Paris 2024: Why is Amit Rohidas Banned From Men's Hockey Semifinal? | First Sports With Rupha Ramani

Подписаться 6 млн

Просмотров 20 тыс.

50% 1

Paris 2024: Why is Amit Rohidas Banned From Men's Hockey Semifinal? | First Sports With Rupha Ramani
Indian men's hockey team beat Great Britain in a penalty shootout to qualify for the semifinals. Despite the victory, Indian team was seething with the referring decisions in the game. India's Amit Rohidas was given a red card in the second minute of the second quarter. This reduced India to a 10-man team for the remainder of the match. Rohidas will miss the semifinal match against Germany. Rupha Ramani brings you the highlights of the tense nervy game and what lies ahead for the Indian Hockey team.
---
Paris Olympics | India | Red card | Hockey | Great Britain | Germany | Amit Rohidas | First Sports | Rupha Ramani | Firstpost | Sports News
#india #redcard #hockey #parisolympics2024 #greatbritain #germany #amitrohidas #firstsports #rupharamani #sportsnews #firstpost
Firstpost is an Indian news and media website. Get all the incisive opinions, in-depth analyses and other visual stories that matter to you and the world right here on this channel.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.c...

Опубликовано:

8 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 50

@Edwinsk43453 Месяц назад

10 min yellow card was enough. Red card is very rare in hockey. Definitely that's not look natural but considering mistake happened with running/movement( out of balance) not statistically, Red card was very hard call

@judewarner1536 Месяц назад

@Edwinsk43453 The fact that a red card is rare in hockey is no reason not to give one when it's deserved. A rule that is never enforced or is unenforceable is a bad rule.

@barnabaskevin Месяц назад

@@judewarner1536can u prove how it’s deserved?

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

@@judewarner1536 your answer is based on the part of his comment not the whole.

@cp_pdn Месяц назад

Also ... The UK Goalie should have been red-carded for using the IPad !!!

@haroldhart5702 Месяц назад

Red card in hockey is extremely rare because i think players follow the rules of the game, the moment you endanger the opponent you are asking for a red card, the same applies in football a rough tackle calls for a red card. There was no need for a great defender to whack the guy on the face , that was a shame and against the spirit of the sport. That being said , India did a brilliant job at defending with 10 men in 3 quarters, not an easy job with the kind of pace and attack in hockey. Well done team india for the win. All the best for the next game.

@Aishwariyajena Месяц назад

He clearly DID NOT wack the guy... the guy came from behind to tackle the ball and the defender was CLEARLY focused on the ball.... also the ground refree did not give a red card...it was clearly no one's fault....it could have been considered for a green but definitely NOT RED!

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

@@Aishwariyajenayellow card tbh. Plus he has running too

@hgbhardwaj816 Месяц назад

Britishers always use backend and here they managed refree

@davidmanoharan3830 Месяц назад

MORE than MEDALS- the fire is back in Indian hockey Roar

@yogesh4997 Месяц назад

I WANT TO ASSURE YOU ALL THAT 'AMIT ROHIDAS' WILL PLAY FINAL.....🤞

@PcTgFamily Месяц назад

Hows that?

@user-go6mt7qo9n Месяц назад

They stopped him from playing semis too ..and now we lost

@PcTgFamily Месяц назад

@@user-go6mt7qo9n unfortunate #SaveSoil

@santanupradhan1094 Месяц назад

Request all players not participate in any international olympics.

@icyy9864 29 дней назад

Abe Tu khacchar hai kya amit ne apni stick upar ki thi us se injury ho sakti thi shayad usko laga player ruk jayega stick uthane ke baad par wo bhid gaya

@josealexander1674 Месяц назад

We are all disappointed that India did not win gold and silver so far and time is running out.

@user-ru7ym9hs4z Месяц назад

The Indian athletes that won medals are also disappointed with Indians like you.

@PauloRodriguesGoa Месяц назад

Amit is a professional player and should know where his stick swings. I think its a deliberate mistake or rather a forced error.

@user-hy5uq9jz6d Месяц назад

Rupha Ramani has no knowledge of hockey, its rules, and interpretations but makes some damning comment about the red card being unfair. Keeping aside emotions, I can as a player and an umpire (desi descent), tell that it was just. You got what you asked for. Amit is culpable of betraying his team with a brain fade. You cannot swing your stick at an opponents face and get away with it. It was deliberate, flagrant, NOT in the flow of the game, and he got the punishment. The manner of referring a non-PC/23 meter region dispute to the 3rd umpire can be debatable, but as shocking as it is, you've gotta call a spade a spade. Now don't confuse that with what the Brits despicably did behind the goalpost during the shoot out with that illegal coaching and having an electronic device near the goal. Deal with that separately.

@PBandJJJJJ Месяц назад

I do not find it shocking that Rohidas was banned for one game. A hit in the face is dangerous, even if it just happened carelessly. The German player Christopher Rühr was banned for one game, for something similar.

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

As far as I am aware of the rule. It's red card when done intentionally. Otherwise when it looks unintentional but was done after the shot was taken "while running". It gets a yellow card

@PBandJJJJJ Месяц назад

@@sinnohperson8813 I think you are making a fair point. I would add that intention is relative and a lot of things can be disguised as unintentional in sports. That’s why there is the term „dangerous play“, which describes a situation in which a player acts with reckless disregard for the safety of another player. I find the decisions that lead to the ban of Rühr and Rohidas quite understandable, as long as this is the way all games at the Olympics are officiated.

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

@@PBandJJJJJ i do think it's fair. But I saw some other games and thought this was little too extreme

@PBandJJJJJ Месяц назад

@@sinnohperson8813 All valid! Take care and I hope you enjoy these lovely olympic games!

@prakharpathak5899 Месяц назад

cost us the semi

@vaibhavVivi Месяц назад

Wrong decision by refree

@raviRehan-cn1wm Месяц назад

☃️.........the red card decision on India's top hockey defender is totally shameful and biased!!!+++ the English goalkeeper goes scott free on typical cheating mindset .....Whao What A 🌎 World Love to Team India Hockey 🏒 In Staying Spirited And Beating Britain WITH ONE MAN SHORT 80 %% OF GAME TIME 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

@keralanaturelover196 Месяц назад

Nonsense. Man go learn hockey rulers. Hit above shoulder is red

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

@@keralanaturelover196 it's yellow when you are running And how would you defend what their goalkeeper did or the penalty shot which was given in the semis instead of penalty corner.

@KO-yz7fz Месяц назад

Absolutely right decision, no discussion left.

@mutesatendolkar2561 Месяц назад

What kind of news is this? Just piggybacking on news we already know. Get real time or get out. Making money for on ads

@Abhishek100. Месяц назад

🇮🇳 I hope Indian clenched the Olympics gold medal at any cost.

@kickass7104 Месяц назад

Wow India is really struggling for a Gold 😐😐😐

@judewarner1536 Месяц назад

Anybody who thinks that a practiced, professional hockey player is unaware of the position of their hockey stick in relation to an opposition player in their IMMEDIATE VICINITY, is either naive or deliberately obfuscating. How many times have we seen a football player in a top league come down from a leap, ostensibly to head a ball they have no chance of connecting with, and leaving an elbow deliberately hanging in an opponent's face and claiming an accident? Same thing!

@freeman19555 Месяц назад

How can you call yourself a superpower while having 0 gold and 0 silver in Olympics? What a f joke!😂😂😂😂😂😂

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

What a fucking joke that you think sports equates a nation power lmfao. Whats your age?

@user-kw6vl1ox6r Месяц назад

At the Paris Olympics, India is not even comparable to Hong Kong, a small city in China, Hong Kong won two gold medals, but India does not have a single gold medal, it is really a super weak country, no country in the world can be weaker than India, because India can't even catch up with Hong Kong's medals, how weak do you say India

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

Pretty sure it's stronger than sofa commenters like you. If you got balls. Try them

@swapnaamitchopra1596 Месяц назад

What about the Brit Goalie ? How about their cheating ? That too deserves a red card ..Frankly I find the refereeing and commentary very biased ..

@judewarner1536 Месяц назад

@swapnaamitchopra1596 "What about this other bad thing", is NEVER a reason for the first party to get away with a dangerous foul. I'm surprised you didn't bring up the British Raj and the Bengal famine. Just accept that there was a just reaction to a piece of dangerous incompetence, which informed authorities have decided on rather than armchair hockey enthusiasts.

@germandaddy907 Месяц назад

@@judewarner1536sure you will say that as that logic benefits you .

@swapnaamitchopra1596 Месяц назад

@judewarner1536 Didn't ask you for your opinion so stay out of this thread ..Understand?

@germandaddy907 Месяц назад

@@swapnaamitchopra1596 neidig neuer (envious neuer ) german wants always to blame foreigners ..now he cannot blame china and is blaming india and indians ..good one from your end ..indians need to unite

@sinnohperson8813 Месяц назад

@@judewarner1536 the comment asked about British goalie foul and didn't use it to defend the red card on India. Being a British you probably should be ashamed of your English comprehension