I can feel the electricity between Emma and Hook, but with her and Neal I feel nothing but a past history and a shared child between them. She may love Neal but she is not in love with him. I believe that Emma and Hook share similar souls. CAPTAIN SWAN FOREVER!!!!
While the "When I win your heart...." speech was lovely, what really gets to me in this scene is how confident he is in her abilities. At this point, romance really isn't even close to the top of Emma's priority list - all she can think about is finding her son, and Killian's reassurance of his belief in her is something that she very much needed to hear. It's clear that she's highly doubtful of herself, so hearing him say he's "yet to see her fail" and that he knows she will succeed was just the self esteem booster she needed. That's what makes this scene incredible to watch, and also what makes it plain to see that Killian is better suited to Emma than anyone else.
I think what it is about his confidence, is that he believes in himself and has faith, that if he continues to be the honourable man that he has been, and fighting for her, that is how he will win her heart... but he wants the Emma, that will want him over Neal, over her walls etc. His faith in his love is good because there isnt a fear and love is about overcoming fear etc.
I love how much Emma has come to rely on Hook to give her strenght and confidence in herself, I mean the way she ask "you think so?", he's the only one who has believe in her since the beginning. Captain Swan forever!!
Hook has faith in his love & belief that he has for Emma, and thats what love should be, faith in your love “So when i win your heart Emma, and I will win it, it won’t be because of any trickery. It will be because you want me"
Agreed, Shauna!! It was hard to hear. But those are the single best words ever spoken!!! **SQUEEEEEEEE**** CAPTAIN SWAN ALL THE WAY!!! Oh my gosh. I can't even......
This is probably my favorite Hook and Emma scene. He was so honest with her and I can feel the love with his speech and with the way he said it. Emma's reaction to what he was saying was so beautiful. She smiles, her eye flutters, you can feel the tension, and she looks at him with eyes full of hope. It's obvious how much he means to her, which was made even more obvious later in the episode, because it is Hook she calls out for in dark hollow.
I seriously am becoming very convinced of CS endgame, especially after this speech. So much foreshadowing and then also raw emotion when Emma looks to Hook for his support and believe in her. This is a true love couple in the making.
I like how when her parents told her she would find Henry in the first episode she was mad at them for their optimism and only when Hook says it does she really believe it.
It just baffles me that this is even a choice she has to make? She knows Hook genuinely loves her. Yeah, Neil loves her and they have a child together, but leaving her was unforgivable. He was also going to marry Tamara, and now that she's out of the picture he wants Emma? Screw that. Hook would take a bullet for her... which I hope he doesn't... 'cause I think she deserves a happy ending with Hook. Plus, he takes her breath away. Obviously, she loves him too.
To be fair to Neal, he didn't know she was pregnant when he left her, and he left her because August told him it was the only way for her to fulfill her destiny and save her family. Of course he's not blameless, he did choose not to find her after the curse was broken and got engaged to another woman. But I don't think that is unforgivable, especially since ten years had passed by that point. It was a lot easier for him to move on with someone new than go back and face his guilt for leaving her. I ship Hook and Emma, but I don't think making Neal out to be a bad and unforgivable guy is the way to do it.
DragonflyandTheWolf amen to that. its hard to decide between the positives and negatives of the situation, because they both make perfect sense and quite frankly are agreeable.
"The only thing I have to chose is the best way to get my son back." "And you will" * eyes full of hope * : "You think so ?" She's never been like that, even with Mary Margaret who is likely the person who tries the hardest to reassure her. Hook only used three little words and she's more optimistic than she's ever been.
She will choose Hook. I can see it in her eyes. When he step close to her and said: "So when i win your heart, Emma.. and I will win it....." If she have no feelings for him, she will step back or walk away or say something to stop him,... but NO. She didn't do anything, she just lost in those meaning words of him (and his sexy eyes ooh..=D) . Captain Swan
Nhu Hoang I personally think if Neal had not died she most likely would have chosen him. Neal did everything he could to get back to her and Henry when they were in the EF. And when they everyone got back to Storybrooke the first person she asked about was finding Neal. She saw Neal in her vision in Season 5. He was her best friend, and she loved him. They did have true love. True Love never dies and Emma’s love for Neal never dies. She never stopped Loving Neal but she was afraid of opening her heart up again.
The way Hook believes in Emma and the way that Emma trusts him - he makes her realize how much more she needs to believe in herself. These two... They just >~< cannot contain the feels! Might as well set the forest on fire with their combustible chemistry. XD
I read somewhere that pulling out the sword like that was a mistake and not in the script to do it that closely, meaning he was very surprised when it happened.
Wow what a great scene...that look in his face when he said "because I was hoping it meant something", the way she's leaning towards him after he says "It'll be because you want me" and breathlessly saying "this is not a contest", how she seeks for reassurance about finding Henry...And his speech..took MY breath away
The look of disappointment on Hook's face when she calls him a pirate = heartbreaking. In "Good Form", he said that the kiss meant that Emma was starting to see him as a man of honor/more than a pirate. But Hook is showing that he's not giving up. And I love how she wants him to confirm that she'll succeed in saving her son- because she trusts him and he's been by her side this whole time. Emma, just pick him!
Yeah, these two have really great chemistry. I hate it when actors dont really have any chemistry and they are supposed to be into each other on shows. These guys sell it!
AHHHHH THE FEELS!!! I absolutely LOVE them together! And i'm so happy that when he took a step closer to her, she didn't step back or even break eye contact. And when he says she will get Henry back, her voice sounds so hopeful when she responds. He is the only one that is really able to provide her with that confidence. they are perfect together!! VOTE FOR THEM FOR FAVOURITE ON SCREEN CHEMISTRY FOR THE PEOPLE'S CHOICE AWARDS
What I really like about this conversation is the bit after he tells her he'll win her heart. When she's talking about making the right decisions to save Henry and sounds a little unsure of herself... Hook has no doubts. AND, most importantly, his belief in Emma is based on cold hard facts. None of your "true love" and "happy endings just because fairy tales" bull that Snow White is constantly peddling. He's seen what she can do and has no doubts that she'll get Henry back because he knows how strong she is and how capable she is, even if she doesn't.
damn hook needs to teach a class for men!!!!!!!!!!!!! he would make millions on the side of already making good money....i really hope this puts him in enough spot light that he gets more roles hes a good actor and hansom :P
Does anyone else notice that Emma always backs away from Neal like when he called for her in the caves or she closes herself off from him but She lets Hook get close and she has from the very beginning.
Also, wouldn't you expect them to kiss at that moment in the caves rather than just hug it out? Hadn't they declared their 'love' for each other before he fell into that portal? Very telling that Emma and Neal didn't kiss in my opinion.
"You think so?" The look on her face after she asks that lol. It's like: oops just asked that out loud. She tends to speak before she thinks around Hook...I like it.
Emma deserves a guy that will be devoted to her wholeheartendly and she needs that in her life/love!... love & devotion is something Hook knows about,& he has such immense faith / believe in Emma & also his own feelings & love for her, that is why he is fighting the right way, the good form way to earn her heart, her heart is the important thing coz it matters and her choice. This is a guy who says things like i will follow u till the ends of the earth... and you just know he would, & thats what Emma deserves, and really when hasnt Hook not followed Emma, ever since meeting her in Enchanted Forest, he has followed even if the reason was something entirely different and situation, but here he is all hers!
Wow! You can really feel Hook's love for Emma. When he tells her she will get Henry I can see the hope and trust she has in him. I hope they stay together and will not be separated by some outside force or death.
I luv the part where Emma almost hits hook with the sword. Also i luv how hook tells tells Emma that he will win her heart not because of trickory because she wants him. Lol i hook.
Love the writing for Hooks character!!! For once we r getting a character with depth!! Every episode this season is building and adding to who Hook is truely.....also love the confidence he has in Emma......all Hook does is mention her succeeding and she right away leans on his support. (Not to mention the way she looks at his mouth just before snapping back about finding Henri). LOVED THIS SCENE!!!!!!
I love how Emma thinks she and Hook will never happen, I've just finished watching Season 5 and just rewatching this has made me laugh so much, I ship them
Okay so here's the thing, I always ship the other guy. the guy the girl is teased with, but never ends up with. She always ends up with the more noble, heroic guy. But this time. . .this time, I saw Hook coming a mile away and was like, "nah, not this time. I'm not shipping the unlikely couple this time." But goddamnit once writers! I am now officially on the Captain Swan shipping train. I think she and Neal make a good fit, but I don't care anymore. Hook pretty much stole my heart in this scene.
I'm exactly the same! I always ship the wrong couple - Spike/Buffy, Gio/betty, Lisbon/Jane to a degree - one of these times I just have to back a winner...don't I? I'd be really ticked off if the writer's write scene's like this and then be so cruel as to either a) kill one of them off (Hook) or b) contrive some silly scene where one or the other (again probably Hook) mistakes what they're seeing for something it's not (Neal kissing Emma but then NOT seeing her push him away) and then he's so upset he goes back to his 'pirate' ways. I hope now that he's returning to the man he once was, he stays that way, whatever happens between he and Emma.
I love this scene! It's almost as good as the real kiss scene. I am a captain swan shipper all the way. I think that even though Emma loves Neal, she wants to move on from him because she can't forgive him for leaving her. Hook and her just have so much in common and so much chemistry I totally ship them
I just can't get over the music they keep putting on their scenes together. IT'S SO BEAUTIFUL! I read that it's true love's song, but im not sure, is it?? because that's just so beautiful if they put true love's song in their scenes. anyways i love it. This scene is perfect, he keeps proving to her that he believes in her and his speech is just so beautiful and confident. I love this man so so much. Captain Swan is my everything right now I swear.
It's not actually True Love from the soundtrack, but it is similar (yep I sat here and played them to compare). Instead, it is their own theme, as it should be :)
I compared the songs too, haha. It's actually so cute and romantic that they have their own theme. Yes, it's very similar to True Love's song but I honestly think this one is more beautiful. I fell in love with it from the moment I heard it for the first time (*cough cough*when I was repeating the kiss again and again*cough cough*, that just made me love the song even more).
OMG OMG OMG!!!! DID ANYONE ELSE HER THE MUSIC PLYING IN THE BACKGROUND IS THE SAME ONE THAT PLAYED DUING THRERE KISS!!!! THATS IT ENDGAME thatss just like kurt and blaine when they have a moment hat little tune plays AM I THE ONLY ONE TO NOTICE THESE THINGS
I'll say this i liked that Hook started his speech of with i believe in good form, & we all know what good form means to him, doing it the right way - & we have seen what it meant to him in his own centric episode... Hook is a old school classic man from a different era, so he will say things like i will win your heart, when i will win your heart because its the things u hear in old movies, fairytales etc
I like how Hook calls Neal "Old friend" instead of "Kid, I once wanted to be a father too because I loved his mother." I really can't wait to see how Emma reacts when she finds that out.Oh.... you're like Henry's step-grandfather...well that's awkward.
"This is not a contest, Hook. -Is it?" Oh gosh !! Even if like I said in my precedent comment I think their relationship came from nowhere, Killian is really funny in this scene ;)
I think Emma should choose hook they would be such a good couple like don't you think when emma makes her choice I think she's going to talk because Neil hasn't been there for her for a long time in the one to guide her through everything along with her parents and everybody else he's been the man that's kind of connected with her through all of that bad stuff that's happened SO IM ROOTING FOR EMMA AND HOOK!!!:)
I feel like here Emma still just sees Hook as a pirate and doesn't see the rest of him and when she says well you are a pirate you can see the disappointment on his face like well ya know Im having trouble describing it but you get the idea! :)
Like I said before: hate when they say: "you are a pirate", emma included. Hook always looks so sad when they say it. They're just judging Hook because he got the wrong way but noone sees that HE IS CHANGING and getting back to the noble person he was. He is redeeming himself just like any other character, like Regina. They have changed. They're becoming kind of heroes and letting behind the villian side. He is new because of love. I don't know if they will get together but I wish them stop judging this character. Everyone have changed, like Hook is doing right now.
I don't know what or what it just me or maybe just how it was said but for me, when Neal said "Oh, thanks but she's got me now" sounded like he was trying to be cocky. Like he was trying to tel Hook, Emma is my girl and I can protect her. You can go name... I have nothing against Neal but I just thought when he said those words, I felt like it sounded he thinks Emma can't handle herself, that she needs him to protect her when she is capable of handling herself... I just couldn't stand that part of this scene.. I had to point this out for it was something that was bugging me..