Lots have been said about Anette's vocals, and I'm not very happy with her live performances too. But: 1) If it wasn't Anette, they would never create these beautiful songs (I mean DDP and Imaginaerum albums). 2) I just can't disrespect Anette for keeping doing her work despite people hating her so hard; also I highly doubt that she didn't realize that she couldn't handle old songs live, however she was trying her best. People may like or not like the results, but for me personally she deserves respect.
0:00 Bye Bye Beautiful 4:17 Dark Chest of Wonders 9:10 The Siren 14:02 Amaranth 18:43 Whoever Brings the Night 23:09 P&P 37:18 Ever Dream 42:23 Sahara 48:21 Nemo 53:30 7 Days to the Wolves 1:02:33 I wish I had an Angel
Yeah, Anette has such a lively and colorful voice. And yeah, it wasn't written for Anette. Anette was hired when Dark Passion Play was already composed.
Begum Lincoln In terms of voice I still prefer Tarja, but Floor is not far behind. Floor´s stage presence and charisma though are off charts IMO. And Anette is sweet, but she was in a tough situation =)
Gabriel Fenili Stage presence is more as a long body and a outfit like a valcury. The presence of Tarja is untopt. Anette, sorry, here she looks like a house wife who sings karaoke.
Hagen Lucht Obviously this is your opinion. And there's nothing wrong in having a normal appearance instead of a Diva one, Tarja's voice always been amazing. Just a question of taste
+Hagen Lucht Anette dresses like housewife was funny kkkkkkkkkkkkkk I have to agree kkkkkkkkkkk she has no problem dressing as a maid, but Anette was well below the level of Tarja, Floor and being the voice of Nightwish best right now.
Depends which sub-genre metal you sing. If you sing symphonic metal, there's nothing wrong having a sweet voice. If your genre is death metal... then probably not. Besides, she doesn't sing sweet every NW songs, in "Slow Love Slow" she is seductive, In "Scaretale" she uses a wacky evil witch voice, in "Come Cover Me" she sings with quite low key, the usual brightness is only shortly heard.
Anette has a great voice. Perfect for these songs and I'm impressed with the way she performed in this concert. Always liked her recorded songs for NW but wasn't always fond of her live performances compared to Tarja and Floor. But Anette did a Great job here. NIGHTWISH is the Best !!
All three singers brought something new to NW I can't say that I dislike any one of them but Floor is outstanding vocally and she can really move nicely :))
Yeah I agree. All three brought their own style and great charisma to the band and I love them all BUT....ahem...Hands Down...Floor just took this band to the next level not only with her strong voice but stage presence and her way of muscling out those jams and taking charge and winning the crowd. Oh and she's very pretty too. : )
GRACIAS POR COMPARTIR ESTE VIDEO....LO TENIA Y LO EN CD Y LO PERDI...Y ME ENCANTA CON ANETTES...SOY FAN DE NIGHTWISH...HACE 15 AÑOS Y TENGO 54 AÑOS...METALERO DESDE LOS 15 AÑOS...Y AMO ESTA BANDA....LA MEJOR BANDA DE METAL SIMFONICO LIRICO...DE TODOS LOS TIEMPOS....ME GUSTA LAS TRES VOCALISTA...LASTIMA QUE ANETTES NO PODIA CON ALGUNOS TEMAS...PERO LA VERDAD TIENE UN ESTILO HERMOSO ME ENCANTA....APORTO MUCHO EN SU MOMENTO PARA LA BANDA..FUE IMPORTANTE...Y FLOOR SU ACTUAL CANTANTE ESPECTACULAR...GRACIAS POR COMPARTIR ESTA JOYITA Y AGUANTE EL HEAVY METAL CARAJOOOO...
1) Bye Bye Beautiful 2) Dark Chest of Wonders 3) The Siren 4) Amaranth 5) Whoever Brings the Night 6) The Poet and the Pendulum 7) Ever Dream 8) Sahara 9) Nemo 10) 7 Days to the Wolves 11) Wish I Had an Angel
Tarja was goddes. But Anette is great too. She is best in the way of her voice and the songs, which is written to her voice. And Floor... Floor can sing Tarja´s songs and Anette´s songs, that´s why she is perfect for me.
Agreed. There are some songs where Tarja's vocals just work better than what Floor does on the song. There are songs where Anette brings out more emotion for me than Floor does. That being said, I have yet to hear Floor try to sing a NW song she couldn't do well. .
@@kmdcompelelct Agreed. Also watch Sydney live 2008 for Annette getting carried away with emotion during Poet and Pendulum - real tears she was so engrossed in the song ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-KxXsyxe4j44.html
I totally agree. After not seeing Tarja the band didn't seem the same to me. Later when I saw Floor it took a few times watching her perform and NOW I realize Floor has the better voice, look, stage presence and muscle that really enhances the live performance to the max. She's now my favorite. She's got that magic if ya know what I mean jelly bean. : )
+hektorlinko Floor can be pretty if she was a man oops gay!!! Tarja has a voice of a living angel it Source high notes like wind Tarja is a BEAUTIFUL lady
ALAN PANNELLA annette is Great.no one says a word for TARA who started band 20 yrs ago maybe you were too little ? Tarja videos go back to Nemo,over the hills numerous contents.She is an Opera Singer too.tara tjuen? But hatr hate to say Flor is Best.kat.
Hey people ! I was wondering how sad your life was if you're masochist enough to watch a singer you don't like live for more than an hour. If you need to throw your hate/insults at someone to feel happy, i'm sad for you. I don't like Delain and i'm not going on every Delain video to post things like "the singer has no taste in clothes" "her voice is horrible" "this isn't even metal". So please, do the same and act as civilised people. You, of course, have the right not to like it, but just say "i don't like it" not "it sounds horrible", because she isn't even singing badly here, you just do not like her voice. And just saying it's crappy isn't contructive criticism :)
+Ochi And i forgot : it would be nice of you to remember that Nightwish isn't yours or your thing. You have absolutely no right to decide what fits or doesn't fit Nightwish. Only band members can do that. I don't like everything Nightwish has made, but free insults aren't gonna get anyone anywhere.
Re:Anette,FlOr,Tarja.After just ONE yr of LISTENING to the THREE,i have Come to SEE the Beauty each Lady brings to a Particular song. Both with Nightwish and Solo. Anette s music on her OWN is Very Beautiful.While Tarja sometimes tries Too Hard.Flor can Do Anything.BUT as Someone brought up on Linda Rondstat,Ann nd Nancy Wilson,Stevie Nicks And Judy Collins EACH Hard Rockers OR just BEAUTIFUL Voices,i Differ to You EXPERTS..kat poletto.feb.5 2017.60 YEARS-LET IT ROCK,kids.'
She has a great recording voice! Listen to the Escapist... her voice suits that song so well, i can't complain about anything she did with the band album-wise because they managed to write the vocals to compliment the music.... but live.... she's all over the place, she's trying to sing with power and it just comes out as bellowing.
tapnerd It comes down to a lack of training properly and understanding technical singing. If a singer really understands singing, she can go really hard without damaging her vocal chords, or having her voice constantly break or miss notes. It's Anette's fault for not taking proper vocal lessons once getting into NW.
I find the back and forth between Nightwish and Tarja at this time hilarious. Tarja leaves / is fired and Nightwish writes "Bye Bye Beautiful". Tarja goes solo and writes "I walk Alone".... adolescent as hell but funny.
Andrew Marlowe Annette is Very Very Good.This goes back a couple of Yrs. But that Solo albu.was Great.Then theres a coupla vids with Annete Émpuu good lead dont know name but FIREFOX BAND ??APOLOGIZE CANT DO BETTER.KAT -6-2-18
Fernando Quevedo how can you say that.She started using her voice the Right way.If she had had the Chance to know herself and how/where changes should be itd have a better ending.this was 10 YRS AGO.try listening to her solo albums.you guys were babies then.kat..poletto
@@ferqueve It is just different from original, but doesnt make her bad singer. In her own songs she did really well and sounds almost like in the albums. There is a slight differense though and i dont see that as a bad thing
All singers put their own mark on songs or they'd all sound the same. Always thought Annette was a good singer in her own right. loved her passion ,energy , smile and singing . Excellent performance by Annette (link below) at Sydney 2008 - such a great non stop passionate/energetic performance and superb singing - the video that really got me into Nightwish ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-KxXsyxe4j44.html
Fun Fact: Tuomas was about to name the song Slaying The Dreamer (Dreaming and Slaying) untill Tarja said to him "I mean you been Writing Slaying The Dreamer alot so the sing should become Slaying The Dreamer" and Emmpu agreed to Tarja's decision and now Tuomas gave you SLAYING THE DREAMER and now Tarja in solo career she is very welcomed to use his song cause she helped him with all the other songs. Now Tarja solo career she can sing Nightwish because she either helped Tuomas to write it and also she was the Original singer of Nightwish and if Nightwish didn't let Tarja sing Nightwish song people will get mad and or frustrated with Nightwish and they will lose their reputation!!!!!
I agree so much. I think they even adjusted the song for her and she still f* up so bad. She can't sing like NW should be sang. Floor is amazing. Tanja is good too but I feel Floor sings more freely.
I have to put that on the band. I used to sing in some bands in college. If there was a song everyone wanted to do and I couldn't hack, we just didn't do it. That simple. If you are going to make such a radical departure from what you had in a singer, you might just have to accept that there are some songs you can no longer do live. You don't torture you vocalist trying to get her to produce sounds she is just not capable of.
Kenny Loggins kenny loggins of Loggins and Messina ? Oh i Missed You.i got stuck in My 70s till Nightwish.BUT MY LP STILL WORKS AND DAUGHTER KAITLYN GREW UP AND LOVED VALLAHALA.LOVING ME LOVING YOU.NOT TO HOT ON WINNY.I HOPE YOU ARE WELL.6-2-18 KAT McGee
Anette seems like a sweet lady with a voice that fits that persona. She obviously has a range that is too small to sing the older songs of NW. Also, the band blows her away; that doesn't mean she sucks, it just means she isn't the singer for this band. Recording is something else as playing music live. I'm happy with Floor. The show last Thursday was crazy, in a good way.
Anette have a beautiful voice and shes too sweet and kind with the guys, but, in voices... Floor is much better. I like Tarja's voice but it too hard -at least for me- Floor, have both, hard voice of Tarja's and sweet voice of Anette. Anyways, I like Nightwish for the guys, specially for Emppu♥ My little love; my dwarf.
A mi me encanta su voz pero esta es una banda con una imagen muy potente y ella es muy delicada, se pierde y a veces no se ve, Marko Hietela se ve mucho más, me parece que lo que le falta a ella es el carisma que si tienen Floor Johansen y Tarja Turunen, igual me gustan los temas con Anette.
floor has all the package voice...she can sing any style and also she have the metal voice and also metal chix...she have the rough voice of metal too and head banging...dats the real spirit of metal
Nightwish nació con Tarja . En otras palabras tarja y nightwish era uno y el estilo y las melodías eran para su registro de vos lo cual es difícil de alcanzar . Ni floor no tienen la potencia de tarja .anette llega en un momento donde el grupo necesitaban una vos .. para terminar sus contratos ya echos y a la salida de tarja del grupo . Anette es del grupo cuando graban un disco e si es parte ya del grupo y le da otro génesis durante ese tiempo al grupo son dos discos echos para ella y uno fuera el más vendido tubo como premios discos de plátanos. Floor tiene más en parecer a tarja pero esta muy lejos de alcanzarla . Pero sin duda tenemos en nightwish . No dio tres fascinan.tes voces para es cucharlas .
The most beautiful voice the band ever had. Tarja and floor are great, but you know, they're just the same kind of voice you can hear in every metal band with girls singing. Anette gave a particular touch to the band's sound.
I have never been a fan of anette (except for her studio songs) always thought she was terrible live.. But this performance changed my opinion of her, she sounds wonderful in her prime! Too bad time always takes its toll :( I love all of the nightwish singers, but gotta admit im a flooraholic :D i do believe that floor in time will also have a hard time keeping up unfortunately
It's the best Anette's live I've heared. At least she's being able to handle her own songs. Well... more or less. The other concerts are so terribly suffered. Long life to Floor!
I can't understand how they had Anette in NW, she never had the voice to fit in the band, i think she did her best anyway. Thank god Floor came to save them xD
eu AMO essa banda...mas...igual a TARJA não existe uma vocal...aquela voz é especial... mas só é perfeita com o NIGHTWISH... que pena, em meu coração e minhas lembranças a TARJA sempre será parte do NIGHTWISH.
Nightwish sounds so much like another Finnish band called HB. Even though all 3 Nightwish singers sound like Joanna of HB, I really like Annette's vocal the best (not that I'm a Nightwish fan). Plus, Annette is more pleasant to look at.
Care to explain how all three singers, who don't sound alike at all, can all sound like someone else? You're bending the laws of physics with that one.
![Nightwish @ Gampel open air 2008 [Subtitles]](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
