NFC West QB Rankings ft. Phil and Matt Simms 

Yes, barring injury this is going to be a special year for the Rams offense.

Mathew Stafford is this generations John Elway he's that DAMN GOOD!

Stafford The rest of the list

Go Rams 😁

Not sure why this is so controversial. Yes... Brock Purdy is a good QB. But Stafford is OBVIOUSLY the best in the division. And it's not even close. 🤷🏾‍♂️ Drop Stafford on that 49ers roster and they win AT MINIMUM the last two Super Bowls. Maybe 3.

I’m so glad to hear Phil say…”Every game MS makes throws no one else in the league could make” because as a Rams fan…I’ve been seeing it and saying it since he joined the Rams. I wish I watched him more and appreciated him more when he was a lion

Kurt Warner is really a poor comparison to make for Brock Purdy. Yes, both were dropped onto great teams. But Warner's numbers were MUCH better. And Warner actually WON games with his arm on the regular, throwing over 200 MORE passes than Purdy in their first two seasons respectively. The 49ers success is BY FAR more predicated on how well McCaffrey, Deebo and their run first, run often offense plays, than Purdy. Warner's first two seasons were head and shoulders better than Purdy's. Oh and he actually also won a Lombardi for good measure.

1. Stafford 2. Kyler 3. Purdy 4. Geno

In my opinion after Mahomes and maybe Josh Allen, I would take Stafford over any of these quarterbacks in the league. His toughness is unmatched and his arm ability is tremendous. He is one of those quarterbacks that could have played in the 80s when quarterbacks were taking tremendous hits and playing through them . Nowadays, you can’t touch these quarterbacks. Back then the entire body was open to hitting quarterbacks. In Stafford is a true pocket passer, which is the definition of a passer not like a lot of these quarterbacks nowadays that earn their bread and butter by running. Example Lamar Jackson, you can keep him. I will take Stafford any day of the week over him. We brag every year about how Lamar Jackson is and he can’t even win playoff game! And I have to mention Phil Simms, this guy would’ve been a top five quarterback nowadays. Talk about a tough guy that hung in the pocket to make a big-time throw, that was Simms.

Stafford! It's not even close.

As a Niner's fan, I agree with the list and why. Stafford has always been a great QB. Sometimes better than the people he had to throw it to. One season, he was stuck just throwing it to Cupp until he got injured. Stafford has more experience than anybody on this list, so yeah, he should be #1 in the NFC. It will be really exciting this season when these teams have to go at it.

kyler murray doesnt have Aaron Donald to worry about anymore.

Rams had the best record in the Nfl last 8 games and almost beat Detroit and Baltimore. Upgrade at line, kupp will have a bounce back year, Stafford is heathly too. The back q.b is as good as the other q.b's in the division! C'mon stop with the B.s! Rams wining the division and going deep into playoffs, maybe all the way!!!

Murray is definitely better than Geno

49ers offensive throws behind and around the line of scrimmage a lot. Leads to a better completion percentage.

Brock Purdy is NOT equivalent to Kurt Warner in anyway on the field. Hard STOP!!!

Geno isn’t 4. 🤦‍♀️

Purdy, Stafford, Geno, and Kyler last. I'm going of division wins plus stats. Kyler Murray can be so much better if his team was better

Stafford for sure over Purdy, imagine Stafford in the 9ers offense. He’d cook!

The Rams will win The Superbowl This year

Rams making Superbowl run! Watch out!

Disrespect should have seen that coming

Everyone can doubt the RAMS ALL THEY WANT........

Garoppolo should be #4. You said consider all the teams as if they were 1 team. If Garoppolo is there, he's nbr 3. The running game will make the pasding game better and vice versa. McVays key is to make the defense guess on every play. A master of disguise!

Did Matt Simms just call his dad by his first name?

Before they give Matthew a new guaranteed contract, FOR GODS SAKE PLEASE TEACH HIM WERE THE DAM PLAY CLOCK IS!!!!!!! 😮😮😮

Not a Geno fan but the back half of this list is just delusional Turdy is obviously the 4th best in the division 1. Stafford 2. Kyler 3. Geno and Turdy is dead Last!!!

Phil "f-ing" Simms...I am honored, wow... ok, now I gotta clarify, was it Phil as Giants qb that got "clothes-lined decapitated" by Kevin Greene rushing off edge beating right tackle? Game was in Anaheim I believe...1986 +/- a couple seasons...

Go 🐏!!

Stafford

Brock Purdy had a better year but Stafford has that SB and has to do more for his team in order for them to compete.

Keep disrespecting Geno 🤞🏿🤞🏿🤞🏿

If Jaquiski Tartt could catch, the narrative on Stafford would likely be a lot different.

Matt, Shawn McVay has a long losing record against Niners.

K1 is behind Stafford he is better than smith & purdy. Get real

What a freaking joke, putting Kyler Murray at four. You’re saying that Geno Smith is better?!?!?!