One direction singing Zayn's part live Vs Zayn - Must Watch 

They look so sad while they singing Zayn's solo..

the boys mic colors: zayn- yellow liam- red harry- green louis- blue niall- IRISH

I personally think Harry did the best at matching Zayn's style, but nobody compares to THE Zayn Malik. His voice was a unique and essential part to those the One Direction ot5 songs

whenever niall had to sing one of zayn's parts, he looked so in pain. let's all be real here, zayn was the big brother niall never had. sure, liam, louis and harry were it too, but zayn had the natural mama bear instinct

the other boys can sing zayn's part too but zayn is just irreplaceable

ALL OF THEM LOOK SO SAD WHEN SINGING HIS PART.....

Nothing can beat Zayn's voice ❤

The ad that played before the video : “irresistibly smooth chocolate” which is what Zayns voice sounds like

is it just me, bc i LOVE how soft and soothing Zayns voice is, especially in Night Changes

Zayn’s voice is just so calming. Edit: i never do this edit thing or something but how in the heck did I get 7.9k on this. Like how!

2:30 Can we just talk about Niall teaching the drummer. He's like the orchestra leader kinda who is doing hand gestures. Like wow

2:58- 3:24 speechless, Zayn not only easily hits the note but adds runs to it, none of them can do his runs

Zayn’s voice is so soft compared to theirs

Niall look so sad when he sing Zayn's parts

Zayn is zayn The king of high notes, but what Liam did.... WoW

The high note Liam did in spite of the fact that he isn't used to it was incredible..I appreciate him a lot for that..I mean it's a really difficult high note and do it as beautifully as Zayn is not a joke

I was expecting Bonus: James corden singing zayn's part in the best song ever... Lol

I dont know but I more like when Zayn sing his parts himself...its just that there's something with his voice that really suits his part...

4:21 OMG I'm crying!! I'm so proud of Liam

Even if Liam couldn’t do “you and I” in a single stretch he did a great job! Zayn will obviously be better because those were his lines. They usually give parts that is perfect for each member so it’s not easy to take other’s part and sing and make it sound great!😘🖤🖤🖤

the thing about zayn is he kept it simple

Let's be honest Zayn is Zayn but we all know that Liam killed it.

In the end: Liam's high notes are underrated and he's so awesome honestly. But with Zayn it's just different and he's irreplaceable. All of them can do his parts but it's just not the same.

In the Night Changes, Zayn had this enchanting tone that fitted more of the storytelling narrative. You could literally feel the magic in how he sang. Niall's way was more like a serenade, also like an intro to a high school prom scene where the protagonist (girl) would be having that iconic moment of heads turning towards her dashing self. Liam's was more like painful nostalgia creeping in your veins, like the girl you loved would no longer be around you, either she rejected you big time or she already went to the clouds. All versions were great. Personally, I really loved Zayn's, because you could really tell that the line was made for him. It was enchanting, at the same time, how Zayn sang it--it was like being cuddled up in the cold of Christmas season. It's like there's a warmth there that's only between you and him. :)

Zayn's irreplaceable, he sings his parts so perfectly and makes it look so effortless

Directioner Who is still waiting to their come back!!!! Like

4:20 didn't expect that Liam killed it

Liam killed it in the You and I high note♥️ i felt like crying😢

4:19 , obviously Zayn is always going to sound better because the parts were made for him and his voice and his vocal range ... but damn Liam hit that 😍

Haters: ThEy CaNt EvEn HiT hIgH nOtEs Zayn: Hold my mic

I'm in love with Harry's beautiful and powerful voice. Liam and Harry absolutely killed it.

Niall always looks so sad when singing zayn’s parts :(

harry and zayn sound almost the same but zayn makes it look easier

4:19 zayn will always sound better in that part but Liam absolutely killed it😳

People's : there's no high note without Zayn. Liam: Hold my beer.

Can we appreciate how perfect liam was in : you and i😍😍😍.And niall on night changes 😘😘

Zayn's voice is a blessing to this planet.

let's not forget Zayn left very abruptly in the middle of a tour. No shade at all but they had to adapt very last minute to sing parts they weren't familiar with.

This made me cry so much! The band will NEVER be complete without Zayn! His voice is SO beautiful!!

The band will NEVER be complete without Zayn. His voice is so beautiful.

watching this in quartine waiting for the reunion :(

4:20 ok but THIS. The way Liam sang it. I'm proud of him 'cause he showed that he can sing high notes well too.

Zayn, his voice, his eyes, his veins. ... literally irreplaceable ❤ I love all of them and their voices.... but Zayn's magic is like....😍🥰

Even though the boys did a amazing job singing Zayn parts, Zayn's irreplaceable, his voice is so soothing and calming. But no matter when they did a great job. 😊🥰

I don't know why but zayn has this unique touch to his voice that i can't put into words

*Harry, Niall, Louis, Liam* : We are coming back! *Zayn* : With me😇 how i wish...😥

Zayns voice is just so unique. It seems like he does not even have to make an effort to sing. The highnotes come out of his mouth so easily

Everyone is talking about how none of the bois can replace Zayn, and I completely agree. However, we can also say that: One Direction is a blessing with 5 irreplaceable gods who cannot be replaced by others or each other. They are also so different and unique, which is what makes them so amaZAYN!! I love them with all my heart. And all of them have precious voices, no one can replace ANY them. ❤️🥺🥰🥰🙏

They tried good but zayn is zayn no one replace zayn

Can we please give Liam the appreciation he deserves? We all know that these parts just are Zayns BUT Liam deserves so much more attention, he totally hits a difficult high note that he was not used to sing So give him a little bit more love bc he is so underrated🥺

Zayn's voice is legendry no one can sing better then him (It's my opinion)

Let's just appreciate how the boys put so much effort singing Zayn's part. They adjusted so much when Zayn left, at least let's be proud of them for doing their best and putting so much effort.

Okay but Liam slayed in the “you and I” part 😍

Man, I appreciate Liam's You & I Falsetto? But like, the transition from the massive belt to the soaring head voice Zayn had going there is mind blowing.

Liam my dear...u killed it

Niall is underrated and under appreciated

Hate it when people always comparing their vocal abilities oo.Zayn is Zayn and so with the other members of 1D...what's the point? They're all amazing!

Let’s be real Zayn is the only one who can sing his part Steal My Girl but Niall singing Through the Dark is pretty goddamn great

2:53 that part of the song wasn't made for harry's voice type but he could do it perfectly, he's flawless

4:20 my heart fluttered at Liam's high note. Him singing zayn's part, trying his best to hit it really touched my heart ❤️ if only they were together 🥺

Haters: THEY CAN'T EVEN HIT HIGH NOTES! Zayn: Excuse me?

lets remember though, those parts were made FOR ZAYN, and they fit his abilities and strengths that were different than the other boys, and because he left on such short notice, I'm astonished by the fact that they could continue doing his parts as well as they did. I don't think its a good idea to compare them either because this parts were specifically made for Zayn and not any of the other boys.

I absolutely adore liam’s way of doing zayn’s verse in night changes

Liam: *smashing that high note in you and i* Zayn sat at home watching: 👁👄👁

I thought I'm gonna find... "Bonus: James Corden singing Zayn's part in Best Song Ever" lol

Zayn Is Better in his parts because they are HIS parts. But i also like how the other members fixed it... maaaan Liam's falsetto was like WTF?! Amazing and super clean 😆😍

Liam does the best at singing zayn’s high notes, at 4:26 he did an amazing job singing his high note in You & I. Not zayn but still sounded awesome to me

1:26 liam sounds so other than other times

Harry:we Niall:are Liam:coming Louis:back Zayn:with me 2020

In through the dark, before Niall could just be carefree at Zayn's part and mimck the drummer like a cutie but now he looks so sad😭😭

Nothing compares to One Direction together .

Zayn's voice touches that one feel of happpiness in our heart ❤🥺

1:45 I WANT TO STRANGLE MYSELF WITH THAT LOOSE PIECE OF ZAYN'S HAIR

3:00 harry killed it !! But we shouldn’t criticise the boys because the parts were made for zayn and the boys had to do their best with what they were given when zayn left x

Zayn’s place is irreplaceable 🥺❤️

I love how Niall is always jamming out with the drummers

i only now realized how soft zayn's voice is

Zayn, in Night Changes, I can hear the emotion and he sings it softer and that makes it have a bigger place in my heart. 💙

Yeah we know Zayn is irreplaceable, and ofc HE IS, but let’s appreciate the boys doing their best, it’s not the same, obviously, but don’t compare them, just love to all of them❤️

It’s amazing how Zayn sounds exactly the same in every concert and he sounds the same as in the prerecorded songs

Ok but is no one gonna talk about how adorable it was that Niall was mimicking the drummer at 2:35😍

don't get me wrong. i love these 5 equally but no one can replace zayn's part in you and i :(. there's just something about his vocals that go perfectly with the song & i miss it so much. i miss this band so much in general 😔.

Zayn insubstituível. Timbre único ❤

No one can cover Zayns part, his voice had distinct rnb and emotional tone and he could easily hit super difficult keys on after the other and he rarely runs of breathe

Obviously, no one can ever replace Zayn but can we talk about Harry at 2:57 and Liam at 4:20 They nailed it man 🥺😳

Y’all hating on the boys when they have a completely different vocal range and none of them asked for zayn to leave the band. They all did amazingly and tried there hardest during these moments and instead of pulling them down and saying they aren’t good enough for zayns part in songs, we should be supporting everything they do. This comment section broke my heart.

Just see the face of harry when he was singing Zayn's ready to run lyrics he looks like he's remembering Zayn and just see at the last when he stoped he was just going to break down into tears..!🙃💕2:50

His voice is so soft.. Just love it.. 🤩🤩

Harry sounds like Zayn sometimes I get confused but obviously Zayn’s got a softer voice so none of them are gonna sound exactly like him Edit: I meant sound

1:21 I CANT ZAYNS HAIR IS PRETTIER THAN MY FACE

Can we just appreciate how serious niall can look in some performances and so jolly and free in others

Each band member is unique....they can't be replaced...but seeing this really broke my heart🥺❣️

The thing is that while writing the songs no one even thought that zayn will leave 1D maybe that's why they gave the high notes to zayn coz there is no match to his high notes..but of course after he left they had to move forward and someone had to sing his parts..so instead of criticizing the other boys let appreciate them for at least trying to give justice to zayn's part as he did. No hate Only love💙

ONE DIRECTION+ZAYN= *Perfect* ❤

Everyone has something unique in them, they are all equally good for me. I don't they like a competition amongst each other. It's just that Zayn always dreamed if becoming a solo artist.It just happened that Simon wanted them to perform as a group, which turned out as a real big hit .

We should not compare them they all are best 💕

I wish people would stop saying like “oh he did better” “no zayn does it better”. No! They all did amazing. Just remember zayn left in the middle of a tour and the boys just had to get used to doing his parts because he wasn’t there.

I'm so freaking proud of Liam in the you and I part

I miss him so much! He was so amazayn! Please come back!

Can we just appreciate how Niall covered zayn's part ❤️🥺He is perfect!!