OH GOD NO but something's wrong... (FNF Cover) 

Wait so if this had lore, would that mean when peach got kidnapped it was a cover up for meetings or something? Edit: No clue how I got the most likes but uh…thank you all.

"I HATE YOU!" but Luigi remembered the bro code.

Background/Lore: (Nova’s Take) Before the beginning of the Creepypasta, Luigi. Spying on Bowser at the time with peach, noticed something peculiar. Instead of Peach actually being a tad frightened.. as she normally was, she was grinning from ear to ear. Almost as if she actually enjoyed this life of being “Kidnapped” Luigi thought nothing of it… at first. He just went along with Bowsers plans like always, however. He was slowly beginning to notice he was showing Peach more of his new estate, and she seemed much more lively then Mario and her. Luigi, guessing that something was seriously wrong. Decided to backpedal, despite him wanting fame.. harming his brother wasn’t something keen in his eyes anymore. It just wasn’t for his life, so he went to his brother to tell him all about what he saw. Mario, despite being pissed off that Luigi would almost betray their brotherhood, at least agreed something was fishy about the constant kidnappings of peach, which happened multiple times. Both brothers began to make their way to the castles Seperately though different passageways, Mario took the passage we know. Luigi, still having a key. Entered though the secret way in, managing to catch up with his brother real quick. A short while later, after the brothers fully caught up. Peach intercepted them. “YOU THOUGHT KOOPA WORKED ALONE!?” So.. Luigi wasn’t lying about Peach betrayal. A bit of surprise to him, but not that big of a surprise. Looks like the Mario brothers will have to take care of her. Double Trouble Style… Who would see the sunlight and fresh air again? Who would melt in the boiling hot lava underneath.

“I was sleeping with King Koopa all along!”

“you thought koopa slept alone?”

A better title for this would be The Wrong Castle

1:28 Mario And Luigi’s line “because we’re the heroes” 1:35 Peach’s “you’re no longer my heroes”

Best possible ending, Mario still has his brother real

Even Luigi is like “yo what the heck”

This is an interesting turn to the creepypasta HAHAHA

I have a lore idea: the only reason Princess Peach gets kidnapped is because deep down she really does love him and of all the times she has been kidnapped she was planning to find a magic spell to make him human without the brothers getting in the way but with the secret pipe as a shortcut to get straight Castle only to find Princess not in the cage, she was standing on the other side bridge when she finally showed her true colors and intentions, Mario and Luigi shocked about the real reason why, Mario thought Peach love him but instead he was part of the plan the whole time, the adventures, the determination in risking his life were all for nothing.

lore for this cuz why not: basically peach has been getting kidnapped more often and makes luigi suspicious of it but mario dosent think anything about it and then peach says that she is captured again but this time luigi comes with mario and tries to find out whats going on and then they get lured here and then the cover happens

Thanks I wasn't expecting Princess Peach to betray them like that

Lore I made up: Mario and Luigi was too tired for always saving/rescuing Princess Peach so they let her be kidnapped, then Koopa asked Peach to worked with her, Princess Peach accepted, Later, Mario and Luigi felt bad as to wanting to save the princess, Princess Peach was angry at them for not saving her so she betrayed them by working with Koopa. (This is kinda dumb idk) Also I feel like the title name should be: ‘Royal Betrayal’ And the lines should be, 1:28 Mario and Luigi: “Because you’re our princess!” And Peach: “I’m no longer your princess!” 1:35

Now i could imagine if toad has betrayed mario, luigi & peach

This actually make some level of sense, Peach can actually fight Bowser and win.

I feel like Peach would say "You thought I wanted to be saved?" instead of "You thought Koopa worked alone?" as the former just makes more sense for her.

i'd like to think that in this IHY timeline peach was hooking with koopa/Bowser all along but luigi notices this in one random day that he decided to save her on his own but when he found out about peach's little affair, Luigi ran away as fast as he could without being seen , then he arrives at their home to warn mario about what he has seen with a face of disbelief and impotent to face it alone but mario at first does not believe luigi... so luigi forces mario to tag along on a adventure together after the long adventure through the 8 worlds they arrive at koopa/Bowser's castle luigi angered because of peach playing with his elder brother's feelings he kicks the castle's doors wide open as he yells ''PEACH !!!!'' in a burst of rage, mario was doubting luigi and even disregarding some of his points but luigi was still determined to show him the truth even if it meant that it would hurt him our heroes arrive at the lava bridge on where they see a peach with a wedding dress and a ring in one of her fingers, mario. now seeing the truth exposed to his very eyes falls on his knees as his body shakes in horror luigi faces peach in a fiercful battle. after the fight, peach severely damaged fell on her knees and looked down as luigi prepared to give her an encore he's stopped by an running yet furious mario who uppercuts peach and gives her the good ol' f-air, falling into the lava peach glances at luigi with a dissapointed face as she screams ''I HATE YOU!!!!'' - in the aftermath: mario and luigi save the day once and for all, after their crazy adventure mario apologizes to luigi for doubting him, luigi accepts his apologies and tells mario: "it's a ok brother. remember no matter what, i'll always have your back as you have with mine." 4 monts later the new ruler of the mushroom kindom was crowned as of the blue and yellow toads became the princes of the kingdom bowing to do better than what peach has done. after the new toad princes's coronation ceremony,the two mario brothers walk back home as they laugh in pure happiness knowing that no matter what, they'll always have each others backs

"you though luigi worked with koopa" "well no I AM"

1:29 “We through you were our princess” 1:36 “I was never your princess”

This would be the biggest plot twist in gaming history, knowing that she was never a naive and defenseless princess haha.

Alternate title : if matpats theory of peach being the villain was true and bowser was actually the good guy

mario:cmon luigi! lets get bowser and save the princess! luigi:okie dokie mario! after a long aventure,the brothers finally arrived at the castle of their enemie but... mario:wait..why bowser is not here? luigi:look mario! its the princess! mario:princess! cmon lets get out of here! peach:.....you tought that koopa was alone? mario:what? but why? you are our friend! luigi:Mamma mia! what are we gonna do mario? mario:...if she is with bowser then... we need to defeat her! luigi: alright bro! sorry princess.. but you did this to yourself!

Nadie habla del hecho de que la voz de peach al inicio es la voz ia de hatsune miku?

This was extremely Spectacular and I just love it keep up the great work and don't stop making possibilities.👍❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

At least Luigi remembered the bro code.

I love this cover 😊

2:08 2:09 Bueno,en vez de sonar amenazante,sono como si estuviera mal de la garganta XD

I need a "I hate you" cover with Peach

The twist that everyone expected

This Cover makes me Remind Something like about "If Super Mario Co-op had a Bad Ending

the sign at the wall written will be "I DISLIKE MARIO AND LUIGI NOW!"

Smg4 peach: you thought the tv man worked alone?

Mario and Luigi: Alr your good with bowser let’s just leave you here💀💀💀💀💀💀

What would happened if you choosed 2 players in i hate you creepypasta:

Story mode - Mario and Luigi were about to save the princess but then peach teams up with Bowser while betraying the brothers

I mean, it would make sense that she worked together with bowser... First what would this mean? It would mean that all those kidnapping attempts were planned together, why fake a kidnapping? Normally it would be for ransom, but in this case could mean that it was a cover up for secret relationship... The best way to hide an accomplice is faking your own hatred towards them (case 2 of rain code) This also would make sense with another fact..... There's something inside the mario games that never made sense, the fact that peach is a princess that lives in a castle but got no guards.. Nothing protecting her, aside from the mario brothers. If she really hated being kidnapped then she would invest more in security for herself, but she doesn't. This would make sense if she actually got an affair with bowser, she wouldn't need security if the attacks are planned. Also first game, why there's so many castles with fake bowsers with a toad telling Mario that the princess is in another castle? Like.. Why build castles and kidnapp toads? Easy, the castles and toads are decoys, all to delay Marios quest into rescuing the princess, so bowser and peach can have more time together. In mario 3 peach says the same exact line that the toads say "the princess is in another castle" well in the end she was joking... But how did she know the exact line that the toads said each time? Because those were scrippted by her. And this grand finale it would be the lies reviling, peach against the two mario brothers (with background help from bowser)

When peach got kidnapped for the last time:screw it I'm joining you

I hate you -> disarming heart

Yeah I prefer this story than Luigi hating Mario.

This is why we have pals before gals.

Mario: Not What As I Was Expecting

tbh mario and luigi would absolutely obliterate peach she has no chance

lol, Mario looks horrified, Meanwhile, Luigi looks like he's ready to throw down. lmao

Thank you Mario But Toad is in another castle

I remembered a song, a part of the song went like this "what if the bad guy wasn't the bad guy? What if the hero wasn't really good? What if the damsel in distress was just living her life? And he took her away from the one she loved" I think that is the best way to describe this

"You thought Koopa was the villain?"

Hey, Twitter user who made this here! Sorry it took so long for me to see this, but thanks for using my images lmao def made my day! (Nice cover too.)

my lore bowser made a deal that he would stop attacking the mushroom kingdom if she kills the bros but mario and luigi end up killing the princess and the rest of the kingdom understands until peach comes back exiled from her own kingdom

*"You thought Koopa slept alone?"*

"You thought koopa trusted you Luigi?"

Just realized this is coronation day peach chromatic without effects

I feel like the lore is that after peach got kidnapped by bowser then kamek put some spell on peach so when mario and luigi got there it was to late and they ended up killing peach

"You thought the koopa could KIDNAP ME?" But you're-a our princess! "YOUR PRINCESS IS IN ANOTHER CASTLE." YOU FOOL. CAN'T YOU SEE WHO YOU'RE DEALING WITH? I'M THE *QUEEN* OF THIS KINGDOM!!!

Does DJ Hallyboo attack *cheaters* too? Punchline: Peach cheated on Mario (with bowser) like he was Mario Party DS and she had cheat codes

1:28 L:"I thought you were he's (Mario) hero.." M:"Why did you two betrayal me..?" 1:35 P:"He was never my hero!"

If Peach finally had enough of the brotherly rivals:

i guess this is before Peach turned into Victim 1.

ALT Name: You boys are too late, BOWSER AND I ARE MARRIED (Cool cover btw)

This were princess peach joins the loops army and she put in the lava below

I throught I was working with the koopa

What, es buen concepto alterno

"you thought you were the hero of the story?"

"you thought koopa leave alone?"

Instead of Peach, it's should be sad Toad 1:10

You should make one where peach sings “I hate you”

I want this to be an alternative part of the i hate you lore😕😕 Peach getting kidnapped by bowser evey time doenst that sound suspicious, peach probaly has been planning something to attack mario and luigi. Send this to the developers

It's the Similar to SMG4: Let's Go Visit Peach

Alternate title: Oh God No but the lore is confusing

Lore of OH GOD NO but something's wrong... (FNF Cover) momentum 100

Because you’re my princess

Mientras tanto en un universo alternativo

guess bowser was getting some peaches

Peach: pensaste que trabajas para los buenos ?

Dang peach cover

Bro como que tu copia de Mario Hackroom I Hate You esta un poquito diferente, no crees?

This time, it’s 2 player.

Bro we nead to get i hate you song on this dude

Alternate line: "YOU THOUGHT I NEEDED SAVING?"

1:11

Alt: We were deceived

1:23

"You think I was getting kidnapped?"

You thought I want to be saved?

so would GF be the player character in the next song

Song name Royal betral

Mario:like a the couch? That’s where ur a sleeping tonight. Peach:WAIT IM SORRY Luigi:I agree with a Mario

Luigi Peach drunk again'a

Jajjaa wtf (aunque podria pasar la verdad)

CAUSAAAA

why can I see this being a thing?

Creepy pasta but you got bro as player 2

Unexpectedly 😅 For that's true

I hate you .exe 2 player ending

Guys Idk but I heard Mario said morty?!?

Bruh that's just kamek disguised as peach

0:03 2:00

Luigi be like: Wtf

It think this is the alternative universe where peach was the one who caused all of this?

Peach has been brainwashed 💀