The story with the "lawyer dog" is absolutely ridiculous. Also, I love your humor. This law should surely include lawyer dogs, as well as other types of animal lawyers.
yes. Every lawyer I know has said: Be respectful. Cooperate with the police. Ask them to have a warrant before searching any of your property (car, house otherwise) BUT shut the fuck up/don't go running your mouth and let your lawyer talk.
100% agree with Dr Grande - if you expect every citizen (regardless of age, education, background, life experience, mental capacity, disability, level of inebriation or injury) to _know_ the ridiculously convoluted & ever-changing legal framework that law enforcement operate under, then _EVERYONE_ must be questioned with a lawyer present - no exceptions. In a country with 50 different sets of laws to abide by _plus_ federal laws... and more types of law enforcement agency than you can count on two hands (PD, Sheriff, State Investigation, FBI, ICE, etc etc)... how could _any_ individual citizen _hope_ to know what rights they have when talking to LE, especially when LE have the ability to lie & deceive when questioning?!
We should spread the message that everyone always should demand a lawyer, not only in America. If you are questioned, even as a witness to a serious crime, always consult a lawyer. Yes, this just may lead to few bastards running away, but would save many innocents from getting convicted
The reality is that in the years since the warnings became required, an astounding number of defendants voluntarily waive these rights even after being informed of them (and advocates of the warnings decry this for any number of supposed reasons). There is a real question about what the benefit of these warnings even is, and that is separate from the obvious point that the Constitution does not, and had never been understood to (up to this case), require a warning of these rights. To answer your question about knowing your own rights...you can know your rights by taking it upon yourself to learn them. Ignorance is no defense and proceeding in spite of ignorance is proceeding at your own peril.
Even people that come from different countries and become a US citizen knows their Rights. If your gonna get into the crime game, you better know your Rights
I appreciate everything about these videos you’ve e been doing on the mechanics of policing & criminal justice and the dirty tricks & deception officers of the court can use to trick you out of your rights. People think it’s a bit odd that I taught my teenager to say NOTHING to the cops, ever, except “I want a lawyer, please”. (And if they ask another question, you can drop the please.) but I think it’s a necessary skill to learn. Say it together everyone: “I’m not comfortable speaking to law enforcement without legal counsel - I want a lawyer (please)”. (“Can I see your warrant, please” is another good one).
This was very interesting. I never knew the story behind the Miranda warning. I'm glad he was retried and found guilty despite the prosecutor not being able to use his confession. And yes, I agree that was pretty silly of the Court to rule that the other guy hadn't invoked his right to an attorney because he said lawyer dog. Crazy!
@@minirock000 Professionals are supposed to be adept at what they do. Not understanding common slang and language is decidedly unprofessional and ignorant I would think.
Oh geez. The police were splitting hairs. They knew what he meant and it’s spelled “dawg.” It’s street slang, unless he was talking about McGruff the Crime Dog which I highly doubt. As always, love your dry humor!
Ohh! Thank-you, Dr.Grande! I don't live in the US, Ive always wanted to learn why the heck it's called Mranda rights! It's a shame Ive never tried to look it up, even tho I love watching 'Law and Order' episodes. Lazy of me.🙈💔 Id love to listen to more of your speculation on historical events.
But no matter how heinous Ernesto's crimes, how awesome is the magnitude of that attorney's appeal to the Supreme Court. It wasn't about Ernie. It was about humanity. It was about people brought up in such dysfunction that they have never ever been able to ask for help and expected to get that help.
Your life depends a great deal on what type of upbringing you have. I believe that but it is also true that you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. This is a tough world to survive in.
7:21 _"Item #2, in June of 2022, the Supreme Court made a ruling which weakened the effect of the Miranda case. They concluded that if law enforcement fails to give somebody a Miranda warning, the person does not have the right to sue law enforcement for a federal civil rights violation. Essentially, this ruling means that the police to not have to face consequences for violating the law..."_ Uh... isn't that kind of messed up?
@@jaymike3302 no, they don't "have " their rights. If your rights are not respected, how do you "have " them? I'm assuming you have never been caught doing anything wrong in your life. Mr. Judgmental. By the way, " criminals " are varied and not all people who get in trouble are bad. They just got caught. Police get away with breaking the law all of the time, they are criminals too.
@@jaymike3302 Criminals? WTF. The people being questioned, are not necessarily criminals. There's a small matter of this little thing called 'presumption of innocence'. If you decide from the outset, that the people being questioned are CRIMINALS, then it's no wonder you think they have sufficient rights already and don't have any justification for suing the police for misconduct and corruption. Perhaps you might appreciate such avenues of recourse, if that shoe was on your own innocent foot.
I absolutely agree with you, Dr. Grande. It’s absurd that it has become the SOP at police departments to evade the suspect’s right to a lawyer by almost any means.
Exactly. Just because you ask for a lawyer, doesnt mean they get you one quickly, and it doesnt mean they cant continue to ask you questions in the meantime. If you accidentally respond to one of their baiting leading questions without your lawyer, they consider that "waving your right".
I agree, forgot about this guy, but remember he was good in TV series; all the actors were. Had a partner?in his lascivious behavior outside his work, who rumor had it, bludgeoned him to death with a lamp shade? over something and got away with it.
My favorite Dr Grande video yet. I am so done! (As in LOL for clarification just in case). As hilarious as it was, depriving people of their rights is no joke. What folks should also know is to shut up! Say you ask for a lawyer in a way they understand and you are sitting with the interrogator waiting for the lawyer arrives. You get nervous so you start talking about the weather and they are able to turn to convo back to the crime, you willingly spoke without provocation. You have again waived your right to remain silent. They can and will use these words against you. Well done Dr.
My lawyer is a dog. He's pretty good, although he tends to run off after squirrels every time one comes near. I wish he wouldn't do that, but it's not really a big deal.
Thank you for a very informative analysis Dr. Grande. I never realised that the act of Mirandising a suspect came about because of a specific case. I've learned two new things .. the other being about lawyer dogs 🤣
Yes it truly is. And the Miranda is what as I recall it being purported to me. Glad I was here for that. I liked to have thought we progressed as a nation, recent events raise serious doubts. 😒
Constitutional law, as it relates to criminal investigations, is extremely interesting. During my 27 year career in law enforcement, there were many nuances of the law that changed. Add to that all the technology changes that then became case law after trials.
What?! Doc, I was born at Good Sam in 1982. Our small world just got even smaller, my friend! All of that aside, this was an incredibly intriguing episode. I had never heard the origin story behind the Miranda Warning. Quite fascinating, especially considering it all began in my hometown. Thanks for sharing, as always, kind sir -- and please, keep up the fantastic work!
9:38 🤣🤣🤣 I've been watching your channel for a year now. You always seem to approach topics in a rational, intellectual way with a splash of my favor kind of humor. Keep 'em coming!
The only word out of one’s mouth when cops try and interact with one is “lawyer,” lawyer is the answer to all questions from a cop until a lawyer is present, it’s potentially life saving for many.
People seem to say this a lot. What if youre a serial murderer? Should they say "lawyer" and stfu? Or should they confess on all the evil deeds they have done? What do you think is the right thing to do? What if your sister was raped and you are being questioned by the police about the whereabouts of the rapist. You know who did it and where he is, but you should just say "lawyer"? I mean come on.
@@Shutityou Someone who's a citizen of another country should also say they want a lawyer AND they want to speak to someone from their own country's embassy too. And say nothing until a lawyer is present. Cops can lie, so regardless of whether someone is an American citizen or not, they should definitely insist on a lawyer.
Hi there dr. Grande, I have a quick question for you. Do you still practice as a counselor or do you do RU-vid and stuff full time now? The reason I ask is because the sheer amount of content you put out is seriously impressive. That coupled with the very high quality of the content and amount of research you have to do is amazing to me even if you do do RU-vid full time.
You raise an excellent point at the end, specifically about people with disabilities; this is definitely a concern of mine. I've got ADHD with pretty severe symptoms. Even on my best days, if something goes ridiculously off track I'll just forget or overlook some basic or obvious things - both in my narrative, and in the steps to navigate a foreign situation. While watching Jennifer Pan's police interview on JCS*, it really struck me hard how most of what they pointed out - from her behaviour, to how her story 'changed', to small details about the event not lining up - were all things that I've done in conversations with authority even when I know the conversation's going to happen. Further 'research' has pretty much assured me that if I'm found at the scene of a major crime _and questioned alone,_ they'll be looking at me with major suspicion. That's pretty scary, but also has empowered me to learn more about my rights both as a citizen and one with a disability. I know I'm far more likely to remember what to do because I've put conscious thought into it.** What's way scarier is the many neurodivergent people who don't know this, or can't understand, or wouldn't have the tools to prepare for this interaction that might never happen. If thrust into this situation we're at an even bigger disadvantage than a neurotypical person already is. And I'm not only taking about innocent individuals, here, because even when actually guilty of _any_ crime we _all_ still have certain rights and we're all still at risk of being misinterpreted, misunderstood, or manipulated. So, yeah. You're absolutely right, having a lawyer present - dog or otherwise - should just be the standard for any questioning, not by special request. Thanks for the opportunity to promote my 'conscious thoughts' to 'statement' status. 👍🍍 * _JCS is a RU-vid channel focused around police interviews and interrogations._ ** _'Conscious thought' includes things like not chattering away like I tend to do with people who show an interest, wording of the statement about talking with a lawyer, and being aware that in Canada they can keep asking questions regardless._
Of goodness gracious Dr. Your dry sarcastic humor of the stupidity of law enforcement is so hilarious, I actually now have begun each day, by watching you newest release. I gotta have ya to enjoy my day. Ya know what? If this podcast thing doesn’t work out, you could have a big career in comedy writer. You are the best there is, and that’s no joke.
Learning all this. It really is funny how the police and courts genuinely wonder why the publics trust in them has tanked so badly. Yet there’s still people that will ardently defend them and stand up. Meanwhile if the cops are told to stomp out those defenders? They’ll gladly do so.
@@jaymike3302 Very presumptuous of you to think that law enforcement never make mistakes (either unintentionally or deliberately), and you only ever get arrested because you're a 'criminal'. Better hope there's no-one with the same/similar name as you committing crimes... or your ID doesn't get sold online to fraudsters.... or you don't piss off someone & they falsely report you to the cops. Because it's law-abiding citizens who get screwed over worse than criminals by assuming the cops will always do the right thing.
That was really interested. I had no idea where the Miranda rights came from. Love the humour. Thank you Dr Grande. Brilliant analysis and sad outcome. Informative topic
When I was a Lawyer I gave Miranda Warning cards away for free. All over the world Judges help the Police as if they are little old ladies trying to cross the street.
I love this!! Gracious, thank you so much Dr. Grande. I learn so much on this channel. I love the videos. Blessings to you and all your channel followers ❤
Cops aren't very good at communicating. My friend worked in the county Sherrif's office typing police reports. She would have go and ask the cops what exactly they were trying to say.
I watch Dr. Grande's videos almost every single day, but the dry humor & sarcasm of this video in particular had me rolling over in laughter... not unlike a lawyerdog rolls over when he, himself, also finds Dr. Grande's video's absolutely hilarious.
i wish you had a third channel dr. grande, where you only do some kind of stand up about interesting cases or people. your deadpan, dry humor gets me every time, even when the crime is cruel and/or sad. you make terrible stories enjoyable to listen to, even when they are not funny in any way. thank you for that !
Could you do one on the gun culture in the United States? Would love to hear your analysis of that. You are the best at helping me understand human behaviour. Thanks for your hard work.
Conversely, one might start listing any sort of conceivable being that could practice law. Give me a lawyer, dog. Give me a lawyer, cat. Give me a lawyer, brother, sister, mother, father. Give me a lawyer, drop bear. Just start throwing things out there so there can be no mistaking that this person wants a lawyer of any species present.
I’m dying with the lawyer dog jokes. 🤣🤣🤣🤣. On a serious note, this was very interesting and informative. I never knew the origin of the Miranda rights. Thank you ☺️.
It's almost 5 AM here and I just couldn't resist to sleep with another great analysis video of Dr Grande. Wish y'all a great day and also a good night❣️✨️❤️✨️😅
that's crazy you were born at Good Samaritan? My mom used to work there when we first moved to AZ. Also, I still live in arizona and I've been arrested a few times (I wasn't doing that great a few years ago) and I can specifically remember like 2 separate times where they didnt read me my rights.
I never knew how the Miranda warning got its name, so thank you for covering this topic. Also, oh my gosh, I did NOT expect I'd be laughing through half of the video. Great humor! :`D
Thank you Dr. Grande. Interesting analysis. Could you analyze what might be going on with former talk show host and gossip queen Wendy Williams? Just a thought... I enjoy the work you do.
Dr Grande , you should try stand up comedy. I know you are a therapist but its never too late to be an artist. Im pretty sure you could put a stand up routine together that people would enjoy. Seriously. I really enjoy the content
I love how your sense of humour shines through. It's not disrespectful but just pokes fun at the absurdity of the situation. Maybe I do want a canine representative if I ever get on the wrong side of the law 🤔
I didn't know the story about how the Miranda rights came to be. Very interesting, and not quite what I would have expected. You had me giggling all the way through the "lawyer, dawg" incident. I think it's very good advice not to confuse the police by mentioning canines! 😂😂😂
I laughed so hard as soon as you started with the whole "Lawyer Dog" speech!! 😂 Also had to laugh just hearing you say "So why don't you just give me a lawyer dog, cuz this is not what's up." ;D;D
Bonjour/bonsoir cher Docteur! Another brilliant analysis (and as always made me 😄) of un incredibly interesting case 😳,. What on earth is a lawyer DOG though ? Im so impressed and delighted to be subscribed to your channel. You are the best! 🤩 👍👏 Merci!
Holy crap you're from Phoenix?! AND BORN in the same hospital as me?! lol Slightly geeking out. Having lived here all my life (our fam has had the same house in historical district for 100 years)... how did I never know about any of this story??
I absolutely agree with you. Everyone should have a lawyer present when being questioned by the police. Police and the FBI can lie with impunity, but everyday citizens cannot. I call that a police state.
Just a reminder, I'm not diagnosing anybody in this video; only speculating about what could be happening when an wrongly accused man can't find the one-armed man who could clear his name like this.
So you're from Arizona Dr. Grande?!?!?!! No way! I'm from Arizona too. Been a big fan, great to see i learned something new just from continuing to watch your content.
Dr. Grande, please consider covering the murder and beheading of Colleen Hufford in Moore, OK by Alton Nolen. I checked to see if you had covered it before but didn't find anything in my search. Thanks for all the intriguing content.
I think that the REID method wears people out emotionally and leads to false confessions. Furthermore, I don't like the fact police are allowed to lie. It seems like nothing good can come out of police lying to anyone in the public.
Very interesting, like a piece of legal history. I don't know what to think about the Miranda Rights... I certainly don't think that citizens can be expected to know all their rights, they would be studying legal things their entire lives due to the complicated nature of the system. Very interesting case, thank you for the video.
I can see him saying "Get me a lawyer, dog,". But who knew that those rotten police were going to use it against him. Hey I've got some updog. What's up dog?
