Тёмный

Noel Gallagher: Which Bands I'd Love To See Reform 

ShortList
Подписаться 2,4 тыс.
Просмотров 218 тыс.
50% 1

This week we sit down with the rocker to ask him your questions -this one is on who we'd love to see reform out of The Smiths, The Jam and Led Zepplin.
Subscribe to Shortlist’s RU-vid Channel for the latest videos: / shortlistmag
Get the full story on: www.shortlist.com/
Join the conversation on Facebook: / shortlistmagazine
Follow us on Twitter: Sh...
Go behind the scenes on Instagram: / shortlistmagazine

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 136   
@ellieodonnell8845
@ellieodonnell8845 9 лет назад
He needs to know this is how we all feel about Oasis.
@joelm6683
@joelm6683 5 лет назад
D
@BB.halo_heir
@BB.halo_heir 4 года назад
He knows and he appreciates it, im sure.
@jrkk6829
@jrkk6829 3 года назад
Things happen we have to accept, it’s so easy for us to want something to happen between others but, remember we also want things to happen for ourselves personally that are almost impossible too! Acceptance is hard but it’s a true strength we must achieve
@Jamesp1972
@Jamesp1972 2 года назад
not all of us, consign them to mid 90s history
@roundtheloopandback
@roundtheloopandback 2 года назад
He knows full well, he just doesn't want to do it, not sure I'd want to do it if what is said about liam and noels family is true.
@Bucboy1001
@Bucboy1001 9 лет назад
So weird, because that's exactly what people think of Noel/Liam and Oasis.
@562tap
@562tap 9 лет назад
***** i think it would be more of a joyce and morrissey dilemma rather than a morrissey, marr dilemma
@Bucboy1001
@Bucboy1001 9 лет назад
***** I would agree with that. Even so, I think Noel and Liam are still years away from reforming Oasis.
@lancashirebomber2739
@lancashirebomber2739 8 лет назад
+Bucboy1001 they only split a few years ago, the smiths is almost 30 years ago. perspective.
@sratus
@sratus 7 лет назад
Fire Dolphin I sure don't
@jmgmarcus808
@jmgmarcus808 7 лет назад
Fire Dolphin I hope they stay gone.
@euanmail3203
@euanmail3203 8 лет назад
He thinks of the Smiths what we think of Oasis
@filmnerd6137
@filmnerd6137 7 лет назад
Euan Mail not anymore Noel is a better singer now
@flyingspaguettmonster8738
@flyingspaguettmonster8738 7 лет назад
Both bands are crap !!! try King Crimson or Van der graaf generator
@laurencechurcher1511
@laurencechurcher1511 6 лет назад
no
@Picnicl
@Picnicl 5 лет назад
Speak for yourself, Euan.
@mattinfullvision9598
@mattinfullvision9598 4 года назад
I think this way about The Smiths and Oasis, I want them both to reform
@UpWithTheBirds23
@UpWithTheBirds23 8 лет назад
This is ironic.... this is how I feel about wanting to see Oasis in concert....they parted way and may never reconcile.
@shopo6847
@shopo6847 7 лет назад
SoSallyCanWait shut the fuck up and move on loser
@shopo6847
@shopo6847 7 лет назад
fuck off
@mattinfullvision9598
@mattinfullvision9598 4 года назад
I want Oasis and The Smiths to reform, wouldn't mind The Jam reforming too I love all 3
@BroKator2
@BroKator2 9 лет назад
Funny cause what he said about Morrissey and Marr sums up what fans think of him and Liam since they split up. Like, Chasing Yesterday is amazing, but wouldn't it be interesting if Liam sang 4 of 5 tunes, specially the up-tempo ones? Maybe the constant conflicts in Oasis were suffocating his creative process.
@TonyaLemon30
@TonyaLemon30 9 лет назад
BroKator2 Yeah it would be interesting with a 20-years-younger Liam, because his voice is really suffering right now. And I feel really sad about this, but it's true.
@cremnitz5345
@cremnitz5345 8 лет назад
Thats a poor argument though because every single album since morning glory (bar be here now) had fewer songs written by noel on and more and more mediocrity from the others...noel started holding back tunes for a solo career and became less involved with the creative process.
@Premofandabbadozy
@Premofandabbadozy 2 года назад
I’ve always thought in the heat of the moment with Liam on the verses and Noel doing the chorus would be unreal. Just imagine Liam snarling out “that lovin man ain’t no rolling stoooone”
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 Год назад
Well you need Rourke and Joyce to complete the band. And Liam and Noel would need the rest of their band to do a reunion. Without them you’re left with two controlling guitarists and two narcissistic singers. And I’m a fan of both alt bands. Morrissey being my inspiration for writing my own lyrics and my own singing back in the day.
@proserpine8857
@proserpine8857 8 лет назад
THIS IS SO IRONIC...
@KINGMONKEY1989
@KINGMONKEY1989 Год назад
Why ? It's not as if musicians in other bands who split dont talk about other bands that have and he'd like to reform. It's not ironic it's just his opinion on the bands he would want to say reform even for a while. I mean look at the Rose's and how successful that reunion tour turned out to be. Hampden park was there last gig ever again. And it didn't disappoint one bit. Along with The Scream it's one of the best and most emotional gigs ave ever been lucky enough to have been a part of.
@TheMisterMonkeyman
@TheMisterMonkeyman 9 лет назад
I absolutely agree with every word. And apply it to Oasis as well. Peace.
@haunter4708
@haunter4708 7 лет назад
NOEL. CAN YOU HEAR YOURSELF?
@denzil4
@denzil4 7 лет назад
I don't usually agree with Noel Gallagher but on the subject of The Jam reforming he's right. It'll never happen. The Jam's music as brilliant as it is stood for youth and class war. It would be silly for a man nearing sixty to be singing about being a teenager and political issues that were happening back in the the post punk era. The Jam stopped at the right time in my opinion and will always be remembered for the classic songs they released. They started their chart career at Number 40 and ended it at Number One. They were recording for five years and if you listen to every track they recorded you'll do very well to find a weak one. You will hear Paul Weller on a couple of tracks on Bruce Foxton's latest album but that's as close to a reunion as we're going to get.
@ludrixte1938
@ludrixte1938 10 месяцев назад
This logic can be applied to Oasis as well.
@thepaulmacfarlane
@thepaulmacfarlane 5 лет назад
If he means he saw Led Zeppelin at the 02 "reunion" * December 2007 I was there and chatted with him after. ; )
@sratus
@sratus 3 года назад
No I'm sure he means when he saw them at Earls Court in 1975 when he was 8 ya clown.
@lam19bo
@lam19bo 7 лет назад
He's talking about Oasis
@mattinfullvision9598
@mattinfullvision9598 4 года назад
He's not, he has no interest in reforming Oasis or even speaking to Liam, you're just relating it to Oasis which I do agree with but you have to know that Noel really isn't talking about Oasis
@camilarsz
@camilarsz 6 лет назад
He definitely knows how we feel, but why not doing something about Noel?
@timmitchproductions4216
@timmitchproductions4216 9 лет назад
Seeing the smiths live would be a dream come true, shame Noels right it'll probably never happen :(
@loochtunes
@loochtunes Год назад
Oasis and The Smiths are very similar bands. They launched into stardom thanks to two people and ended over their differences that may never reconcile.
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 Год назад
Morrissey, Marr, Rourke, and Joyce were great together.
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 6 месяцев назад
Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce were amazing! Don’t ever forget them. Morrissey, Marr, Rourke and Joyce were The Smiths. Great alt band.
@F10MTL
@F10MTL 7 лет назад
It's like what he says about a Smiths reunion also applies to Oasis getting back together... :-(
@PeteJones81
@PeteJones81 Год назад
Knew his answer before I started.
@captaincomputaa
@captaincomputaa 3 года назад
Can't argue there.
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 Год назад
Andy has joined Johnny on stage. I think Mike is still in touch. But no one speaks to Morrissey.
@defoperator7993
@defoperator7993 3 года назад
The bass player from the smiths goes hard too
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 Год назад
Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce best rhythm section.
@TheMaceo900
@TheMaceo900 7 лет назад
Zeppelin rules maaan
@brendanpeahl7055
@brendanpeahl7055 5 лет назад
The one comment that’s not about Oasis lmao
@stevens5541
@stevens5541 5 лет назад
Bag of shit
@lucasm3879
@lucasm3879 6 месяцев назад
The Verve were fantastic as a group, much more than the sum of their parts individually.
@oscaralbino374
@oscaralbino374 11 месяцев назад
😢😢😢😢 never gonna happen... RIP Andy😢
@uberkitsch3928
@uberkitsch3928 2 года назад
Oh the irony…. Imagine the two of them on stage together again it would be fantastic! No one sings those songs quite like Liam, no one plays those songs quite like him. Wise words one should consider Noel.
@bigtimeballer5010
@bigtimeballer5010 6 лет назад
Noel somehow turned the question into a speech about himself
@mattinfullvision9598
@mattinfullvision9598 4 года назад
I'd love to see Oasis reform, although I can imagine one of the two brothers getting hurt
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 Год назад
Morrissey, Marr, Rourke, and Joyce were great together. Morrissey and Marr were half the band. Need that great rhythm section of Rourke and Joyce. All four make up The Smiths. Great alt band.
@anthonyaylmer1704
@anthonyaylmer1704 5 лет назад
The best bands never reform...forever remembered in their prime.
@johnbarber9637
@johnbarber9637 3 года назад
You all talk about Liam and Noel. To see Oasis reform? I would pay 10x the money to see the La's reunite (Lee, John, Cammy, Neil) and release album #2.
@bowie9889
@bowie9889 3 года назад
Literally no one asked you
@bmarkyt132
@bmarkyt132 5 лет назад
Led Zep all the way. The Smiths too though would be nice.
@setobrownstone
@setobrownstone 4 года назад
0:57 This grimace man, hahah.
@badideaorgenius
@badideaorgenius 3 дня назад
The little man has done the right thing for once don't look back in anger.
@rizzledizzle3443
@rizzledizzle3443 2 года назад
The smiths will never reform but I agree, wow
@tommymorgan73
@tommymorgan73 2 года назад
I heard something that he would reform oasis for 100 million? He would definitely maybe (oi oi) make that and probably more if they did. They would sell out Wembley for countless nights along with the Ethiad. Not to mention Scotland, Ireland and Wales.
@Drummer8282
@Drummer8282 17 дней назад
This comment aged well 😆
@ustheserfs
@ustheserfs 3 года назад
Even Noel knows work of the Smiths is streets ahead of his own.
@warrenermish1454
@warrenermish1454 3 года назад
A jam, enough said
@Riffmaster227
@Riffmaster227 4 месяца назад
As big of a fan as Noel is of the smiths we are of Oasis. C’mon man do it for the fans.
@jhwalsh93
@jhwalsh93 4 года назад
Every time Noel says "great" take a shot
@lucasm3879
@lucasm3879 6 месяцев назад
I saw Oasis with the new line up in Summer 2000, for all those that haven’t seen them, it wasn’t ever the same after Bonehead and Guigs left (and the new material wasn’t as strong). They were still good but that was the feeling at the time with most of the fans. The best time to see them for me would have even been before Alan White joined, like on the Live By The Sea gig at Southend, before they became massive.
@rizvanxd8724
@rizvanxd8724 3 года назад
Stone roses oasis 😭
@palacerevolution2000
@palacerevolution2000 2 года назад
I know there is always some wise-ass who has to say it, but I feel like I do have to make sure Andy and Mike are included here. IMO, no band ever has become 'great' w/o having the engine room in place.
@vinceeager8553
@vinceeager8553 2 года назад
I agree, and I think Morrissey agrees as well. In his autobiography, Morrissey said he was offered £75,000,000 to tour with Johnny Marr, and said that the offer implied Andy and Mike were as replaceable as parts of a lawnmower Joyce ruined any chance of a Smiths reunion when he won his court case against Morrissey and Marr. Neither of them want to give him another penny, and I don't blame them
@ericsilberstein667
@ericsilberstein667 Год назад
@@vinceeager8553 I think it started when Morrissey and Marr secretly signed the contract without them. Marr and Rourke are still friends and are in touch with Mike, I believe. Mike is a gentleman. I’ve talked to him through Facebook. No one talks to Morrissey. Too much ego.
@stardust8359
@stardust8359 6 лет назад
I have heard same thing from so many famous singers, including Brandon Flowers of The Killers and Chris Martin of Coldplay and i just dont get why, tried very hard but can't get into smiths at all :/ i don't get whats so fascinating about them, someone help :D
@kwoylee5617
@kwoylee5617 3 года назад
I'm the same. I've tried, but I just don't get it.
@jerrysummers5971
@jerrysummers5971 3 года назад
The Jam 🤞
@krisscanlon4051
@krisscanlon4051 3 года назад
What no feelings Jefferson Starship or Air Supply reformation Noel ???
@mariusstrmglendrange2411
@mariusstrmglendrange2411 2 года назад
Sooooo pretty much how we feel about you and you r dear brother mate ;)
@oliverread2532
@oliverread2532 5 лет назад
His face at the ends tastes of irony.
@dannydorko7075
@dannydorko7075 4 года назад
you've tasted his face?
@jamesmcrory3419
@jamesmcrory3419 Месяц назад
Dire Straits!!!!!
@danfisher7097
@danfisher7097 2 года назад
The La’s
@robtrauth4518
@robtrauth4518 2 года назад
how about oasis reforming. that would be good.
@joedavies6407
@joedavies6407 8 лет назад
Noel going on like this but won't reform oasis when he knows he can't sing half as good as Liam
@hammill444
@hammill444 8 дней назад
Because some artists have integrity. Unlike Noel, whose now reformed Oasis is all about the money.
@TheGeniegenius
@TheGeniegenius 7 лет назад
a hero off the 90s a social climber from then on. you blew it noel
@Wearethewingmakers
@Wearethewingmakers 8 месяцев назад
Theres more chance of you and your brother sharing a stage than those two mate, sadly.
@anthony_stevens
@anthony_stevens 4 года назад
Fookin Oasis Noel... come onn
@thefakengx3839
@thefakengx3839 4 года назад
OASIS ya potatohead
@lucax8934
@lucax8934 5 лет назад
noel do you realize what youre saying? :,D
@pedrobarnez5502
@pedrobarnez5502 4 года назад
oh the irony
@docsavage8640
@docsavage8640 Год назад
The Jam actually could given there was no real reason they had to stop.
@Briank0912
@Briank0912 2 года назад
Irony
@nicholasgargano7396
@nicholasgargano7396 2 года назад
Noel tidy beard
@colinharvey840
@colinharvey840 7 лет назад
Saw Oasis live a couple of times and they were terrible. The audience were turning away, but the press would never dare tell you that. Better to believe the myth.
@bordercollie1140
@bordercollie1140 6 лет назад
COLIN HARVEY, if they were so terrible, why did you go a second time?
@aledum1815
@aledum1815 Год назад
@@bordercollie1140 True.
@aledum1815
@aledum1815 Год назад
Not true.
@michaelathanasiou2030
@michaelathanasiou2030 2 года назад
It's a sad situation we find our selves in the UK when we allow junkies to voice their opinions
@ieatcrayons3322
@ieatcrayons3322 2 года назад
Lol
@mojopin1997
@mojopin1997 Год назад
I don’t care as long as suede are still going.
@nathansmalle7054
@nathansmalle7054 2 года назад
A bit rich
@madforit2
@madforit2 3 года назад
I'm glad the smiths broke up because morrissey solo work has been tremendous
@jackcooper3307
@jackcooper3307 11 месяцев назад
Led Zeppelin don’t qualify; a quarter of the band is dead
@Grandmastergav86
@Grandmastergav86 2 года назад
Anyone but Oasis much like The Beatles, they're painfully overrated.
@AB-ds1lg
@AB-ds1lg 2 года назад
Boy I think cocaine ate most of his brain because he doesn't make much sense.
@marshallemmet1366
@marshallemmet1366 4 года назад
S a y s T h e G u y W h o R e f u s e s T o F o r m T h e B a n d A g a i n much less even talk to your own brother.
@ramdizzle9133
@ramdizzle9133 Год назад
The smith's over zeppelin?? I knew I never liked Noel.
Далее
Johnny Marr On Noel Gallagher
6:00
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Пришёл к другу на ночёвку 😂
01:00
Самый БОЛЬШОЙ iPhone в МИРЕ!
00:52
Просмотров 1,2 млн
10 things Noel loves\hates
2:59
Просмотров 961 тыс.
OASIS Roll With It
17:15
Просмотров 2,2 тыс.
Liam Gallagher Vs Cute Kids
4:12
Просмотров 4 млн
Why Wonderwall's Success Surprised Noel Gallagher  🎸
9:22
Пришёл к другу на ночёвку 😂
01:00