Palestinians: Would you agree to a binational state? 

Even if you're pro-Palestinian & against a one-state solution, you can't expect millions of Israelis (most of whom were born there without a choice) to suddenly leave and jump into the Mediterranean Sea. It's unfortunate that so many Palestinians left after 1948 (by force or by choice) but it isn't feasible to expect the same of Israelis in the 21st century. You guys need to work this out and somehow coexist, religious sympathies aside (e.g. the drama over Jerusalem).

When I was in Israel-Palestine and the Westbank for a few weeks, I realized a lot of hatred and aggression from palestinians and short temper from Israelis when confronted with Arabs. What I realized was that the better educated people on both sides just wanted peace and were willing to discuss the hard questions.

A binational state has a good chance to collapse into war like Lebanon does. I think better is one Israeli state, one Palestinian state, two governments. Then form a union to cooperate on peace and economy, and roads.

The Palestinians who speak English are always the most open-minded, which shows how important education is to solve the conflict.

Really felt for the woman at 9:00. You can tell she's struggling so hard for her kids

The third one 😆 >what's the 2nd best option? -Second best option is living together. >Would you accept such option? -no, no way. 😂😂

The last man seemed like a genuinely good, sincere human being, but he was not entirely correct, Jews did not always live that well in Iraq, Syria, Egypt, etc. There were some peaceful periods, especially when these territories were dominated by foreign powers (Ottomans and then British and French), but quickly the political and social mood could change and the Muslim majority would attack and pillage its Jewish, Christian and Yazidi minorities.

Like I say in other videos on this topic, it's going to take time for the populations to reconcile. Once an actual solution is reached, it'll take a few years for the scars to heal.

13:52 - "Jews lived with more rights under Arab and Muslim states than they do under Israel" Oh is that right?

I found it amusing how the video ends with one intelligent, coherent, logical Palestinian woman making sense, which is then followed by a former Palestinian government official talking absolute nonsense, referring to religion and the quran and the creator. It is just more evidence that the wrong people are in positions of authority or propping up those same delusional people in positions of authority.

Thanks for providing these insights, very interesting!!

Good morning everyone, i hope you have a great day💟

Both peoples want all the land for themselves. It's like a gambler's fallacy with blood. They feel they have sacrificed too much to back out. Either they agree to share it all or the conflict will never end.

Found a report of a 2019 poll that said the preference among West Banks Palestinians was as follows: ~60% wanted one Palestinian state from the river to the sea ~30% wanted two states ~10% wanted a binational state

Me as a Palestinian I do agree with a binational state, because it’s the only way to end this conflict.

What a wonderful thing to do. Thanks to all who were part of this.

Palestinians= "All of Palestine or nothing" Israelis: okay nothing.

The woman at 9:00 gives me hope.

Why do people keep saying that modern Israelis are not the real Jews because most are White Europeans? If you watch this video you will see that half of all Palestinians look like white people too. But the truth is that most Israelis are dark Middle Eastern looking people, that half of Israelis came from Arabic countries. Sure, when Jews lived in the diaspora in Europe, many intermarried with Europeans and they became whiter, when Jews lived in Ethiopia they became blacker, when they lived in India they became like Indians, when they lived in China, they became Asian looking. What´s the point? That does not mean they are not real Jews. Just like Muslims in Africa, just because they are black, does that mean they are not real muslims? Remember Nazi Germany and the racism they had against the Jews, they said Jews of Europe were easy to spot, most had dark skin, big noses, and kinky curly black hair. They put up posters everywhere showing what European Jews looked like. Most did not look the same as white Europeans. The most obvious Jewish looking people were quickly rounded up and burn´t in the Concentration camps, many of the Jews that survived in Europe, survived solely because they didn't look so Jewish, did anybody every think about that? So, the Ashkenazi Jews of today, those that survived the Holocaust, and went to Israel, many of them were of the whiter variety, hence they survived.

Only choice you got. Wake up, non-Arabs and non-Muslims have lived in this area forever.

Funny that she mentions nablus as an example of how it used to be racism free, one of the cities where Jews got massacred.

🤣🤣🤣🤣 these people play right into the hands of Israeli right-wingers. "All of Palestine or Nothing"

"It is Palestine or nothing." Fine, so I guess we have our solution.

I cant understand why people think a certain land is created for anyone, it's a short life, now enjoy if you can.

1:06He was in favor of it and then when he realized that it was a country with the Jews he opposed it, why? Who else did he think he meant?

Morning, Boker tov.

I liked that the woman at the beginning said that the Jews were racist, and at the end she came out as racist when she included all the Jews in something specific

When you ask this kind of question to the "Palestinian" Arabs and then to the Israelis, you can easily see who are those who want peace and who has continuously fueled this conflict since the beginning of the 20th century.

Yeah, it worked great in Lebanon...

I would like to give a big hug to a the palestinian mom - i think peace is in the hand of women.

how can peace be achieved if literally Palestine cannot compromise..??? So frustrating..

Love your videos but I have to say that your translators are not great. They're not asking the questions exactly how you ask them, and translating the responses imperfectly, calling for confusing clarifications and indirect responses.

8:55 nice lady

I feel sad about the old guy who was talking in the last minutes.

They all have to be equal which is not going to happen because we have racism between Arabs and jews...between Muslims and Jews...between Muslims and Christians...that is unfortunate. We need to accept each other first then respect then we can talk about living together as neighbors.

The word 'Palestine' is taken from the ancient Philistines. They were an ancient pagan people who lived in the area before the Babylonians forced them to move to Mesopotamia hundreds of years before Christ. The ancient Romans forced the Jews to leave Israel in the second century AD. The Romans renamed a large part of the area "Palestina" to insult the Jews. Then the area became populated mostly by non-Jewish pagans who had lived nearby. As Christianity spread, the region became mostly Christian. When Islam spread, it became mostly Muslin. The scriptures of the Jews plainly states that the land of Israel was given to them by God, and they lived there for hundreds of years. Mohammed said the Jewish scriptures were given by the god he worshipped, and the Jewish scriptures still say the same thing. They still say that the land of Israel was given to the Jews by God. Islam teaches that any land which was once controlled by Islam, will forever be considered to be Islamic land. Both sides claim to have a permanent, God given, right to the land. This dispute will not end until all Jews and/or Muslims die. Or Jesus returns.

im Muslims and im down with Palisrael as a state

In basically every A,rab ruled country there is suffering and bloodshed. From Yemen to Syria to Libya.

This is never going to happen. A clueless international community asking dumb questions. This will happen around the 12th of never!

stop asking kids that think life is a video game lmao

I will NEVER accept a,-rab rule.

I love how arabs on this forum while living in the West are claiming Middle Eastern land.

The UN Members should face a Court Trial for its choke-neck, un-ceasing BS Actions on Israel: “The al-Aqsa Mosque was built on top of Solomon’s Temple.” - Eleventh century historian Muhammad ibn Ahmad al-Maqdisi and fourteenth century Iranian religious scholar Hamdallah al-Mustawfi [“Allah Gave the Land of Israel to the Jews”] QURAN: ISRAEL BELONGS TO THE JEWS. Allah assigned Israel to the Jews (Sura 5 Verse 21), and that Jews are the inheritors of Israel (Sura 26 Verse 59). Muslim Cleric: "How can Mohamad go to the Jerusalem Mosque when it was not yet built for 60 years?" (128) MUSLIM CLERIC: AL AQSA MOSQUE IS NOT IN JERUSALEM (Palestine) - RU-vid The real #AlAqsa is in Medina, not Jerusalem: “#Jerusalem is Not Ours. And Never Was. Period.”, proclaims #Imam of #Peace, Imam Mohamad Tawhidi. (731) MUSLIM CLERIC: AL AQSA MOSQUE IS NOT IN JERUSALEM (Palestine) - RU-vid According to Saudi journalist, Al Aqsa mosque is not in Jerusalem | BLiTZ (weeklyblitz.net) (38) Syrian Scholar Firas Al-Sawwah: Al-Aqsa Mentioned in Quran Is Not in Jerusalem - RU-vid #quran #un #israel

Answer: No

Corey Gil-Schuster ask them what was found under Solomons temple, after Solomons death

The previous film made me sad this one terrified me...

Corey i feel like you should have both Israeli/Palestinian views in one video to compare the answers.

I'm a Palestinian and the last guy was lying big time. Quran said the Holy Land was inherited to Jews by God. It's the bitter truth.

A binational state is stupid. Would the US agree to merge with Mexico into a binational state? There's your answer.

Corey ask this question to a rabbi,if the Jewish people are chosen people then why the god of Abraham punishes (spell)them , what’s the secret of the soul ?.

I would like to know, if they can do a DNA test for both sides and see how close they're

There is no such thing as "Palestine."

imho binational state is bad idea. I am from Europe and my country in past was part of multinational or binational state(s) and it never worked....

Corey, many of the people in this video share very similar points of view about their disdain on Israel. Is this concurrent with all Palestinian folklore or if you go into Gaza and WB you will get varying points of view on whether Israel should exist. I am just trying to help understand the differences from one Palestinian town to the next. Thanks.

Hahaha who wrote the subtitles?? "Of course" A moment later: "...of course not." "This is something" A moment later: "...something impossible."

It’s messed up how the people with zero power and are living on international good will will make no concessions

This video could have been 1 second long. "No"

Corey, i have a question. I have a friend of mine that is in a bit of a conflict, and i wanted to help him. Founded your channel and i think u are the only one that can give him a good view of the problem. He's mother is converted by reform/conservative judaism before he was born, and he's father is jewish. Is he jewish? Can u ask to some rabbine or some random jews in the street, u dont need to do a video of it, i just want to know if u could help me. Regardless of the outcome, thank u very much!

I wish all Americans would watch this and stop trying to tell the Israelis/Palestinians what to do and how to live. Let them decide without our interference.

Never give up even a centimeter of Israeli land! You saw what happened when we left Gaza!

"We need a two state solution!!" "NO, we need a one state solution!!' Anarchists: _Allow me to introduce myself_

When you're all or nothing, you've made it inevitable that you'll get nothing. If you want a sensible solution and want the violence to stop, you've absolutely got to be willing to put your pride aside and come to the table. This sort of intransigence is absolutely why so much of the non-Islamic world (and even some of the Islamic world) has given up on the Palestinians; if they don't want to negotiate, there's nothing the rest of us can do.

As a Palestinian, I strongly support a one state solution and changing the states name to Canaan instead of Palestine/Israel so that people would stop fighting on the name. Seriously enough enough enough. Land is not more important than blood. We are killing each other thinking we are serving the SAME God, seriously can we be any more stupid? If ultra orthodox and the ultra muftis could be tamed a bit, the vast majority will eventually learn to coexist.

Seems like the best solution is a 2 state solution as this is what most people want and neither trusts the other enough to have a 1 state with jewish and arabs living together. Both Israelis and Palestinians can live in multicultural states elsewhere such as the US or Canada but cannot make a multicultural state work in their own country because of their history.

Isn't jisia a pure form of racism? Keep dreaming... But at the end, it is a simple case of "Dar el harb" vs "Dar el Islam".

As an impartial observer who is neither Muslim, Jewish, or Christian. Can someone explain to me why is that Israelis feel a claim to the land? Is it only because of religious justification? Weren’t both groups living in the same land? Which side is correct? My final and most important question: why can’t there be a two state solution? Obviously both sides feel strongly about the land and are living in the land. Sincerely, impartial observer.

That last guy LOL, a "moderate" of the Palestinian Authority - the whole land must be an Islamic theocracy, a Shari'a hellhole state where Jews would have the right to breathe the same air, "as long as they know their place". What was it he said, "there are Jews in the all the Arab countries", forgetting to mention they were all ethnically cleansed, exiled where not massacred. 800,000 Jews lost their homes, and had their ancient communities completely destroyed.

Good video but Corey really should've put the viewer straight on the experience of Jews in Arab lands eg. the Farhud.

The woman at 9:00 is an amazing person. She is telling the truth and in general has a good and valid point of view.

I feel like you`ve asked this question or questions with the same answer a hundred times before...We just have to accept that this is fucked and will never have a solution

My dream is to witness in my lifetime a country called United Palestine and Israel, where Jews and Arabs live side by side in peace. 🕊

Israelis and Palestinians no longer want a two state solution but a status quo where both are trying to achieve what individually will be best for them. In this situation Israel will win as it will do the annexation of Area C of the West Bank and the Palestinians cannot do anything about it.

They're for bi national state which is Jew free.

Did anyone propose a bi-national state in WB as a trial run to see how it works out? Too late for Gaza I suppose.

2:23 An add for beer in Palestine? Must be a Christian area.

Palistinians and Jews will be like good brothers, restore the temple and put into "restoration" all things Torah and all things Koran... They will work together in a new Light

You have to ask the question with some more details, would they be living under the israeli rule on equal terms, you will get a different answer.

The whole business could and should have been settled back in the mandate era. Already by 1947 both sides had become totally entrenched in their positions.

I love Palestinians and Palestine. They don’t take shit from no one. Israel has no chance in the long term.

Last guy is a lier. According to the Holy Quran G-d gave land of Israel to Jews. This is stated in number of suras. While Israel exists, Muslims has no religious right to govern Israel. This is not Dar al Harb.

Muslims really need some reeducation

It’s gods land

It appears Theocratic people think they are the boss and everyone has to submit to their philosophy .

Another interesting video ruined by the translator.

9:48 I've just noticed the star of David in the background on the floor designed so people (if you can consider most of them as people) will step on it, so it just proves that even if there are individuals who want peace among them like the lady talking it's still not possible with most of them. and I can guarantee you there is nowhere in Israel where there is an Arab country's flag or another symbol that's represent them (or any other country...) drawn on the floor so people can step on it (that the Israeli authorities put there).

We have G-D on our side 🇮🇱🥰🇮🇱🥰

Sad. These people have a life full of frustration ahead of them. Christina ? .... was the only one realistic and somewhat logical. I hope she has a decent life come what may.

The old man at the end has a clean soul and humble 🥺🤲🏻

I mean it’s a pretty good idea 🤷🏻‍♂️

And this is, ladies and gentlemen, why there is no Palestenian state 😢

Do Palestines hate all Jews or only Zionists.? Can you ask that next

A large percentage of Palestinian families and clans residing in villages or cities have Canaanite origins. For example, there is a family in Nablus called Canaan, even if a second city is to be departed, you will see that the family in them has Christian or Muslim faith. The Bedouins of the Bedouin of the Arabian Peninsula (Saudi Arabia) the farmers, some of them are Arab from the Arabian Peninsula some of them are of Canaanite origin and civilians are mixed between Turks, Kurds, Arabs of the Arabian Peninsula and the Canaanites, but of course civil society differs from the closed Bedouin or agricultural society, which of course has a civil status that has non-Arab veins

*---* *THE FACTS ABOUT THE SO-CALLED PALESTINIANS* *---* There has never been such a country called Palestine. Israel was re-formed on land previously ruled by the Ottoman empire, similarly to other countries in the region such as Lebanon, Iraq and others. There is no such thing as "Palestinian people". It's worth noting that newspapers such as the 'Palestine post' were Jewish newspapers (this one for example turned into the 'Jerusalem post'). This is also true about other official "Palestine" related stuff from the time before Israel was re-formed. Hebrews were the majority in Jerusalem even before the birth of the Zionist movement in the 19th century. If someone happened to use the term "Palestine" before the re-formation of Israel, he was referring to the homeland of the Jevvs (the land of Israel) - not the Arabs. It's worth noting that the flag of the "Palestinian Authority" is the flag of Hejaz. The British Mandate over the land, after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, actually included also what is now Jordan (which includes the "east bank" - part of historic Israel), and according to the League of Nations (precursor of the UN), this Mandate was to become a national homeland for the Jevvs (the Arabs would get their own independent lands in all the rest of the greater middle-east, an area which makes the land of Israel insignificant in comparison). Note that according to the UN's constitution, all the past resolutions of the League of Nation are valid. The British Authorities, due to their own interests with the Arabs (among others - future oil dealings), gave them 77% of the land - which later became what is now Jordan. There are over 20 Arab countries, and almost 60 lsIamic countries - each on average way bigger than Israel, but the Arabs couldn't tolerate the existence of tiny Israel, even after being given most of the land of the mandate. Instead, they tried to annihilate it by force with the Arab armies the moment it was officially independent (and have attempted to do so several times again since then). The coIoniaI term "Palestine" was discarded after it was brought to life under the British rule, as it should have been, because the original name for the land - Israel, has been restored (Israel is not Palestine, just like Jerusalem is not Aelia-Capitolina, and Schehem is not Nablus). It is only in the mid 1960's that the Arabs hijacked the term, and its widespread usage only took off after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. The Arabs used this terminology as a political propaganda tool to de-legitimize Israel, after they failed to steal the Hebrew homeland by force with the Arab armies, by invading and attempting to conquer the land. Ironically, the term "Palestinian" originate from the term 'Pleshet' to describe INVADERS by the Hebrews. Those who willingly identify as "Palestinians" are declaring themselves to be invaders/colonizers in Hebrew land. It's important to note that this propaganda tool was supported by the Communists/Soviets. On the other hand, just a few decades before that, the Arab "Palestinians" were hand in hand with the Nazis. They have aided them under the leadership of the mufti Amin Al-Husseini - who is often regarded as the 'founding father' of the Arab "Palestinians". During WW2 he became an SS general, but he had anti-Jewish genocidal ideology long before the Nazis rose the power. He has incited and caused violence and terror against the Jewish people in their homeland since the early 1920's (for example: 1929 Hebron massacre). "Palestinians" are nothing more than bands of foreign invaders, squatters and illegal immigrants from all over the Islamic world - mostly the Arab world (some of them even originating from places that are not part of the middle-east, such as Bosnia), as well as several other places. The overwhelming majority of them first settled in the land of Israel in recent centuries - mostly in the 19th and 20th centuries. Some of them even came to Gaza, Judea and Samaria from Egypt and Jordan while these areas were under Egyptian and Jordanian occupation in the period between 1948 to 1967. Informative quotes from Arab "Palestinian" leaders: "There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' was invented by the Zionists. There is no Palestine in the bible ...Palestine is ALIEN to us" - Arab "Palestinian" leader Awni Abdul Hadi, Peel Commission, 1937. "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity... Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa, while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan." - Arab "Palestinian" leader & PLO member Zuheir Mohsen, 1977. "I don’t think there is 'Palestinian People', I don’t think there is a 'Palestinian Nation' at all… 'Palestinian Nation'? I think that is a colonial invention. When were there ever 'Palestinians'?" - Arab "Palestinian" leader Azme Bishara, TV Interview. "We all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian in Gaza and throughout Palestine can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, Yemen or anywhere else." "... Half the Palestinians are (Arab) Egyptians and the other half are (Arab) Saudis" - Arab "Palestinian" Hamas minister Fathi Hammad, 2012. Here are some common "Palestinian" families and their place of origin: Saudi, Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi Arabia Yamani, Azad - Yemen Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids) Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt (Bedouins) Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon Bushnak - Bosnia Khamis - Bahrain Afghani - Afghanistan Mughrabi - Maghreb Araj - Morocco Djazair - Algeria Kurd - Kurdistan Hindi - Indian Subcontinent Abid - Sudan Yasser Arafat, the most famous "Palestinian" and leader of the PLO terrorist organization, was not native to Judea. He called himself a "Palestinian refugee" but spoke Arabic with an Egyptian accent. He was born in 1929 Cairo, Egypt. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956! His full name was Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat Al-Qudwa Al-Husseini. Yasser Arafat also proudly stated in his authorized biography that: "If there is any such thing as a Palestinian people, it is I, Yasser Arafat, who created them." Genetic data for "Palestinians": According to a 2010 study by Behar et al. Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudi Arabians which was described as "consistent with a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula". A study found that the Palestinians, have what appears to be Female-Mediated gene flow in the form of Maternal DNA Haplogroups from Sub-Saharan Africa. Palestinian individuals tested, carried maternal haplogroups that originated in Sub-Saharan Africa. The explanation for the presence of predominantly female lineages of African origin in these areas is that they trace back to women brought from Africa as part of the Arab slave trade, assimilated into the areas under Arab rule. In a genetic study of Y-chromosomal STRs in two populations from Israel and the Palestinian Authority Area: Christian and Muslim Palestinians showed genetic differences. A 2013 study of Haber and et al. found that "The predominantly Muslim populations of Syrians, Palestinians and Jordanians cluster on branches with other Muslim populations as distant as Morocco and Yemen." The authors explained that "religious affiliation had a strong impact on the genomes of the Levantines. In particular, conversion of the region's populations to Islam appears to have introduced major rearrangements in populations' relations through admixture with culturally similar but geographically remote populations leading to genetic similarities between remarkably distant populations." Even according to the Quran: And thereafter We (Allah) said to the Children of Israel: "Dwell securely in the Promised Land. And when the last warning will come to pass, we will gather you together in a mingled crowd" [17 : 104] O my people (Jevvs)! Enter the Holy Land, which God has assigned unto you [5 : 21] We (Allah) settled the Israelites in a blessed land and provided them with good things [10 : 93] It was our (Allah's) will to favor those who were oppressed (Jevvs) and to make them leaders of man, to bestow on them a noble heritage and to give them power in the land (of Israel) [28 : 5-6] We (Allah) gave the persecuted people (Jevvs) dominion over the eastern and western lands which We had blessed (the east and west banks of the Jordan River). Thus your Lord's gracious word was fulfilled for the Israelites, because they had endured with fortitude [7 : 137] Watch: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-IJggz2HIkS4.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-SN838zu6iio.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-u8ELap2uhkA.html

To me as an outsider, the one state solution makes the most logical sense. However, there is a lot of hate and mistrust on both sides that will take decades of living together to overcome.

Why the only peaceful solution is a 2 state scenario by 1967 boarders. At this stage it would be too difficult and a one state proposal would come across as a deception.

Disgusting. We see here in broad daylight who’s the problem here.

JESUS CHRIST GAVE THE LAND TO ABRAHAM AND HE DIDN'T GIVE TWO STATES ONLY ONE AND THAT'S ISRAEL 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

I try to give empathy to Palestinians, and yes there are some exceptions which does make it hard. But as most Palestinians prove the point, and my Belief says- more Power to ISRAEL!

Ridiculous question.Will never happen.The Arabs have to edit what they say for fear of retaliation.They keep their honor but then have to live with occupation

To be continued ...