introduced in the Buggy's arc, never before that. So the changed made in the live adaption is pretty justified I'll say.

The reason I think Nami is introduced earlier than the manga/anime is because Oda wanted it that way. In the original manga, an editor convinced him to save females for later or something, because the target audience relates with males, and I understand that Oda didn't like that he went along with it. The live action will be a universe where Oda gets to change things he might not like, so change can be good! Another example of this is that Luffy's flashback with Shanks in the manga was chapter 1, but the anime stuck it in a bit later, so the live action will be closer to the manga than the anime.

Just remember that Oda, the creator is working heavily with this. He asked straight out why is Luffy wearing shoes! They then said its because of safety, wich Oda totally agreed on. Stuff that works in anime might not even be possible in real life, or straight out dangerous for the actors. Oda has even said that if he is not happy or feel like something is missing, he will NOT give this a OK good to go. So the fact that he says OK👍 says alot From the scenes its season 1 in the anime, so the first 60 ish episodes

Fun fact, the actor cast as Cabaji (unicycle dude) is a professional circus acrobat. They have the stuff, that's just one example of good casting.

Let me tell you some details Biggest thing is the author of One Piece , Oda is all the way involved in making this . He himself hand picked the characters for this . And it is said that the quality is gonna be Avengers Endgame level . It is also said by Oda himself that until he was satisfied with everything he wasn't letting them make progress through stuff . Second biggest detail for you as you asked why can't they make a literal copy of anime and manga well I disagree to you because that way in real life A LOT of stuff becomes cringe and stuff , especially with a manga or anime like One Piece which has a lot of goofy characters and stuff . Think of Luffy being over dumb in real life , that would make the whole thing way cringe . Third big detail which A LOT of people miss here is Oda is bringing One Piece in real life not only for manga fans or anime fans . He stated himself that this might be the only chance for him to make One Piece known world wide so off course here and there some stuff may change but the story is gonna go on the same route . So remember this watching One Piece in manga vs anime vs real life are all gonna have their own impacts and stuff . Now fourth is that people have mixed feelings for this as people are afraid that it might fail . Because in the past there are some animes like Dragon Ball Z , Death Note , Cowboy Bepop and even Attack on Titan that also have live adaption but they were not good at all . But the person named Oda has never let his fandom down so we all have faith in him .

I love how they are only 14 episodes in and even they realize Luffy is out of character. 😂

Keep in mind this is early crew - when Nami and Zoro didn't get along, Nami was cold towards Luffy, Zoro and Luffy were still getting used to each other. It's going to be fine. It won't be a 1:1 copy, but it shouldn't be. It'll be its own thing and that's good! Also, with Oda on the floor it'll be fine. If we wanted the exact same experience, we could just read the manga or watch the anime. Also, you guys are saying it's too fast? It's literally a 1:30 min _teaser_ ! Of an 8 hour show. Of course it's going to be different, but different isn't bad. And Luffy has always been goofy when he's not mean mugging.

About some of your questions. This live action will adapt the first saga of One Piece that consist in 6 arcs. You guys at least in youtube are currently watching Syrup Village, the 3/6 arc in the saga. And no, this isn't the first live action anime adaptation but is one of the few that people are actually hyped for. Almost all live action adaptations are bad but this one is quite promising.

It always get better and better everytime i watch the trailer, in my opinion the Live action will be good but not as good not as legendary as the Anime, Anime is still the best

You guys should watch the Speed Racer live-action adaption, it was made by the same people that did The Matrix, and its one of the few genuinely good live-action adaptions!

Live action adaptations of anime are rather common actually, maybe once twice a year.

The OP Live Action Season has 8 Episodes a 45 to 60 Minutes Long : is only The East Blue Saga Arc / Chapter 1-102 Or First 62 Episodes ( Startet on 31 August 2023)

The reason why Ussop didn’t have a nose, Sanji not having his curly eyebrows and the crew’s dialogue is because they are keeping things real. If you make the live action look exactly like the characters from the anime, it’s gonna look goofy and basically just like a cosplay, I know the dialogue’s from the crew are different to how they are in the anime but you just can’t transfer anime comedy to real life, it doesn’t work. There are only a few things real life can do but in anime you can do anything because it’s a drawing and it looks natural, it looks normal but you just can’t easily do that in real life. Anime has their elements and real life has their elements that’s why the straw hats have kind of a different chemisty together so yeah keep that in mind. Imo it’s better this way because it’s more realistic I mean look at Cowboy Bebop for ex. They literally replicated everything from the anime that’s why it looked so goofy like 100% took it out of the anime and didn’t change a thing, that’s why these changes are amazing and I absolutely love it.

It was a little hilarious to hear you complain about the Nami involvement in the marine base - because the anime changed it first. She was never seen in the manga before Orange Town.

I have hope for live action, anime can't be replace but ...We never want anime in real life, We want a good anime adaptation in real life.

This is going to cover the whole east blue saga. If this will be well received season 2 will be the Alabasta saga. Whole season will be 1 saga. One piece isn’t defined by seasons but by sagas, it’s like a saga is equivalent to 1 book if it’s in novel form.

why is my guy sounding like hes watched hundreds of episodes but hes only on episode 14 somehow

I know nothing about One Piece I know nothing aside from the name but this looks like it might be fun

Ive watch lot of reaction, a lot of them like the line of th 3 crew, their dynamic is so strawhat. Imagine after they said not a crew" and luffy laugh?

Like what a lot of other comments are saying, Oda (the author) is very caring and protective of his work so most if not all of the stuff is done is with his approval. Also there other anime live action adaptations but the good to bad ratio is very bad. However there are some bad adaptations that are guilty pleasures for some people, so to each their own. As for recommendations- Initial D, One Punch Man, and Miss Kobayashi’s Dragon Maid.

This is just a teaser, maybe we soon find out more in the next trailer

Season 1 is gonna be 8 Episodes: From the start to Arlong Park (Episode 44) or at MOST the end of the East Blue Saga (Episode 53). SInce ya'll didn't recognize the blond guy, I think you haven't gotten there yet. Here's the thing tho: The ORIGINAL CREATOR Eichiiro Oda, who writes and makes One Piece to this day, had the final say in litarally EVERYTHING. He even had the power to stop the whole Show from launching until he was satisfied... So I have faith! As for Luffy's dialogue, I imagine that they had to give him a few more brain cells before Ussop and the others join... Just so an american audience doesn't find him unlikable and thinks of him as a kid trying to play pirate before he makes it... Which is still kinda his vibe! So long as the fights look good and he's allowed to be brutal, Iñaki Godoy has my FULL faith!

" i sense a little bit of tension in the crew" is so....luffy would NOT say that bruh

Dead Note Had a Live Action Season too and Dragon Ball movie Live Action

One piece doesnt have seasons, but it has sagas. So one season of the live action will cover one saga of the anime

Yeah it won’t be the same, they did say it’s an adaptation not a reboot of the anime/manga. There will be some differences here and there, but I hope they don’t change it too much or add some stuff that would be ignored later on.

I do understand your concerns. Adaptations are tricky to do well. But I remember when people said adapting fantasy novels to live action was impossible and adapting superheroes was impossible. I believe it can be done. Even if One Piece is the show that proves it to the world that manga can be adapted into live action, there will be good and bad adaptations in the future. But I have hope here. Like you said, sets and costumes look good. They do have a different actor for Kuro, they have found an actor/unicyclists for Moji. As for the dialogue, it is hard to judge with just a few lines, but I think they are building on the character traits that remain consistent over the course of 1000 chapters and they are just highlighting some of the characteristics that become more obvious later in East Blue, and maybe shifting the nuances a little based on which elements of the characters the writers and actors are best able to portray. This happens with good and bad adaptations so I hope you still give the series a chance. I do have a few concerns still, but I have a lot of hope that this series will be fun and interesting to watch.

nami was supposed to be the first crew member in the altor's head she would even have a mechanical arm LOL

honestly don't mind if they cut stuff from the anime... actually I don't mind if the anime cut stuff from the anime

Psycho pass, demon slayer, hunter x hunter, steins Gate, full metal, jujutsu kaisen

Oda is heavily involved. just think of the series as something Oda would have done in a different dimension.

About Chopper, the reindeer, if the CGI is good, that can be easily done, think about Pikachu in detective pikachu or Sonic in Sonic the film, they were perfect (also the show stops at logue town, so the reindeer will not be here, because it stops at episode 50 more or less) I'm curios, I'm definitely going to watch it knowing this has to be differnt from the manga, because a copy it will end in a failure, it has to be different, but faithful to the original story, like setting and behavior of the characters. If the authors are able to unite fantasy and reality in the right way to not make it cringe, then it's already a success

I love how you're only 14 episodes in and you're already like 'he wouldn't say that!' about the 'I sense a little tension amongst the crew', like the rest of the fandom 😂 There are quite a few live-action version of anime, but generally they are pretty bad... But as a major One Piece fan, I am already pleasantly surprised. (still a little sceptic but... getting carefully positive). They will probably cut some little things out/change little things, but Oda, the author of One Piece is closely working together with the crew of this Live Action, so that's definitely a positive thing. Like, the important bits will stay. And I don't think they will merge arcs, but the first arcs are probably not gonna be more than 1 episode (but longer than an anime episode). Also the actors are major One Piece fans, especially Luffy and Nami. Anyway, I was hoping you'd react to the trailer, but I did not dare suggesting it because there are a few things in there that you haven't seen in the anime yet.

What people have got to remember is that Live action adaptations of anime/manga can't be 100% accurate to the source material: there are limitations with what we can do in RL and with a set budget. The team behind this have tried to be as faithful to the manga as they possible can and you can see it in the costumes, set pieces and casting. The haters just shit on this without considering those factors or know about the behind the scenes news. It really pisses me off. Oda senei is the exec producer for this show and has the final say on what he approves of and doesn't to go into live action. This teaser looks good and generally i'm seeing a 65/35% in favor for this adaptation.

They don't know Sanji yet lol

A little more information about this live action is it will only go on for I think 11-12 episodes, every episode is about 45 minutes to an hour and they will release per week just like a regular anime schedule to keep hype. Now about the story itself, it is canon and it will take the story from the manga itself, if I remember correctly the live action series will cover episode 1-60 of the one piece anime and it will end when the straw hats go to the grand line and meet Laboon. If the live action becomes a hit and it succeeds maybe they will make a season 2.

There are atleast 7 other anime live action movie/series

I think luffy is like don’t give a fuck a guy and that leadership dialogue there is soo not him the talk person suppose to be like nami or zoro 😅

The English dub doesn’t sound anything like the actors here but that’s ok. I like that they don’t. Just like I feel the anime dub is just as good as the sub.

This is Oda's last chance to make One Piece goes worldwide. Even tho the manga is most selling in japan with 5 millions of copies but they can't beat Naruto that already known worldwide

To find out if this gonna work or not is pretty simple, because we already have all the benchmarks before us: -watch Death Note anime, then watch the Netflix adaptation. -watch Cowboy Bebop anime, then watch the Netflix adaptation. -watch Dragon Ball anime, then watch Dragon Ball Evolution adaption. And even the live actions produced by the Japanese themselves are also as miserable, which shows that all of it can and will go wrong even without a cultural gap, like Fullmetal alchemist or Attack on titan. What works perfectly in anime and manga simply won't work in a movie. Especially when the world and the characters are so animated and caricature like one piece. Instead you have to witness a bunch of millennial cosplayers speaking in monotone uninterested voices filmed with a dull mexican filter. Which part of this screams "one piece" exactly? Oda specifically designs characters so exaggerated so that the reader could feel what that character is all about from just a glance. But here we have a bunch of normal looking people doing normal things and that's it. They even removed Usopp's nose and Sanji's eyebrow to make it more realistic and grounded. Yeah, because one piece is all about realism and being normal.. Somehow they still left Buggy's red nose which is his real nose btw. Consistency much? I'm not even starting about all the craziness that will start happening later in the series. Will all of them also be reduced to just normal people without any features? I'm surprised Chopper will be fully cgi (oh god, the horror!) instead of just making Dwayne Johnson play him in a deer suit with his nose tip painted blue. Because at this point I won't be surprised any more. Even after all this there are somehow people who still think "but this time is different" Sure.. This live action adaptation will be nothing but a compilation of aha moments, so you could yell "oh, I remember that from the anime/manga" every 10 seconds. Forget about any world building or character development in this adaptation. Also everything will be loud and in your faceblike in LazyTown, and everything will be "tell don't show", because in the west subtleness is not a known concept. You can already see where this is going and who it's aimed at because the dialogue resembles the bickering you see in MCU movies and where everyone is just an assholes to each other. This whole production is so un-One Piece, ugh.. The worst part is that this may actually have the opposite effect. Instead of inviting new fans it can cause damage by staining the one piece name and turn potential fans off even more from the series. For example many people who don't watch anime at all tried to watch the Attack on Titan live action adaptation and came to the conclusion that they were right all along about anime sucking in general and that all anime fans are just some mentally challenged weirdos for liking something like this.

I agree about Luffy but you need to have Luffy conversational dialogue or it will sound fake it can’t replicate anime dialogue. Then it would be bad ass dialogue in Amazon lord rings that’s my though.

I think this is going to be a bit of a mixture between filler and Canon cause we don't see some of these scenes in diffrent orders. The costuming like luffy's shirt in that one scene was new so maybe that part is filler. I don't know I'm just guessing. Now the bigger question is if we change the audio on Netflix will it be the original voice actors in Japanese???

dialogue didn't bother me at all. Ive rewatched the show so many time and honestly I just saw it as the characters in a different medium, felt honestly organic to his character to point out the tension in the beginning when Nami wasn't really apart of it yet but he wanted her to be. edit btw just thought this should be pointed out, the way the actor playing Luffy talks is the actors real accent, which is a GOOD thing because Oda has said Luffy would be barzillian if he was real, which the actor playing Luffy is!! so you really just made fun of Luffys accent

There have been quite a few live action anime Dragon ball Death note Another death note one Cowboy beepbop Avatar the last air bender All horable failures but there have been a lot

i wouldnt worry yet. its not even out and we know they couldnt fit too much (about 60 20min episodes into 8 one hour episodes) anyway, it'd going to have to sum up a lot, perhaps each new crew member will have its on episode for their whole arcs, maybe nami and sanji get 2 each. the fact that the author is involved in this project gives me hope and yeah, perhaps it isnt made for the die hard fans and more so for people new to this world or the world of anime/manga in general, its a nice way to introduce it. maybe its gonna be bad but maybe not! but changes are inevitable, especially for something so big as one piece but no point in being negative abt it till its out! you just gotta dive in with the mindset that it wont all be 1:1 cuz thats just impossible and unrealistic

In regards to whether they have done live action adaptations of anime before, yeah, it is not rare for them to do so. They usually have a bad reputation (at least when it comes to shounen manga adaptation), though one has to remember that they are different mediums and what works in one does not necessarily work in another (for example, if Luffy acted the same in the live action adaptation as he does in the manga, he would look like a psychopath). As some examples, the Death Note's adaptation is known to be bad, as are the ones for Attack on Titan, Full Metal Alchemist and Dragon Ball. On the other hand, I heard that Samurai X and Gintama have good adaptations as does Battle Angel Alita and Hentai Kamen; Sailor Moon's is campy and not the best quality (newbie actors and bad special effects) but fun in its own way and did some good work in the character development department and plot (save for some questionable choices regarding Luna) and Liar Game has a meh adaptation. So it is very much a hit or miss situation, though in general they have bad reputation. As for how long it will be, as far as I know it won't be the whole series that will be adapted but the first part of it (so up two more arcs after the one Usopp is introduced in).

Copying it exactly is not the way to go. It never works, so they're being slightly original. This will make its own mark, and I suggest maybe watch more of One Piece before judging the dialogue. Luffy's lines are fine because he's actually emotionally intelligent while also carefree. The actors worked really hard to practice their craft (Zoro's actor is already a live action anime swordsman actor) and they were also cast through Oda's input. If the live action will be goofy, it's because the source manga is goofy, all intentional. IF the writing flops, it's because not all people like the source.

I think the dialogs of luffy seem too quirky, luffy is just dumb, nami and zoro arguing he would probably be laughing or comment something stupid

Why you complaining so much about such small changes, like the fact, that they apparently gonna meet Nami a little bit earlier, than they did in canon, or the fact, that there no gonna be that freaking statue of Morgan! (which not even clear yet). Well, thank God, at least you don't whine about the fact that Luffy's and Usopp's clothes differ from the canonical ones in some scenes...

I also thought that luffy's dialogues are not so luffy, but making luffy in the real world I think it would be very ridiculous and they even removed ussop's nose

Yeahhh.... I think the thing that puts you off about luffy is... he kinda seems like a nerd. When luffy is supposed to be a chad.

one piece live action needs to be it's own thing, it can't be a copy of manga, not possible, and what would be the point of doing that? i think one piece live action is going to be decent

the attitude of Luffy in the live action is a little off like when Zoro and Nami are arguing. Oda's Luffy doesnt care about things like that and just do something stupid around the ship.. In the live action I think Netflix Luffy is little mature..... and yeah why is Nami fighting in Morgan's Navy Base???? why o why?? oh my..

Date a live 1-4 anime

There have been western live actions of anime. Theyve pretty much all have been bad. Dragon ball evolution, cowboy bebop etc. One piece is by far the most ambitious property theyve tried to adapt. The author oda has been involved and the actors look pretty damn good. Getting luffy right is gunna be really tough and u have to love luffy for the shie to work. Lets give it a chance and hope its good

There were several American live-action adaptations of anime most of them were garbage Dragon Ball Z, Cowboy Bebop, Fist of the North Star, and Death Note being the most notorious stinkers Only Battle Angel Alita and Edge of Tomorrow were truly good Ghost in the Shell and Speed Racer were OK, but not great. The live-action adaptation of City Hunter that was made in Hong Kong and starred Jackie Chan was pretty awesome, but that does not count among the American adaptations (pretty sure there were several live-action adaptations of anime made in Hong King during the 80s and early 90s)

There have been quite a few live action anime adaptations, and pretty much all of them have been terrible. A few of them have some redeeming qualities, but they are overall bad. The best one I've seen is the Bleach Live Action Movie, which still wasn't anywhere near as good as the anime or manga. If nothing else One Piece's Live Action will look nice(the sets were actually built, so they'll be cool to see). Also it's impossibility to copy an anime/manga 1:1, because it's impossible to translate what can be done in animation, which is why most people just say to leave it as animation.

Dialogue was my issue as well. And Nami coming off as angsty instead of spunky and adventurous.

Cartoonish humor can't be done in real. So some characters need to adapt. You'll get used to it. Look at its own thing, don't compare with animation.

Yeah agree it's good but sound cringe ngl