Panel discussion on clashes at JNU over Afzal Guru event- Part II 

Rohit Sardana you rocked---great job

Be grateful that you can speak your mind with such freedom in India and now think about how to protect the integrity of this country!

one word this type student only "Gaddar" .

They are not even letting omar speak 😂 why are you so afraid of him even the reporter is getting into the debate lol . now i feel Zee news is way better than big boss😂😂😂🙏🙏

"PAKISTAN ZINDABAD", "HINDUSTAN KA HOGA HAZAR TUKRA": So called 'Students' are shouting @JNU. How can 'Intolerant' (Desh) 'Bhakts' are calling the 'Students' Anti-National​ ???? Actually We Need To BE INTOLERANT.... TOO MUCH TOLERANCE IS SUICIDE .... BHARAT MATA KI JAI.

Shut down the JNU...

Who ever is involved in these acts should be stripped off their Citizenship and deported to no man's land.

अब हम हिन्दुस्तानियों के सामने एक ही लक्ष्य होना चाहिए...खानग्रेस मुक्त भारत...खुजली मुक्त भारत. जय हिन्द...जय माँ भारती...!!!

superb sambit ji

proud on you sourav kumar

Where is Congress????????????

6 Delhi churches's window glasses were broken which was later came out as incidents with no communal connection and in one case a Muslim boy broke the windows of Church because a Christian girl rejected his love proposal!! Opposition : BJP is against all Christians, intolerance is rising!! Mahammad Akhlakh killed unfortunately in Dadri by fringe over suspicion of eating, Uttarpradesh under SP Govt Opposition : BJP is against all Muslims, intolerance is rising!! Rohith Vemula called himself dalit though his dalit identity is in doubt, he instead of doing the Dalit Movement did everything except Dalit Movement, became Terror apologizer and supporter, he was got hijacked by Islamist forces like Shri Jogendra Nath Mondal got hijacked and later he and his followers paid heavy price in the hands of Islamist Forces for trusting them, he supported Yakub Memon, he beaten up those who were themselves dalit students and opposed him not because of his dalit identity but because of his Anti - India stance, he got suspended and later out of frustration unfortunately committed suicide. Opposition : BJP is against all Dalits, intolerance is rising!! Some anti - nationals inside JNU brought Pakistani Intellectuals during 1999 Kargil war and held an Anti - India ceremony and when 2 Army Officers present opposed Anti -India slogans like what happened recently, they were beaten black and blue and they had to fire their pistol in the air just escape from there, after that in 2010 there was celebration of BSF Jawans got killed in the hands of Maoists, in 2013 Hem Mishra arrested for Maoist Activities and in this case the so called students were celebrating Afjal Guru, Maqbul Bhatt, demanding destruction of India, hailing Pakistan for years, only this time due to the power of social media, the video got spread, mainstream media also caught up the story and GOI took action against the culprits!! Opposition : BJP is against all Students, intolerance is rising!! BJP : Facepalm!!

*Very well said Saurav, keep it up bud.*

real face of kttwas of India

Favourite journalist✓

If you do not accept Supreme Court order then you have no rights in India. You are lier and two faced Omer we can see you in the footage! Har Azfar ko Rasi milagi. Jai Hind!!!

Umar khalid should have quoted the whole statement of the Supreme Court on Afzal Guru. The statement clearly stated that Afzal's direct involvement was not found but he was involved in many conspiracies against the nation including the Parliament attack of 2001. Since he was not directly involved so Capital Punishment could not have been implemented but his involvement in many such conspiracies was so grief that nothing less than Capital Punishment could have satisfied the society.

i am a leftist. but now i think . i am wrong. i am planning to join RSS though it is against my antaratma.

kanoon india ki akal ki andhi hai agar in deshdroh ko punishment nahin milega toh

through out from India !!

I'm Indian this type of people should proudse in front of public in front of indian people then see what will happen jnu name should be charged & management also who is this student against India & Supreme Court decision police 👮 should take action soon

Umar khalid to gaya bas 2-4 roz me

Hi All, We will give one offer to all Secular (Rahul, Kejiriwal, Assahaudin and Left's) faces. Ask them to take responsibility to surrender all the students (based video tapes) who made statements against our country within a week. If there are not able to make them surrender, cases should be filed against these secular faces as they are supporting these anti national elements. All secular faces, do you agree? Real secular will always agree without any second thought

Shame on these students who are studying getting lots of free things specially in JNU in tax payers money.. Why should our money be spent for these cowerds .. Who can't even own there fault s

Sudhir Chaudhary, editor and prime time anchor of the channel however on a telecast made a statement saying "our channel only showed what was happening there, whatever we have shown is 100% authentic."[25] A forensic report of the Delhi Police however later stated that the footage was doctored.[26]

It is a GREAT SHAME to see this coming out of one of the top universities In India.I have the greatest respect for JNU. I was student there at one time and to hear and see this happening ...Well really people. Do not give this UnIversity such a bad name!!!! Shame on these people who are having such protests...This is a place of learning NOT a place for protesters. I did not even bother to see details of this story because I am appalled to see what is happening here. PLEASE PRESERVE THE DIGNITY OF THIS MOST RESPECTED UNIVERSITY IN INDIA.

Where did RSS come here? No, RSS doesn't decide what is anti nationalism, common Indian loyal citizen decides.. and no, you Umar Khalid or whoever you are You don't have the right to raise anti national slogans on Indian soil and rest of the India decides that

nor hindu neither muslim first is constitution. ...

Well said Saurabh

Vahh Rohit jii good

If i am not wrong then afzal was legally punished in congress regime...

please govt make strict law and hang till death this kind of people. who want to divide our country....

Y this people r not behind the bars

The statement clearly stated that Afzal's direct involvement was not found but he was involved in many conspiracies against the nation including the Parliament attack of 2001. Since he was not directly involved so Capital Punishment could not have been implemented but his involvement in many such conspiracies was so grief that nothing less than Capital Punishment could have satisfied the society.

Very nice rohit ji

throw them out of university

कितने ही बादशाह आये और धूल हो गए.. कितने ही लार्ड गवर्नर आये और खो गए... हिंदुस्तान ना तब मिटा था ना कभी मिटेगा... चाहे जितने नारे लगालो

zee media mein kuchh din pehle swamy ji ne ehi bat pura spasta bole the ki jnu mein antinationalist badh rahe hain. ea satya sahi nikal gaya.sat sat namah to swamy jaisa bidwan ko.

कोई आपको गाली दे और कहे कि ये उसकी अभिव्यक्ति की आजदी (Freedom of speech) है , ये तो कोई आजादी नही हुई, ये तो attack है.. Freedom of speech के नाम पर आपको किसी को भी और कही भी, कुछ भी बोलने का अधिकार नही मिल जाता, और ये तो देश के खिलाफ बोल रहे है, देश को बर्बाद करने की बात कर रहे है.. इनको क्या सजा देना है ये तो अब भारत सरकार ही फ़ैसला करेगी..

Zada democracy achi nahi lagti

Rohit sardarna I have salute you

Rohit sir u rock.

This is the tolerance of my country allowing this kind of anti national people gets a chance to justifying himself. join with Arundhati Roy and get lost from my country

actually muslims needs azadi from islam

great umar khalid

Aag lage aise students m.

RSS is growing in number but army men are dying everday. Army men die , while their widows and children are left in this world. While Modiji still spends on RAMDEV all time , he travels abroad and comes to find new soldier died. While most of relatives of RSS son's study in US , Russia ,China , they never care of Indian of Indian Army .

rohit bhai aap ne sahi sawal pucha ye kya deta hai desh ko

Wow Saurabh, you are stuttering like a real speaker should 🤡 I know creating the imaginary facts and theories requires time to process so well done bro. You should become a fictional writer.

Respected media, I have a request to you. Please do not call those people who against our country. Sorry but they actually got success in their plan. Because you show many times and they do not deserve to come in your show. We all Love our country. We should serve everything for our nation.

why rohit sardana calling him sir

Umar khalid too smart parson kitna smil h... dekhe aap sab, tight this type matter closed JNU

just one question. .Umar Khalid got arrested or not?.

"Collective conscience" has been historically a misquoted phrase used by all and sundry - out of context, including our "intellectual conscience" made up of the likes of Arundhati Roy. The use of the phrase "collective conscience" in the judgement is as follows:- "The gravity of the crime conceived by the conspirators with the potential of causing enormous casualties and dislocating the functioning of the Government as well as disrupting normal life of the people of India is some thing which cannot be described in words. The incident, which resulted in heavy casualties, had shaken the entire nation and the collective conscience of the society will only be satisfied if the capital punishment is awarded to the offender. The challenge to the unity, integrity and sovereignty of India by these acts of terrorists and conspirators, can only be compensated by giving the maximum punishment to the person who is proved to be the conspirator in this treacherous act. The appellant, who is a surrendered militant and who was bent upon repeating the acts of treason against the nation, is a menace to the society and his life should become extinct. Accordingly, we uphold the death sentence." "NO DIRECT EVIDENCE" That too is farcical/muse to satisfy and justify hate mongering. Here is what the judgement says:- "Mostly, the conspiracies are proved by the circumstantial evidence, as the conspiracy is seldom an open affair. Usually both the existence of the conspiracy and its objects have to be inferred from the circumstances and the conduct of the accused. (Per Wadhwa, J. in Nalini’s case (supra) at page 516). The well known rule governing circumstantial evidence is that each and every incriminating circumstance must be clearly established by reliable evidence and "the circumstances proved must form a chain of events from which the only irresistible conclusion about the guilt of the accused can be safely drawn and no other hypothesis against the guilt is possible." Circumstantial evidence independent and irrespective of his confession was also considered. "The circumstances detailed above clearly establish that the appellant Afzal was associated with the deceased terrorists in almost every act done by them in order to achieve the objective of attacking the Parliament House. He established close contacts with the deceased terrorists, more especially, JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 77 of 107 Mohammed. Short of participating in the actual attack, he did everything to set in motion the diabolic mission. As is the case with most of the conspiracies, there is and could be no direct evidence of the agreement amounting to criminal conspiracy. However, the circumstances cumulatively considered and weighed, would unerringly point to the collaboration of the accused Afzal with the slain ’Fidayeen’ terrorists. The circumstances, if considered together, as it ought to be, establish beyond reasonable doubt that Afzal was a party to the conspiracy and had played an active part in various acts done in furtherance of the conspiracy. These circumstances cannot be viewed in isolation and by no standards of common sense, be regarded as innocuous acts. His conduct and actions\027antecedent, contemporaneous and subsequent\027all point to his guilt and are only consistent with his involvement in the conspiracy. Viewed from another angle, the Court can draw a presumption under Section 114 of Evidence Act having regard to the natural course of events and human conduct that the appellant Afzal had nexus with the conspirators who were killed and all of them together hatched the conspiracy to attack the Parliament House and in that process to use explosives and other dangerous means. We are, therefore, of the view that there is sufficient and satisfactory circumstantial evidence to establish that Afzal was a partner in this conspired crime of enormous gravity. (x) Punishment: Identification of the appropriate provisions of POTA and IPC under which the accused Afzal becomes liable for punishment is the next important task ...." Had our friend Umar Khalid only read the above snippets, he would have understood the mechanism of law in context of Afsal Guru's hanging instead of making a fundamental error of judgement which is well portrayed when he "quoted" the judgement of the supreme court on 10:20 of the above video.

Ashamed of those people, who support anti-nationalism activities... they must be treated as antisocial people including those who were presence inside the campus during the event; they all must be punished; i doubt few people intentionally trying to create disturbances in our country.... Debate won't be the solution...let's find out the reason, why it's happened... Koi toh hoga in students ko bhadka raha hai......

Taal thok ke zee news team plz share my masage and othr news chanel. I salute zee news and his all reporter for such a brave and clear news. And also abvp for expose the video. No politics can tolarte sucha a bull shit which is like terrorist.

You did not go legal to raise voice so dooo not ask Indians to be legal with you!!!

mtlb koi parliament pr attack krega or usko fansi na ho...wah g wah judicial killing....had hoti hai its wrong...government ko strict action lena chahiye koi mercy nai ye srasar galt hai

this person umar kalid should be put behind bar. he said that's his rights to defend Pakistan.

rohit you are not agent of RSS/BJP your are anchor Zee TV

today martyrs would be ashamed!!!!!!!!

Jis Desh mein paida Huye us Desh ka samman Karna chahie bharat ke logo ki bharat ke khilaf nhi bolna chahiye ek sachcha deshbhakt baniye kuch bhi kar le Hindustan jindabad tha hai aur rahega india is great jay hind jay bharat vande mataram bharat mata ki jay mujhe Garv hai ki mein Hindustan mein paida hua hu

Inn ko aur do azadi..

I think if you try to understand this...These are few Kashmiri students who are chanting these Anti Nationalists Slogans...But this can't make complete JNU Anti Nationalist....I believe you must punish them but JNU is one of the best institution with freedom of speech....DON'T RUIN IT!"

JNU SHLD BE CLOSE DOWN

these people are not letting omar khalid "antinational " to keep his views....anchor is also doing politics ..comman sense..shame...if u don't let a guest to speak why to invite them,,,,shame....

I have not understood one thing...Why is there no case against this person? Tushtikaran ki rajneeti

अगर अब भी इन देश द्रोहीयो को सजा नहीं मिली तो अाने वाले वक्त के अफजल गुरू इस देश का कानून खुद पैदा करेगा

What the hell man why not debate on haryana strike where is ur mind

Umar khalid ka jawab sunny ki himmat hi ni usy bolny hi ni dy rahy...main kashmiri hon main bolta hon...afzal guru zindabad Pakistan Zindabad...

abhi umar khalid ka world tour nhi,jail tour chal rha h

hindusthan Zindabad

Media wale umar ko bolne nhi de rahe

Y this are not behind the bars

World tour nahi, tumhara narak tour karavana hai.

how come Indian Govt tolerating this traitor Umar Khalid? He is another example of Indian Muslims who ove Pakistan more than their motherland.

Afasal guru koi desh bhakt nahi tha ki hm uske bare me jane samjhe na

Jis ghr se afzal niklega.. Us ghar ko hum jala dnge.. Jis kokh se afzal janmega.. Us kokh ko hm gira dnge..

Omara khalid is zeri .... So loughing...

RSS guy is quoting Bhagat Singh....He was true leftist guy...If he were alive today, these RSS guys may have sent him to pakistan along with others. Is it not true????

This Khali-ed has adverse opinion against Constitution of India and the Appex Court of this Country. In law it is called resjudicata, as the matter has been ended in proper court of law ,thus is contempt to court and defamation of the Honour ble President of India.

where is award wapsi people .and the hell with those people who are supporting these antinational .my God one painter painted something against mamta Banarjee then he was arrested within hours and these gaddars are still roaming free on my land is unbearable .silent Indians are watching everything Modi ji pls don't let these gaddars go free .Today soilders and freedom fighters family's are in pain .Bardast kee haad hoti hai

Democracy is not for idiots..we should understand that.. This kind of people of jnu dont deserve democracy. They need to be send where captial punishment is their in every muslim country even for stilling.. than they would understand how lucky they r to leave in democratic country.

abey rakesh sinha... baatla house encounters was totally fake... and rakesh sinha RSS supported nathu ram godsey. ... & shamefull judgement of supreme court that there was no direct evidence against afzal guru. ...

i will be highly thanful to you to that person jo bus iska adress de do

4 vs 1 .. well played. Omar is winner.

Very good

Rohit, For your question what JNU is giving to this nation. Let me answer you- JNU is giving vibrant personalities who can critical analyze social and moral principles. It is giving visionaries, educationalist, politicians, journalist(few like u) and artists. It is not making machines as IIT's do. By the way your question reflects how narrow minded you are.

umar yar esase tera jada fayada nahi ho payega ..kejariwal aur rabul bhai ..bolege desh ki janata kush nahi ..hai.. kuch din bad..rah gayi tere aajadi ki bat ..hame bhi dukh ..hai tere jaise log bharat me hai..tu logo ko control nahi kar pata to kyu ye sab orgnisation karata hai..agar neta banana chahate hi ho ban lekin bhul mat ki bharat ke lia karana hai...SALAM

Sabhi University par dhyan rakhana chahiye jaha bhi iss tarah ki aatankvadi activity hoti hai... aur aise university ki subsidy radd karana chahiye

subsidy pe education mil rahi h

muslim and dalits since when they are same. Muslims were rulers.

hahaha..... even president of India did not support the capital punishment of afzal guru & yaqoob....

1 vs 4 panelists

Delhi has failed india yet again

meri baaki sabse winti hai ki please kiiko iske liye blame na de especially religion ko......please please please!!!!!!!

ek pakistani ne virat kohli ke prospective me india ka flag lahraya tha use 10 saal ki saza ho gayi then jnu ke student ke sath kaya krna chahiye 11 saal afjal guru pe mukdama isliye chala ki pure sach ka pata chale aur jnu wale us afjal guru ke liye khade hua jisne indian parliment pe attack kiya aur 8 police ke bande mare bhai

Ander karo inn gadho ko. Ipc offences again the state

Good umar and kanhaiya

agar ab bhi bharat ne kuch action nahi liya to hum phir ek baar gulam banege.