Тёмный
No video :(

Nirvana or Seether? who did “Heart-Shaped Box” better? 

Vice Rock Music
Подписаться 15 тыс.
Просмотров 101 тыс.
50% 1

Nirvana VS Seether: Who did the song “Heart-shaped box” better?

Опубликовано:

 

6 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 394   
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic 10 месяцев назад
Have you subbed yet?❤
@saul_goodmanirl
@saul_goodmanirl Год назад
dude its obviously nirvana, they literally made the song
@YosefTesfaye10
@YosefTesfaye10 Год назад
Lmao ikr
@sliver_inheart
@sliver_inheart Год назад
Nah, sometimes covers are even better than the original. Like "The man who sold the world" of Bowie fits better in Nirvana's genre.
@saul_goodmanirl
@saul_goodmanirl Год назад
@@sliver_inheart most covers i know are trash but the man who sold the world from nirvana and word up from korn are 2 i know that are actually good
@David-vg8lx
@David-vg8lx Год назад
@@YosefTesfaye10wrong
@nathandiviney706
@nathandiviney706 Год назад
Fr
@Leon-Coils19912
@Leon-Coils19912 Год назад
That's a really good cover of this song, his voice is similar to Kurt's 👌 but the Original Always!!
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
🤟🏻🔥
@arccityangels
@arccityangels 3 месяца назад
Fun fact, Seether started off as a Nirvana tribute band in South Africa. That’s probably why they sounded so similar on the first record. 😊
@ericlaurie6671
@ericlaurie6671 Месяц назад
Pat smear done it best 😂
@xi11ma
@xi11ma Год назад
seether will ever be the only band that covers nirvana correctly
@AndrewSingerOfficial
@AndrewSingerOfficial 9 месяцев назад
Time will tell
@opa_spin
@opa_spin 9 месяцев назад
​@@AndrewSingerOfficialthey've been doing it for 20 odd years now
@AndrewSingerOfficial
@AndrewSingerOfficial 9 месяцев назад
who cares? that doesnt mean no one else will. duh@@opa_spin
@opa_spin
@opa_spin 9 месяцев назад
@@AndrewSingerOfficial I perhaps misunderstood you?
@AndrewSingerOfficial
@AndrewSingerOfficial 9 месяцев назад
@@opa_spin they are the best and most popular. Just saying don’t underestimate the newcomers.
@zenthemanchild
@zenthemanchild Год назад
never heard of seether before but they sound great
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
@Capin-Crunch
@Capin-Crunch Год назад
⁠@@Galifamackus More good ones are, Fine again, What would you do, and nobody praying for me, words as weapons, rise above this.
@gamekiller9046
@gamekiller9046 Год назад
Check them out, I reccomend Remedy, Driven Under, Careless Whisper (cover), Nobody Praying for Me, Needles, Your Bore, Pig, and Tied My Hands (Acoustic) which is under the name Saron Gas
@Capin-Crunch
@Capin-Crunch Год назад
@@gamekiller9046 I wonder how many people know there original name.
@gamekiller9046
@gamekiller9046 Год назад
@KillShot probably not many in the US. But a lot in South Africa I would guess
@user-me9in1yu6s
@user-me9in1yu6s Год назад
The front man for Seether actually has the perfect tone to cover Nirvana. His voice is very similar in terms of grit to Kurt's. Excellent cover.
@maverick3741
@maverick3741 Год назад
seether is so good as underrated
@Alwayslearnimg
@Alwayslearnimg Год назад
Still not Nirvana. Good yes.
@gamekiller9046
@gamekiller9046 Год назад
Probably kurt, but Shaun has an amazing voice and his Nirvana covers are always on point
@Kyle_Frederick_Schaeffer
@Kyle_Frederick_Schaeffer Год назад
2 of my favorite bands playing my favorite song
@giovannisolis2628
@giovannisolis2628 Год назад
Both. Kurt would be proud of seun
@faytgreen3308
@faytgreen3308 Год назад
*Shaun
@whocares110
@whocares110 Год назад
No contest, nirvana. Seethers version is like owning a Eagle talon when what you really wanted was a Mitsubishi eclipse.
@stevenmorgan5579
@stevenmorgan5579 Год назад
Lol, this comment is both hilarious and eerily nostalgic to me. I had a friend back in 1996-ish whose mom bought him a red Eagle Talon. Of course, eventually, he wanted a Mitsubishi eclipse so they traded it in for one in forest green. Interesting comparison and bang-on to the point.
@Animus7
@Animus7 3 месяца назад
Seether has the most underrated live sound. His voice fills a room like no other voice I've ever heard. It's pretty special. One of the EXTREMELY rare voices that have to be heard in person to get it.
@basketkase404
@basketkase404 Год назад
As a big nirvana fan, seether definitely got it closer to the studio version… can’t wait for the reply’s on this one
@jaxoncollins4525
@jaxoncollins4525 Год назад
You know what I like Shaun’s better only because his voice sounds fuller and Kurt’s sounds broken even though that’s the point
@MarkJohnson-rg5mr
@MarkJohnson-rg5mr Год назад
That other guy is Shawn from SEETHER and he’s fuck’N great ❤how his different tones that come from within
@tcphll
@tcphll Год назад
The Seether cover is outstanding and they're obviously trying to sound as much like Nirvana as possible, and they do a great job at it. For this, I'd give it to Nirvana, and I think Seether would agree.
@tacovrontron4420
@tacovrontron4420 Год назад
The flipping MAN who wrote it!!!
@chair3439
@chair3439 Год назад
The answer is very clearly the cover that was on Guitar Hero 2
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
🤟🏻
@foxysky014
@foxysky014 Год назад
I didn't even listen to the 2nd part of the video, Kurt will always be better than any cover
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
🤩
@ar1a.luvs.nirv4na.
@ar1a.luvs.nirv4na. Год назад
Me neither
@JCAchannel100
@JCAchannel100 Год назад
Ya. No
@carlharris2606
@carlharris2606 Год назад
How would you know if you never heard the second song? Schrödingers heart shaped box.
@sageminentjunky5197
@sageminentjunky5197 Год назад
​@@carlharris2606because the guys comparing Nirvana with Seether
@drewmonroe4641
@drewmonroe4641 Год назад
Kurts raspy high pitch is magical
@controlfreak6387
@controlfreak6387 11 месяцев назад
Personally no offense to Kurt I preferred Seethers LIVE version better, I prefer the original recording tho
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic 11 месяцев назад
Ok
@GraveBoy09
@GraveBoy09 Год назад
Seether is an amazing band and they both sounded really good but I still gotta go for nirvanas.
@cjsmith4152
@cjsmith4152 Год назад
I never thought that the song live was as good as the actual song or did it any justice IMO their best song and my fav song of all time
@NSCVlogz
@NSCVlogz 7 месяцев назад
Nirvana for sure, without question, without thought, and without any other explanation whatsoever.
@patriotic80
@patriotic80 Год назад
Nobody is better at Kurt’s Music than he was . He is the original and an obvious huge influence to seether.
@donmclee1569
@donmclee1569 Год назад
damnn, Seether's cover sounds angrier
@Taylor_swiftie_forever
@Taylor_swiftie_forever Год назад
The cover is amazing but there ain’t no competition. Kurt always. ❤
@paulyt4814
@paulyt4814 Год назад
Seether has something else that make them great💯🥺
@Duurston
@Duurston Год назад
Seen Seether 3 times. Each time they’ve played a nirvana song. While the original is best. I tell you they do a Fkn good job.
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
🤟🏻
@GoofySillyGuy
@GoofySillyGuy 5 месяцев назад
Nirvana: Heart Shaped Box Seether: Heart Shaped Cube
@kimgriner5532
@kimgriner5532 Год назад
They killed it seether is a great band
@TheArkhamLantern
@TheArkhamLantern 2 месяца назад
I am surprised that Seether has not done a full studio cover of a Nirvana song like they did careless whisper
@jaytheboatguy
@jaytheboatguy Год назад
NIRVANA DUH...! Pat Smear was so puckish backing up vocals, Dave even was giving back up vocals. Nirvana had such a bold sound playing live.
@pumpkinspicelatte1731
@pumpkinspicelatte1731 23 дня назад
I mean Seether does really good covers, I wouldn't really expect many others to do nirvana songs, but no NO ONE WILL ever be able to do Kurt's screams, his voice in general no matter how close, he used to cough up blood after shows becoz of his style of singing..he shredded his cords because it'd scream so hard, and he did it not because he couldn't sing right, but because he wanted the anger, angst, depression, anxiety, love and hate all to come through in his singing, sometimes I think the way he sang the words meant more then the words he sang, not for every singer understand, but definitely Kurt, there was a reason he emphasized certain parts of song and lyrics to others..at least to me. RIP Kurt and Layne, the world lost so much talent 8 years apart on the same day, and i wish we could have seen what was to come, even if that meant retirement and sitting on a porch playing an acoustic guitar..could you imagine a song where Kurt would play acoustic guitar and backing vocals with Layne singing lead...omg that've been fucken nuts, some kind AIC, Nirvana, Johnny Cash and Beatles all smashed together. Who knows what they wouldve accomplished clean and sober..fuck even if they'd have got on suboxone or methadone the rest of their life and really used the program correctly..any over losing them..even if that meant no more music at all from them, I don't think they'd ever been able to go without some form of musical creation within their lives..it was just part of them.
@CorpseCopain
@CorpseCopain Год назад
obviously love the original, i have no idea who the second guy was but i friggin love his tone! never considered listening to nirvana covers, because the random clips i may hear in a short never do the songs justice
@chrissmolinski9220
@chrissmolinski9220 Год назад
Until this video I had no idea seethed did a cover of this song. Hell yeah I like both
@sammydavis3796
@sammydavis3796 Год назад
Man I loved nirvana first so I’d have to say Kurt did it better, although Seether is my favorite band Shaun is probably the only person that will ever come that close to sound like Kurt in my opinion.
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
cool
@bullworthguy5999
@bullworthguy5999 Год назад
Nirvana Dave grohl once said “there’s nobody like us that’s sounds like us”
@MossadHunter88
@MossadHunter88 Год назад
Nobody could ever do this song better than nirvana but with that said, Seether is the most underrated band all time. Seether still putting great hits out. They are the best of the 90's bands left:
@nemainfae
@nemainfae 2 месяца назад
Dark divine feminine vs dark divine masculine. Both good, but completely different. It frustrates me when people say they sound alike because there are distinct differences. I do acknowledge there are similarities. For instance someone trained AI on Kurt's voice on RU-vid and then puppeteered him to sing Change by Deftones, and then that version sounded exactly like Shaun Morgans' version of that cover. However neither Kurt or Shaun sound like Chino Moreno so it's interesting.
@CKCoasterLawrence
@CKCoasterLawrence Год назад
Nirvana, if u choose any other option ur wrong
@jasonhansard
@jasonhansard 3 месяца назад
Nothing beats the original, of course (and it's Nirvana, duh), but Seether does a damn good job covering it. One of the best Nirvana covers I've ever heard. They were his inspiration after all!
@elisabethashley7236
@elisabethashley7236 Год назад
Seether did really great .
@Puff_123
@Puff_123 2 месяца назад
Check out Dead Sara's band cover of the song, its absolutely heavenly.
@jonland-oi6zo
@jonland-oi6zo Год назад
Both are really good, Nirvana is better bc its the original, but Seether did amazing
@WickedSnazzy
@WickedSnazzy Год назад
I like Seether. One of my favorite band’s growing up but any Nirvana cover they do will always be good but not good enough to be better then the original. I’m sure that wasn’t Seether attention to make it better. They just wanted to acknowledge the band and this is the only band I see doing a lot more then most.
@Slimshadylove399
@Slimshadylove399 6 месяцев назад
Both❤ I love seether and nirvana too much.. SO BOTH😂
@user-ex1lz9dn2v
@user-ex1lz9dn2v Год назад
Seether sounds good they are underrated
@Smothzilla
@Smothzilla 10 месяцев назад
Nirvana but they did pretty dang good too 🤟🏻
@rafanew20
@rafanew20 Год назад
Really good cover!
@saturn5087
@saturn5087 11 месяцев назад
I honestly prefer seether
@RamonaStanley-mu1dl
@RamonaStanley-mu1dl Месяц назад
💙💙 love both
@clintonbreeden6970
@clintonbreeden6970 Год назад
Original is better without a doubt, but cover is surprisingly amazing
@evandromateusdasilva9349
@evandromateusdasilva9349 Год назад
Seether nas músicas dele é muito melhor que a voz do nirvana, e a única coisa que vejo aí é a qualidade do vídeo, mas o vocal do seether tá cantando super bem essa música.
@Beavisandbuttheadrule
@Beavisandbuttheadrule 10 месяцев назад
They’re both good, but I definitely like Nirvana’s version a lot more.
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic 10 месяцев назад
♥️♥️
@Dariuszwwanie
@Dariuszwwanie Год назад
If Nirvana is an option they automatically win
@user-og8wx1cz7r
@user-og8wx1cz7r Год назад
Kurt and Nirvana are and always will be the best ever. R.I.P Kurt Donald Cobain. We love you and hope you rest peacefully, brother.
@brianbaker6303
@brianbaker6303 Год назад
Dude no contest most definitely Nirvana
@arfriedman4577
@arfriedman4577 Год назад
The original. I grew up with it. Not bad 2nd version.
@Musicforsoul23455
@Musicforsoul23455 Год назад
tbh seether
@ViceRockMusic
@ViceRockMusic Год назад
🤭
@Eurxnymous
@Eurxnymous 7 месяцев назад
Nothing beats Nirvana
@manuteboler
@manuteboler Год назад
Seether for sure, come on guys Nirvana did a good job covering it but seether wrote a banger with this one, gonna have to give it to them.
@gildissbarcellar6688
@gildissbarcellar6688 Год назад
O Shaun Morgan do Seether canta muitooooo... Pra mim ele é o cara que faz as melhores versões do Nirvana, mas sempre gosto mais do original - assim como gosto mais das músicas do Seether na voz Shaun.
@Jgf802
@Jgf802 Год назад
Nirvana don’t need to ask the ridiculous question
@stefanramisch8801
@stefanramisch8801 Год назад
Ever and ever the original.
@joeyorozco3691
@joeyorozco3691 Год назад
As much as Pat brought to Nirvana's sound, I prefer the trio. Dave just rox regardless of bandmates.
@Windykun
@Windykun 6 месяцев назад
I always forget that Kurt basically made sweet love to the microphone
@steveharris1974
@steveharris1974 Год назад
Nirvana obviously I love Nirvana
@MarkJohnson-rg5mr
@MarkJohnson-rg5mr Год назад
Kurt will and always be, he is is really good too just for the simple fact, that guy is too
@saulisprobablygreat
@saulisprobablygreat 5 месяцев назад
Literally Nirvana, they made the song and Kurt is literally a god.
@kellyzemartis
@kellyzemartis Год назад
Great cover but silly question.. Nirvana of course!! Kurt always
@Fanc-E-Kitten
@Fanc-E-Kitten Год назад
Shaun sounds like a Kurt who reached 35
@sephysycotic
@sephysycotic Год назад
Its truly not easy to cover nirvana songs and be better than the original...
@chuchu750
@chuchu750 Год назад
KURT COBAIN- NIRVANA 🙌❤️
@purplehairedholly
@purplehairedholly Год назад
Nirvana. Always. Kurt was and will always be the best 🤘
@chrishankins2114
@chrishankins2114 19 дней назад
Seether started as a nirvana cover band
@edwinhernandez6627
@edwinhernandez6627 Год назад
Just like KFC 🍗 The Orginal is the ɓest!!!!!! Long live the spirit of Kurt Cobain!!!!!! 🎸 🕊
@bailey7361
@bailey7361 Год назад
love seether but nirvana just rocks that song
@rayes119
@rayes119 Год назад
I love this song
@Zack_-st3se
@Zack_-st3se Год назад
Huge fan of both but gotta give it to Tommy vext version
@ledzep9943
@ledzep9943 Год назад
I love Seether. But Nirvana… this is a comparison that didn’t need to happen 🤣
@tonyascarlett2413
@tonyascarlett2413 11 месяцев назад
As good as Shaun Morgan is, it's Nirvana. It's ALWAYS Nirvana
@LaFlor718
@LaFlor718 10 дней назад
Just wanna leave this here. Around 23:30 she reads her moms text. The mother wanted her out because the mom wanted more benefits. Meaning the mother is on welfare. At 18 in a lot of states if your parent is on welfare, they lose the benefits they have for you because you are now a legal adult. So she could no longer milk her child and the system and wanted her out. I’m betting the son isn’t 18 yet. Also betting that someone told her that if your child who is 18+ opens their own case, they can get their own benefits, so now she wants her daughter back. I worked in the field for years and saw this happen many times. Sad and irresponsible on the mothers part.
@vintediscos9480
@vintediscos9480 Год назад
Nirvana !!
@lilafrazer7373
@lilafrazer7373 Год назад
Theres like....no questions ❓❓❓❓ kurt is tha fuckin goat
@watkinscharles829
@watkinscharles829 Год назад
Nirvana,no competition.
@AaronLakes-ge9su
@AaronLakes-ge9su Год назад
It's nirvana of course but Seether was the closest we ever got to a 2nd nirvana
@iwannabekrazylikerabb1t561
@iwannabekrazylikerabb1t561 Год назад
I think seether sounded better live but if it were studio it would be Nirvana
@mehmetetkagemici4981
@mehmetetkagemici4981 2 месяца назад
İnfamous second son version was the first one ı Heard and ıt's still the best version for me
@iamjesuschristintheflesh5866
Father John Misty’s cover is the best
@Erik-bd6ll
@Erik-bd6ll Год назад
I love seether, but nothing can beat the og
@sheronoswaldoguzmanocamp-tv2xm
Come on dude!! Nirvana meng!!😂😂
@donniewoodland8467
@donniewoodland8467 Год назад
To ask who did the song better as kurt himself wrote it ..i think im going to give it to the man that the song was about his life ..
@teabag402
@teabag402 5 месяцев назад
Love Seether but often emulated but never duplicated....I'm giving this one to Nirvana sorry
@eyeamnecyrb4567
@eyeamnecyrb4567 Год назад
sean got realy close to the original sound
@Demipaintings
@Demipaintings Год назад
Maybe I should try that one haha. Nirvana, mainly because they other guy has a lower gruffer voice
@druslocallawncare109
@druslocallawncare109 Год назад
Voices are so close but nirvana wins song is just cleaner sounding
@kanallzika6519
@kanallzika6519 Год назад
O QQ pega mn,Heart-shaped box e o q eh ,uma música romântica,nem tão alta e nem tão calma ,e o equilíbrio inigualável do Nirvana,mas o cover NN ficou ruim kkk
@user-yp7ri9qb5i
@user-yp7ri9qb5i 6 месяцев назад
Nirvana all the way no question about it
@Ziggy_stardust0
@Ziggy_stardust0 Год назад
Kurt ofc⭐