Nintendo Are Suing Palworld Creators!

Подписаться 48 тыс.

Просмотров 2,7 тыс.

50% 1

Official Nintendo Report Suing Palworld Creators:
www.nintendo.c...
-------
►Subscribe For More Nintendo Content! www.youtube.co...
FOLLOW ME ON:
►Twitter | / jskeleton92
►Facebook | / jskeleton92
►JOIN THE DISCORD COMMUNITY: / discord
OTHER CHANNELS:
►Nintendo Channel: www.youtube.co...
►JSkeleton (Gaming Channel)
| www.RU-vid.co...
►Skelly Reacts (Reaction Channel)
/ @skellyreacts
►Twitch Streams | / jskeleton92
►Music Channel | www.RU-vid.co...
►Original Music: linktr.ee/seve...
►JSkeleton Rants (Podcast): / @jskeletonrants5006
►SHOP JSKELETON APPAREL | teespring.com/...
►USE CODE "JSKELETON" for 10% OFF Kontrol Freek!
www.kontrolfre...
►USE CREATOR CODE "JSKELETON" in Fortnite & Epic Games if you'd like to help support me!
►USE MY LINK WHEN SHOPPING ON AMAZON!
AMAZON US: www.amazon.com...
AMAZON CANADA: www.amazon.ca/...
►MY GEAR ON AMAZON (US)
MAIN CAMERA - Sony A6400
amzn.to/2R6BY87
DUMMY BATTERY FOR CAMERA
amzn.to/2ULH2iW
ELGATO CAM LINK 4K
amzn.to/3dFF4cT
128GB SD CARD
amzn.to/2WNGDze
CAMERA - Logitech C920
amzn.to/2UG5uT5
MICROPHONE - Shure SM7B
amzn.to/33SVgCI
CLOUDLIFTER (For SM7B)
amzn.to/2WMgJMa
MIC PREAMP - Presonus Studio 26
amzn.to/2QRNKTA
GAME CAPTURE - Elgato HD60
amzn.to/2Jn0v4d
MOUSE - LOGITECH G502
amzn.to/2wJ7WQv
KEYBOARD - CORSAIR K95 PLATINUM
amzn.to/2JkaffB
MOUSEPAD - CORSAIR MM800C RGB
amzn.to/2UJIxy2
ELGATO GREEN SCREEN
amzn.to/39soDNw
BENQ XL2411 1080P 144HZ 1MS MONITOR
amzn.to/2UFAh2m
LOGITECH 27UK650 4K/HDR 60HZ 5MS MONITOR
amzn.to/2WPKjRc
Cover Music (often) used with Permission by:
CSGuitar89: / csguitar89

Опубликовано:

26 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 126

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

Palworld RESPONDS and their response is kinda funny...😂 Watch here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-mPzK3rBkyxo.html&ab_channel=JSkeleton%27sNintendoWorld

@darththeo 8 дней назад

The important thing to remember is this is a PATENT case, not a TRADEMARK case. It has nothing to do with the designs. And keep in mind this suit is in Japan, not the US. Japan has no fair use.

@Timosaurus48 8 дней назад

This ^

@flamjamok 8 дней назад

I agree.. honestly idk what I expected from a creator with Nintendo World in their youtube name, but this JSkeleton is just a simp. Maybe every video is illegal because it doesn't say sponsored if hes being sponsored? Otherwise a simp

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

My point (perhaps I was not clear) was that Palworld through and through lacks genuine, individual creativity, and has clearly lifted a LOT from Pokemon, so in a sense it's not a surprise that Nintendo and The Pokemon Company are finding something to go after them with.

@shadowwolf4209 8 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo Well when Pokemon start making up their own ideas instead of piggy backing off of other games then they can sue. Lycanrock is literally Tiger from Monster Rancher. Yet Nintendo doesn't get sued? Yeah they are retards.

@Timosaurus48 8 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo im not trying to be mean but the entire video completely glosses over the fact that it's a patent case. You mostly talk about likeness which has no relevance to the case

@lionsprideanimation 8 дней назад

You need to pay closer attention to how you're framing the issue. The violations Nintendo is pursuing aren't about copyright or trademark; they're specifically related to patents, which is a completely different legal area from intellectual property like trademarks or copyrighted characters. The core issue here revolves around the game mechanics and coding used in Palworld, not the design of characters or creatures. It's important to understand that patents cover functional elements, while copyright protects creative works, and trademarks safeguard brand identifiers.

@VixYW 8 дней назад

Wait a minute, in that case, they have zero legal standing in the matter. Why the heck they are doing this? They can't possibly have a patent over coloful spheres that trap creatures in them, otherwise SEVERAL games would be in trouble.

@emersonssbb 8 дней назад

@@VixYW What games. Ive played other monster catching games none of them had sphere or balls. Ive played coromon/nexomon, etc.

@XMaster340 8 дней назад

@@VixYW Even better! Patents on video game mechanics are illegal. So, if we're lucky, this could end with Nintendo permanently having some of its patents revoked. That would be amazing!

@brianvanhal4974 8 дней назад

@@XMaster340 Not to side with Nintendo, but you can patent certain video game mechanics. Case in point, the Nemesis System from Shadow of War

@sirflimflam 8 дней назад

@@VixYW I won't say their case is entirely without merit, however if I had to guess I would say Pokemon is probably trying to bury them in legal costs. Being "right" is only a small part of the legal process as long as they can use their weight to force the other side to submit.

@The_Punisher 8 дней назад

How much is Nintendo paying you bro?

@superj8575 8 дней назад

No kidding, fan boy, pro nintendo & will always agree with Nintendo.

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

LOL okay bud. Objectively speaking, Palworld lacks creativity and uniqueness. Legality aside, they lifted so much from Pokemon it's crazy.

@DesuNee 8 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo Creativity is in mixing survival mechanics from ark with monster world from pokemon is what make it unique game and launching it on PC while fans were begging for pokemon game on pc for years is just good marketing choice. Ppl wouldn't hype palworld so much if nintedo would listen to fans instead of adding new gen with new shit desing of old monsters

@real_ros 8 дней назад

@@superj8575 So true... what a bad video. He's sitting in his basement... "finally i can make a video against them...hahaha" Palworld lacks creativity and uniqueness.. really? Its an EARLY ACCESS.. learn to research the facts. And lets be honest here... most Pokemon Games are just a ripoff and cashgrab from Nintendo that REALLY lack cerativity and uniqness.

@LaughingStockArt 8 дней назад

@JSkeletonNintendo I guess things can't be inspired by pokemon anymore?? Guess we gotta go and sue Digimon now. Right? Palworld is original, and genuinely nothing like pokemon, besides some inspired designs and the fact that you can catch creatures. The game is unique, and creative. I love pokemon like hell, but you can't seriously defend a company like Nintendo in pretty much any of the crap they do. This is NOT a case. Not even remotely.

@PeytStrick 8 дней назад

They waited for them to make a bunch of money.. so they could have something to actually sue for. Nintendo not the good guys lol

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

Takes time to get legal stuff in order and organized to present a case🫠

@MrBandit972 8 дней назад

Actually yes they are the good guys they started the law suit at day one when they released the game why even speak if someone as dumb as you doesn't know what's going on

@goseigentwitch3105 8 дней назад

Dude, Nintendo posted publicly that they were aware of people's complaints about Palworld like immediately after Palworld came out. They knew when it came out that none of the Palworld designs infringed on Nintendo. The lawsuit isn't even about the designs.

@JSkeletonNintendo 7 дней назад

Designs were a point of the fact that the creators of Palworld lifted a lot from Nintendo, some that has legal warrant and some that does not. The point being, the creators should have tried to come up with something a bit more original, than trying to take so many 1 for 1 ideas from Nintendo.

@eventhorizonsingularity 8 дней назад

they’re just now doing that?😭

@Peh84 8 дней назад

No, they were investigating since release. Got the evidence and went to sue.

@MrBandit972 8 дней назад

No they been fighting it

@TheTriple2000 8 дней назад

Obviously they needed for the hype of the game to die down a bit so the backlashes wouldn't be too severe for them as well as waiting for pocketpair to garner a large amount of money first before they sue them for those said money

@Salvatore98B 8 дней назад

What infringrments? Only 3 or 4 Pokemons are actually patented

@Ricctis 8 дней назад

Didn't pokemon take inspiration from a bunch if other games?

@real_ros 8 дней назад

yes several... Mail Order Monsters by EA for C64 & Atari for example. Released 1985. Pfff.. Nintendo is just butthurt...

@fartedididnot3685 8 дней назад

Nintendo has so many good games, yet it sure does act like a spoiled brat.

@darththeo 8 дней назад

If you had a patent, and someone used said patent without your consent ... you would just let them because you don't want to be a "spoiled brat"?

@SuperSonicBrawl1 8 дней назад

@darththeo Do you by chance remember minigames during loading screens? Namco owns the patent for that and it's why you have not seen it for years. One of Nintendo's patents is throwing an object to capture a creature. This is where the problem lies, they have many more for simple mechanics patents of the monster taming genre like egg raising and using a creature to fight. Nintendo could ruin the whole genre with their new patents which were made around may and gives them more legal power to sue small games and developers which they were already doing for things like free fangames.

@fartedididnot3685 8 дней назад

@@darththeo Nintendo does not own creature capture concepts. There's a massive difference between something being inspired by, and something by copied by. As a Game Dev myself, if someone copied my assets for profit without my permission, yes I'd be annoyed. But something similar to a game I've made? There's nothing wrong with that. Similar pokemon designs mean nothing, there's over 1000 pokemon, so what if some are inspired by them? If Pokemon wins for a reasonable reason, fine. But if its something stupid like a similar concept, then it really is just being a spoiled brat.

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

@@SuperSonicBrawl1 only problem is digimons been doing the tomagochi just as long so they don't have a monopoly on it yet, also that's so basic of a idea don't think you can patent it

@DeadlestSpartanGroup 8 дней назад

@@xaviergould8747The thing is that they have Patented things like that effects field characters aka Pokeball mechanics.

@hoddrock5850 8 дней назад

I want a refund from gamefreak

@aerrae5608 8 дней назад

Jealous cause their Pokemon games suck now and someone did it better. Competition though amirite? We love to hate it! How dare they make incompetent Gamfreak have to improve as a developer and make something that actually captures the attention of anyone with minimal critical faculties? Dreadful! I hope they fail miserably. I hope they fail so hard the precedent it sets never allows any company to do this ever again. If you can't compete with your games then you deserve failure, OR if you're actually smart, you offer to lease the license out for a game or two and make profit while your audience gets a game that isn't an insult to the intelligence of toddlers.

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

its funny to me the last Pokemon game came out and had more problems then a game with less of a team on a engine they've only just started with

@flamjamok 8 дней назад

I hope nintendo loses ^^ Nintendo had all the time in the world to create anything like Palworld and now they just want a piece of the pie they didn't create.

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

Why would you hope Nintendo loses (which they won't) when Palworld basically couldn't be very unique in and of itself and essentially copied the homework of Nintendo but made a few changes xD

@leonoliveira8652 8 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo nintendo did NOT release anything like palworld. Closest thing might be Dragon Quest Builders or Treasures. This is a mashup of game styles that wasn't *actually* attempted before, and it works.

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

@@leonoliveira8652 Lol okay. Fact is, much of what is in this game looks like a rip-off, no name brand version of Pokemon and Breath of the Wild. It is what it is. You can enjoy it if you want, but it doesn't change those facts.

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo ok bro reel in your Nintendo fan boy, they can lose their not invincible and palworld is just different enough Nintendo could be told to chill

@JSkeletonNintendo 7 дней назад

Bro, be real, you're a Palworld fanboy. See how that works? I'm not talking about personal opinion, I'm talking about legal rights (which Nintendo has whether you like it or not) and so many of you are getting flustered about that because it's not what you WANT to hear. I could care less who likes or dislikes Palworld or Pokemon, that isn't the point I was making at all. But some of you can't see that through your thick Palworld fanboy glasses because you have such a hatred for Nintendo going after them that you're incapable of having an objective conversation on the legal side of things and the fact that Nintendo has a track record for winning these lawsuits, meaning they DO have these rights whether I, you, or anyone likes or dislikes it.

@taerziato 8 дней назад

I hope palworld just doesn't go belly up just from the letter

@phantomofnyx 8 дней назад

Oh GOD would I love for this court case to set a president, and Square enix tourning right around and going Bro, so about that homework you stole from me? ( Edit: for people who don't know, almost half of the original 151 pokémon ) but I can assure you, if nintendo have a case, so does square enix against nintendo, and I wonder how much money the pokémon franchise adds up to, If nintendo were clever they would let sleeping dogs sleep

@darththeo 8 дней назад

They are suing patents, not trademarks. Pokemon are trademarked, not patented.

@phantomofnyx 8 дней назад

@darththeo yeah I figured as much not exactly sure which patent they are going by though, I know nintendo lost their case against temtem so it should be because palworld is using some sort of tech they feel they have exclusive rights to ? I looked it up they have patented the idea of throwing a spherical object at a creature to capture it. And to then use said spherical object to call it to battle These are the likely two patents they are suing for

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

@@phantomofnyx I'm thinking what patent are they going for a throw balls at monsters or monster raising game, because as a digimon fan I know they got anything on it because Gods know they would have gonna after that already

@RetroPiero 8 дней назад

Gotta Sue 'Em All!

@wirlogx 8 дней назад

Let me guess, the game was coming to PS5 and Nintendo/PKMN Company had a little itch on their asses. The only Pal I'd say is a copy is the damn Grass Bunny with Cinderace, then the others are not, just following the design philosophy. And let's not forget that Microsoft was backing Pocket Pair...

@LukeTheLukeZ 8 дней назад

direhowl is not a lycanrock,there both just wolves

@leonoliveira8652 8 дней назад

You could also just sue tpc/creatures/gf/nintendo since lycanroc is actually just Tiger from monster rancher with spikes instead of horns.

@shadowwolf4209 8 дней назад

@@leonoliveira8652 I just looked it up and you are so right. Tiger is Lycanrock just painted blue and has horns.

@skytrooper3537 8 дней назад

Just to play devil's advocate, some of pokémon's pokémon looked like some of the same as its other pokémon. So even if palworld reskined some pokémon, technically, if 2 similarly looking pokémon can "be different" then technically so can the Pals in palworld

@tabbywolf801 8 дней назад

Not Cool Nintendo...

@Salvatore98B 8 дней назад

Just look up. Are they kidding? For some things other games have it too. Are they patenting really day night sleep scedules? Tsk

@JoeJoe0o 8 дней назад

Lucario 💀

@whytchywooo 8 дней назад

Its another Coke vs Pepsi issue.... tough noogies Nintendo... "cola" is for everyone, even store brands! Here's hoping the judge tells them to take a flying leap off a rolling donut!!!! 😂😂😂😂

@Shizuka965 8 дней назад

but they don't have the same and doesn't exactly look like their pokemon counterparts so its going to fail lmao

@sirflimflam 8 дней назад

The case is patent infringement, not trademark in infringement. Those are very different issues. Whether or not they have a leg to stand on here is anyone's guess, but Nintendo is probably just hoping they can bury Palworld in legal costs rather than being "Right"

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

i dont see this going anywhere, palworld is different enough any reasonable courts going to look at nintendo and go well they both look like animals thats it, this would be like bandai sueing over mega evo

@mak3x7 8 дней назад

I will say some are a bit of parody and similar animals, but alot are still unique. It should go without saying Nintendo doesn't own the trademark on animals (wolves), or religious religions (annubis, and the norse deer). But yeah the Garchomp, eevee, luxray, cinderace, the one with with primarinas exact hair model, Mewtwo, and other examples are way too close i will admit. It does make me upset seeing people say things like the grass squirrels and jolthog are ripping off pokemon just because Pokemon already used those animals. Similar with Lucario and Anubis being jackels based off the Egyptian god Anubis, though i guss the fighting style and movement is similar.

@RestynPeece 8 дней назад

please, nothing will come of this. no pals are EXACT copies and the game and gameplay are totallly different than anything nintendo has done. I never liked pokemon, it was boring. I actually like to play palworld. If nintendo would have done this sooner we'd be playing that, thats what this is about. Nintendo wants to be able to copy THEM. LOL. THis is what youi call a "SORE LOSERS" lawsuit.

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

it could backfire Nintendo could get hit with a falsified case which means they could have to pay pocket, and maybe even and rework their parents to only their properties

@michaell1892 8 дней назад

Dead? Palworld have more than 26K active player. Did you put any research before making this video?

@xaviergould8747 8 дней назад

dude he's stuttering the whole video I think he's nervous this could backfire hard

@JSkeletonNintendo 7 дней назад

Considering they went from 1M players to 18K currently active players, yeah I'd say they died off pretty hard. OBVIOUSLY they aren't COMPLETELY dead at literally 0 players, it's relatively speaking, but you knew that and just wanted to try and be all smart.

@Dankeszteri 8 дней назад

Nintendo glazers are sooo mad that these guys made the best pokemon game you ever seen and its not even close 😭😭 Zero grounds for a lawsuit just trying to bully another company into a settlement, get real.

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

If there were zero grounds, there would be no lawsuit LOL You didn't think that one through my friend. Nintendo has a legendary track record for winning these lawsuits and wouldn't be pursuing it if they had no grounds for it. Seems like some of y'all are just big mad that Nintendo won't let someone copy their homework😂

@nintendorakyamato1859 8 дней назад

And The Pokémon Company wins 15 million dollars

@scientificapple69 8 дней назад

never have I been more excited to see a video title in my life 😃

@imjustalittleqwerty 7 дней назад

Yes, a lot of designs look too similar to Pokemon. No, that has no relevance to the lawsuit. This is a patent lawsuit. There’s likely some mechanic that’s too similar to Pokemon’s. You also debate that Palworld lacks originality when it’s done nothing but iterate on Pokemon’s ideas by including elements of survival, tycoons, and real-time combat. I recommend deleting this video and making an updated one with more research and less bias, because man, this one’s a stinker.

@blastprocessing5229 7 дней назад

Couldn’t agree more. I’m a diehard Pokemon fan and even I think this guy is working in bad faith. Palworld shows a lot more promise than current Pokemon games and I think this guy is baiting people. He even has a follow up video trying to stoke the flames more. I wouldn’t bother watching this guy’s stuff anymore. He’s like Verlisify trying to get rage clicks.

@JSkeletonNintendo 7 дней назад

My point of stating that, was that the creators of Palworld couldn't be more original and had to take so many elements from Nintendo IPs which objectively lacks creativity on their part. I mean just the Pals mechanics with how you catch them in a ball and how the catching mechanic looks with the ball shaking and either being successful or not, having to fight them, throwing them out of your ball to fight alongside you, of course as I mentioned the clear copying of how similar many Pals look to Pokemon, I mean c'mon, I think you're the one with a bias towards Palworld on this one, my friend. Nintendo wouldn't pursue a lawsuit if they had no grounds for it. That alone proves that there most certainly are infringements, and the game devs of Palworld just come across as lazy.

@JSkeletonNintendo 7 дней назад

It's not about what has promise or not. It's not about opinion (my OPINION is that I would hope Pokemon would be more than it has been and even performance issues alone has been a serious problem), it's about stating objective facts (like it or not, the Palworld devs were lazy and lifted a lot from Nintendo IPs instead of trying to be more original and create something more uniquely individual). Also, your comment proves you've never seen my stuff before, because I do not bait for rage clicks, that is just a stupid thing for you to say. Just because you disagree with me, does not mean that is what I am doing. Get a grip. Most of my Channel is merely Nintendo News and Guides. This was News that I presented with the fact that Nintendo has a track record of winning these lawsuits (because it is their legal right, like it or not), and that Palworld HAS taken A LOT from Nintendo IPs that are WAY too similar in many ways. Like honestly, how on earth am I baiting when the title and thumbnail are simply what is being reported, which is that NINTENDO IS SUING THE PALWORLD CREATORS? Like, do you actually think before you type, man?

@imjustalittleqwerty 7 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo I’m not arguing that Nintendo has no legal grounds for this lawsuit. I’m saying it’s not fair to dismiss Palworld as completely unoriginal. Yes, you’re right, it DOES do a lot like Pokemon… while also doing a hundred other things that Pokemon doesn’t. Again, real-time combat, survival, and tycoon elements are what help separate it from Pokemon despite their commonalities. By your logic, Pokemon is a ripoff of Shin Megami Tensei because they’re both about finding creatures and taking them to use for battle. Nothing is truly 100% original. Persona lifted from Final Fantasy lifted from Dragon Quest lifted from Dungeons and Dragons. If Nintendo didn’t legally have a patent for their mechanics, you wouldn’t feel this way. I’m sure you understand the basic concepts of inspiration and iteration. Palworld is exactly that while admittedly flying too close to the sun in some aspects. You’re allowed to acknowledge what Palworld does right while thinking it overstepped in some ways. It’s not healthy to view everything as black and white.

@blastprocessing5229 7 дней назад

@@JSkeletonNintendo Well when you respond to people with “Cope” when they make valid arguments, it gives it all away. It’s the oldest troll trick in the book. Verlisify does the same thing to get views and engagement. You’re just like him.

@NSB0953 8 дней назад

We need Palworld: Pocket. Imagine a GBA style version of Palworld similar to FireRed.

@lava3256 8 дней назад

They need the money to make their games better

@Windclaw 8 дней назад

And on the day they actually make a good Pokemon game again, Satan will be ice-scatting to work.

@goseigentwitch3105 8 дней назад

oh... after reading your replies to comments, I realize you're just a hater

@JSkeletonNintendo 7 дней назад

LOL I'm a hater? hahaha. Cope buddy. What makes me a hater? Defending myself from trolls? Stating objective truths about the game that they absolutely lifted a ton from Nintendo IPs instead of focusing on being more unique? Sheesh. Get a grip man, it ain't that serious. Some of you are acting like I just dissed your Mom or something with this game. You can like it if you want, I could care less. But fact of the matter is they still ripped a lot from Nintendo IPs and Nintendo has the right to pursue them legally whether you like it or not. It's not about my opinion because my opinion one way or the other does not change the facts of the matter, just like anyone else's opinion does not change anything.

@Lylatroid 8 дней назад

To be fair, Palworld isn’t as creative as Digimon. They’re way too lazy and they don’t want to be original with creating creatures. Nintendo has the rights anyway. Them and Gamefreak.

@SerifineAzailius 8 дней назад

2:28 "And listen You gotta resepct that" No you dont, its a multi million dollar company witha history of stomping on its own fandom when itncomes to mods and fangames, im rooting for palworld soley so Nintendo can lose.

@JSkeletonNintendo 8 дней назад

It doesn't matter if it's a starter company or a multi-million dollar company, they have the rights to protect their IPs; doesn't matter if you like or dislike that, the fact of the matter is it IS their right.

@VixYW 8 дней назад

Good. I hope Nintendo loses. Someone has to trip them down from their legal high horse, and this is the best candidate we had so far to do so.

@gamerbeast3616 8 дней назад

They will win palworld is a pokemon cioy

@VixYW 8 дней назад

@@gamerbeast3616 It isn't tho. And they have a lot of money to fight back. Nintendo's case needs to be really solid this time around, and I don't see what kind of patent infringement card they could possibly pull.