i loved this rewind but i think the editing should have been a bit less whilst there was actual gameplay. But the editing switching between clips was really good and besides that minor issue i still found it fun to watch:)
I think overall you did an okay job with the info and different opinions on the rewind, but I really feel like the bit at 7:11 was unnecessary. Like, I obviously don't know whether you and Zylice still have "beef" with each other, but it just felt like beating a dead horse. If that bit was meant to be ironic, then I apologize for going too deep into it, but you could've done a better job with it (if it was ironic). Overall, okay video, you're getting better and better with info gathering and others opinions.
Some of these points brought up were things I never had thought of. I never got 5 minutes into it because of all the stuff going on in the video. I am on the autism spectrum and if things get too noisy and bright it doesn't end well.
In MY opinion: I did like the osu!rewind 2023 BUT I prefer the other osu!rewinds (like the 2020 rewind) which had a more directed focus to the scores itself, I feel like this rewind has the editing as the main focus. Which I don't think it's bad, it's just overwhelming and scores are barely impossible to even hype for because they stay in the screen for 3 seconds.
honestly I loved this rewind, it was so fast paced, just like 2023 felt i will admit that there were a lot of scores that i wish couldve been included, and maybe tone down the editing a bit since while I really like it, general audiences will find it a bit much still though, worth the hype imo
as someone that into AMV community, rewind's editing style is pretty much familiar to me except the one that Patch part, his part is unique. and as someone that enjoy variety genre of music, the audio transition and choice is pretty clean. Kudos to them👏🏻
while i was at the roundtable at lvl up expo i talked to ed a bit about the rewind a bit, idk if this was WHY he pushed it back, but he said that the rewind before the delays was like 15 minutes long and didnt have a lot of the sections it has now, namely the tournament section being one he named specifically also imo the whole "i wanna be able to see the play why is it flashing everywhere" argument is kinda stupid, theres a bunch of compilations on youtube for plays, rewind is completely different, its meant to hype up all the plays and quickly go back through memories, not give us another compilation of plays also saying vaxei didnt deserve that much screen time is crazy didnt need to mention zylice's video lol, not sure if this was the intention but it just makes it seem like your still salty about it
Why is it on my fyp page only now? This is what i call good and structured criticism. We will definitely take notes from most of people's feedback including this one. Liked the video though!
For me It wasn’t the best but not the worst. I don’t really like the fact that some plays were missing and how over edited it is (second thing it’s subjective obviously)
One of the complaints that I have is that the transition doesn’t make sense in some places, like what does gnahus aim score have to do with Freddie Benson returning???
@@akrakizamazing my guy. Instantly makes you the best of yourself whether people say whatever they want. You can be rank #1 or #1 million but if you have self confidence you are always the #1. Love your positivity, keep the game a better place with people like you. Have a good day.
imo the overediting complain is so dumb because rewind is about remembering things from the past year not literally re-watching things from the past year lol, and so this overediting makes remembering these things super hype and unique and cool, its something nothing can do but rewind but the fact that they missed zoomer stage 5 score is insane thats my biggest complain lol how did they miss it (and some other scores as well but this is the biggest one)
