Вы понимаете о чем поют то песня Гимн Казаков Последний где она была популярна Армия Нестора Ивановича Махно Анархист и интернационалист Где Украина не стала выше воли народа
@Seltnyt others can claim your videos if they have the copyright and force ads on your videos from which they get the money then. Better alternative than having your video taken down.
And that flag and that parole were actually disapproved by Makhno. The bolsheviks used that picture of the soldiers and that flag to defame the Black Army and to accuse them of pogroms against jews. In an article in 1927 Makhno commented the picture with: "NO es una bandera 'majnovista' y ellos son soldados 'petliuristas'." - "It is NOT a 'Majnovista' flag and they are 'petliurist' soldiers." Refering to the soldiers of Symon Petliura, the first president of the Ukrainian People's Republic. To be fair, the Ukrainian People's Republic under Petliura had full rights for Jewish people, but his militia will later commit multiple pogroms against Jewish people and he will try to stop it, but he will fail, so his soldiers killed a lot of people against his order.
Howdy, here is a rhymed translation for the first song - "Anarchy-mother" (Based on a poem by Nestor Makhno. The chorus likely added later by more contemporary author(s) Horses tear through miles of steppes, Freedom is most sweet to us. Through the sight of my machine gun I seek foes in the dust, (Chorus) To Anarchy-mother all sons are beloved, Our Anarchy-mother - strong and just. With shower of lead embracing the foes, Our Anarchy-mother is for us! With my fire, like with dagger, Cut them down as they come close. Nothing burdens me in battles No regret, and no remorse, To Anarchy-mother all sons are beloved, Our Anarchy-mother - strong and just. With shower of lead embracing the foes, Our Anarchy-mother is for us! - Just rejoicing at the smashing Power of my iron friend. Of all enemies before me Only dead ones I can stand. To Anarchy-mother all sons are beloved, Our Anarchy-mother - strong and just. With shower of lead embracing the foes, Our Anarchy-mother is for us!
@@lada4200 аргументуй, чому він не може підтримувати погляди Нестора Івановича, будучи при цьому французом? Напам'ятаю, що сам Нестор Махно не підтримував ідеї національних держав. Також напам'ятаю, що перші сучасні анархо-комуністи, представником яких був і сам Нестор Махно, виникли у Франції: Жозеф Дежак, Сильвен Марешаль та інші.
@@lada4200 что за бред вообще?) Махно так-то стрелял за тот же анти-симетизм - ничего?) он был против деления на национальности. Не подмазывайся "справа" к левому политику и вождю. Да и образование человек получал в рассеянской тюрьме. В чём ни он, ни его наставник, ни, например, я проблем не видим. Завязывай со своим землячеством)
@@elpavlovsky8966 я бы тоже хотел назвать тебя братом, но, увы, в силу событий, которые прямо сейчас происходят в моей стране, это будет немного лицемерно.
The colonisation of space leaves us with two possibilities: 1 The vast distances of the cosmos will allow for people to organise themselves away from governmental tyranny. 2 Space colonies just become corporately-owned hellholes where Elon Musk and his dynasty enslave who generations of people
@@ZephLodwick It's probably gonna be the second :/ After all, how will we, the Anarchists, get into space in the first place? Either you'll have to be rich, or sign away your freedoms to become a slave like in The Outer Worlds.
I can offer a translation for the "Song of Liberty" at 23:53 ("Дума про волю" - Duma pro voliu, literally - "A thought about freedom". Duma ("thought") is an epic genre of Ukrainian folk song. Please see below Oh, you, bat'ko, our youthful bat'ko! Won't you, bat'ko, come back to your land? As the time of pain Sweeps over Ukraine, Won't you bring us freedom again?” - Oh, you, fellows, my Ukrainian fellows! I was breathing freedom, but I breathe no more, There's no strength to save, For I'm in the grave, For so many years, in the foreign soil. Black is the soil, green is the grass, Blue is the sky, white clouds above us, Yellow's the sun, red is the blood, All mixed together - to end and to start. "Oh, you, bat'ko, bat'ko just and fair, Nothing is the same now as when you were here, Cast off your tombstone, Make our foes be gone, The miracle of freedom is yours to give!” - Oh, you, fellows, you my reckless fellows! Freedom came to those who were fighting for it There’s no magic I wield - People made it real, All I did was hold high the flag for the free. Black is the soil, green is the grass, (etc....) “Oh, you, bat’ko, our forgotten bat’ko! When you are not here, there’s no freedom for us! Must it be our fate - Forever to wait Till we people have our freedom at last?” -Oh, you, fellows, freedom-loving fellows! Who can give you what you already have got? Freedom’s never granted, Freedom’s always conquered - By those who let freedom live in the heart! Black is the soil, green is the grass, Blue is the sky, white clouds above us, Yellow's the sun, red is the blood, All mixed together - to end and to start.
@@yyyyyy55554 большинство песен в списке на украинском (most songs in the list are in Ukrainian but a couple of them are in Russian, most people in the Free State were Ukrainian speaking)
дв?! брэшишь, у вас с августа месяца получали политическое убежище белорусские анархисты, сейчас Европа за этим не следит и вы их обратно сюда кинули, у нас в Беларуси с анархистами никто не размауляе, адразу спыняюць дзеянасць самым зверским способоом, Украина небезопасное место для свободных людей
@OVOD.net тогда было чуть ли не 4 Украины: УНР, ЗУНР, Вольная Территория и УССР. И все, кроме УНР и ЗУНР, враждовали друг с другом!(УНР и ЗУНР пытались союзничать и объединились , вроде как)
@@ИосипБроз-я9з + еще Всевеликое Войско Донское, КНР(Кубанская Народная Республика), ДВУНР (Дальневост Укр Нар Республика) или Зеленый Клин - все украинские. Органы власти были сформированы по результатам выборов еще при Временном правительстве. То есть это прямые легитимные правоприемники Вр Правительства. В отличии от большевиков, 5 колонны Германии, набранных из китайцев, венгров, и каторжников, после Мировой войны, перешедших под контроль Антанты. Или "Белых" - изначально созданной Антантой силе. Антанта не желала появления нового серъезного игрока на мировой арене - Украины, и фактически создала СССР. Но в учебниках такого не напишут.
Geras Al-Aqras Assad is a Tankie tho. Kind of like Xi Jinping. As far as being an Arms dealer for terrorists, wouldn't that be the Free Syrian Army, Tahir Al-sham, and Turkey?
Stalin wasn't a communist, he made the USSR much more state capitalist than any form of communism. Not trying to undermine all the good stuff he did, but he never worked toward communism.
The ba'athists are not socialists in the same vein as Xi Jinping at all... Ba'athists are "Arab socialists" which does not inherently insinuate Marxism. "Arab socialism" is opposed to confiscation of private property (nationalization) for instance, and instead focuses on unifying the Arab world and creating social progress and secularization. Vanguardism is a part of the ideology, but that's more of a way to achieve power and maintain it than how to run a state.
@@tiagorochagoncalves9140 thanks comrade. I'm not sure did i notice it before or after your comment but either way i appreciate your help. Together we shall win.
Hate to advertise, however it could be for the better of the movement I'm founding... We're starting a new movement in Alberta, Canada, which advocates anarchism and a sort of self-governing. We strongly urge people organize themselves within collectives and groups that serve different interests. One important type of group is the militia, of which I personally suggest anyone wanting to defend the interests of the people to join a militia. I have one that I lead (similarly to how Nestor Makhno led his own militia) that follows what I believe in: freedom of self-expression and identity, freedom in armament/situations training of the population, and world freedom against tyranny and oppression) - called the Freedom Frontline. I do only want people that are willing to die for the people's best interest (which I too am willing to do), and will be knighting members myself. If it's not something for you, there are always other militias and the ability to create your own. As the movement grows, eventually we'll be able to start extracting people from other countries should they have no way of their own to come aid, and hopefully in the future we should expand across the globe.
@@canadian_cranberry we keep having to push back on the big public event because shit is shit and the timing keeps getting fucked by unforeseen events.
@@ZivkoSkobic Time and time again the Communists have used and spit on Anarchism. For anarchism to succeed as it has in Chiapas, Anarchists need to distance themselves from Reds. An authoritarian is an authoritarian, no matter the color of ideology they wear.
...also want to offer a rhymed translation for the song at 11:22 "Lads, unharness your horses" - said to have been a hit with Makhno's guerrillas. Possible author - Ivan Negrebetsky, a village teacher in the Maknovist-controlled region. (Verses 5 and 6 are not part of the recording) "Lads, unharness all your horses, Rest your heads and get some sleep - And I'll go to cherry garden, Dig a well there, fresh and deep In the midst of cherry garden I was digging on and on, Hoping that the girl comes out For some water at the dawn". So she did, she did come out At the dawn to fill her pail - And the Cossack with his stallion Follows her along the trail. Asked to let him use the pail - She would not give it to him, Offered her a gift of ring then - She would not accept the ring. "Oh, I know, I know, my sweetheart, How I angered you so bad - For last night before the sunset With another girl I met. She is small, and she is pretty, In the blossom of her years, With a sky-blue silken ribbon Waving through her waist-long braids" "Lads, unharness all your horses, Rest your heads and get some sleep - And I'll go to cherry garden, Dig a well there, fresh and deep"
любо, брачи, любо is actually an old Cossack song. About a man who died, ''writing'' a poem after his death, telling his comrades not to cry and keep on fighting for liberty with their ''batka'' (leader).
There are actually two versions of the song. There is the Cossack prayer version and the Cossack recruit version, and the folk version is about the nature of Ukraine and all that is experienced The version you know is the prayer after Adamant Terrick left the soldier in the snow to die, and the soldier was convinced it was his fault and is apologizing to everyone he knows for being a failure.
@@chelipedrik Russia is a textbook hungry imperialist bully, not anarchist you absolute buffoon. They're so anti freedom that not only do they want absolute control in their own already massive country but also in other independent countries tbat want nothing to do with them. Also who tf is "he"?
Yes, sadly the Makhnovist movement was hijacked by the nationalist youth that believed too much in the Soviet propaganda films about Makhno. I may be the last Ukrainian to be a real Makhnovist and that speaks Ukrainian.
Someone made a song with lyric a year ago.if you search it you'll find it.i would give you the link but i do not know how to do that in cellphones. The channel name is "i made you read this"
Another video with this song : ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uiv3VT13AcQ.html - this same recording, repeated 3 times head-to tail, superimposed onto video sequences from 2006 TV series "Nine Lives of Nestor Makhno" :)
I imagine if the Ukraine had Nestor Makhno today they would have an even greater fighting spirit then they have now. Long live Anarcho Communism for the spirit has the might and the fight of soldiers, comrades!
Dude no this war wouldnt exist then because makhno would have destroyed nazis after nazis broke the ceasefires(if he would make ceasefires with the nazis at first) and there would have been a larger support for the USSR, meaning todays russia might still have been the USSR
FYI, Nestor's chaps weren't anarcho-communists specifically, the French and Spanish ones were. Machno's black army didn't really see any difference between communists and monarchists, same old tyrrany either way. Needless to say, before the World War, Machno was like number one bogeyman for Bolsheviks, they hated him almost as much as monarchists. But Nestor would be proud of us today nonetheless! Communist or not, Russians always the same.
@@BIGESTblade That's not true at all. Makhno and various Black army members very specifically took influence from Peter Kropotkin's works and the remnants after the war would go on to draft up platformism which went on to influence modern anarcho communist organizations such as Revdia which is currently active in Ukraine fighting the Russian invasion. You can go read Makhno's correspondence with Malatesta on the anarchistlibrary where he very explicitly refers to himself as a communist anarchist.
@@michealruth8925 So? If someone gets influenced by the works of Aristotle that means they are a classical philosopher? Nestor didn't care weather it was communism or capitalism, he was a soldier. He was fighting a war and allowed other people in his controlled territory to think about how they want to conduct business. Kind of goes against whole anarchist idea to try and enforce some arbitrary *better model of economy, doesn't it?
anarchy mama eh, back in the 18th century, philosophers speculated that a century would pass, two centuries and the same human evolution would begin and anarchy would inevitably come, now 2 centuries have passed, and anarchists are still conducting the same dialogues about evolution, apparently most people are not ready to solve their own problems and be a developed civil society.
I liked the set. However, just for the record: not all of the songs are Anarchist or Communist, not all of them are Ukrainian or even in the Ukrainian language (some are in Russian, some are Ukrainian translations of well known Russian songs), some do not belong to the time related to then content (they are contemporary lamentations about the past). So, good but not properly labeled and not really authentic.
Hi to all! Is there lyrics of this version of The Internationale? This is not an bolshevik version,so I want to have text of it. I tried on google with no luck. Greetings from Serbia!
Where can I find the "Song of Freedom" in a separate video. This 1 hour video is great, believe me, but when I just want one song, I don't want to go searching every time I wanted to listen to it.
To paraphrase Noam Chomsky: Power, whether it be over the individual or the collective, is immediately illegitimate unless proven otherwise. Thusly the burden of proof is always on they who claim any sort of authority is legitimate, failure to provide means the dismantling of the structure must be carried out.
The fourth song unharness your horses is the traditional way of singing it not the Machno 1, 2,3 is picking grapes that was added because alot of Machno infantry had trouble telling the difference of left and right its true even under the Tsars forced infantry to tie hay and straw so Machno used numbers instead.
