Тёмный

NT Greek or OT Hebrew? Which should I learn first? 

Biblical Mastery Academy
Подписаться 41 тыс.
Просмотров 24 тыс.
50% 1

Which of the major two biblical languages should I learn first - NT Greek or OT Hebrew? In this video, we have a discussion with Dr. Bill Barrick, Old Testament Professor emeritus at the Master’s Seminary to ask this question.
Learn Biblical Hebrew free at Dr Barrick’s website at drbarrick.org
To get started with biblical Greek, download your roadmap to mastery of the Greek New Testament at mntg.me/roadmap
Which would you learn first and why? Leave your comment in the comments section below!

Опубликовано:

 

16 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 165   
@pep4Christ
@pep4Christ 4 года назад
I started studying the Greek language first but when I started studying Hebrew I wished I had started with it first. Hebrew, to me is much simpler than Greek and it has a unique structure that I enjoy learning about.
@coldfusionmusical
@coldfusionmusical 3 года назад
I started with Hebrew because I was drawn to it very strongly even though others told me that Greek was easier. Till now I haven't really started learning Greek though I can read the script, which is quite easy. I don't regret my decision at all, Hebrew is actually easier grammatically. Biblical Hebrew can be learnt together with Modern Hebrew which can be spoken, this I find it very very helpful. Unfortunately for Greek, biblical Greek is often taught so differently from Modern Greek, especially in pronunciation, making it very difficult to switch between the Biblical and the Modern one. I can switch between Biblical Hebrew and Modern Hebrew quite easily, without feeling like I have to switch to another type of pronunciation. It would be better if Greek was taught with Modern Greek pronunciation so that students can potentially learn Modern Greek as well, because having a the modern spoken version of the language can greatly help solidify the Biblical vocabulary, making it feel more alive than just for the purpose of deciphering and translating. I can also pray in Hebrew, which gives me a sense of a linguistic pilgrimage to the Holy Land since I can't physically travel there and speaking the language of the people of our Lord. This is why being able to speak a language is so important, it really feels alive, not dead.
@KingoftheJuice18
@KingoftheJuice18 3 года назад
Nice comment. Yes, I agree that overall Hebrew is significantly simpler grammatically than Greek. Here's an example I like to use: In Greek there are 24 forms of the relative pronoun (not counting the indefinite relative pronoun). In Hebrew there's only one form. The hardest parts of Hebrew for English speakers are usually (1) the different alphabet; and (2) the verb structures (binyanim). But all things considered, it's just an easier language to master. However, for Christians there could be other motivations to start with Greek, as noted in the video.
@cosmicnomad8575
@cosmicnomad8575 Год назад
I love the Hebrew Language, it’s a fascinating language that just feels holy and is holy. But yeah, I hope to learn both to have a fuller understanding of the Bible and also because they’re both interesting languages.
@Quarton
@Quarton 3 года назад
I had 3 years of N.T. Greek before taking one of Hebrew. I found both to be great languages, but Hebrew was easier. Both are fantastic, but for different reasons. I love the light they each shed on the culture, and the people of their times. So, if I had the opportunity to choose, I'd learn Hebrew, then Koiné Greek.
@jossdr
@jossdr 2 года назад
Perhaps you say Hebrew was easier because you studied Greek first?
@appy115
@appy115 2 года назад
Having studied both Hebrew and Greek, I find Hebrew much easier. It just makes more sense to me.
@mikemccune4078
@mikemccune4078 4 года назад
I had Dr. Barrick as a prof at TMS. He really challenged me but taught me a lot! I learned Greek first and it does click faster with a western mind. Although, Hebrew, to me at least seems easier in some ways (the direct object is nice since it has a marker for that sometimes and the verbs are less complex or so it seems). As you said in the comments somewhere, Greek was "easy" to learn and then I got into a second year course and felt overwhelmed. I have found what Dr. Barrick says is true, if you love God's Word, it will help you overcome any difficulties in learning the language. I am also currently teaching Greek and Hebrew, I am by no means an expert but I know that endeavor forces me to learn it better, for which I am thankful. Thank you for your channel.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for watching! There is no better way to learn than to teach! Blessings!
@dianawho2810
@dianawho2810 4 года назад
סרטון מקסים. גם בתור דוברת עברית כשפת אם אני מוצאת את הטקסטים הקדומים ביוונית מרתקים למדי. הכי כיף לקרוא דברים בשפת המקור.
@jacobhouck1182
@jacobhouck1182 Год назад
As a native Hebrew speaker, were you able to just start reading the Hebrew original scriptures, or did it take some studying first?
@gilsalinas3224
@gilsalinas3224 4 года назад
Thank you for introducing Dr. Barrick!!! A very well presented video... I'm interested in both NT Greek and OT Hebrew. Hope to master both before the rapture! Great video... Gilbert
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@jesusstudentbrett
@jesusstudentbrett 4 года назад
The only rapture will be the return of Christ, him raising all of the dead and Judging us all.
@ArmyScoutMom
@ArmyScoutMom 2 года назад
These two are funny going back and forth! It is encouraging me to learn biblical languages. Just subscribed! 🙏
@bma
@bma 2 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@elizabethhankins6973
@elizabethhankins6973 11 месяцев назад
Such a fun video! I wanted to learn Greek but tackled Hebrew first since Aleph with Beth was further developed than Alpha with Angela. I'm most of the way through all of the videos for both of those programs and have to say that the Hebrew has been easier for me than the Greek. Granted, I have a looooooong way to go in my studies, so maybe I'll change my mind as I continue progressing, but that's where I land for now. Hebrew has seemed simpler, and Bethany and Andrew Case are pretty funny, so that helps too. (There have been numerous times when my husband has heard me laughing aloud as I'm studying and commented that it sounds like I'm having too much fun. That's an impressive feat for a language instructor!) One question I have regarding Greek and the Septuagint...how much additional vocabulary does one have to master to be able to read the Septuagint with ease (compared with say NT vocab)?
@nancyamanna4919
@nancyamanna4919 Год назад
Such a delight to listen to you both. Thank you Dr. Very grateful for your videos are of great help in learning Hebrew. Watched again and again. Now watching the grammar 2 first one. The devotionals are an absolute delight.Has been such a great blessing 💖. Weak verbs are tough to get. I got stuck here,but the wrestling is on. God's love stirs up so that will continue to study.
@thomassmedley8474
@thomassmedley8474 5 лет назад
Hebrew is on my "bucket list." I spent a decade reading through the Greek NT once a year for ten years, and am comfortable with that text, if not fluent. (I can read it for pleasure.) At the moment, I'm working on Turkish.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Awesome goal!
@TheStrataminor
@TheStrataminor 4 года назад
As a person who studies both, I am finding Greek easier in some ways...I find that my western brain just picks up Greek faster..but Hebrew is exotic and fascinating...however Hebrew has less vocabulary in one sense..hmmm if I could go back I would probably go and do Greek though....easier to pick up a bible and start reading something quicker...Greek I find that if you know the 'rules' you can make quick sense of the language, whereas Hebrew to me is more subjecting and intuitive.
@jamesroberts7021
@jamesroberts7021 3 года назад
Wow. I was watching one of Dr. Barrick's Hebrew lessons on RU-vid when Greek popped into mind and I found this video! And you're from NZ too. I've really been enjoying the Hebrew lessons from him and I know where to go when it's time to learn Greek.
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
Wonderful!
@crownedpillar3232
@crownedpillar3232 Год назад
Very interesting. I just started (again) to study greek in the morning & hebrew at night. Both are a struggle. I'm Indonesian. Indonesian nouns have no gender & for number we just write them twice for the plural, e.g. 'buku' is book, n for books we write 'buku-buku.' Indonesian verbs have active n passive voice & if we need reflecsive we just add an adverb before the verb. No tenses, we just use adverbs of time to indicate time. No case, the context have to tell the case. So even at the very beginning it is difficult to learn both hebrew & greek. First we need to understand that nouns have gender, etc. & verbs have all these aspects. Added to that is our order of word determined which noun is subject n which is object, unless we are using passive voice which implicitly tell which is the subject. It is fortunate that most Indonesian learned English as our second language. But to really get to the biblical languages we have to go through English, since we dont have many Hebrew / Greek references in Indonesian language. So many of us are discouraged because it is so difficult n take a long time to master Hebrew Greek, so that after finishing our bachelor's degree in theology or ministry, we don't touch the grammar books anymore. I was one of those many years ago, but this year I have committed myself to read n study Hebrew Greek all over again from scratch: I have forgotten all Hebrew & Greek, to the point that I have to learn to read every consonants & vocals all over again. So sad that I have wasted so many years forgetting about the languages our Scripture are originally written. Quite happy that I have advance in the learning though. Thank you for your videos, I have learned much from you.
@isaiah2810
@isaiah2810 3 года назад
I personally found Hebrew to be easier but I studied classical Greek in college, which is a lot more difficult than the koine Greek of the New Testament. Had I studied Koine, my opinion may be different. I found classical Greek to be extremely hard because it’s so irregular and it seemed like there was an exception to every rule. It was very grammatically unpredictable. Its also possible that I found Hebrew to be easier because I already had that preexisting foundation and knowledge of grammar of ancient languages through studying Greek, which may have made learning a second ancient language all the more easier.
@coleedward9642
@coleedward9642 Год назад
As Dr. Barrack said in one of his lectures, "Every rule has an exception... Including this one" 😂😂
@manikdey4619
@manikdey4619 Год назад
I first started learning Hebrew, Lason Hakodosh. Respect and love to Dr. William D. Barrick. I really feel proud of being his student.
@DavidYanesC
@DavidYanesC 4 года назад
I'm learning English to learn New Testament's Greek, but I wanna learn Hebrew too! XD Great channel!
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Keep up the great work!
@theodorawu9889
@theodorawu9889 4 года назад
I would want to learn Koine Greek first, though I love both testaments.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Nice! Sign up for the wait list at masterntgreek.com/membership. It would be great to be able to help you!
@hebrewgreek7420
@hebrewgreek7420 4 года назад
If you pursue Greek but forgo Hebrew, you’ll always be missing a huge influence on the NT. To truly understand the Greek New Testament fully, and especially the Gospels, you need Hebrew-arguably more than you need Greek itself. Aramaic is important for NT studies, as well, and a trilingual approach, which matches the trilingual environment of the Land of Israel in the 1st century (with Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek), is ideal and highly recommended.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
The ideal is that we learn all three languages. Unfortunately, for most this is very hard if not impossible. Thanks for your comment!
@thegoodshepherd7862
@thegoodshepherd7862 2 года назад
Hmm interesting ..... I was thinking of learning greek alone but now m having a second thought
@ExposingLieswithTruth
@ExposingLieswithTruth Год назад
Well this comment has helped me decide, thank you :)
@manikdey4619
@manikdey4619 Год назад
Glad to hear Dr. William D. Barrick,. My First Hebrew Teacher..
@migueldaviddavilapalomino3270
@migueldaviddavilapalomino3270 4 года назад
Thanks for this dialogue between this two gentlemen. I guess I prefer to think that greek help us introduce into the richness of the Bible, but Hebrew allow us to know it's depth.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@jimmellema7487
@jimmellema7487 4 года назад
I have been working on both Greek and Hebrew for many years and for me the Greek seems to come easier. I think it is partly because of the familiarity of the alphabet ( I was a math and physics major in college) and the similarity of the vocabulary and grammar to other Indo-European languages including English. Sometimes the differences in Hebrew intimidate me thus requiring more effort on my part to keep at it.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
English (and Math) borrow from Greek, so that will make it easier! Thanks for watching
@donovanaustinjr3708
@donovanaustinjr3708 3 года назад
I love Hebrew, both modern and biblical, and the way the language sounds. But I find that biblical Greek fits much easier into my native English brain.
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
With you there!
@MichaelHernandez-lc2wb
@MichaelHernandez-lc2wb 2 года назад
Nice video! Dr. Barrick, the best of the best
@oterosocram25
@oterosocram25 Год назад
I started with Greek, because of the relation to the NT, would love to master both though.
@danielstone2719
@danielstone2719 3 года назад
When I was deciding the determining factor was Greek because of the Septuagint. I figured I could at least largely read the OT in Greek. Hebrew is on the list though!
@rodrigopadron6655
@rodrigopadron6655 4 года назад
Great video! I’m currently working on Greek, I’m trying to get fluent on it. After that I wish to learn Hebrew for a better understanding of the whole Bible.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for watching, Rodrigo! Keep up the great work!
@wayner9628
@wayner9628 5 лет назад
Study Classical Greek especially Koine for Scriptural studies. The New Testament (oldest) copy is Greek, Old Testament in Greek is older than any surviving Hebrew copy. Not to say Hebrew is not important. Also, Greek furthers study in other periods of ancient Greek writings, Plato, Socrates, Homer, etc.
@bma
@bma 5 лет назад
Thanks Wayne!
@jesusstudentbrett
@jesusstudentbrett 4 года назад
That is kind of true... the Greek LXX has 4th centuries witnesses (Codices Vaticanus and Sinaiticus) and qutoed and referenced by early christian 2nd and 3rd century AD writers attesting primarily to the LXX but... the Dead Sea scrolls has lots of older Hebrew OT (200 BC to 50 AD).
@wayner9628
@wayner9628 4 года назад
@@jesusstudentbrett The Dead Sea Scrolls are fragments of the Old Testament. Due to Judaism's codification of the TORAH, they destroyed all known copies of the Older ones. The oldest OT Hebrew complete copy was written in about 1000 AD. This was severely damaged in recent events. So the Greek OT is at present, the oldest complete version of the OT. At the time of Christ, it was read more widely than the Hebrew due to the Jewish Diaspora across the Mediterranean area. They outnumbered the Jewish community in Israel.
@KingoftheJuice18
@KingoftheJuice18 3 года назад
@@wayner9628 Who supposedly destroyed :all known copies" of what "older ones"?
@theburlyburrito
@theburlyburrito 3 года назад
@@wayner9628 The Dead Sea scrolls are not all fragments, while some may be fragmented quite a few of them are complete or are large portions. Scrolls like this are the Great Isaiah Scroll or scroll 4Q41-4Q Deut
@BradCooperCCF
@BradCooperCCF 4 года назад
Great discussion! And I agree. Also, nice to learn about Dr. Barrick and his Hebrew course. I've watched a few of your videos now. Excellent content on helpful issues. Well done.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thank you, and thanks for watching!
@AmyAndThePup
@AmyAndThePup 3 года назад
In Hebrew, what I find confusing, so far, are some irregular nouns with suffixes, imperfect regular verbs, imperative regular verbs. Somewhere in the midst of those I feel like I've hid a roadblock. But i'm going to keep at it.
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
Yep, keep at it! The endings, proniminal suffixes and infixes, all make Hebrew morphology hard!
@TangomanX2008
@TangomanX2008 3 года назад
I'd say it depends on your goals. The two main difficulties with Greek are the participles. The Greek Participle takes everything that drove you nuts about conjugating verbs with everything that drove you crazy about conjugating nouns. I've only worked myself to half of a Hebrew Text (Basics of Biblical Hebrew by Pratico and Van Pelt), but I think I can say this. Part of Learning Biblical Hebrew also involves learning Tiberian Vocalization (those are the little extra symbols underneath the Hebrew letters, such as the patah, and the shureq. There is a whole set of these you need to memorize from the beginning (and that isn't the hard part I'm referring to). These symbols, as these Scholars know, are there to help the uninitiated make the correct vowel sounds when reading Hebrew. The problem is that words, including verbs and pronouns result in subtle changes depending on how and when they are used. These changes results in crazy grammatic rules and complicates the language. So when you learn the Hebrew Verb, you have to memorize different variations of verb conjugations due to these Tiberian Vocalization symbols (eg Strong & Weak Verbs). From what I've seen in the text books that I've seen, Its a good idea to do Greek first because, a) its easier, b) a decent course in Greek should give you a good review of English Grammar, which is important when studying a foreign language.
@andreialves6260
@andreialves6260 4 года назад
Thank you brother! Keep teaching greek! I'm from Brazil.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks! Keep studying! Blessings!
@mikeyoung8547
@mikeyoung8547 2 года назад
As an Orthodox Christian, the Septuaginta is more relevant to us than the Hebrew OT. Thus Koine will help me for the OT and NT.
@JohnVianneyPatron
@JohnVianneyPatron Год назад
I didn't really have a choice - at my seminary Hebrew was required before Greek and I think that's the correct order.
@alexdj28
@alexdj28 2 года назад
I like and always waiting explanation about Hebrew and Greek languages,it very interest for dig and interpretation content of our Bible.
@dooglitas
@dooglitas 4 года назад
I've studied both Greek and Hebrew. Neither one is easy to learn. However, I find certain aspects of Hebrew to be quite impenetrable. I don't have the advantage of having a professor to ask questions. Some aspects of Hebrew seem vague and confusing. The morphology of the verbs is also confusing for certain verbs. Also, there is a much greater availability of reference books for Greek than for Hebrew. Many Hebrew books are very expensive. If you know German or Modern Hebrew, there is a larger selection of resources available. I love Greek and the New Testament. So I spend much more time there than with Hebrew.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for sharing and watching! I hear you!
@dooglitas
@dooglitas 4 года назад
@@bma And thank you for doing what you do!
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Anytime!
@davidwhunt
@davidwhunt 3 года назад
Helpful & encouraging video. Thanks!
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@douglasarnold5310
@douglasarnold5310 Год назад
I have really been struggling with Hebrew I use dr. Bill Barricks Hebrew class on RU-vid I love it but I am not good in languages
@brettthaxton7511
@brettthaxton7511 4 года назад
For those people who are looking to learn Biblical Greek after having learned Biblical Hebrew and Aramaic, The Elements of New Testament Greek by Jeremy Duff is a great book to use. The book teaches the subject concisely and effectively. As a result, it does not take near as long to complete as some of the other introductory Greek Grammars out there. This way, you are able to get into the Greek New Testament Scriptures quickly; just make sure that you start reading your Greek New Testament immediately after completing the book. This way, you do not have to discontinue your Hebrew and Aramaic Scripture readings as you learn Greek. Lastly, it saves a lot of time to learn Greek this way for those who have hectic schedules. God bless!
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks Brett! I hope to review Duff at some point. Blessings!
@1994ZBO
@1994ZBO 3 года назад
I started with Greek several years ago and now that I am able to advance with Greek at my own pace through regular reading, I thought it was time to start with Hebrew. I've begun with John Dobson's Learn Biblical Hebrew textbook and I feel like my blissful ignorance 'about' Hebrew has made it much more enjoyable. In retrospect, Greek was much more difficult because of the baggage that I had accumulated in listening to people talk about how difficult of a language it was to learn. Everybody has an opinion about which resource is the best and which approach is best suited to individual learning. All of this factored into making Greek much more difficult to learn.
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
Thanks Zolt! I agree - lots of voices can be problematic. This is probably the strength of having someone you're learning under, as opposed to working by yourself and needing to get input from various authorities. Thanks for your comment and for watching!
@g.v.6450
@g.v.6450 8 месяцев назад
Did he say that Rabbinical Hebrew is different from Biblical Hebrew? I found some writings of Gregory Palamas (1296-1359) which were written in Koine Greek! (The people of Constantinople didn’t speak like this, but that’s how theologians wrote.)-another pro in the Koine Greek column. Although I’m learning Classical Greek in order to directly access more Greek literature.
@aneforeffort
@aneforeffort 2 года назад
That last comment made the stressful part seem better. We love God and His love letter to us was preserved in Hebrew and Greek. We will go through the effort to learn knowing the truth of this as our motivator. PS the lazy side of me wants to learn greek first but ideally id like to master both. God bless brothers!!!
@bma
@bma 2 года назад
One language at a time is the way to go! There is so much to learn it is easy to get overwhelmed, so learning one, developing competence with that one and then adding the second language is the way to go!
@aneforeffort
@aneforeffort Год назад
@@bma thank you gentlemen. Keep fighting the good fight of faith!
@wesleythemime
@wesleythemime 11 месяцев назад
Very helpful…thank you.
@stevenv6463
@stevenv6463 3 года назад
I learned Arabic before and OT Hebrew was so easy for me. Now I am struggling through Greek and I keep on wishing it was a semitic language.
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
If you already have a couple of languages, you can do it! It is interesting how different language families have different cognitive requirements though!
@Noname-qz5hg
@Noname-qz5hg 3 года назад
I speak an Arabic native speaker, so would this make Hebrew easier than Greek for me? Was learning Hebrew easier because you knew Arabic?
@stevenv6463
@stevenv6463 3 года назад
@@Noname-qz5hg Hebrew (especially biblical) is super easy from Arabic (especially فصحى). A lot of the grammar is quite intuitive and there are a lot of similar words. Greek is super difficult for me. I speak English and Spanish natively and it feels so foreign.
@Noname-qz5hg
@Noname-qz5hg 3 года назад
@@stevenv6463 This is so motivating! Thank you and God bless you 😄 One last question sorry haha, how long did it take you to learn hebrew?
@汪克豪
@汪克豪 3 года назад
I start to learn Koine Greek.It’s different with the Morden Greek. I wanna get some easy dialogue in Koine Greek,can you give me some material,Doctor!
@deanahill4529
@deanahill4529 Год назад
Thank you. I am ready to learn. Great information. I do love the Lord God Jesus Christ and I want to learn the language. I have been so hungry to learn. There were just many things in the way. I need to learn now. Where do I begnin
@theoglossa
@theoglossa 2 года назад
I love the exchanges here. Greek or Hebrew?
@seankennedy4284
@seankennedy4284 Год назад
Thank you, fellas.
@AmyAndThePup
@AmyAndThePup 3 года назад
I started out with Hebrew. Got through to prefixes and suffixes for certain verbs, and lost my way. I'm blind, so learning in braille, which means I'm not sure how to type out the words I was needing to translate into Hebrew, if I were to show you an example. I think it's something about imperatives on perfect verbs? If anyone has a rather older book by Weingreen, A Practical Hebrew Grammar, it's around lesson 40 that I get confused. I feel like he barely goes over it at all. I have another book by Fullilove , that's written in another way of accenting Hebrew, so it's like learning a completely new language (very difficult to explain to sighted people.) This means I don't know where to look in his book, or whether it would help me understand the prefixes and suffixes more clearly. I'm reading a little about Greek, and what throws me are all the rules with the grave, circumflex and acute vowels. It makes a little sense, but, in braille, each of these are different symbols, so like, say, epsilon. Would be a braille e, but then, the other three with the accent marks are completely different characters. It's the same with Hebrew, but in Hebrew, the vowels seem to have fewer changes, the rules fewer. It seems easier to grasp, more streamlined, more structured. Often, learning a new language in braille is learning two new languages. It's a lot of work, but I love the puzzle of translating Hebrew. I've wept over Bible verses that I could finally understand. Even simple ones! "God created the heavens and the earth." I just cried and cried. It was powerful. There's a profound and deep emotional connection there. There've been several times this has happened. I'm a novice musician, and extremely detail-oriented. Maybe this is why Hebrew comes more naturally to me? Or maybe it's where my heart is, for some reason. I'd love to learn both, though. When I pick up Greek, I'll be able to say what I think of learning it. I suspect seeing words in English based somewhat on Greek will be fascinating and really fun to learn. How difficult do people find trying to learn both at the same time?
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
Wow. Great work! Keep up the great work! I found learning both at once hard, and I know others have too!
@josephde-zordi7324
@josephde-zordi7324 3 года назад
it is essential to learn these languages, especially since we have so many detestable english miss translations, that promote ignorance, such as King James
@eurech
@eurech Год назад
How about this: learn them at the same time? Good or bad idea?
@bma
@bma Год назад
Great question. I tend to recommend you do them one at a time rather than together. The more time you devote to it the easier it will be, but I've found that learning them together multiplies the difficulty of learning by a factor somewhat greater than 2x.
@sheffeyrogers379
@sheffeyrogers379 5 лет назад
"Once you have greek under your belt". Ha! That seems like a statement that needs to be explained. How "under your belt" should you be in Greek before hebrew if you get to choose?
@bma
@bma 5 лет назад
Great question. There is a higher level of discomfort after Greek which makes it harder.
@SixStringOverdose
@SixStringOverdose Год назад
All this and no mention about Hebrew being written right-to-left?! :D I'm shocked :P
@justinj_00
@justinj_00 Год назад
I was told in college that most Bible students tend to have either a "greek brain" or a "hebrew brain" meaning one of the Biblical languages usually comes much more intuitively to a student than the other. In my experience I've found that to be very true. The greek language has come very naturally to me, while everything about Ancient Hebrew feels alien to me, while my roommate at the time (who was taking Hebrew and Greek simultaneously) took off and excelled in Hebrew while struggling with Greek. I think the biblical languages serve as a good illustration of the overall principle that God has gifted different Christians in different ways and our strengths work together for the glorification of God
@g.e.k1047
@g.e.k1047 2 года назад
Hi, I’m looking to purchase a Hebrew and Greek Bible software where each Hebrew/Greek word has its own definition. Do you recommend any particular software? Thank you for your time and I appreciate your expertise.
@bma
@bma 2 года назад
I use Logos Bible software most of the time. I've published a number of videos on Logos including this one: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-kdIwlR9OYKI.html - you can find more about Logos 10 at bma.to/logos10
@joybabu2075
@joybabu2075 2 года назад
I started with Greek but am much interested in Hebrew culture
@christo-chaney
@christo-chaney 3 года назад
I’m Jewish and I love having my JPS Hebrew-English Tanakh to use.
@lynnphimsoutham5328
@lynnphimsoutham5328 3 года назад
I started in Hebrew and found that the Greek was a little more time consuming, and somewhat familiar because of having studied Latin for 4 years as a teen. The Hebrew was fine until I got into the piel, hitpiel, etc.
@dennissantos7704
@dennissantos7704 4 года назад
For me am i got interested very lately so my interest is greek becasuse the application of new testament is very usefully in our daily lives thats why it is very interesting to learn the greek. But some one the verse in NT is needing a verse in OT basic you step little bit backward if you want to learn them both. Thank for this topic it ist very sensable
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@lloydcrooks712
@lloydcrooks712 Год назад
Learnt Greek first currently learning Hebrew must admit enjoy Hebrew more than Greek. Greek has more rules but easier to learn the vocabulary than Hebrew
@elijah4840
@elijah4840 4 года назад
What is the different of biblical and non biblical Greek? If Aramaic is in the Old and new Testament, then at what point do I learn that?
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Biblical Greek is known more broadly as koine Greek and encompasses the Hellenistic Greek used from around 300BC to 300AD. There are just 10 chapters of Aramaic in the Old Testament, and the rest is Hebrew. So this video argues Greek first, then Hebrew, then Aramaic.
@elijah4840
@elijah4840 4 года назад
Master New Testament Greek Thank you! I appreciate your response!
@TubeVision2
@TubeVision2 3 года назад
If we can read the Septuagint in Greek, should we study Hebrew?? Is there value in learning two different biblical languages, or could we do just as well with Greek alone?
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
The Greek OT is a translation from Hebrew, and in some parts is very different to the Hebrew, so I think there is still a lot of value in learning Hebrew. I hope that helps!
@prince223681
@prince223681 3 года назад
Does this apply to modern languages? Or only accident version?
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
We're primarily talking about learning Greek vs Hebrew for the purpose of reading the Bible in the languages it was written in. Generally speaking, the closer a language is to what you already know, the easier it should be to learn.
@BaawBee
@BaawBee 3 года назад
For some reason Duolingo teaches Hebrew in hebrew. I did the Japanese one and arabic one and they both taught it with english. I don't know why
@rubyvampiredean.
@rubyvampiredean. 3 года назад
I love ALL languages🤩🤩🥰🥰
@YaIshe
@YaIshe 3 года назад
How about learning Latin
@joybabu2075
@joybabu2075 4 года назад
Am interested in cultural background
@stevothebrush
@stevothebrush 3 года назад
Recommended text book/primer for learning Hebrew, self-taught?
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
Sure. Dr. Barrick recommends Kutz and Josberger which you can find on Logos at mntg.me/lbh or on Amazon at amzn.to/3AdNseo. I hope that helps!
@baruchbobo9993
@baruchbobo9993 Год назад
Wouldn't starting "In the Beginning" make sense!
@Aris-yb1uy
@Aris-yb1uy 4 года назад
I have finally decided to enroll in Koine Greek at the University of Western Australia after having read the Old Testament and several ancient texts related to Gnosticism and Hermetism. I find that both these languages are subject to a lot of controversies, especially within the biblical context. Chief Rabbi of the Turin Hebrew community said in a conference that the Greek Bible is a disgrace to the Jewish community. That's a very interesting statement. Many words have been interpreted from biblical Hebrew to greek and unfortunately, we still do not know the meaning of several Hebrew words such as Elohim, Ruach, kevod etc... That makes me very confused especially considering that the Bible is a source of inspiration for governments and people in power who claim to having a divine truth from it
@DarrylBurlingNZ
@DarrylBurlingNZ 4 года назад
Thanks for your comment! I hope you enjoy learning Koine Greek! Don't be held back by other people's opinions. The value of reading the original languages is to follow the thoughts of the original authors in their own language. Enjoy!
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Thanks for watching!
@gilsalinas3224
@gilsalinas3224 4 года назад
@@DarrylBurlingNZ Thanks for the comment. I appreciate your advice and focus!!!
@au8363
@au8363 Год назад
Glory To The Triune GOD
@michaelfalsia6062
@michaelfalsia6062 3 года назад
Greek first! Definitely Greek first unless you are that adept and capable! In my view the new testament is essential and necessary for any proper understanding of the old testament. Our best English translations are worthy and good enough to reveal what God conveyed to man in the Hebrew. But if you can do both effectively then in the immortal words of Rocky "GO FOR IT!
@tracilong681
@tracilong681 2 года назад
Are you with the beard Greek because you sound Australian... I guess I don't really know what the Greek accent sounds like
@bma
@bma 2 года назад
I'm from New Zealand, which is why I don't have an accent 😜. The Greek accent would have sounded different all around the Greco-Roman world. 😀
@danilomillendez4343
@danilomillendez4343 4 года назад
Sir, as far as I know, your OT Hebrew was just a copy from Greek called Septuagint becoz the surviving manuscripts were Greek, the Hebrew original has been long gone or maybe destroyed during the course of time, what we have now is an incomplete dead sea scrolls maybe a copy from the original one.
@bma
@bma 4 года назад
Actually, the Greek Septuagint is a copy of the original Hebrew, and while we don't have original Hebrew texts, neither do we have the original Septuagint texts. The evidence for the original ancient texts is found in copies regardless of whether we are talking about the Bible, Dead Sea Scrolls, Plato, Seneca or any other ancient text. This is why we have text criticism as an academic discipline. :) Thanks for your comment!
@baqarah131
@baqarah131 7 месяцев назад
Hebrew first. Greek like English is an Indo-European language, and Greek translates well to English. Not so Hebrew. which is a whole new way of thinking. The Bible in Hebrew is incomparably beautiful. Translation is only a shadow or the original.
@raysalmon6566
@raysalmon6566 Год назад
im on my own and deaf but post my stuff on mewe baby biblical Greek few comments but helpful
@Tom-bs3zh
@Tom-bs3zh 4 года назад
Or you could learn Coptic. Then if you want to learn Greek or Egyptian Hieroglyphics you will already have a headstart.
@theburningelement.6447
@theburningelement.6447 3 года назад
By far Hebrew
@kylec8950
@kylec8950 3 года назад
Hebrew. It was probably the first language ever spoke by Adam and Eve, and the Biblical Greek builds off the Hebrew.
@logosphone
@logosphone 3 года назад
At the time of Christ the Jews spoke Greek was the international language and Aramaic, Hebrew knew. The Pharisees the simple people did not know Hebrew. This was the reason the seventy Jews in origin translated the old into Greek. The apostles often refer to it. On the contrary, the Hebrew changed life span in time of people so as not to attribute the advent of Christ removed the 53 chapter of Isaiah and other changes. So that the Greek translation is more authentic.
@bma
@bma 3 года назад
It sounds like you're confusing what the Jews do and believe with what is written in the Hebrew Texts. There is very little that has changed over the last two millenia in the Hebrew TaNaK, and the most significant is probably the addition of the masoretic pointings and masora. Isaiah 53 is still there. So, regardless of what the Pharisees may or may not have known (and your point about them not knowing Hebrew is dubious), the text hasn't changed as you suggest and therefore the Greek OT is not more authentic. Can you share with me where you learned this? Thanks for watching!
@talentheturtle
@talentheturtle Год назад
5:54 😁
@tataondit49
@tataondit49 2 года назад
Greek is more popular in world
@angelamc2923
@angelamc2923 Год назад
Cute video, but it's shocking that the Hebrew professor didn't role out the best argument for Hebrew-- that we need to understand Hebraic thought and culture to understand scripture, including the New Testament which was written by Jewish people. The problem with prioritizing Greek is that people end up subconsciously thinking that Greek meanings and culture are the key to understanding instead of Hebraic thought. They then try to prove their theologies based on Greek word studies instead of the underlying Hebraic concepts being referred to. Regardless of the NT being in Greek, all the authors were Jewish, or in the case of Luke, learned the faith from and interviewed Hebrew speakers who had a Hebraic perspective. It might even be better to read the Gospels and James, at least, in Hebrew and just refer to the Greek when you want to check something, exactly like most people do with their English Bibles. Note: I am not advocating for any weird Messianic promotion of Gentile believers keeping Mosaic Law or rabbinic customs, just common sense understanding that Jewish writers were expressing Hebraic concepts and culture in Greek as best they could, but we take Greek thought and mindsets (plus tradition, modern thought and practices) and import them into a fundamentally Hebraic book, including all the Hebraic-theology based New Testament teaching, and acts of a Hebrew Savior and Hebrew apostles, prophets, and evangelists.
@Массинисса-у1э
@Массинисса-у1э Год назад
For me Hebrew is much easier because I know Arabic.
@goldengun9970
@goldengun9970 2 года назад
No such thing as an OT. We do have a tanach though
@tataondit49
@tataondit49 2 года назад
More biblical knowledge in studying Greek or Hebrew refer to bible
@dougmajor6992
@dougmajor6992 Месяц назад
We could just read it in our language and it's the same love letter. Religion says we have to learn the original language, yet many scholars who were more proficient than any of us translated the Bible into our language. God created man, therefore God is the God of all language. I will stick with English and use a Strongs Concordance when I want to know a Greek or Hebrew literal meaning. I can learn so much more from studying the Bible which will produce a transformation in my life,. Think about how much more value you could be to yourself and others if you put as much time into the word of God and not the languages used to communicate that word. There is no 11th commandment thou shall be proficient in Greek and Hebrew to show your self approved. Christianity is about studying the life and teachings of Jesus, not what language He spoke them in. Religion will be religious, I challenge everyone who takes Greek and Hebews to feel educated or well-studied to master the languages if they are vital for you to learn. You also need to add Aramaic to make sure you become a master translator! If you want to study it because you enjoy it, then great, but a lot of academics try to act like it's imperative to study these languages or your degree program is lacking..... Maybe they have become so religious and linguist masters that they missed the simplicity of the gospel, Furthermore, I'm willing to go out on a limb and say the professors of the languages miss the Great Commission of Jesus and don't win souls or win many souls, I will also say they haven't won ONE soul using Greek or Hebrew! This is religion vs relationship and the perfect picture to put the proper perspective of God vs man's thoughts and mind in place. I know this will cause a lot of people who studied these languages to manifest, as they will hate hearing this, but that proves my point even more. Check your hearts if you think studying Greek and Hebrew is a must, then check God's.
@bma
@bma Месяц назад
Thanks for your comments. However, given you’ve not learned the language(s) you are probably not in a great position to argue that it doesn’t provide sufficient value for the time invested. I agree that it isn’t for everyone though. Thanks for watching!
@harrybrooks8514
@harrybrooks8514 Год назад
Learn Sahidic Coptic first 😁
@autumnwoe6356
@autumnwoe6356 Год назад
Learn Hebrew first. Then you won't need Greek. 😂😂
@micat89
@micat89 Год назад
Hebrew first . The language of the Bible is and still HEBREW .
Далее
Greek NT: How to choose a Greek New Testament
12:32
Просмотров 11 тыс.
How Similar Are Biblical Hebrew and Biblical Aramaic?
24:24
The Ultimate Showdown!! Septuagint vs Hebrew Bible
11:36